Write For Me Good Dissertation Online
Schenectady
Write For Me Good Dissertation Online Old Mill Road zip 10024
Calculate Your Price
Word count 275
Price for this order:
$12
Proceed to
Order

When can we help you?

Running late with the deadline for your work? Then we are your reliable assistant in paper help.

Get ready to ask for our assistance when you need essays, research or course works, reports, case studies, etc. Our experts have seen it all and are ready to start working on your assignment right away. Go for it!

Why trust us?

With over 6 years of experience in the custom writing service, our team of support agents, managers, editors and writers has got a lot of knowledge about everything that may be required by you. Here’s what you get for sure when cooperating with us:

  • Professional paper writer. Our native speakers are true masters at creating unique and custom works per the most detailed and even the vaguest instructions you have.
  • Quality writing. We check all works with several detectors. To make sure your work is 100% unique, add a Plagiarism Report to your order.
  • Convenience of your personal control panel. Signing in, you can get your expert in touch through a direct message, also place orders there, and see their statuses.

Everyone needs some paper help from time to time, because we are only human.

What’s included in the total cost?

Our prices start at $10 per page for works completed from scratch and from only $6 per page you need to be edited and proofread.

What factors influence the cost of our paper writing services? There are 5 of them:

  • Type of work
  • Deadline
  • Academic level
  • Subject
  • Number of pages

You’re a lucky client! Why? Because you never pay for everything. You have lots of freebies to go with every single assignment. They are:

  • title page
  • reference page (bibliography)
  • formatting
  • 3 free revisions
  • scan for originality
  • email delivery

Asking for our paper writing help, you don’t only pay us. We also pay you! You can receive up to 15% bonuses back and even earn money with our referral program.

Your full security

We understand that sometimes you may want your deeds to go unknown. That is why we guarantee your complete privacy and security with our paper help writing service. After registration, you receive a unique ID and that is the only thing along with your instructions visible to our experts. Only our support team will see all the details you provide to be able to contact you in case any questions arise and send you a happy birthday discount on your special day.

Our custom writing service is completely ethical and provides busy students with great resources for their assignments. In the modern world when we need to do a lot of things at the same time, it’s nice to know you can count on someone for back up. We are always here to create the needed sample or perfect your work through editing/proofreading or explain the solutions to any problems you may have. Find out how much more free time you can get with our writing help.

Daemen College summerslam retro report new york entry level cover letter for resume Swedish Institute of Massage Therapy Fulton, grylloblattodea ppt presentation vodafone and airtel comparison essay Battery Place zip 10280 presenter reportase malam Dutchess County LIU Brooklyn need someone to write report on criminology asap Ludlow Street zip 10002. Onondaga gun control laws for mentally ill Madison Avenue zip 10022 fox sports sideline reporter Cayuga Community College wrItINg a tErM EvOLuTIOn WriTeRs IN ApA sTyLe cheltenham festival preview night reports icon.

>> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THE CLERK WILL CLOSE THE ROLL. THERE BEING 76 AYE AND 50 THAT TRIP TO THE BILLS PASS AS AMENDED AND TITLE AGREED TO >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: NEXT BILL ON THE CALENDAR FOR THE DAY IS SENATE FILE 803. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE CLERK WILL REPORT THEBI LL. >> CHIEF CLERK: SENATE FILE 803 NUMBER TWO ON THE CALENDAR FOR THE DAY AND ACT RELATING TO PUBLIC SAFETYUNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: I RECOGNIZE REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH TO INTRODUCE YOUR BIL L >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH; THIS THE PUBLIC SAFETY OMNIBUS BILL SENATE FILE IT 03 BEFORE I BEGIN I LIKE TO THANK THE STAFF JEFFREY DIEBEL AND BEN JOHNSON OUR HOUSE RESEARCH JOHN WALSH THIS GO ANALYST MIKE-COMMITTEE ADMINISTRATOR; JASON-COMMITTEE LEGISLATIVE ASSIGNMENT DAVID [INAUDIBLE] AND LAURA DFL RESEARCH. WITH THEIR HELP IT GET TO ME TO GET 134 VOTES MINOR SENDING [INAUDIBLE]. NOW; TO EXPLAIN THE BILL; I WILL DO A HIGH ALTITUDE FLYOVER AND THEN IF YOU WANT ME TO DIG DEEPER I WILL. I'LL RUN THROUGH THE INCREASE SPENDING HIGHLIGHTS AND SOME OF THE POLICY THEN ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. HE SPENDING HIGHLIGHTS ARE $52 MILLION ACROSS JUDICIAL BRANCH IN AGENCY FOR 1%; TATIAN INCREASE IN INCREASED HEALTH INSURANCE COST. ONE POINT 7;000;004 JUDGE IN IS A TWO OR 1000 YEARS FOR TREATMENT HURT. 20;000 IS FOR NEW CASE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR THE TAX COURT. 4.1 MILLION TO BE PLACED ON PREDATORY OFFENDING REGISTRY AT BCA. 3.2 MILLION FOR UPGRADED TECHNOLOGY SYSTEM TO ALLOW POLICE OFFICERS TO ACCESS AND SERVE AS TRAINING ORDERS FROM 2 MILLION TO REPLENISH THE DISASTER ASSISTANCE ACCOUNT. BYRON THOUSAND OAKS AND GRANTS COMBAT TERRORISM RECRUITMENT FOR AND 79;000 FOR ADDITIONAL SEX TRAFFICKING PREVENTION GRANTS. TWO AND 1000 FOR DE-ESCALATION TRAINING PUBLIC SAFETY PERSONNEL. 150 GRAND FOR A PRIVATE SECURITY GRANTS. 15 MILLION FOR ADDITIONAL REIMBURSEMENTS AND LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES FOR TRAINING. THAT'S THE POLICE TRAINING BILL. 20 MILLION FOR INCREASED INMATE HEALTHCARE COSTS FOR THE DOC DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS OR 5.7 MILLION FOR [INAUDIBLE] SUPERVISION OF SEX OFFENDERS. SOME OF THE SEX OFFENDER BILL WORK WE DID IN HERE IS FUNDED. 2.2 MILLION FOR RED WING D OC THE PREVENTION OF RAPE COMPLIANCE ACT COMING FROM THE FEDS WE HAVE TO FUND. 1.5 MILLION FOR EXPANDED MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES AT DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS OR THREE AND 70;000 FOR ALTERNATIVES INCARCERATION TREATMENT FOR CERTAIN NONVIOLENT SUBSTANCE-ABUSE OFFENDERS WHO VIOLATE TERMS OF PROBATION DRUG THOUSAND FOR TARGETED VESTED PENSION PROGRAM FROM OF CORRECTION IT A COUPLE OF THESE NUMBERS COULD CHANGE TO DO WITH THE AMENDMENT MAKING THE BILL SO THOSE NUMBERS WILL CHANGE SLIGHTLY. FOR THE POLICY HIGHLIGHTS; WE HAVE THAT LAW FORCING TRAINING BILL THAT I TALKED ABOUT WHERE WE MANDATE AND FUND TRACES INTERVENTION MENTAL ON THIS MENTALLY DISTURBED PERSONS; SUICIDE AND CONFLICT MANAGEMENT MEDIATION AND ALSO TRAINING IMPLICIT BIAS. WE'VE INCREASE PENALTIES FOR ILLEGAL PROTESTS GET AT THE PROTESTER BUILDER WE'VE NARROWED DOWN NOW TO MORE OR LESS FREEWAYS AND AIRPORT AND RAIL. THE ONLY INCREASE IT TO A GROSS MISDEMEANOR NOT A FELONY. THEY'RE FINE PLEASE OFFICERS WAY TO CARRY PRIVATE ASSUMPTIONS BASICALLY THAT ALLOWS FULL-TIME LICENSED OFF-DUTY OFFICERS LIKE THE ORIGINAL INTENTION THE BILL BACK IN 2005 AT EFFECTS. WE INCREASE THE FARMERS ACCESS TO LEGAL AID SO THEY MAY APPLY FOR LEGAL AID PROPERTY LIMIT. PROTECTING MEDICAL PERSON L AS ASSAULTING HOSPITAL MEDICAL PERSONNEL TO THE FOURTH DEGREE ASSAULT STATUTE. SO WOULD BE ANY NURSE IN THE BUILDING INSTEAD OF JUST THE EMERGENCY ROOM. OPTION TWO WEEKS OR OWN THE APPLETON PRISON PROTECTING VICTIMS OF SEXUAL ABUSE. THAT'S THE BOUT STATE ADJUDICATION AND IMPOSITION OF SOME OF THESE PROMINENT CASES YOU HEARD ABOUT IN THE NEWS LATELY BEEN ENSURING RURAL CROPS UP DISASTER RELIEF FUNDING AS PART OF THE DISASTER ASSISTANCE FUND. THEN WE HAVE A NUMBER OF THING PROBABLY FOUR BILLS DFL BILLS AND ASSORTED GOP BILLS IN THEIR. I WOULD NOW STAND FOR ANY QUESTIONS OR TAKE AMENDMENT ESTHER SPEAKER. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: CORNISH MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE NUMBER 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS FOLLOWS. THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 31 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH: THIS AMENDMENT REMOVES THE APPROPRIATION FOR MINISTRY THAT COST POTENTIAL LEASE OR PURCHASE OF APPLETON PRISON $208;000. IT ISN'T REALLY NECESSARY AT THIS TIME SINCE ANY POTENTIAL COST WOULDN'T BE INCURRED UNT IL THE COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIONS DETERMINE THE NEEDS EXIST UNDER THE CURRENT LANGUAGE OF THE BILL. THE PROBATES AN ADDITIONAL 100;000 PER YEAR FOR TREATMENT GRANTS UNDER THE ALTERNATIVE INCARCERATION PROGRAM FUND WHICH IS GOING TO BE AVAILABLE FOR TREATMENT OPTIONS OF CERTAIN NONVIOLENT SUBSTANCE ABUSE OFFENDERS WHO RECEIVED TECHNICAL VIOLATIONS WHILE ON PROBATION AND IT INCORPORATES $104;000 A YEAR TO THE TAX COURT TO OPERATE THE NEW CASE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM THEY REQUESTED. THEY REQUESTED MORE THAN THAT BUT I'LL LEAVE THIS WILL NOT BE ENOUGH TO SATISFY THE REQUIREMENTS. MN.IT IS ASKING FOR AN ADDITIONAL $152;000 AND WE ARE NOT COMPLETELY CONVINCED THAT'S NECESSARY SO THAT THE AUTHORS AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION ON THE A- 31 AMENDMENT? REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM: MEMBERS; I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU TO VOTE FOR THE A- 31 AMENDMENT. THIS REMOVES THE MONEY PUT IN PLACE IN ORDER TO ASSESS THE VALUE OF THE APPLETON PRISON WHICH AM VERY MUCH OPPOSED TO AND I BELIE VE IT IS A MORE APPROPRIATE USE OF THE RESOURCES. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION ON THE A- 31 AMENDMENT? SEEING NONE; ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY; AYE. [CHORUS OF AYES.] OPPOSED; SAY NAY. THE MOTION PREVAILS. THE AMENDMENT IS ADOPTED. >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: DEHN BOOST AMEND SENATE FILE 103 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 21. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE DEHN: THE UNIFORM COLLATERAL CONSEQUENCES OF CONVICTION THAT WAS A BILL WE HEARD IN PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE. IT DID NOT MAKE IT INTO THE PUBLIC SAFETY BILL . I THINK THERE ARE SEVERAL OF US VERY DISAPPOINTED IN THAT. WHAT IT DOES DO IS MAKES IT CLEAR THAT FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE CHARGED WITH A CRIME AS THEY GO THROUGH THE PROCESS IN THE COURTS THAT THEY ARE REALLY ENTERING INTO A CONTRACT WITH THE STATE THAT IF I PLEAD GUILTY AND A LARGE MAJORITY OF OUR CASES THE GO THROUGH THE COURT SYSTEM HAVE WHAT'S CALLED A PLEA BARGAIN THAT TAKES PLACE. BUT IF THEY DO PLEAD GUILTY THAT'S IMPORTANT FOR THEM TO UNDERSTAND NOT JUST THE CONSEQUENCE WITHOUT ACTUAL CHARGE WHAT THAT MEANS DIRECTLY BUT ALSO WHAT ARE THOSE COLLATERAL CAUSES MOVING FORWARD; WHETHER THAT BE DIFFICULTY IN FINDING A JOB; DIFFICULTY IN GETTING HOUSING ; MAKING SURE IT'S CLEAR THAT CERTAIN TYPES OF PROFESSIONS THAT MAY BE PROHIBITED FROM GETTING LICENSES TO ACTUALLY PRACTICING. SO I'VE HAD SOME CONVERSATIONS WITH CHAIRMAN CORNISH; AND I DON'T BELIEVE THAT THERE'S INTEREST AT THIS TIME TO TAKE THIS AS A CURRENT AMENDMENT BUT HE'S MADE A COMMITMENT TO CONTINUE TO WORKING ON THIS TO GET THE LANGUAGE IN A PLACE THAT FOLKS CAN BE HAPPY WITH MOVING FORWARD; POSSIBLY KNOWS MAYBE LATER THIS YEAR; MAYBE NOT TILL NEXT YEAR BUT AT THIS TIME I LIKE TO WITHDRAW THIS AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN WITHDRAWS THE A- 21 MIN. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: HILSTROM BOOST AMEND SENATE FILE IT 03 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 22. THE SPEAKER REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM THE A- 22; THE A- 23 AND A- 24 ARE ALL NOW GOING TO BE OUT OF ORDER FINANCIAL WE ADOPTED REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH'S AMENDMENT; WERE MOVING THE MONEY FROM HOUSE AND WE ELIMINATED THE MONEY SO I DO INTEND TO A STRAW ALL THREE OF THESE AMENDMENT. I JUST WANT TO MAKE IT CLEAR WHAT IT IS WE ARE WHAT'S MISSING FROM THIS BILL. SO THAT YOU'RE ALL CLEAR AS WE GET READY TO GO INTO CONFERENCE ABOUT WHAT I HOPE WILL COME OUT BETTER. MEMBERS; THE PROBATION OFFICERS ARE WE WERE REQUESTED IN THE GOV. BUDGET WERE NOT FUNDED. IS A 1% INCREASE FOR THEIR SALARY AND IT GOES TO PAY FOR THEIR INSURANCE. HOWEVER; WAS NO STEPS A ND LANES PROVIDED AND THERE WAS NO INCREASE IN THE ACTUAL NUMBER OF PROBATION OFFICERS. THE M ICE 23 AMENDMENT DOES THAT FOR THE PUBLIC OFFENDERS IT IS NOT ONE NEW PUBLIC DEFENDER IN THIS BILL IN THE A- 24 AMENDMENT IS FOR CORRECTIONS OFFICER. WHILE WERE DISCUSSING WHETHER NOT TO OPEN THE APPLETON PRISON; WE ARE NOT IN THIS BILL EVEN FINDING THE PROPER CORRECTIONS OFFICERS TO ADMINISTER THE CORRECTIONS DEPARTMENT THAT WE HAVE AT THIS TIME. SO WITH THAT MR. SPEAKER AND MEMBERS I WOULD WITHDRAW THE A- 23; A- 22; A- 23; AND A- 24 MARKS >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM WITHDRAWS THE A- RANGE AMEND. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. SPEAKER >> CHIEF CLERK: CONSIDINE MOVES TO AMEND THE UNOFFICIAL GROSSMAN AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 25. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE: THIS AMENDMENT WE HE ARD TESTIMONY AND WE HAVE A PROVISION IN THERE NOW THAT ANYBODY THAT IS 10 YEARS OLD AND OLDER HAS A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO AN ATTORNEY; WHICH WE PUSH FORWARD . UNFORTUNATE; BUT WE DO NOT DO WAS INCREASE THE PUBLIC OFFENDERS BOTTOM LINE WHICH MEANS THAT IN ADDITION TO EVERYTHING ELSE THEY ARE DOING; THEY WILL NOW HAVE TO STEP UP AND REPRESENT THESE 10 YEAR OLDS. UNFORTUNATE; FOR ME; REPRESENTATIVE AND CORNISH BELIEVE NOW HAS USED UP THE MONEY I WAS PLANNING ON USING SO I GUESS I'M GOING UP TO WITHDRAW THE AMENDMENT SO THANK YOU. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE WITHDRAWS THE A- 25 AMENDMENT TO IS IT ALSO 110 TO WITHDRAW THE A- 26 WOULD YOU LIKE ME TO INTRODUCE THAT? THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: CONSIDINE MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 80 3 THE UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 26. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE 28 TO THE A- 26 AMENDMENT. >> REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE: REPRESENTATIVE KRESHA BROUGHT FORTH A BILL THAT I THOUGHT WAS AN OUTSTANDING BILL THAT ALLOWS FARMERS TO ACCESS THE LEGAL SERVICE BUT I THINK WE WANT OUR FACTORIES AND FARM COMMITTEES TO HAVE ACCESS TO LEGAL ADVICE; PARTICULARLY; IF THEY CAN-ME ET THE THRESHOLD FOR INCOME. AGAIN; UNFORTUNATELY; THOUGH WE HEARD LEGAL SERVICES WAS ALREADY A MAJORITY OF THE PEOPLE THAT THEY ARE CURRENT LY REQUESTING SERVICES FROM AND THEY'RE HAVING TO TURN DOWN. SO; KEN WAS HOPING TO SOME MONEY TO SUPPORT REPRESENTATIVE TRENCHARD ISSUES BILL HERE BUT AGAIN THE MONEY HAS DISAPPEARED SO I WILL WITHDRAW IT. THANK YOU >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE WITHDRAWS THE A- 26 AMENDMENT. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: WARD BOOST AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 27. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE WARD TO THE A- 27 AMENDMENT. >> REPRESENTATIVE WARD: MEMBERS; USE INTERVENTION PROGRAMS HAVE BEEN AROUND AROUND FOR A LONG TIME. THEY WERE ORIGINALLY ESTABLISHED AS A FEDERAL PROGRAM AND EVERY COUNTY IN EVERY STATE HAD A USE INTERVENTION PROGRAM. AFTER A NUMBER OF YEARS; THAT WAS ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WAS CUT FROM THE FEDERAL BUDGET AND IT WAS DETERMINED THAT LOCALS LOCAL GOVERNMENT SHOULD PAY FOR THIS. IT IS A COMMUNITY-BASED APPROACH USE INTERVENTION REVERSES THE GROWTH IN STATE GOVERNMENT. THE OUTCOMES ARE SELF-SUFFICIENT ADULTS WORKING SHIPPING MEMBERS OF SOCIETY. USE INTERVENTION WORKS. YOUTH DO BETTER IN SCHOOL ; IMPROVE THEIR LIFE SKILLS; DEVELOP THOSE SOCIAL ATTITUDES AND 90% OF THEM DON'T GET INTO TROUBLE AGAIN WITH THE LAW. IT SAVES MONEY. WE GET ABOUT $10 BACK FOR EVERY DOLLAR THAT WE PUT IN. THAT'S WHY I WAS THINKING IN TERMS OF USING THE MONEY THAT WE WERE GOING TO SPEND ON THE APPLETON PRISON FOR USE INTERVENTION BECAUSE WHY NOT PREVENT THE PROBLEMS FROM DEVELOPING INTO ADULT PROBLEMS? IT WOULD DIMINISH THE NEED FOR MORE PRISONS; BUT I ALSO APPRECIATE WITH A MODERATE IS GOING OUT. SO USE INTERVENTION PROGRAMS SERVICES ARE PROVIDED FOR FRACTION OF THE COST OF OTHER PROGRAMS. TO THOSE MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES; ADDITIONAL SERVICES AND OTHER ISSUES THAT YOUNG PEOPLE FACE ARE DRESSED ADDRESSED AT THE LOCAL LEVEL. LAW ENFORCEMENT SUPPORTS USE INTERVENTION. THE USE INTERVENTION PROGRAMS NEED -THE NEEDS AROUND THE STATE OF MINNESOTA OVER $60 MILLION WAS REQUESTED FROM THE US E INTERVENTION ASSOCIATION IN 2015 ONLY 6.5 WAS APPROPRIATED. SO OUR GOAL IS TO REFORM HOW WE SUPPORT USE T O BECOME PRODUCTIVE ADULTS. TO DO THE INTERVENTION EARLY. RATHER THAN LATER WHEN IT'S FAR MORE EXPENSIVE AND WE HAVE LOST PEOPLE. MR. SPEAKER; GIVEN THAT THERE IS NO MONEY AT THIS POINT; I WITHDRAW THE AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE WARD WITHDRAWS THE A- 27 AMENDMENT. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: DEHN MOVES T O AMEND SENATE 80803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED IN THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 20 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT. BTV DEHN BMIS 20 AMENDMENT THOSE THINGS SIMILAR TO WHAT THE A- 38 AND LOOKS THAT WE JUST PAST. I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WHEN WE TALK LETTER PRISON POPULATION THE WAS A LOT OF TALK THIS YEAR ABOUT EXPANDING THE NUMBER OF BEDS AND THAT'S ONE WAY TO ADDRESS IT. ANOTHER WAY OF COURSE TO ADDRESS IT IS TO LOOK AT ALTERNATIVES INCARCERATION. EVIDENCE SHOWS OFTENTIMES THAT INDIVIDUALS THAT DON'T GO TO PRISON I DON'T GET LOCKED UP ACTUALLY END UP HAVING A MUCH MUCH LOWER RATE OF REOFFENDING IN THE FUTURE. WHILE WE CONSIDER WHAT WE DO WITH THOSE INDIVIDUALS THAT HAVE WANT US ON THE COMMISSION OF CRIMES WE ALSO MAKE IT CLEAR THAT WE CREATE OPPORTUNITIES TO MOVE FORWARD WITHOUT BECOMING [INAUDIBLE] IN OUR DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS. I THINK IT IS FASCINATING THAT MYSELF AND SHERMAN CORNISH HAVE REAL SIMILAR AMENDMENT TO THIS BILL. AND WHAT TO DO WITH THE FUNDING THAT WAS CURRENTLY IN THE BILL FOR FUNDING FOR THE STUDY OF THE APPLETON PRISON. SO; AT THIS TIME I LIKE TO WITHDRAW THIS AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN WITHDRAWS THE A- 28 MOUSE. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: DEHN MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 29 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN; TO INTRODUCE THE AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE DEHN: THIS AMENDMENT WOULD HAVE ACTUALLY PARTIALLY FUNDED THE JUSTICE REINVESTMENT ACCOUNT WHOSE PURPOSE IS TO MAKE SURE THAT THOSE INDIVIDUALS WHO DO THAT ARE CONVICTED OF A CRIME TO END UP SERVING TIME THAT HE ACTUALLY DON'T GO BACK AGAIN AND THE INTENT OF COURSE IS IF WE INVEST IN REDUCING THE AMOUNT OF RECIDIVISM TO OFFENDERS WHEN THEY RECOMMIT THAT ULTIMATELY THAT'S QUICK TO SAVE US MONEY IN THE LONG RUN. THE ON SAVING US MONEY IS ALSO THE RIGHT THING TO DO. I THINK ALL OF US THINK ABOUT THOSE THINGS WHEN WE WERE YOUNG THAT WE DID IT MAY NOT HAVE BEEN THE SMARTEST THINGS THAT MANY OF YOU KNOW MY STORY. IF GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY MANY INDIVIDUALS ARE MORE THAN HAPPY; MORE THAN WILLING AND THEY REALLY DESIRE TO DO THE THINGS THAT ARE GOOD IN SOCIETY THE THINGS GOOD FURTHER SOCIETIES AND THINGS GOOD FOR ALL OF US. BUT SINCE THERE'S NO LONGER ANY FUNDING AVAILABLE GIVING TO A- 31 MR. SPEAKER I LIKE TO WITHDRAW THE AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN WITHDRAWS THE A- 19 AMENDMENT. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: HILSTROM MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 20 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: I RECOGNIZE THE MEMBER REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM MEMBERS THIS IS THE PRE--JUDGMENT INTEREST AMENDMENT THE CHANGES MINNESOTA LAW. CURRENTLY; IF YOU SUE SOMEONE AND YOU FIND THAT THE COURT FINDS THAT A HARMED YOU YOU ARE CURRENTLY ENTITLED TO PREJUDGMENT INTEREST IN THE AMOUNT OF 10%. THIS BILL CHANGES THAT. IT MAKES IT SO THAT IF YOU WERE AN INDIVIDUAL AND YOU WIN IN YOUR CASE; THAT THE AMOUNT OF INTEREST IS LOWERED AND IT'S BASED ON A CALLED EIGHT T-BILL BUT BASICALLY IT'S WHAT A COST FOR SOMEONE TO BORROW MONEY. NOT WHAT IT COST YOU TO BORROW MONEY. MEMBERS; THE INTERESTING PIECE ABOUT W HAT THIS BILL DOES IS IT SAYS IF YOU'RE A LITTLE PERSON AN INDIVIDUAL SU ING SOMEBODY YOU DON'T GET THAT HIGHER INTEREST RATE ANYMORE. HOWEVER; COMPANIES WHO CHOOSE TO SUE ONE ANOTHER THEY STILL GET THAT HIGHER INTEREST. SO WHAT THIS DOES; IF YOU LOOK AT LINE -PAGE 30 LINE 23; THAT'S WHAT THAT STATUTE 68.011 SAYS. MEMBERS; THIS IS MAKING AN ON LEVEL PLAYING FIELD IT'S MAKING IT HARDER FOR INDIVIDUALS TO RECOVER THE MONEY THEY'RE ENTITLED TO IN THE COURT PROCESS AND IT GIVES A DISINCENTIVE FOR BUSINESSES TO SETTLE WHEN THEY ARE IN CASES THAT INVOLVE INDIVIDUALS. MEMBERS; I WOULD ASK FOR A ROLL CALL BOAT AND I'D ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT FOR THE A- 20 AND LOOKS TO REMOVE THIS PROVISION >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ROLL CALL HAS BEEN REQUESTED. SEEING FIFTEEN HANDS THERE WILL BE A ROLL CALL. REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH I WOULD ASK FOR A NO VOTE ON THE AMENDMENT BUT I DEFER TO REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS TO EXPLAIN WHY. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS >> REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS: MEMBERS; THIS LANGUAGE WAS ALSO IN THE PUBLIC SAFETY OMNIBUS BILL THAT THIS HOUSE PAST TWO YEARS AGO. IT'S HELPFUL TO GO BACK A WHILE AND FIGURE OUT HOW WE ENDED UP YOUR. REMEMBER THAT IT WAS A FEW YEARS BACK THAT THE LEGISLATURE DECIDED TO MOVE PRE-AND POST JUDGMENT INTEREST RATES TO 10%. ONE YEAR AFTER THAT MOVE LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT CAME BACK TO THE LEGISLATURE AND LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT CITIES COUNTIES TOWNSHIPS SCHOOL BOARDS; THEY CAME BACK TO THE LEGISLATURE AND THEY SAID; 10% INTEREST IS NOT CONNECTED TO THE MARKET. IT'S PUNITIVE. WE CAN'T AFFORD TO PAY THAT. SO WHAT DID THE LEGISLATURE DO? THE LEGISLATURE SAID; OR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT WE CAN CHANGE THAT BACK TO 4%. BUT FOR EVERYONE ELSE; WE WILL STICK YOU WITH A 10%. SO WE'VE COME BACK YEAR AFTER YEAR TO TRY TO RETURN THE P JUDGMENT INTEREST BACK TO REALITY AND BACK TO THE NORMS OF THE MARKET. IN STATUTE; THIS IS CONNECTED DIRECTLY TO THE P-BILL RATE. IF THE T -BILL RATE; OR 10% IN STATUTE NOW AFTER TH AT CHANGE. WHAT WE ARE TRYING TO DO IS CHANGE BAC K TO CONNECTED TO THE T-BILL RATE WITH A FLOOR OF 4%. IT MIGHT INTEREST YOU THAT 35 STATES ARE NOW BELOW 10% HAVING MOVED DOWN OVER THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS BECAUSE OF HISTORICALLY LOW INTEREST RATES. SEVERAL STATES JUST THIS YEAR LOWERED THEIR RATES AGAIN AND AGAIN. IN FACT; WEST VIRGINIA JUST A FEW WEEKS AGO WENT FROM 7% TO 4%. SO WE'RE SEEING THIS CONSTANT MARCH DOWN AS OTHER STATES ARE IDENTIFYING WITH THE REALITY OF THE MARKET IS WITH INTEREST RATES. I JUST WANT TO MENTION; REALLY BRIEFLY; CHAPTER 60-A .08 11 THE LAW PROVISION THAT EXCLUDED IN THIS IS A SEPARATE AGREEMENT WAS HAMMERED OUT HAVING TO DO WITH A PUNITIVE INTEREST RATE FOR AN INSURANCE COMPANY THAT HAS A FAILURE IN THEIR DUTY TO REPRESENT. THAT IS A PUNITIVE CLAUSE FOR A BREACH OF CONTRACT. COMPARING THAT IS LIKE COMPARING APPLES TO MONSTERS. IT JUST DOESN'T WORK. SO DON'T BE CONFUSED. WE NOW HAVE 35 OTHER STATES THAT ARE FOLLOWING THE MARKET . THAT ARE FOLLOWING WHAT WE SAY IN STATE STATUTE THAT WE OUGHT TO DO WHICH IS CONNECTED TO THE T-BILL. LET'S FOLLOW THAT. REMEMBER; WHEN GOVERNMENT CAME AND ASKED FOR HELP THIS LEGISLATURE HELPED. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS; TO PARAPHRASE WHAT MY MOTHER ONCE ASKED ME; IF YOUR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT TOLD YOU TO JUMP OFF A BRIDGE WOULD YOU EQUIP >> REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH; I GUESS IT DEPENDS IF YOU GO FIRST. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: WELL; IS BEEN QUITE A FEW DAYS SINCE I'VE GONE BRIDGE JUMPING AND YES MY MOTHER WOULD HAVE CAUTIONED AGAINST IT. WHICH WHY I DID NOT TELL HER AT THE TIME BUT HERE'S MY POINT. YOUR ENTIRE ARGUMENT IS PREDICATED ON THE FACT THAT WE ALL THOUGHT THAT CHANGING INTERES T FOR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT WAS A GREAT IDEA. WE DIDN'T. MR. SPEAKER ; REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS; DO YOU KNOW THE VOTE BY WHICH THAT PASSED THE HOUSE WE MAYBE INTEREST CHANGE FOR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT? >> REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS : THAT WAS BEFORE MY TIME. I DO NOT. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: WE'VE ALL GOT THESE COMPUTERS ON YOUR. THEY'RE SUPPOSED TO TELL US IN THE HOUSE JOURNAL BUT WAS NOT BY A HUGE MARGIN I WILL TELL YOU THAT. SO THE SUGGESTION THAT WE GOT 1% AGREEMENT OF THE FACT THAT SHOULD WORK FOR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT WE SHOULD APPLY TO EVERYONE; IS A BIT OF A STRETCH. I WOULD NOTE THIS. REMEMBER MEMBERS; THIS INTEREST IS FOR PEOPLE WHO WERE WRONGED. THIS IS NOT FOR FOLKS ARE JUST TRYING TO SHOOT FOR THE MOON AND GET A GOOD DEAL AGAINST THE LOCAL EUROPE GOVERNMENT OVER A BUSINESS COULD THIS IS FOR PEOPLE WHO WERE WRONGED. WHILE THEY HAVE TO WAIT FOR THE GRINDING YEARS OF JUSTICE TO COME AROUND AND GIVE THEM WHAT IS THERE DUE THE Y HAVE TO PAY FOR THOSE COST OF NOT HAVING A JOB OF MEDICAL BILLS. OF HOUSING AND YOU KNOW WHAT THEY DO; THEY PUT IT ON A CREDIT CARD. WHICH ARE CREDIT CARD INTEREST RATE? YOU THINK SOMEHOW IT'S A GOOD IDEA TO LOWER THIS TO THE T-BILL RATE YOU KNOW. IT WAS NOT I GET YOU REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS FOR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT. BUT THEY CAME AROUND HAT ENHANCING THIS IS JUST TOO MUCH AND BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT FOR PROFIT ENTITIES; THEY'VE ALL HEAVY HERE AT TH E LEGISLATURE; THEY GOT IT BECAUSE THEY SQUEAKY WHEEL GETS THE GREASE AROUND HERE. BUT THAT DOESN'T MEAN IT WAS A GOOD IDEA. S O TO SUGGEST WE PASSED OUT AGAINST WHAT WAS THE BETTER JUDGMENT OF MANY OF US IN THIS BODY THAT SOMEHOW WE NEED TO STICK IT TO EVERYBODY ELSE; TOO; THAT SOMEHOW YOU WERE FAMILY MEMBER WAS INJURED BY TARGETS WERE BY CAR GUILT OR BY GENERAL MILLS; OR ANY OF THE OTHER MULTINATIONAL CORPORATIONS IN THE UNITED STATES; SOMEHOW; NO; YOU GOT TO PUT THAT ON YOUR CITIBANK CARD AT 15% INTEREST BUT WE WILL PAY YOU BACK; FOUR. THAT'S NOT FAIR; MEMBERS. THIS PROVISION SHOULD BE REMOVED. YOU ARE GOING TO HEAR FROM MAYBE NOT A MAJORITY OF YOUR CONSTITUENTS BUT THERE WILL BE SOMEONE HERE OR THERE WHO SAYS; THIS IS CRAZY BY DIRECTOR PAY CITIBANK 15% OF THE PEOPLE WHO DID THE DAMAGE ON ME 4% ON THAT? IT'S NOT FAIR. VOTE FOR THE ADDITIONAL AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM: MEMBERS; AGAI N AS REPRESENTATIVE LESCH JUST SAID; MOST OF THE FOLKS GOING THROUGH THIS PROCESS OF COURT ARE PAYING THE BILLS BY PUTTING THEIR EXPENSES ON THEIR CREDIT CARDS. I DON'T KNOW TOO MANY PEOPLE THAT CAN BORROW MONEY AT 4%. EVEN MANY PEOPLE AS HOMEOWNERS MORTGAGES ARE AT A HIGHER RATE THAN THAT. YOU DON'T GET THE INTEREST THAT YOU WERE DUE UNLESS YOU PROVEN IN COURT THAT YOU'RE ENTITLED TO THE MONEY. S O WHAT INCENTIVE DOES THE COMPANY HAVE TO SETTLE BUT THEY CAN USE YOUR MONEY AT A CHEAPER RATE THAN WHAT YOU CAN USE IT FOR. THERE'S A LOW PENALTY FOR IT. NUMBERS; I DON'T THINK WE SHOULD PUT OUR FINGER ON THE SCALE AND HELP BIG BUSINESS COMPARED TO OUR INDIVIDUAL CONCISION. THAT'S WHAT I BELIEVE THIS PROVISION DOES. PLEASE; SUPPORT THE A- 20 AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: SEEING NO FURTHER DISCUSSION THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL ON THE AMENDMENT. >>[ROLL CALL VOTE]. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THE CLERK WILL CLOSE THE ROLL. THERE BEING 56 AYE AND 75 NAY THE MOTION DOES NOT TRAIL AND THE AMENDMENT IS NOT ADOPTED >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: HILSTROM OFFERS THE FOLLOWING MEMBERS. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. SPEAKER >> CHIEF CLERK: HILSTROM MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 18 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM ON THE A- 18 MIN. BTB HILSTROM: MEMBERS YOU SHOULD BE GETTING THREE HANDOUTS FROM ME RELATED TO THIS PROVISION. IN THIS BILL ON PAGE 33 T HIS BILL REPEALS THE SEATBELT GAG RULE THAT MINNESOTA HAS HAD IN LAW FOR MANY MANY YEARS. I BELIEVE SINCE ABOUT 1965. MEMBERS; WE AT THE LEGISLATURE AND THE COURT MAKE A DETERMINATION ABOUT WHAT IS FAIR FOR A JURY TO HEAR AS EVIDENCE WHEN THEY ARE DETERMINING WHAT SHOULD HAPPEN IN A CASE. WE HAVE DECIDED SINCE 1965 THAT JURIES SHOULD NOT HERE WHETHER OR NOT A DRIVER HAS INSURANCE. WE DON'T BELIEVE THAT JURIES SHOULD HEAR WHETHER OR NOT SOMEONE WHO'S INVOLVED IN A CRASH; IF THEY HAVE INSURANCE BECAUSE WE BELIEVE THAT MIGHT CHANGE THE OUTCOME IN THE DECISION THE JURY MIGHT MAK E. IF SOMEONE HAS INSURANCE; THEY MAY BELIEVE THEY CAN AFFORD TO PAY MORE IN DAMAGES. WE AL SO HAVE SAID THAT THE JURY SHOULD NOT HEAR WHETHER OR NOT THE PERSON WHO IS HARMED IN THE CRASH WAS WEARING A SEATBELT. BECAUSE IF YOU'RE NOT AT FAULT FOR THE CRASH YOU'RE STOPPED AT A STOP SIGN ; YOU ARE NOT MOVING AND SOMEONE RUNS YOU OVER; AND YOU ARE HARMED; WE DON'T BELIEVE THAT GOES TO WHETHER OR NOT YOU WERE AT FAULT FOR THE CRASH. THEREFORE; THE JURY SHOULD NOT HERE IN DETERMINING DAMAGES. THIS BILL UNDOES THAT GAG RULE. I'M PASSING OF THREE PIECES OF PAPER . THE FIRST ONE; TRACY MORGAN. I CAN'T BELIEVE WALMART IS BLAMING ME. THIS IS AN EXACT EXAMPLE OF HOW AN INSURANCE COMPANY; OR SOMEONE WHO DID YOU HARM; WOULD SAY TO A COURT; I SHOULD PAY YOU LESS. YOU SHOULD BE ENTITLED TO LESS DAMAGES BECAUSE YOU WERE NOT WEARING YOUR SEATBELT. EVE N IF YOU HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH WHY THE CRASH OCCURRED. RIGHT HERE IN MINNESOTA; RIGHT NOW; WE HAVE A CRASH OUT OF ST. CLOUD WHERE SOME FOLKS WERE SITTING AT A TRAFFIC LIGHT AND THEY WERE KILLED. THAT'S THE SECOND HANDOUT YOU HAVE HERE. THE PROVISION OF THIS BILL WOULD SAY THAT THE TWO FOLKS WHO WERE KILLED ; THAT THE JURY SHOULD GET TO LOWER THE AMOUNT OF DAMAGES THEY POTENTIALLY ARE PAID. ON WHETHER OR NOT THEY WERE WEARING THEIR SEATBELT. AGAIN; THEY WERE STOPPED. THE CRASH WAS NOT THEIR FAULT. IN DETERMINING HOW MANY DAMAGES SHOULD BE PAID THIS BILL WOULD ALLOW INSURANCE; NEEDS TO PAY LESS GOOD THAT'S WHAT THIS IS ABOUT. THEN THERE'S AN ARTICLE YOU HAVE AS WELL WHERE IT ACTUALLY TALKS A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT WALMART BLAMING TRACY MORGAN FOR NOT WEARING HIS SEATBELT. MEMBERS; SOMEONE IS SAYING THIS IS TRACY MORGAN GETS BLAMED; WHAT CHANCES DO YOUR CONSTITUENTS HAVE TO FIGHT THIS? MEMBERS; WE DECIDE WHAT IS FAIR FOR JURIES TO HEAR BECAUSE WE WANT A FAIR AND JUST OUTCOME. WHAT A THIS PROVISION WOULD DO; FOR EXAMPLE; IF YOU ARE STOPPED YOU ARE STOPPED IN YOUR DRIVEWAY; STOPPED IN FRONT OF YOUR HOUSE AND MAYBE YOU HAVE YOUR SEATBELT ON BECAUSE YOU'RE WAITING FOR SOMEONE AND YOU ARE HIT BY A DRUNK DRIVER. NOT YOUR FAULT. THE INSURANCE; HE WOULD GET TO PRODUCE EVIDENCE THAT YOU WERE NOT WEARING YOUR SEATBELT AND THEREFORE YOU ARE HARMED BECAUSE OF YOUR OWN FAULT. I DON'T THINK IT'S THE RIGHT PUBLIC POLICY TO INCENTIVIZE PEOPLE WHO HARM OUR CONSTITUENTS TO PAY LESS. THIS THEN BECOMES A WAR OVER EXPERT WITNESSES. CAN YOUR CONSTITUENTS AFFORD EXPERT WITNESSES TO GO UP AGAINST BIG INSURANCE COMPANIES? MANY OF MINE CANNOT. THIS PROVISION WOULD ALLOW INSURANCE COMPANIES IN THESE CASES TO SAY; MOMS AND DADS; YOU PUT THAT KID IN THE CAR SEAT AND YOU DO NOT PUT THE CAR SEAT IN QU ITE RIGHT. THEREFORE; YOU ARE AT FAULT FOR THE DAMAGE TO YOUR CHILD SUFFERED; THE INJURIES Y OUR CHILD SUFFERED; EVEN IF YOU ARE HIT BY A DRUNK DRIVER AND IT WAS NOT YOUR FAULT. I DON'T THINK THAT IS FAIR. I DON'T THINK THAT IS JUST. I THINK THAT IS THE WRONG THING TO DO. I WOULD ASK YOU TO VOTE IN FAVOR OF THE A- 18 MIN. AND MR. SPEAKER I WOULD ASK FOR ROLL CALL >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ROLL CALL HAS BEEN REQUESTED. SEEING FIFTEEN HANDS THERE WILL BE A ROLL CALL. REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH: MEMBERS I WOULD AGAIN ASK FOR A NO VOTE ON THIS AMENDMENT. AS GIFTS REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN WOULD YIELD TO EXPLAIN WHY. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: MEMBERS; WITH THIS AMENDMENT ON THE BILL IS ATTEMPTING TO DO IS TO TAKE A PROVISION OUT OF THE BILL THAT WILL ALLOW A JURY TO CONSIDER ALL RELEVANT OR GERMANE FACTS IN EVIDENCE TO A CASE. YOUR PREVIOUS BILL SHEEH AN MENTIONED PUTTING A FINGER ON THE SCALE. THE SEATBELT GAG ORDER IN TODAY'S LEGAL ENVIRONMENT DOES JUST THAT. LET ME WALK YOU THROUGH WHY WE HAVE THE GAG ORDER. FOR A LOT OF PEOPLE IT'S HARD TO EVEN IMAGINE WHY WOULD WE INTENTIONALLY KEEP EVIDENCE OF THE COURT CASE? WHEN SEATBELTS WERE FIRST INVENTED YOU HAD TO PURCHASE THEM AS AN EXTRA ON YOUR CAR. HOW LIABILITY WAS SUPPOSED TO MINNESOTA AT THE KIND WAS THAT IF YOU WERE INJURED THAT YOU PLAYED A ROLE IN-YOUR NEGLIGENCE CLAIM A ROLE IN HOW [INAUDIBLE] OR IF YOU ARE INJURED AT ALL YOU DO NOT COLLECT IF YOU CONTRIBUTED TO THE CAUSE OF THE ACCIDENT YOU WERE OUT. IN MINNESOTA WE CHANGED HOW WE IMPOSE OUR LIABILITY AND NOW DO WHAT IS CALLED COMPARATIVE NEGLIGENCE. EVERYONE IN HERE IS FAMILIAR WITH THAT WERE WE ARE GOING TO CO MPARE WHAT HOW MUCH YOU WERE AT FAULT IN THE ACCIDENT TO HOW MUCH I WAS AT FAULT IN THE ACCIDENT TO HOW MUCH THE PASSENGER IN THE CAR WAS AT FAULT FOR THE ACCIDENT THE TOTAL AMOUNT IS 100%. THE EXAMPLE THAT WENT AROUND THE HANDOUTS THAT WENT AROUND IF HIS SEATBELT USAGE WAS NOT A FACTOR DURING THE RULES OF EVIDENCE PHASE DURING THE CIVIL TRIAL; THE JUDGE WOULD DEEM IT TO BE INADMISSIBLE. IT WON'T BE PUT IN. THER E ARE MANY CASES WHERE SEATBELTS ARE NOT A FACTOR IN THE LOSS AT ALL. BUT THERE ARE MANY CASES WHERE THEY ARE A FACTOR. IT'S GERMANE EVIDENCE THAT PERMIT APPLIES TO ALL OF THAT. THE AUTHOR OF THIS AMENDMENT HALF OF THE COS T OF EXPERT WITNESSES. IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING CIVIL CASES THAT IF SOMEONE PREVAILS AND AGAIN; THE USAGE OF SEATBELT THAT EVIDENCE IS IN COURT TO CHANGE WAS AT FAULT. IT CHANGES HOW MUCH YOU WERE AT FAULT. IF THEY PREVAIL; ANY OF THOSE COURT COSTS CAN BE SHIFTED TO THE OTHER PARTY. I ASK YOU TO VOTE; NO; THIS AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; DO YOU KNOW WHAT RELEVANT EVIDENCE IS DEFINED AS IN MINNESOTA? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: I DON' T KNOW WHAT THE TECHNICAL DEFINITION WOULD BE LITTLE BE MY ASSUMPTION AND COMMON SENSE- BECAUSE THIS IS COMMON LAW-WOULD BE EVIDENCE THAT WOULD HAVE A DEMONSTRATABLE RELATIONSHIP TO WHATEVER THE INJURY OR DAMAGE WAS. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; IT'S NOT COMMON LAW. STATUTORY LAW. BECAUSE IT'S CODIFIED IN MINNESOTA STATUTES. I'LL READ IT TO YOU. RELEVANT EVIDENCE MEANS EVIDENCE HAVING ANY TENDENCY TO MAKE THE EXISTENCE THAT EFFECT OF CONSEQUENCE TO THE DETERMINATION OF THE ACTION MORE PROBABLE OR LESS PROBABLE THAN WOULD BE WITHOUT THE EVIDENCE. SO IN A LAWSUIT FOR NEGLIGENCE; YOU GOT FOUR PARTS ROUTE YOU KNOW THIS. I KNOW YOU KNOW THIS. JUDY; BREACH; CAUSATION AND DAMAGES. NOW; TH E BREACH; THE BREACH OF THE DUTY MEANING THAT YOU SHOULD'VE BEEN AWARE OF SOME INCIDENT ON THE ROAD AND YOU ARE NOT; AND SO YOU CRASH INTO ANOTHER VEHICLE; HOW DOES THE FACT THAT A PERSON IN THE CAR THAT YOU HIT WAS OR WAS NOT WEARING A SEATBELT; HOW DOES THAT MAKE IT MORE LIKELY THAT YOU WERE GOING TO HIT THEM WITH YOUR CAR? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: THE PREACHER TALK ABOUT AT THAT ASPECT WOULD BE FAILURE TO PUT ON THE SEATBELT. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: THAT' S NOT CORRECT. YOU ARE NOT LEGALLY CORRECT. BECAUSE THE DUTY IN THE BREACH ARE TWO DIFFERENT THINGS. THE DAMAGES THAT THEY SUFFER THAT YOU WANT TO ENHANCE BY THE FACT THEY WERE NOT WEARING A SEATBELT THAT'S THE DAMAGES PHASE OF A TRUCK THAT'S WHAT CURRENTLY HAPPENS. SO PERSON WOULD HAVE BEEN IN THE HOSPITAL WITH A MASSIVE HEAD WOUND AND SUFFERED A LOT MORE. HAVE THEY BEEN- IT COST $1 MILLION. IF THEY HAD BEEN WEARING A SEATBELT WE LL IT WOULD'VE COST LESS THAN THE DAMAGES PORTION OF WHAT YOU ARE DOING HERE; RIGHT NOW; IS YOU WANT TO BE ABLE TO INTRODUCE THE EVIDENCE OF SEATBELT USE IN ORDER TO PREJUDICE THE JURY AGAINST A DEFENDANT WHO IS OTHERWISE INNOCENT OF THIS. THAT'S WHAT'S UNFAIR. NOW; THE EXAMPLE OF THIS THAT REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM JUST PASSED OUT OF THE TRACY MORGAN INCIDENT. BACKUPS WATCHING SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE WITH MIKE LAST NIGHT I SAW THE EPISODE REKEY BACK THE FIRST TIME WITHOUT WALMART TRUCK ROLLED OVER HIS LIMO BUS AND TRY TO BLAME HIM. HE DID WELL ON THEIR. WE HA VE THIS GRAPHIC AND TRAGIC EXAMPLE OF HOW UNFAIR THIS IS TO MINNESOTA TO JUST COME ON MARCH 19; MEMBERS; ON MARCH 19; LESS THAN A MONTH AGO; A SEM I TRUCK STRUCK FROM BEHIND A STOP TAXICAB ON HIGHWAY 10 IN ST. CLOUD REPRESENTATIVE KNOBLACH; YOUR DISTRICT AND I KNOW THIS GUY DRIVE RIGHT THAT INTERSECTION EVERY TIME WHEN I DROVE UP TO CAMP RIPLEY THIS MCDONALD'S ON ONE CORNER EIGHT COPPER KETTLE ON THE OTHER ONE. IT JUST PAST THE UNDERPASS THERE. THIS INDIVIDUAL THE CAB JAYBIRD SITTING THERE HAD TO BACKSEAT PASSENGERS. THEY WERE GOING EASTBOUND AND A SEMI TRUCK ON A 50 MILE AN H OUR ROAD SMASHED INTO THE BACKEND . MEMBERS; THERE WAS NOT A SINGLE SKIDMARK IS BUT A SINGLE SKIDMARK BEFORE STRIKING THE VEHICLE. THE CAB DRIVER; TOM FINLEY DIED. A 22-YEAR-OLD PASSENGER OF THE TAXICAB DIED AT THE SCENE. THE BACKSEAT PASSENGER; MARK SHEA; IS CRITICALLY INJURED SHE STILL IN THE HOSPITAL. MEMBERS; IF YOU LOOK AT THE HANDOUT THAT REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM HANDED OUT SHOWING THE DISRUPTION OF THE GAP AND THINK ABOUT THE ACCIDENT RELATION TO THE PROPOSAL BY INSURANCE COMPANIES AND TRUCKING FIRMS; TO AVOID PAYING DAMAGES; YOU SEE HOW OUTRAGEOUS THIS PROVISION IS. JURIES HEAR THIS RELEVANT EVIDENCE AND NOW IN THIS PROVISION REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN WANTS YOU TO THINK THAT THE RELEVANT EVIDENCE TO WHEN THE TRUCK SMASHED INTO THE BACK OF A CAB AT 50 MILES AN HOUR WAS WHETHER OR NOT THEY WERE WEARING A SEATBELT. IN THE CAUSATION OF THE CRASH. JURIES HEAR THAT IN DETERMINING CAUSATION OF THE CRASH. CURRENTLY; IT'S LIMITED JUST TO THE DAMAGES PORTION YOU WANT TO INCLUDE IT SO YOU JURIES WHEN THEY DECIDE WHO IS MORE AT FAULT FOR THE CRASH ITSELF THEY CAN DECIDE WHETHER OR NOT SOMEONE WAS WEARING A SEATBELT. BY THE WAY; IN THE TRACY MORGAN SITUATION IT WAS A LIMO BUS AND IN THIS CASE IT WAS A CAB. SO HOW MANY OF YOU PUT SEATBELTS ON ANY CABS? THEY HAVE IN NEW YORK THEY HAVE THOSE SIGNS IN THE FRONT SEAT THAT YOU ARE SUPPOSED TO WEAR YOUR SEATBELT BUT DON'T HAVE A BOX OF DISINFECTANT BECAUSE IN NEW YORK CITY TAXICAB SO HOW MANY PEOPLE ACTUALLY GRAPPLE WITH THE THING IS UNKNOWN. BUT WE KNOW FROM CASE EXAMPLES IN THREE STATES ALLOWS THIS EVIDENCE THAT INSURANCE AND TRUCKING COMPANIES BLAME THEIR VICTIMS FOR THEIR INJURED. IT'S HAPPENING RIGHT NOW IN ST. CLOUD. IT'S HAPPENING IN NEW JERSEY WITH TRACY MORGAN. TRACY MORGAN IS A HIGH-PROFILE CELEBRITY AND WALMART BLAMED HIM FOR HIS INJURIES WHEN THIS TRUCK-THIS DRIVER WOULD NOT SLEPT FOR 28 HOURS FALSELY AND CRASHED INTO THE BACK OF HIS LIMO BUS. SEVERELY INJURING FOUR PEOPLE AND KILLING COMEDIAN JIMMY MAC. WALMART RESPONSE WAS THAT MORGAN AND THE OTHERS WERE RESPONSIBLE FOR THEIR OWN INJURIES BECAUSE THEY WERE NOT BELTED INTO THIS LIMOUSINE BUS. YOU HAVE THIS PICTURE ON YOUR DESKS THAT SHOWS YOU THE DAMAGE TO THAT. IT'S PRETTY SEVERE AND SUBSTANTIAL. 30;000 MINNESOTANS ARE INJURED IN SOME WAY IN OVER 75;000 AUTO CRASHES EVERY YEAR. IF WE APPLY THIS PROPOSAL TO THE ST. CLOUD INCIDENT THAT HAPPENED LESS THAN A MONTH AGO THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT WILL HAPPEN. SO MS. LETOURNEAU; WHO DIED AND MS. PRICE; WHO'S LANGUISHING IN CRITICAL CARE RIGHT NOW LIKE MANY OF US BACKSEAT PASSENGERS A LOT OF TIMES THEY WERE THE SEATBELT IN THE BACKSEAT. MR. FINLEY WITH THE CAB DRIVER DID HE WAS BELTED HIM IN ST. CLOUD BUT HE STILL LOST HIS LIFE. SO; I WONDER REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: IF YOU CAN ADDRESS YOUR QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS TO THE SPEAKER IN WHICH WE RECOGNIZE. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: THANK YOU. I S THAT MEAN YOU WANT ME TO FACE YOU YOU'LL SENT AWAY ? REPRESENTATIVE G O TALK TO IRAN BECAUSE IT WAS KIND OF CREEPY WHEN TALKING TO REPRESENTATIVE LIEBLING SO I CAN BUT I DON'T KNOW HOW YOU LIKE TO LOOK AT THE BACK OF MY HEAD REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN BUT I FIND IT KIND OF DISRESPECTFUL BUT I'LL TRY TO DO THAT MR. SPEAKER. LET ME ASK YOU THIS. I WILL THIS UP REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN I KNOW YOU HAVE A PICTURE O F THIS. EMILY PATERNO; SHE BELIEVED SHE WAS AT FAULT FOR HER DEATH IN A CRASH IN ST. CLOUD? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH; BASED ON THE LIMITED AMOUNT OF TAX I HAVE I WOULD SAY; NOT. DURING A CASE LIKE THIS YOU CONTEND THAT THE PLAINTIFF PART SUCH AS THE CASE OF TRACY MORGAN HOMERED CONTENDING THE SEATBELTS WERE A FACTOR IS NOT THERE CALL. IT WILL BE THE CALL OF THE JUDGE WHETHER EVIDENCE IS ADMISSIBLE OR NOT. I AGREE WITH YOU IN THESE IS IS IS AND I'LL AGREE THERE'S OTHER INSTANCES WITH OTHERS SEATBELT USAGE IS AWKWARD TO BE A FACTOR. BUT MY POINT IS AND WHAT REMOVING THE GAG ORDER DOES IS IT INAPPROPRIATE WITH THAT DECISION IS CLOSE TO THE SITUATION AS POSSIBLE. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: YOU JUST ADMITTED THERE'S NO REASON FOR YOUR BILL. Y OU JUST ADMITTED THAT THERE IS NO REASON FOR YOUR BILL FOR THIS PROVISION IN THIS BILL. BECAUSE IF SHE IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR HER OWN DEATH THE N YOUR BILL IS GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY FOR A JURY TO THINK THAT SHE COULD BE RESPONSIBLE FOR HER OWN DEATH. NOW CURRENTLY IN MINNESOTA LAW JURIES TO GET TO CONSIDER SEATBELT USAGE WITHIN THE DAMAGES PHASE 2 IS NOT IN THE CAUSATION PAGE WHICH IS WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING AT DOING. YOU ARE SUGGESTING WHETHER OR NOT SHE WAS WEARING US ABOUT IT MORE LIKELY THAT THAT TRUCK WAS CALLED CRASH INTO HER. REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; DO YOU BELIEVE THAT MARSH A PRICE WAS AT FAULT FOR HER INJURIES WHEN SHE MAY NEVER BE COVERED FROM? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: AGAIN REPRESENTATIVE LESCH ASKED ME TO ANSWER A QUESTION I DON'T HAVE ALL THE INFORMATION ON. I HAVE NOT SAT TO THE FACT THAT I'M NOT ON ANY JURY. WITH THIS PROVISION DOES IS IT MOVES THE DECISION ON WHETHER OR NOT EVIDENCE IS ADMISSIBLE OR NOT IS CLOSE TO THE SITUATION AS POSSIBLE. THIS IS IN ANY DIFFERENT THAN YOU ARE TAUGHT HANDWRITING TEACHER SAID GET YOUR HAND ON BY THE END OF THE PENCIL. YOU GET AS CLOSE TO THE SITUATION AS POSSIBLE. HAVE BETTER DATA. THERE SITUATIONS WHEN I'M AWARE OF IN MY INSURANCE AGENCY WHERE SEATBELTS WERE NOW FUNCTIONING. WE COULD UP WITH THE SEATBELT ON. THE REALITY IS THIS A BILL DOESN'T FIT YOU MUST ACQUIT. YOU CAN COUNT THAT WITHOUT ALL BE DONE BASED ON THE RULES OF EVIDENCE DONE ON THE TRIAL. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; IN LIGHT OF WHAT YOU ARE JUST SAYING; YOU HAVE INSURANCE; YOU SELL INSURANCE POLICIES TO PEOPLE ASSUMING INSURANCE POLICIES FOR OPERATING MOTOR VEHICLES. SO; DO YOU THINK IT'S APPROPRIATE FOR JURIES TO HEAR EVIDENCE AS TO WHETHER OR NOT A PERSON WAS INSURED TO A CERTAIN LEVEL? OBVIOUSLY IN FACT THIS MUST MEAN THE MOVIE SPENT A LONG TIME SINCE I PUT A MOVIE IN THERE BUT WAS FRIED GREEN TOMATOES WHEN A WOMAN CRASHED INTO A BETTER WOMAN IN A PARKING NOT AND SHE SAYS; FACE IT; LADIES I'M OLDER I HAVE A LOT I BETTER ENGENDERED MAYBE IF YOU WERE INSURANCE USUALLY LESS CAREFUL DRIVING ON BECAUSE YOU'RE COVERED. SO IS IT APPROPRIATE BECAUSE UNDER YOUR DEFINITION OF RELEVANCE IS IT APPROPRIATE FOR JURY TO HEAR RELEVANT EVIDENCE LIKE THAT IN MINNESOTA? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH; I WOULD HAVE TO ASK YOU A QUESTION FIRST. WITH THE AMOUNT OF INSURANCE THE PERSON CARRY HA VE ANY RELATIONSHIP OR ANY AFFECT ON HOW INJURED THE OTHER PARTY WAS OR NOT? >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: I THINK REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; YOU JUST PROVIDED AN ANSWER WHY THIS BILL IS IRRELEVANT. BECAUSE IF YOU'RE SUGGESTING THAT YOUR LEVEL OF INSURANCE HAS NO BEARING ON WHETHER THE CRASH OCCURRED THEN THERE IS NO WAY THAT A PERSON WHO'S SITTING IN THE CAR THAT WAS HIT HAS A BEARING ON WHETHER THE GUILTY PARTY STRUCK YOU. YOU JUST ESSENTIALLY ADMITTED THAT THIS BILL IS POINTLESS AS NOTHING MORE THAN A GIVEAWAY TO INSURANCE COMPANIES. REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; CAN YOU TELL ME IF WE WERE TO ADOPT THE TRUCKERS AN INSURANCE COMPANY PROPOSAL WE KNOW THEY WILL USE THIS TO LIMIT THEIR RESPONSIBILITY FOR CRASHES LIKE THIS. WE SAW IT IN OTHER STATES MUCH LIKE THEY DID IN NEW JERSEY THE TRACY MORGAN TO SAVE THE MONEY. REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; MS. PRICE'S LANGUISHING IN CRITICAL CARE RIGHT NOW IS 21 YEARS OLD. SHE STILL RECOVERING. LET'S ASSUME HER MEDICAL BILLS WOULD BE $500;000 FOR WEEKS OR MONTHS OF BEING IN THE HOSPITAL AND SURGERIES. OPERATIONS AND REHABILITATION WHICH IS NOT A REASONABLE NUMBER WHATSOEVER FOR THAT AMOUNT TIME AND THIS LEVEL OF INJURED CAN YOU TELL ME HOW MUCH YOUR MEDICAL INJURIES IF THE TRUCK AND INSURANCE COMMITTEES CONVINCES AN INJURY THAT SHE'S 50% AT FAULT FOR HER INJURY BECAUSE SHE'S NOT WEARING A SEATBELT? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: WHAT I CAN TE LL YOU REPRESENTATIVE LESCH SHE WOULD COLLECT 20;000 UNDER PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION UNDER THE NO-FAULT STATUTE. AS FAR AS THE 50% ASSIGNMENT O F NO CUSHIONS WHICH IS VERY UNCOMMON; CERTAINLY IS NOT IN THE 35 YEARS IN THE BUSINESS HAS SEEN IT ONCE-I DON'T THINK EITHER PARTY CAN COLLECT. WHAT YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT IS YOU LIKE TO SEE A CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE WHICH ARE WE HAPPY TO WORK WITH YOU ON CHANGING THE LIABILITY HOW SIMPLE 02 CONTRIBUTORY BASIS WHERE IT'S ALL OR NOTHING ALL BE ALL FOR THAT. THAT'S WHEN THE GAG ORDER CAME TO PLACE. WHEN WE CHANGED THE COMPARATIVE DATA BECAME A CAKE AND EAT IT TOO SITUATION THAT WE WILL ASSIGN NEGLIGENCE TO DIFFERENT PEOPLE BUT WE ARE NOT GOING TO COUNT-WE ARE NOT GOING TO BE ALLOWED TO SUBMIT CERTAIN EVIDENCE THAT IS RELATED TO THE AMOUNT OF INJURY YOU SUSTAINED OR WHETHER YOU ARE INJURED OR NOT. I WOULD ASK REPRESENTATIVE LESCH TO YIELD TO A QUESTION. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH HAS THE FLOOR RIGHT NOW. REPRESENTATIVE LESCH >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: MR. SPEAKER; LAST QUESTION AND YOUR INSTITUTE AND I'LL ANSWER THAT IN MY NEXT ONE. THE ANSWERS BELOW LIEBLING IS 50%. FOR HALF BILLION-DOLLAR MEDICAL BILLS SHE BE RESPONSIBLE FOR $250;000. I DON'T KNOW WHO AROUND HERE IS $250;000 LAYING AROUND INCLUDE THIS EVIDENCE OF SEATBELT USE. IF THE BIG INSURANCE AND TRUCKING COMPANY LAWYERS CONVINCE PEOPLE THAT THAT'S HOW MUCH SHE WOULD HAVE TO PAY. LET'S SAY; THEY FIND HER A 10% FAULT. SHE WOULD LOSE OVER $50;000 TO COVER HER MEDICAL BILLS UNDER YOUR PROPOSAL. THE SHIFT TO PAY FOR THAT HERSELF OR CAN THE STATE PAY? TO EMPLOYER PAID HEALTH INSURANCE PAY ? WHERE ARE THESE COSTS SHIFTED TO UNDER YOUR PLAN ? WINZIP COVERING THESE MEDICAL BILLS? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH TO THAT QUESTION THAT'S ON THE NATURE OF THE BILLS IF THEY'RE ACTUAL MEDICAL BILLS THE MEDICAL PROVIDER CAN PARTICIPATE IN THE SETTLEMENT AS WELL GET TYPICALLY WHEN THIS BIG CASE LIKE THAT THEY DO GET IN LINE AND SEEK COMPENSATION UNDER THE AMOUNT OF COVERAGE THAT IS AVAILABLE. AS FAR AS HER PAIN IT THEMSELVES SHE HAS HEALTH INSURANCE THAT'S WHERE WOULD END UP GOING. THERE'S A COUPLE MORE STOPS. WE FINISH MY ANSWER. SHE WHAT HAPPENS IS SHE COLLECTS FROM AN ASPHALT PARTY THEY DON'T HAVE ENOUGH INSURANCE ENOUGH COVERAGE TO INDEMNIFY HER UP TO IF SHE IS; AND THEN SHE COMES BACK UNDER HER OWN POLICY UNDER HER UNINSURED MORALS AND INVOKES THE COVERAGE AS WELL. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: THANK YOU FOR YOUR LATITUDE. THE ANSWER THAT REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN JUST GAVE IS WE ALL DO. WE ALL PAY THAT. SO IF IT IS UNDER HEALTH INSURANCE WE ALL PAY. THE STATE PAYS FOR WE ALL PAY IT YOU KNOW WHO DOESN'T PAY AT? THE DRIVER WHO SMASHED INTO HER CAR. THAT'S WHO DOES NOT PAY THIS. NOW REPRESENTATIVE 10 AMENDMENTS LIKELY THE TRUCKING COMPANY AT THE ACADEMY TO SPREAD THE PLANE TO OTHERS. JUST TO KNOW; LET'S SAY IF YOU GET WHAT YOU WANT AND LET'S SAY THAT A JURY COMES BACK AND FINDS MS. MARSH EIGHT WAS LANGUISHING CRITICAL CARE RIGHT NOW 40% AT FAULT AND LET'S SAY THEY FIND THE CHUNKING COMPANY IN THE CAPITAL MANY AS 60% OF FALL. EQUALLY AT 30% EACH. REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; IN THAT SCENARIO; HOW MUCH DOES MS. MARSH EIGHT COVER FOR INJURIES OR MEDICAL BILLS? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: FOR THAT QUESTION; AND THESE WONDERFUL WERE PROBLEMS. THE CONNECTION OF A DETERMINED SETTLEMENT IS MY UNDERSTANDING AM NOT AN ATTORNEY AND INSURANCE AGENT; I'VE STUDIED THIS. IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THE JURY GOES THROUGH A PROCESS AND DECIDES WITH THE ACTUAL DAMAGES TO THE PLAINTIFF . THEN THEY GO THROUGH IT ASSIGN PERCENTAGES OF NEGLIGENCE IN ANY AMOUNT OF RECOVERY THAT PLAINTIFF WOULD HAVE WOULD BE REDUCED BY THE AMOUNT OF NEGLIGENCE THAT'S ASSIGNED TO THEM. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: I WILL GIVE YOU THE ANSWER. THE ANSWER ZERO. ZERO. SHE SAID 40% THE CAP COMPANIES THAT 30 THE TRUCKING COMPANIES AT 30 SHE GETS ZERO BECAUSE YOU CANNOT RECOVER IF YOU ARE AT FAULT SINGLE PERCENTAGE OR HAIR OFF PERCENTAGE MORE THAN ANY OTHER PERSON AND YOU CANNOT RECOVER. YOU GET ZERO DOLLARS. THAT'S WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING TO DOING THIS. WE'LL TRUCKERS AND INSURANCE COMPANIES WANT TO PAY LESS THAN THIS. BUT MY LAST QUESTION MR. SPEAKER IF I COULD; REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; HOW MUCH WILL THE REST OF THE SAFE IN AUTO INSURANCE COSTS OR INSURANCE COSTS IF WE PASS THIS BILL WITH YOUR PROVISION IN IT? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: THANK YOU FOR THAT QUESTION REPRESENTATIVE LESCH BECAUSE YOU ARE RIGHT. THEY SHOULD PUT DOWNWARD PRESSURE ON INSURANCE PREMIUMS ON AUTO INSURANCE PREMIUMS. THOSE TWO ROLE OF THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT IS TO ENFORCE THE STATUTE OF HIS DREAMS CANNOT BE EXCESSIVE THEY CANNOT BE INADEQUATE AND THEY CANNOT BE DISCRIMINATE. WERE PUTTING IN PROVISIONS THAT BRINGS MORE FAIRNESS INTO ALL OUR LOSSES ARE SETTLED MESS WITH THIS PROVISION DOES; THEN YOU ARE RIGHT. VISHNU DOWNWARD MOVEMENT ON WITH THE AUTO PREMIUMS ARE. NOW YOUR PRIOR QUESTION WERE TALKING ABOUT THE COMPARATIVE NEGLIGENCE THRESHOLD AND WITHOUT MEANS MEMBERS IS THAT IF THE VICTIM C AN ONLY COLLECT FOR PEOPLE MORE AT FAULT IN AN INCIDENT LIKE CAR ACCIDENT IN THIS CASE THAN THEY ARE. A CHANGE THAT THRESHOLD I DON'T WANT NO I WANT TO SAY THE LAST EIGHT YEARS MAYBE SOMETHING LIKE THAT. I WAS NOT HERE OBVIOUSLY BUT THEY CHANGED IT AS FAR AS WOULD GET STUCK PAYING FOR EVIDENT THAT THROUGH THE TERM DEEP POCKETS. THAT'S WHERE THAT COMES FROM. REPRESENTATIVE LESCH; THE IMPORTANCE OF AWARENESS HE FELT WERE NOT WEARING A SEATBELT IS FILLED OUT CORRECTLY THAT A SENIOR BEAUTIFUL DAUGHTER TIME I'VE A GRANDDAUGHTER THAT SAME AGE. WHEN I TAKE HER IN A VEHICLE AND MAKE SURE TO PUT IT IN A CAR SEAT. I PUT HER IN A CAR SEAT BECAUSE I KNOW THAT IS SAFE THAT IS SAFER B UT EVERYONE UNDERSTANDS THAT. IF I FAILED TO DO THAT IF I FAILED TO PUT MY SEATBELT ON I'M NOT AS SACRED VOWS MY NEGLIGENT ACT. THAT WAS MY DETERMINATION. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH ON A NOT ASK AN Y MORE QUESTIONS BECAUSE I'M KIND OF GETTING THE STINK EYE FROM YOU SO WHAT I WILL SAY IS THIS. MEMBERS; SEATBELT USE OF MINNESOTA IS AT -OVER 94%. THAT'S 90% FOR WOMEN. I DON'T SEE ANYTHING IN THIS BILL THAT'S GOING TO INCREASE SEATBELT USE . ALL I SEE ARE PROVISIONS THAT ARE 28 HANDOFF TO INSURANCE COMPANIES. AGAIN. WE SAW WITH THE HEALTH INSURANCE COMPANIES AT THE BEGINNING OF THE SESSION WE SAW IT WITH TRAINS JUST THE OTHER DAY FOR INSURANCE COMPANIES. JUST LOOKING TO GIVEAWAY TO INSURANCE COMMISSIONER THAT DOWNWARD PRESSURE YOU TALK ABOUT REPRESENTATIVE COMPANY WHICH HER MONEY WHERE YOUR MOUTH IS. LET' S SEE SOME REAL NUMBERS ABOUT WHAT WERE ACTUALLY GOING TO SAVE AND INSURANCE PREMIUMS. BUT WITHOUT THOSE REAL NUMBERS IN THE BILL; ALL IT IS IS A GIVEAWAY. IT DOESN'T DO ANYTHING FOR MINNESOTANS. I T DOESN'T DO ANYTHING FOR SAFER STREETS. ALL DOES IS ALLOW INSURANCE COMPANY LAWYERS TO GET INFORMATION IN FRONT OF JURIES THAT THEY THINK IS GOOD TO MAKE PEOPLE LOOK BAD. SO; YES; MY DAUGHTER NIGHT; SO SHE'S A PEACH FOR SILLY ACTIVITY HERE TALK ING TO YOU FINE PEOPLE AND SET UP GOING WITH HER THE FACT IS I LOVE SPENDING TIME WITH HER AND I REMEMBER WHEN SHE WAS BORN MY WIFE I S NOT UPSTAIRS THIS TIME; WHICH HE MADE US GO DOWN TO THE FIRE STATION TO GET THE CAR SEAT PUT IN AND YOU COULD'VE HEARD MY EYES ROLL FROM A MILE AWAY. GIMME A BREAK I COULD READ INSTRUCTIONS AND PUT THE CAR SEAT IN THE RIGHT WAY. IT'S A NEWFANGLED EUROPEAN MODEL WITH SCOTT THE FOOT THAT SITS ON THE FLOOR WERE SOMETHING THAT KICKS OUT. I WONDER IF I HAD USE THE OLD MINNESOTA MERRICK AND INGENUITY DECIDED TO READ THE INSTRUCTIONS TO PUT THAT SEATBELT AND AN SOMETHING HAD HAPPENED AND I KNOW EXACTLY THE KIND OF LINE OF QUESTIONING I WOULD GET FROM AN INSURANCE COMPANY LAWYER FROM 80 MAIN DOOR DECEASED CHILD TRIAL AND THAT WOULD BE ; DID YOU GO DOWN TO THE FIRE STATION EQUIPPED TO OTHER OPTIONS DID YOU DO ANY KIND OF SUMMER TO MAKE SURE YOU PUT IN THE RIGHT WAY? THIS IS THE KIND OF THING THAT REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN WANTS INSURANCE; YOU WARRIORS TO BE ABLE TO DO TO YOU. SHOULD TRAGEDY EVER BEFALL ON YOU OR A FAMILY MEMBER. AT THE WORST TIME OF YOUR LIFE WHEN YOU'RE SUFFERING AND BREATHING MORE THAN YOU EVER COULD THEY WANT TO MAKE YOU THINK IT IS YOUR FAULT. BY THE WAY; TAKE A BIG OLD PAYDAY ALONG WITH IT. THAT IS SAD. THE RE IS NO REASON JURORS NEED TO GET THAT INFORMATION ABOUT YOU OR YOUR FAMILY BECAUSE YOU CAN WEAR YOUR SEATBELT WHICH I VOTED AGAINST BY THE WAY AND I'LL PUNCH YOU IN THE FREEDOM CAUCUS DID YOU. PRIMARY CIPRO. THEY WANT USE THAT AGAINST YOU. AND THE WORST TIME OF YOUR LIFE. GO LOOKS CLEAN ON THE HILSTROM AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM >> REPRESENTATIVE TRY NOSECONE JUST HAVE TWO QUESTIONS; REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN:. REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN HIGHLIGHT HUBEI WAS WEARING MY SEATBELT? DON'T WAS PEOPLE GET OUT OF THE CAR WHEN THERE'S A CRASH ? HOW DO THEY THEN PROVE THEY ACTUALLY WERE WEARING THEIR SEATBELT? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION. AT THIS SCENE OF THE ICE OF THE OPPOSITE IS COULD YOU FILL OUT AN INCIDENT REPORT THAT'S WHAT QUESTIONS PEER THAT IS CURRENT AS NOTHING. THIS BILL DOES NOT CHANGE THAT. >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM: REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; HOW MANY MORE TRIALS WITH THIS BILL REQUIRED AND HOW MUCH DOES IT COST THE JUDICIARY? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: I DO KNOW THE ANSWER TO THAT KID I KNOW ACTUALLY A SMALL NUMBER OF CASES GO ALL THE WAY TO TRIAL. THE VAST MAJORITY THE BULK OF THEM ARE ACTUALLY SETTLED OUTSIDE OF COURT. >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM : REPRESENTATIVE CHUMLEY; THE COURT DISAGREES WITH THE GROUP MEMBERS I'VE A FISCAL NOTE RIGHT HERE. PREPARED BY THE COURT. IT SAYS THAT THE FULL-TIME EQUIVALENT POSITIONS ARE THREE FTES IN THE BIENNIUM WILL COST $851;000 . IN THE SECOND BIENNIUM $818;000. YOU CAN EXPECT IT TO BE MORE CASES THAT WILL GO TO TRIAL I T ACTUALLY COST MORE THAN AN ENTIRE JUDGE UNITS. LET ME REPEAT THAT. THESE CASES WILL BE A NEW ENTIRE JUDGE UNITS. OR MORE. WHY SET THE CASE MEMBERS? IS BECAUSE MORE PEOPLE ARE GOING TO TRY TO PAY LESS. THEY WILL FIGHT IT OUT IN COURT BECAUSE YOU HAVE THE HIGHER EXPERT WITNESSES. MEMBERS; I WANT YOU TO KNOW THERE'S ALSO TO THINGS IN STATUTE THAT WE KEPT JURIES FROM HER BECAUSE WANT PEOPLE TO GET A FAIR HEARING. IN ADDITION TO KEEPING THEM FROM HEARING WHETHER OR NOT YOU HAVE INSURANCE WE ALSO UNDER MINNESOTA STATUTE 169.94; TO NOT PERMIT THE ADMISSIBILITY OF EVIDENCE OF YOUR CONVICTION . SPECIFICALLY SAYS; NO RECORD OF THE CONVICTION OF THE PERSON FOR ANY VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER SHALL BE ADMISSIBLE AS EVIDENCE IN ANY COURT IN ANY CIVIL ACTION. SO WHILE REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN MAKES HIS ARGUMENT THAT THE JURY SHOULD HEAR EVERY PIECE OF EVIDENCE ; WE HAVE DECIDED AS A BODY AND ASSIST STATE WHAT IS FAIR EVIDENCE FOR THE JURY TO HEAR. MEMBERS REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN IS GOING ALONG WE HAD TO BENEFIT INSURANCE COMPANIES CAUSE THEM TO PAY LESS. I THINK IT IS WRONG AND ASK YOU TO GO LOOKS IN FAVOR OF MY AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE PINTO >> REPRESENTATIVE PINTO WHO WOULD'VE THOUGHT SUCH A SIMPLE PROVISION OF SUMMIT HOMES IS OUR HOPE POINT OUT OF CONCERN ON BEHALF OF KIDS. THIS BIN REFERENCE BEFORE THE CHILD RESTRAINT SEATS AT THIS WON'T TAKE TOO LONG BUT I DO WANT TO POINT OUT THAT THIS BILL WOULD PROHIBIT WHETHER OR NOT A KID WAS A CHILD RESTRAINT SEAT FROM BEING- TAKEN OUT AS WILL MY CONCERN THIS WILL WILL PUNISHING KIDS IN CAR I THEY NOT DON'T PUT THEMSELVES IN THESE SEATS. IF THERE'S A MISTAKE IN TERMS OF BUCKLEY AND THE MEN OR REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN REFERENCES FAMILIES WELL SO MY QUESTION RECOGNIZING THIS WOULD WE PUNISH KIDS WERE IN THOSE CAR ACCIDENTS BY ALLOWING WHETHER OR NOT THEY WERE IN THE SEA TO BE USED IN THE CASE IS THAT YOUR INTENT OF THOSE KIDS WHO BROUGHT IN AND HAVE THEM EXTRINSIC PUNISHMENT AS WELL AND IS ADDITION TO OTHERS? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION REPRESENTATIVE PINTO. NO; THAT'S NOT MY INTENT. I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE NUMBERS. AGAIN I'M NOT A LAWYER BUT I BELIEVE THAT A CHILD THAT IS A MINORITY AGE IS NOT CONSIDERED PEOPLE COMMITTING AN INTENTIONAL ACT IS HELD TO A DIFFERENT STANDARD THAN ADULT WOULD BE. >> REPRESENTATIVE PINTO: IF YOU DON'T WANT TO HAVE KIDS BE A BROUGHT IN UNDER THIS PROVISION I WAS SUGGEST YOU SUPPORT THE HILSTROM AMENDMENT. THIS CLEARLY NEEDS MUCH MORE WORK TO GET THIS WILL DOUBT IT ALLOWS THE USER NONUSE OF THE CHILD RESTRAINT TO BE USED AND INTRODUCES EVIDENCE IN TRIAL. S O IF YOUR INTENT IS TO NOT HAVE THAT BE BROUGHT IN REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN CAN I WAS CERTAINLY SUGGEST YOU SUPPORT THE HILSTROM AMENDMENT. IN ADDITION TO THIS BY PEOPLE NOT REQUIRED TO BE WEARING SEATBELTS. FOR EXAMPLE; FOLKS INVOLVED IN FARMING DURING FARM ACTIVITIES. DRIVING OR RIDING IN A PICKUP TRUCK REPRESENTATIVE CHUMLEY; IS YOU INCLUDING THOSE PEOPLE BECAUSE THEY'RE NOT REQUIRED TO THE SEATBELT BUT INSURANCE COMPANIES COUL D INTRODUCE THEIR USER NONUSE OF THE SEATBELT. IS IT YOUR INTENTION OF THEM BE PUNISHED AND BROUGHT IN BY THIS WILL AS WELL? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: THANK YOU REPRESENTATIVE PINTO. HERE'S WHAT THE HEAVY LIFTING THE GAG ORDER DOES. IT ALLOWS IN EACH CASE BASED ON THE EVIDENCE OF EACH CASE; TO DECIDE WHAT EVIDENCE IS ADMISSIBLE AND WHAT IS A GOOD THAT'S WHERE DOES IT THE CASE THAT YOU'RE CITING RIGHT NOW; WOULD BE MY ASSUMPTION BUT JUST MY ASSUMPTION- THAT DURING THOSE FEW RULES OF EVIDENCE THEY WOULD SAY THAT'S NOT ADMISSIBLE. >> REPRESENTATIVE PINTO: I'M NOT SURE WHY THE PERSON BEING REQUIRED OR NOT REQUIRED TO THE SEATBELT WOULD BE A ALL RELEVANT; JUST LIKE WHETHER OR NOT THE PERSON WEARING THE SEATBELT WOULD NOT BE RELEVANT TO WHETHER OR NOT AN ACCIDENT OCCURS GOOD ALL DAY TO THE CONCLUSION MEMBERS CHRIS IS A LONG TIME ON THIS PROVISION; JUST TO POINT OUT; KIDS; PEOPLE ENGAGE IN FARM CARRIED MAIL CARRIERS BELOW DON'T HAVE A CIPRO AVAILABLE AFTER LEADER VEHICLE NUMBER OF THESE PEOPLE ARE REQUIRED TO WEAR SEATBELT AND WHAT WE ARE DOING UNDER THIS UNDERLYING BILL PUTTING THIS EVIDENCE IT FRONT OF THE JURY HAVE IT BE CONSIDERED IN FACT IT HAS NO RELEVANCE AS TO WHETHER A ACTION HAS OCCURRED. MEMBERS APPRECIATES THE CHUMLEY TALK ABOUT KIDS AND THESE ARE THE GROUP SHOULD THIS NEEDS A LOT MORE WORK FOR GO FORWARD AT ALL AND MEMBERS I WOULD URGE YOU TO VOTE SCREEN AND DEFEAT THIS PROVISION. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION? THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL. >>[ROLL CALL VOTE]. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: [INAUDIBLE] 66 NAY MOUSE IS NOT ADOPTED THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: CONSIDINE MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS FOLLOWS. THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 30. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE >> REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE: MR. SPEAKER I THINK THERE'S A AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE'S A AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: CORNISH MOVES TO AMEND THE CONSIDINE AMENDMENT. TO SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 42 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: CHAIRMAN CORNISH TO YOUR AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH: THE A- 42 AMENDMENT AMENDS A- 30 EXTENDS THIS ON-SITE DATE BUT SPECIFIES THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT WOULD BE REQUIRED OF THE BOUNCE IN THE RAILROAD OF PIPELINE SAFETY ACCOUNT IT GOES BELOW 1 MILLION SHOULD ALSO INCREASE THE APPROPRIATION FOR URBAN SAFETY ROPE CROSSINGS BY $100 THOUSAND WHICH WILL FUND BALANCES CURRENTLY 6.2 MAY BE WILL TO CONTINUE EXPANDING THE USE OF THIS FUN TO IMPROVE SAFETY AT RAILROAD CROSSINGS WITHOUT THE NEED TO CONTINUE THIS SPECIAL RAILROAD AND PIPELINE TAX. MR. SPEAKER; THE REASON FOR THIS AMENDMENT IS THERE WAS A TWO-YEAR AGREEMENT; AN AGREEMENT THAT WENT ON WITH THE RAILROAD AND ITS SON SAID. WELL; THEN HAVING A SUNSET DATE AND ALWAYS SEVEN THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY CAME INTO TESTIFIED JU ST SAID THERE WERE GOING TO EXTEND THAT THEY HAD NOT DONE ANY TALKING TO THE RAILROAD. SO SINCE IT WAS AN AGREEMENT THAT WAS ENDED WE DECIDED TO END IT SO THAT' S WHAT THIS IS ALL ABOUT NOW WITH THE AMENDMENT AND THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT COULD REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE ADDRESSES A FURTHER REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER I LIKE TO YIELD TO HIM EVENTUALLY TO TALK ABOUT IT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER >> REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER: THANK YOU CHAIRMAN CORNIS H FOR BRINGING THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT FORWARD TO AT A MEASURE OF SAFETY TO OUR RAIL SYSTEMS IN A RAIL CROSSINGS. I'VE UNIQUE SITUATION IN MY DISTRICT WHICH FRANKLY IS PROBABLY SIMILAR TO MANY VIEWERS. THERE IS SPINE OF MY DISTRICT IS THE BURLINGTON NORTHERN FREIGHT LINE. WE HAVE THE UNIT TRAINS THAT GO THROUGH ROUGHLY EVERY 20 AND 30 MIN. AS THEY TRAIN THAT RUNS THROUGH . FIVE MY SIX MAJOR CITIES IN MY DISTRICT. ALSO THE DISTRICTS ANYWHERE OF THAT WHOLE LINE YOU CAN GO FROM MOREHEAD ALL-ENCOMPASSING CLOUD THESE UNIT TRAINS MEMBERS THAT CARRY EVERYTHING. THEY CARRY EVERYTHING FROM NUMBER TWO CHEMICALS TO PETRO CHEMICALS TO SOMETIMES THE THINGS WE DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT THEY ARE CARING; MEMBERS. THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT TO OUR SAFETY. I CAN TELL YOU RIGHT NOW WITH THE THE AMENDMENT IS ADOPTED. TALKING OILFIELDS SOMETIMES THOSE TRAINS THOSE UNIT TRAINS OF TWO HUNDRED 10 CARS APIECE. THE FLASHPOINT IF YOU ASK ANYONE IN FIREFIGHTING THE FLASHPOINT FOR BOK INCLUDE OIL IS VERY LITTL E RATE COMPARED TO OTHER PETROL LOOK AT IT ONLY TAKES ONE MEMBERS ONE TANKER CAR IN THIS POST-9/11 WORLD TO EXPLODE TO SET OFF THE OTHER 109 CARS AND 110 UNIT TRAIN SYSTEM. ONE CAR . ONE CAR CAN FLY UP TO THREE QUARTERS OF A MILE AFTER IT EXPLODES. MEMBERS COME IF WE HAVE 110 OF THESE GOING OFF INSIDE ANYONE'S COMMUNITY MAY GOD HAVE MERCY ON ALL OF US. MEMBERS; VERY GRATEFUL THAT CHAIRMAN CORNISH WAS ABLE TO BRING THIS FORWARD. THIS MIMICS TO THE AMENDMENT IT GUARANTEES. AS I READ IT IF [INAUDIBLE] THIS WILL KICK IN AND ALSO ALLOCATES EXTRA FUNDING TO MNDOT. SO CHAIRMAN CORNISH UNGRATEFUL YOU THE FORESIGHT TO SEE THIS TO OFFER THE MIMICS TO THIS AMENDMENT AND MEMBERS COME AGAIN I WOULD LIKE YOU TO MEMBER VIEW OF A REAL SYSTEM VIEW OF ANY RAIL AT ALL IN YOUR DISTRICT IS OR TO YOU. ANOTHER EXAMPLE IS TO REVIEW MIGHT SAY WEALTH WE DON'T HAVE ANY PETRO PRODUCTS: ON. NONE. BUT I CAN TELL YOU WHAT YOU DO HAVE. YOU HAVE FARM CHEMICALS. THOMPSON [INAUDIBLE] AMMONIA IS USED FREQUENTLY IN THE AGRICULTURE INDUSTRY. IT'S WHAT HELPS TO MAKE THIS THRIVE IN OUR ECONOMY. BUT MEMBERS IT ONLY TAKES ONE ANHYDROUS LEAK TO WIPE OUT AN ENTIRE COMMUNITY. WE HAVE A SITUATION A COUPLE DECADES BACK IN REVERSE POPULATION IS WORKING AT NIGHT. WHEN A SITUATION WHERE WE HAD A TRAIN DERAILED. IT WAS AN ACCIDENT AND I JUST CART IT WAS AN ANHYDROUS LEAK. THE ONLY THING MEMBERS; THE ONLY THING THAT KEPT THAT ANHYDROUS FROM BECOMING LETHAL IN WIPING OUT AN ENTIRE COMMUNITY NEWLY REASON YOU NEVER HEARD ABOUT IT IN THE NEWS BECAUSE THE IMMUNE AIR TEMPERATURE WAS ABOUT 43°. IT KEPT THAT ANHYDROUS FROM SPREADING TO GET THAT DOWN CLOSE TO THE GROUND THERE BUT TO CONTAIN IT AND ABLE TO TAKE CARE OF THAT PROBLEM. MEMBERS; THAT AMBIENT AIR TEMPERATURE CAN 40° OR HIGHER; WE PROBAB LY BE STILL TALKING ABOUT THIS NOT TO NAME THE COMMUNITY BECAUSE A CAUSE OF LOT OF DISTRESS TO THE MEMBERS THAT LIVE IN THE COMMUNITY COULD THEY DON'T WANT TO THINK ABOUT IT. MEMBERS OF THINGS THAT TRAVEL ON OUR RAILS ARE IMPORTANT TO OUR ECONOMY. IMPORTANT TO THE WAY WE LIVE. IMPORTANT TO THE VERY STRUCTURE OF OUR SOCIETY. MUST HAVE RAIL. BUT THERE'S A SITUATION WE HAVE TO DEAL WITH IT IT'S CALLED SAFETY. CHAIRMAN CORNISH ONCE AGAIN I'D LIKE TO THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THIS AMENDMENT TO THE MIMICS. FOR ADDING ADDITIONAL FUNDING AND WITHOUT MEMBERS WOULD ASK YOU FOR A YES VOTE ON THE CHAIRMAN CORNISH'S AMENDMENT THIS AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HORNSTEIN >> REPRESENTATIVE HORNSTEIN; MEMBERS I WOULD ALSO URGE A YES VOTE. THIS PROVISION WAS INCLUDED IN ORIGINAL 2014 WIL L SAFETY LEGISLATION I THINK REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER TO THE NEXT JOB OF DESCRIBING SOME OF THE SCENARIOS THAT WE WORR Y ABOUT. THOSE ARE ASHES FROM THE SCENARIOS WE DISCUSSED ON FRIDAY WHEN WE ACTUALLY LET THE RAILROAD'S OFF LIABILITY INSURANCE. SO THAT IS WHY I HOPE THIS ISSUE CAN BE REVISITED WE TALKED ABOUT ON FRIDAY ON LIABILITY AND SECONDLY; WE HAVE RECENTLY; AS RECENTLY AS JUST NOVEMBER 2016 HAD A MAJOR ACCIDENT IN ALLENDALE MINNESOTA. THE ENTIRE TOWN WAS EVACUATED I THINK IT'S BEEN REPRESENTED THAT THIS IS A SAFE INDUSTRY AND EVERYTHING IS GREAT AND THERE ARE STILL OUTSTANDING ISSUES. SO EXTENDING THIS SUNSET IS A GOOD IDEA AND I WOULD SUPPORT IT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH MR. SPEAKER ONE LAST THING. WE ALSO HAVE PENDING LEGISLATION WHERE SOME OF THE FIRST RESPONDERS AND THE ROAD COMPANIES HAVE BEE N IN DISCUSSION BECAUSE THERE'S NOT THE KIND OF COMMUNICATION THAT WE NEED TO HAVE BETWEEN THE FIRST RESPONDERS AND THE RAIL COMPANIES THAT LEGISLATION HAS ALSO BEEN INTRODUCED. I DID A VERSION OF IT GOO D THAT LEGISLATION IS JUST SITTING WAITING TO BE ACTED ON. WE NEED TO DO THAT THE SESSION AS WELL. SO THIS IS REALLY IMPORTANT WITH A COUPLE OF THE RAIL SAFETY ITEMS THAT NEED TO BE ADDRESSED. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE >> REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE: REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH ; THERE'S A SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION FOR $100;000 FOR RAIL RATE CROSSING IS THAT IN ADDITION TO THE 500;000 THAT I HAVE IN THE AMENDMENT WAS THAT REPLACING THE 500;000 WITH 100;000? >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH: THAT IS IN ADDITION. >> REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE: IN ADDITION. THANK YOU MR. CHAIR AND REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH. GOODNESS; I LIKE THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT. THIS RAIL SAFETY ACCOUNT IS A 2.5 MILLION DOLLAR ASSESSMENT TO THE RAILROADS AND PIPELINES FOR RAILROAD AND PIPELINE SAFETY. WE HAVE SOMETHING IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD OF 4000 AT GRADE CROSSINGS. A LOT OF THEM LIKE REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER'S OR THERE'S ONE IN ANOKA AND NOT EVEN SURE WHOSE DISTRICT THAT IS IN-IT IS EWERS?-EXTREMELY DANGEROUS. I GUESS THE ONLY THING I WOULD SAY IS THAT I THINK WE SHOULD PROBABLY KEEP THIS ASSESSMENT AND UNTIL WE DEAL WITH THOSE . THESE ARE SAFETY ISSUES THAT ARE DIRECTLY ATTRIBUTABLE TO THE RAILROADS IN THE PIPELINES DOING BUSINESS IN MINNESOTA. BUT I WOULD URGE EVERYBODY FOR A CLEAN VOTE FOR REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH'S AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE FRANKE >> REPRESENTATIVE FRANKE: I RISE IN SUPPORT OF CHAIRM AN CORNISH'S AMENDMENT. I DON'T KNOW HOW MANY BE NOBODY IN MY AREA WE HAD TWO YEARS AG O SEMITRUCK VERSUS A TRAIN. IT HAPPENED TO BE RIGHT ALMOST SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE OF WESTERN REFINERY. SO IN MY AREA I CPA RAILROAD. I PNS RAILROAD OF RUN ALMOST COINCIDE STRAIGHT THROUGH WESTERN REFINERY. SO WHEN IT COMES TO BILL SAFETY AND PIPELINE SAFETY THIS IS A BIG CONCERN OF MINE AND CITIZENS IN MY AREA. SO AT THE TIME THIS AT THE RAILROAD CROSSING WHERE THE ACCIDENT HAPPENED WAS THE FIFTH MOST DANGEROUS ON GOV. DEAN'S LIST OF AT GRADE RAILROAD CROSSINGS. THROUGH THE HELP OF THE GOVERNOR AND OTHERS STAKEHOLDERS AND THE RAILROAD ASHLEY KICK IN A LITTLE BIT WE WERE ABLE TO GET THAT CROSSING CLOSED AND REDESIGN. SOME IN BIG SUPPORT OF THIS IN ANY FASHION I WOULD THINK THE CHAIRMAN FOR BRINGING FORTH AND REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE. THANK YOU >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE LOEFFLER >> REPRESENTATIVE LOEFFLER: MEMBER S I WANT TO SAY I WAS DISAPPOINTED IN THE ORIGINAL BILL THAT SUNSET IT THIS KEY FUNDING SOURCE FOR PUBLIC SAFETY AND WHILE THE TWO WEEK YEAR EXTENSION IS BETTER THAN NOTHING I'VE GOT TO SAY PROTECTING OUR COMMUNITIES IS AN ONGOING RESPONSIBILITY A S REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER DID A NICE JOB OF SHARING HOW SCARY THESE KIND OF SITUATIONS CAN BE I REPRESENT A DISTRICT WITH TWO RAILROAD YARDS. I THINK 27 RAILROAD BRIDGES; PROBABLY 45-50 AT GRADE GRADE CROSSINGS AND MY ABSOLUTELY ENTIRE DISTRICT IS IN THE AQUATIC BLAST ZONE IF USING THE BLAST ZONE MAPS. THIS IS NOT A MINOR ISSUE IN ANY PART OF OUR STATE. I THINGS GOING TO BE AN ONGOING ISSUE WE WILL HAVE TO TRAIN FIRST RESPONDERS TO DO WITH NEW CHEMICALS; NEW SHIPMENTS NEW RISKS ONGOING AND I HOPE THIS EXTENSION EXISTS IS THE BEGINNING OF MAKING THIS MAKING AN ONGOING PART OF OUR SUPPORT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE CORNISH AMENDMENT TO THE CONSIDINE AMENDMENT? ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY; AYE. [CHORUS OF AYES.] OPPOSED; SAY NAY. THE MOTION PREVAILS. >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: TO THE CONSIDINE AMENDMENT AS AMENDED. DISCUSSION? ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY; AYE. [CHORUS OF AYES.] OPPOSED; SAY NAY. THE MOTION PREVAILS. THE AMENDMENT IS AMENDED TO THE BILL >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: HILSTROM MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED IN THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 35. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM; >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM; MEMBERS MY AMENDMENT ALSO GOES TO THIS RAILROA D SAFETY ASSESSMENT THAT IS PAID FOR BY THE RAILROADS. AMHERST; WE HAVE AN EMERGENCY RESPONSE TEAMS THAT WE HAVE ALL CROSSED THE STATE TO RESPOND TO EMERGENCIES. CURRENTLY; IN THE BILL IT TAKES THE MONEY TO FUND THOSE FROM THE FIRE SAFETY ACCOUNTS. WE HEARD FROM THE FOLKS OF THE FI RE SAFETY ACCOUNT THEY BELIEVE THAT WAS NOT THE PROPER PLACE TO BE FUNDING IT FROM A BELIEVE THE RAILROAD PIPELINE SAFETY ASSESSMENT IS A MORE APPROPRIATE PLACE. SO NUMBERS I WOULD ASK YOU SUPPORT THE MIMICS TO FUND THESE EMERGENCY RESPONSE TEAMS OUT OF THAT RAIL SAFETY ASSESSMENT THAT IS DUE TO SUNSET. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE'S A MIMICS TO THE HILSTROM MEMBERS. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIE F CLERK: CORNISH MOVES TO AMEND THE HILSTROM MIMICS TO SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 43 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: CHAIRMAN CORNISH >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH: B- 43 AMENDMENT MEANS THE A- SERVER BASIN IN THE SUNSET DATE BY COUPLE YEARS. TWO YEARS. IT SPECIFIES THE OWNER WILL SUSPECT WILL ONLY BE [INAUDIBLE] AND PIPELINE SAFETY ACCOUNT GETS TO THE $1 MILLION BUT I ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT ON THE A- 43 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT? REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM: MEMBERS I'M GOING TO ENCOURAGE YOU TO SUPPORT REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH'S MIMICS BECAUSE I WANT THE MONEY TO BE IN PLA Y BUT MEMBERS I WANT YOU TO KNOW THAT REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH DOESN 'T MAKE IT SO THAT IF THE MONEY THAT'S IN THE COUNT IS MORE THAN $1 MILLION I N THE ASSESSMENT DOES NOT CONTINUE IN HIS THE GOV.'S POSITION IS ASSESSMENT SHOULD CONTINUE WHILE HE REDUCES THE AMOUNT OF THE ASSESSMENT. HE DOES BELIEVE THAT ASSESSMENT SHOULD CONTINUE THIS WOULD SAY IT ONLY CONTINUES I F IT GOES TO $1 MILLION. SO WHILE I WOULD ENCOURAGE MEMBERS TO SUPPORT REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH'S AMENDMENT I WOULD ASK REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH TO CONSIDER IN CONFERENCE LOSING THAT PROVISION ABOUT $1 MILLION. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE CORNISH AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT? ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY; AYE. [CHORUS OF AYES.] OPPOSED; SAY NAY. AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT IS ADOPTED. >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: TO THE METRICS A S AMENDED. REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM: ELECT TO SEND A VERY STRONG MESSAGE TO THE SENATE THAT WE IN THE HOUSE LEAVE RAIL SAFETY IS VERY IMPORTANT FILM HOPING THAT EVERYONE WILL BE A GREEN VOTE AND ONGOING ASKED FOR ROLL CALL TWO AT THAT AMENDMENT TO THE BILL >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ROLL CALL HAS BEEN REQUESTED. SEEING FIFTEEN HANDS THERE WILL BE A ROLL CALL. DISCUSSION TO THE AMENDED AMENDMENT? THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL. >>[ROLL CALL VOTE] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THE CLERK WILL CLOSE THE ROLL. THERE BEING 129 TREMONT AND TWO TREE TO THE AMENDED MEMO SAYS ADOPTED. >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: BECKER-FINN MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 17. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE BECKER-FINN >> REPRESENTATIVE BECKER-FINN: MEMBERS; THIS AMENDMENT WOULD DELETE THE LANGUAGE IN THE BILL HE ANTI-PROTESTER LANGUAGE THAT INCREASES PENALTIES FOR THOSE WHO PARTICIPATE IN PROTESTS. I WANT TO START BY POINTING OUT THE IRONY HERE AS WE SIT HERE TODAY DEBATING THIS BILL THAT WOULD FURTHER PENALIZE PROTESTERS WE SIT IN A BUILDING THAT SITS ON REV. DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING JUNIOR BOULEVARD. HER BUSINESS CARDS ARE STATIONARY; THE SIGNS OUTSIDE THIS BUILDING ALL BEAR HIS NAME. WHEN WE HEARD THESE BILLS IN COMMITTEE I LEARNED THAT ON EVERYONE IN THIS BODY IS FAMILIAR WITH LETTER FROM UPPER MANHATTAN GET TO THE UNFAMILIAR IS PERHAPS DR. KING'S MOST WELL-KNOWN WRITING. THE LETTERS HE WROTE WHILE IN JAIL FOR PEACEFULLY PROTESTING. IN THAT LETTER; HE RESPONDED TO THOSE WHO WONDERED WHY HE CAME TO BIRMINGHAM IN THE FIRST PLACE. HIS ANSWER WAS; I AM BIRMINGHAM BECAUSE INJUSTICE IS IN HERE. SO I SUBMIT TO YOU THAT THE RECENT WOULD HAVE MORE PROTESTS RECENTLY IN OUR STATE IS THAT INJUSTICE IS HERE . I KNOW SOME YOU WILL WAY THAT AWAIT OR ARE NOT LISTEN BECAUSE YOU DO NOT SEE THE INJUSTICE. YOU DO NOT FEEL THE INJUSTICE. THAT ABILITY TO WAVE IT AWAY IS CALLED PRIVILEGE. IT IS NOT A PRIVILEGE THAT ALL MINNESOTANS OUT. I ASK YOU TO REALLY TRULY TRY TO PUT YOURSELF IN THE SHOES OF THOSE WHO PARTICIPATE IN PROTESTS. WHY DO YOU THINK THEY DO IT? IS IT TO THEM KNOW WHAT YOU? IS IT TO CAUSE TROUBLE? IS IT TO INCONVENIENCE YOU? THE REALITY IS THAT IT'S NOT ABOUT YOU. IT IS ABOUT DRAWING ATTENTION TO INJUSTICE. TH E ABILITY TO USE DIRECT ACTION AS A TOOL TO DRAW ATTENTION TO THAT INJUSTICE THAT THE CORE OF WHAT IT MEANS TO BE AMERICAN. ABO UT OUR HISTORY AMERICANS HAVE USED THIS TOOL TO MOVE OUR GREAT COUNTRY TOWARDS PROGRESS. EARLIER THIS SESSION WHILE WE WERE IN THE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE WE TALKED ABOUT FIREWORKS. SEVERAL REPRESENTATIVES WERE IN FAVOR OF EXPANDING THE FREEDOM TO BUY FIREWORKS. THE FIRE DEPARTMENT AND THE EMTS AND MANY IN THE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE TOLD US THIS WAS A BAD IDEA. FOR MANY REPUBLICANS ON THE COMMITTEE THE FREEDOM TO BUY AND SELL FIREWORKS SUPERSEDED ALL THOSE SA FETY CONCERNS. SO WHAT MESSAGE DO YOU THINK YOU ARE SENDING PARTICULARLY; TO THOSE WHO SUFFER THESE GREAT INJUSTICES IF WE ARE IN FAVOR OF FREEDOM TO BUY FIREWORKS COME UP BUT NOT IN FAVOR OF THE FREEDOM TO EXERCISE A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT? WHAT I'M FOR EVERYONE IN THIS ROOM AND EVERYONE WATCHING TO CONSIDER IS THAT THE MESSAGE YOU ARE SENDING ; THE PEOPLE OF MINNESOTA IS THAT IT'S MORE IMPORTANT FOR YOU TO BE FREE THAN IT IS FOR OTHERS. THAT; THAT IS PRIVILEGE AND THAT IS INJUSTICE. I WILL NOW SHARE WITH YOU THE WORDS OF DR. KING. WE KNOW THROUGH PAINFUL EXPERIENCE THAT FREEDOM IS NEVER VOLUNTARILY GIVEN BY THE OPPRESSOR. IT MUST BE DEMANDED BY THE OPPRESSED. FRANKLY; I'VE YET TO ENGAGE IN A DIRECT ACTION CAMPAIGN THA T WAS WELL-TIMED IN THE VIEW OF THOSE WHO'VE NOT SUFFERED UNDULY FROM THE DISEASE OF SEGREGATION. LAW ENFORCEMENT TO NOT ASK YOU TO MAKE THIS CHANGE REGARDING PENALTIES. PROSECUTORS ARE NOT ASK YOU TO MAKE THIS CHANGE. ST . PAUL AND MINNEAPOLIS DID NOT ASK YOU TO MAKE THIS CHANGE IN THE PEOPLE OF MINNESOTA DID NOT ASK YOU TO MAKE THIS CHANGE. I ENCOURAGE A YES VOTE ON THIS AMENDMENT TAKE THE LANGUAGE OUT OF THE BILL. THANK YOU. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION? CHAIRMAN KNOBLACH >> REPRESENTATIVE KNOBLACH I LIKE TO REQUEST A ROLL CALL ON THIS AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ROLL CALL HAS BEEN REQUESTED. SEEING FIFTEEN HANDS THERE WILL BE A ROLL CALL. CHAIRMAN KNOBLACH >> REPRESENTATIVE KNOBLACH: MEMBERS; PEOP LE HAVE A RIGHT TO PROTEST. PEOPLE HAVE A RIGHT TO FREEDOM OF SPEECH AND I FULLY SUPPORT THAT. BUT; THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT AN EXERCISING THOSE RIGHTS THEY NEED TO PUT THE LIVES AND LIVELIHOODS OF OTHER PEOPLE AT RISK. SO WHAT WE'VE GOT IN THIS BIL L IS LANGUAGE SAYING THAT YOU CAN'T BLOCK FREEWAYS. M OUNCES TRAVEL ON FREEWAYS. LAW ENFORCEMENT TRAVELS ON FREEWAYS. TAKING THIS LANGUAGE OUT ALLOWING PEOPLE TO PROTEST ON FREEWAYS WITH THE LIMITED PENALTIES THAT ARE IN IT RIGHT NOW THE HONORA BLE KURT L. DAUDT; SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE AND THE HONORABLE SANDRA L. PAPPAS; PRESIDENT OF THE [INAUDIBLE] >> REPRESENTATIVE ECKLUND AM GOING TO SAY THIS A LITTLE TOO LITTLE TOO LATE. YOU'RE IN THE WRONG STATE IN FACT. BACK IN YEAR 2004 WERE FREEWAY BLOCKAGES AND IT ACTUALLY SKEWED PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION. TOO LITTLE; TOO LATE. IT'S EMBARRASSING TO HEAR THAT YOU WANT TO ANALYZE MINNESOTANS FOR ENTHUSIASTICALLY EXPRESSION OF THEIR GRIEVANCES CONCERNING THE ACTIONS OF LAW-ENFORCEMENT OFFICIALS. YOU SEEM TO FORGET THIS PARTICULAR TACTIC WORKS WELL FOR GEORGE W. BUSH TO THANK YOU. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE THISSEN >> REPRESENTATIVE THISSEN: MEMBERS; I URGE YOU TO SUPPORT THIS MAN WORKS. THE PROTEST THAT WE ARE SEEING HERE IN MINNESOTA RECENTLY AND ACROSS THE COUNTRY ARE ONLY A REFLECTION OF A LARGER CRISIS FOR OUR DEMOCRACY. IT'S NOT JUST ON THE STREET IS IN OUR WORKPLACE. IT'S AT THE BALLOT BOX. THAT IS THIS BROUGHT UNEASY SENSE OF THIS-EMPOWERMENT THAT THEY ARE FEELING BETTER COMMITTEES AND THEMSELVES CAN CONTROL THEIR OWN DESTINY ANYMORE. THAT'S WAS UNDERLYING THIS. WE CAN SEE WHY. CITIZENS UNITED THAT AMPLIFY THE VOICES OF WEALTHY WELL-CONNECTED PEOPLE AT THE EXPENSE OF ORDINARY VOICES IN OUR ELECTION PROCESS. WE ARE SEEING MORE AND MORE AND MORE ECONOMIC POWER ESPECIALLY IN THE COMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY AND INFORMATION ECONOMY WILL BUY FEWER AND FEWER HUGE CORPORATIONS WHO REALLY DON'T HAVE ANY VAL UE AND SHOULDN'T BECAUSE THIS IS HOW WE SET THEM UP; VALUE FOR HUMAN BEINGS EXCEPT THEIR VALUE TO THE CORPORATE BOTTOM LINE. WE HAVE A GOVERNMENT ESPECIALLY IN WASHINGTON DC; BRIGHT HERE; IN THE STATE OF MINNESOTA MORE AND MORE UNFORTUNATELY THAT SIMPLY ISN'T RESPONSIVE AND CAN'T GET ANYTHING MEANINGFULLY DONE ANYMORE. NO WONDER; PEOPLE ARE FEELING THIS SENSE OF THIS EMPOWERMENT THIS FEELING THEY HAVE NO VOICE. THE PROTEST THAT WE'VE SEEN RECENTLY AS THE IN THE CASE REALLY THROUGHOUT OUR COUNTRY'S HISTORY IS THE VOICE OF THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN UNHEARD TO LONG DEMANDING TO BE HEARD. THAT IS PROBABLY THE MOST AMERICAN THING THAT THERE IS. IN FACT; YOU COULD DEFINE AMERICAN HISTORY IN THOSE WORDS. THAT'S AMERICAN HISTORY IS ABOUT MORE AND MORE PEOPLE DEMANDING THAT THEIR UNHEARD VOICE BE HEARD. SIMPLY BECAUSE WERE ANY CONVENIENCE STORE PROBABLY WAS MORE IMPORTANT BECAUSE WERE MADE UNCOMFORTABLE BY THOSE VOICES; SHOULD NOT GIVE US ANY RIGHT OR ANY REASON TO PUNISH THEM OR SHUT THEM DOWN. IN FACT; WHAT WERE DOING HERE TODAY IS EXACTLY THE WRONG SOLUTION TO OVERSEEING IN THIS COUNTRY. THE PROTESTS ARE NOT THE PROBLEM . THE PROBLEM IS THAT WE'VE HAD AN UNWILLINGNESS TO LISTEN TO AND RESPOND TO THESE PEOPLE WOULD HAVE NOT OTHERWISE BEEN HEARD. SO INSTEAD OF PUSHING THEM ASIDE WE SHOULD BE DOING IS INVITING THEM TO THE TABLE. WE SHOULD BE RESPONDING TO REAL PEOPLE'S NEEDS. WHEN ROBERT KENNEDY WENT TO DELANO CALIFORNIA TO BE WITH CAESAR CHAVEZ BACK IN 1966; THE YEAR I WAS BORN; -BY THE WAY PROTESTERS MARCHING DOWN THE HIGHWAY FROM THEIR FIELDS THEY WORKED INTO THE CAPITOL IN SACRAMENTO- HE SAID THIS. I THINK THIS REALLY CAPTURES WHAT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT TODAY. IN THE LAST ANALYSIS ; THE ANSWER IS THAT WE PASSED LAWS OF THE OLD REMEDY INJUSTICES. THAT'S WHAT WE SHOULD DO. THAT'S WHAT THOSE OF US IN GOVERNMENT SHOULD DO. WE SHOULD JUST DEPLORE THE VIOLENCE AND UP FOR THE LAWLESSNESS. WE SHOULD PASS THE LAWS THAT REMEDY WERE PEOPLE WRITE ABOUT. WE HAVE NOT BEEN DOING THAT. MEMBERS; INSTEAD OF PASSING THIS KIND OF LUCK I WOULD ENCOURAGE US TO DO THAT WORK TO PAY ATTENTION TO THAT. IT IS MUCH HARDER. IT REQUIRES MORE COURAGE THAN MAKING CRIMINALS OUT OF OUR FELLOW MINNESOTANS BECAUSE THEY FRIGHTEN US. BUT IN THE LONG TERM; IT IS THE BEST AND REALLY THE ONLY ANSWER TO DEALING WITH WHAT WE'RE SEEING IN OUR STATE AND COUNTRY COULD I WOULD ENCOURAGE A YES VOTE ON THE AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE PINTO >> REPRESENTATIVE PINTO: MEMBERS IT SEEMS TO ME WE CAN'T IGNORE THE CONTEXT WITHIN WHICH THIS PROVISION IS BEING PROPOSED. THIS IS PART OF A NATIONAL TREND. AS BILLS IN MANY STATES TARGETING PEOPLE WERE PROTESTING FOR THEIR RIGHTS THAT IS TRUE IN OUR STATE AS WELL. A TREND OF TARGETING PEOPLE WERE PROTESTING ON BEHALF OF THEIR RIGHTS. THIS WOULD'VE A PACKAGE OF BILLS ADVANCE BY THE MAJORITY . THIS ONE FOLKS ARE AWARE OF THAT'S MOVE THROUGH THE PROCESS ALONE THE GOVERNMENT TO SUE PROTESTERS FOR EXERCISING CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS. I CAN'T LEAVE ANYTHING MORE UN-AMERICAN OF THAT CONCEPT THE GOVERNMENT SUING PROTESTERS. I WANT TO NOTE THAT THIS STATE-RUN CERTAINLY NATIONAL TREND AS WELL STOPPING US FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT ARE PROXIES THEY DID NOT TESTIFY ON THIS BILL DID NOT TESTIFY THIS IT IS NO COINCIDENCE OF TARGETING PROTEST IS COMING AT THE SAME TIME A TREND OF PEOPLE INCREASINGLY SPEAKING UP ON BEHALF OF THEIR RIGHTS. MANY OF THEM MINNESOTANS OF COLOR AND IMMIGRANT PEOPLE FEEL DISPOSSESSED RECOGNIZING: ATTENTION TO RESPONDING TO FUNDAMENTAL INEQUITIES IN OUR SOCIETY. A SENSE THAT TOO OFTEN IN OUR SOCIETY WHAT YOU EXPERIENCED YOUR EDUCATION YOUR HEALTH YOUR INCOME; YES YOUR EXPERIENCE WITH THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM IS TOO OFTEN STATISTICALLY LINKED TO THE COLOR OF YOUR SKIN. INCREASING RECOGNITION OF THE ROLE THAT RACIAL DESCRIPTION BY DISPLAY IN A BROAD SET OF VARIOUS SOCIETY. ONE POINT OUT CONTRAST NUMBERS. SEVERAL YEARS AGO THERE WAS A TREND OF RIOT S ON COLLEGE CAMPUSES. QUITE A FEW. WERE TREMENDOUS PROPERTY DAMAGE AND INJURY FAR EXCEEDED MOST CASES THAT FROM THE PROTEST BY THIS BILL WHITE IN THOSE THESE SORTS OF CHANGES. RATHER THAN INCIDENTS PROTESTING FOR THEIR RIGHTS. INCREASING THE PENALTY FROM A 90 DAY MISDEMEANOR TO A ONE-YEAR GROSS MISDEMEANOR IS NOT GOING TO ACT AS A TOKEN PEOPLE DON'T GO TO THE LIBRARY POCKETBOOK AND OPEN UP AND LOOK AND SAY; GUESS WHAT; THE GROSS MISDEMEANOR AND I GUESS I WON'T GO OUT AND PROTEST TODAY. I WOULD'VE IT WOULD BE A MISDEMEANOR. THIS IS A RESPONSE TO INJUSTICE WHICH IS NOT BEING ADDRESSED. IT'S TRUE THIS MAY WELL SCARE SOME PEOPLE FROM ATTENDING CERTAIN EVENTS. AS THEY WAIT CHILL SPEECH AS WE THINK CONSTITUTIONAL LAW CHILL SPEECH PEOPLE TENDING TO ATTEMPTING CONSTITUTIONAL SPEECH. THE MIGHTY SMALL PULP PROTEST THE GHOSTLY PROCESS. THE MIGHTY BIGGER PROTESTS PEOPLE WHO FEEL THE SENSE OF INJUSTICE. I ANTICIPATE THE ARGUMENT THAT OFTEN WE ARE SUPPORTING ANY INCRE ASE IN PENALTIES IT IS NOT ABOUT DETERRENCE AS WELL. WELL; NO; MEMBERS; PENALTY WE IMPOSED FOR OFFENSES OFTEN AMONG ABOUT TO TURN. PLEASE NOT MIGHTY WAS A PROSECUTOR. THE PENALTIES NEVER TOLD THAT AN OFFENDER ACCOUNTABLE FOR BEHAVIOR THAT VIOLATES THE CITY NORMS. THAT IS THE POWER OF PROTEST OF COURSE THAT BREAKS THE LAW. IT IS SAYING; THE PEOPLE PROTESTING ARE SAYING WE THINK THAT SUCH AN UNFAIR SITUATION WERE WILLING TO VIOLATE SOCIETY'S NORMS AND IT EXCEPT CONSEQUENCE. THERE'S OF COURSE A LONG HISTORY IN OUR COUNTRY. MANY OF US ARE AWARE THAT BU T HOPING BECOMING EVER MORE WET BUT THE COST WAS UP TO BE COMMENSURATE WITH THE CONDO. AS A POLICY MAKER THE PROSECUTOR ON CONCERN THE PENALTY FOR OFFENSE BASED ON THE BROADER STRUCTURE [INAUDIBLE] WITH THE BROADER STRUCTURE HERE? I KNOW MISDEMEANOR 90 DAYS. WHAT'S ANOTHER EXAMPLE THE PENALTY THAT'S 90 DAYS? WELL; THE TWO- WAY FLOW WITH DOMESTIC ASSAULT. FIRST TIME YOU PUNCH YOUR SPOUSE GIRLFRIEND; BOYFRIEND; THAT IS A MISDEMEANOR. IT'S GOT A PRETTY HIGH LEVEL ENTRY TO GET TO GROSS MR. MIRROR WITHOUT IT ACTUALLY INFLICT A LOT OF DAMAGE BUT A LOT OF CUTS A LOT OF BRUISES THAT ARE STILL MISDEMEANOR DOMESTIC ASSAULT. THIS MORE SIGNIFICANT A VIOLATION THAN THAT? YOU THINK ABOUT PARTICULAR KINDS OF PROTEST IN THIS BILL. BUT THINKING ABOUT INTERSTATE SITUATIONS. I WOULD POINT OUT THIS IS FAR BROADER THAN THIS. YOU BLOCK THE ENTRANCE TO LIGHT RAIL TRAIN THAT QUALIFIES FOR THIS. IT'S ONLY PICKING IF YOU NOTICE HER; IS ONLY PICKING CERTAIN PROVISIONS TO BE INCREASED IN ONLY SOME KINDS OF BLOCK. NONE OF US ARE: THE PLOT TRANSPORTATION BILL. WE ALL KNOW WHAT THIS IS. DOES THE LOCK PROTEST OH. #WERE AIMING IN A SET SPEECH THAT'S WHY CHAIRMAN KNOBLACH; WITH RESPECT ABOUT PUBLIC SAFETY. IF THERE ARE INCIDENTS IN WHICH THERE IS A DAMAGE IN THAT CASE OTHER OFFENSES APPLY. WERE PICKING UP THE TICKER KINDS OF BLOCKING INCREASING APPEARED AGAIN THIS IS NOT THE REQUEST BY LAW ENFORCEMENT BY THOSE OFFICERS OUT THERE I WORK WITH EVERY DAY WORKING TO KEEP PEOPLE SAFE . THIS IS BEING PUSHED AS PART OF A SYSTEMIC AGENDA NATIONALISTS ON THE INTERSTATE TO SUPPRESS DISSENT. I JUST WANT- AND WITH A FINAL QUESTION ONTO FOLK SUPPORTED BY THE TEA PARTY? THE TEA PARTY WAS AN ILLEGAL PROTEST RIGHT? WE WENT TO 7073 UNTHINKABLE COMES TO KING GEORGE VERSUS THE AMERICAN REVOLUTIONARIES I WOULD KNOW WHICH SIDE YOU WOULD BE ON. VOTE; GREEN. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE FISCHER >> REPRESENTATIVE FISCHER: I'VE GOT THREE THINGS I'D LIKE TO SHARE IN REGARD TO THIS AMENDMENT. FIRST OF ALL ON ENCOURAGING PEOPLE TO VOTE SCREEN AND COMES FROM THREE DIFFERENT THINGS THAT COME TO MIND. NUMBER ONE IS BACK IN 79 I WAS INVOLVED IN A PEACEFUL PROTEST WAS A MINOR INJUSTICE GOING ON. AT THAT POINT INVOLVED IN OCCUPATIONAL [INAUDIBLE] EVENTUALLY MOVED IN AND WE OCCUPIED THE WEEKEND HERE IN THE STATE CAPITAL AND THE THERE FOR ABOUT A WEEK AND A HALF. THAT POINT IN TIME WILL POINT OUT BECAUSE WE FELT WAS MINOR INJUSTICE AT THE TIME WE WERE TO GO TO JAIL BECAUSE OF WHAT WAS GOING ON. THAT'S ONE OF FOCUS ON THE INJUSTICES IS WHEN PEOPLE FEEL THERE'S BEEN A GREAT INJUSTICE YOU CAN PUT A PENALTY OUT THAT THEY'RE GOING TO SAY THE PENALTY OF THEIR PILLS COMPARISON TO THE INJUSTICE. THAT BRINGS ME TO MY SECOND STORY. NOT LONG AGO THERE WAS A SHOOTING IN MINNEAPOLIS AT THE FOURTH PRECINCT I WORK AT A HOMELESS YOUTH SHELTER HALFWAY BETWEEN WHERE A PERSON WAS KILLED AND THE FOURTH PRECINCT. DURING THAT TIME THE NUMBER OF OUR YOUTH WERE INVOLVED WITH THE PROTESTS. ONE OF THE THINGS THAT CAME TO MY ATTENTION SOME PEOPLE LAW-ENFORCEMENT HAD CONTACTED ME AND TOLD ME THEY WERE SEEING A LOT OF SOME DISTURBING VIDEOS OUT THERE OF PEOPLE WHO WANTED TO COME TO THE PROTEST CREATE AN INCIDENT AND DO SOME SHOOTING BECAUSE THEY WERE TRYING TO SUPPORT RACISM OUT THERE WANT TO KILL SOME PEOPLE WHO WERE OF COLOR. PURE AND SIMPLE BACK INTO MY ATTENTION ABOUT A WEEK AND A HALF BEFORE THE SHOOTING. I FORMAT INFOR MED SOME OF OUR STUFF AND SOME OF OUR YOUTH SAYING THIS IS A DANGEROUS SITUATION YOU MAY NOT WANT TO GO THERE. WHAT ENDED UP HAPPENING IS SOME OF THE STAFF AND YOU DAVNIE AND SAID; THAT THE INJUSTICE THAT IS OUT THERE IS SO GREAT WE FEEL THAT WE COULD END UP DYING WITH HER WERE OUT THERE PROTESTING WERE NOT. SHORTLY AFTER THE SHOOTING TURNOUT ONE OF OUR YOUTH WERE THERE AND WAS GRAZED BY BULLET THAT OCCURRED AT THAT POINT IN TIME TO REMEMBER THESE ARE YOUTH I WANT IS A POSSIBILITY THEY COULD BE KILLED BEING THERE. THAT DID NOT STOP THEM FROM A PROTEST. THE NEXT THING I'LL MENTION GOING BACK TO A LEADER OF INDIA; GANDHI; BACK IN THE 40S; I WANT TO MENTION AN INCIDENT THAT STANDS OUT VERY STRONGLY THAT WHEN THEY GET THEIR PEACEFUL PROTEST AT THE SALTWORKS THEY WERE TRYING TO SHUT IT DOWN. HER MEMBER THESE PEOPLE COMING UP TO THE GATES OF THESE FACILITIES. THEY HAD CARDS. THAT THE POLICE ENFORCEMENT OF FRONT WITH WOODEN STICKS. EACH PEACEFUL PROTESTERS THEY WALKED FOR WAS BEATEN WITH A STICK INTO THE PEOPLE COLLAPSED AND WERE HAULED AWAY. THIS WENT ON FOR OUT TO THE ENTIRE DAY. WHEN ON SOME OF THE MULTIPLE TIMES >> >> >> MINNESOTA STATE GOVERNMENT; HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES FLOOR SESSION FOR MONDAY; APRIL 3; 2017 WILL RECONVENE SHORTLY. >> >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THE HOUSE WILL COME TO ORDER. CALENDAR FOR THE DAY. THE FIRST BILL ON THE CALENDAR FOR THE DAY IS HOUSE FILE 140. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE BILL. >> CHIEF CLERK: HOUSE FILE NUMBER 140 NUMBER ONE ON THE CALENDAR FOR THE DAY AND ACT RELATING TO EDUCATION 50 ENGROSSMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: TO THE BILL REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON I HAVE A AUTHORS AMENDMENT AT THE TABLE I LIKE TO TAKE UP PLEASE >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: ERICKSON MOVES TO AMEND HOUSE FILE NUMBER ONE 4050 ENGROSSMENT AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 35. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: TO THE A- 35 AMENDMENT REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: MEMBERS; THE A- 35 AMENDMENT IS BASICALLY A CLARIFICATION . FIRST OF ALL IT CHANGES THE MEMBERSHIP SLIGHTLY IN THAT THE PRINCIPLES NOW WILL ALTERNATE BETWEEN SECONDARY AND ELEMENTARY SPEECH OR EXCUSE ME CHAIRMAN ERICKSON >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: EXCUSE ME. MEMBERS PLEASE TAKE YOUR CONVERSATIONS TO THE ALCOVE OR THE BACK ROOM WHERE THE PARKING GARAGE REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON : THANK YOU. MEMBERS; AND OF COURSE; MR. SPEAKER THE OTHER CHANGE IN MEMBERSHIP WOULD BE ADDING A BOARD APPROVED TEACHER REPARATION. PROVIDER. WE THINK THAT'S IMPORTANT TO BE-WE LISTEN TO THIS IS MEDICS-35 SO YOU KNOW WE'VE BEEN LISTENING TO ALL THE CONCERNS THAT COME ALONG. WE ALSO DELETE SOME REDUNDANT LANGUAGE. WE ALSO MAKE SOME SPECIFICITY FOR ALLOWING THE BOARD TO DETERMINE CERTAIN TEACHER PREPARATION PROGRAMS ETC. SO WITH THAT; MEMBERS I WOULD ASK YOUR FOR YOUR SUPPORT ON THE A- 35. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE A- 30 AMENDMENT ? REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: I WONDER IS HE WENT TO ERIC WOULD YIELD TO A QUESTION? REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; SO PART OF THIS AMENDMENT ALLOWS FOR INSTEAD OF A-INSTEAD OF ONE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL SECONDARY SCHOOL PRINCIPAL THE BOARD WILL INSTEAD HAVE ONE STAFF MEMBER OF A BOARD APPROVED PROGRAM SHOULD I THINK THAT'S MOVING IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION. WHEN OF THE CONCERNS THAT WAS EXPRESSED ABOUT THE PROCESS HAD TO WORK ON IT [INAUDIBLE] HIGHER EDUCATION PRESENCE ON THIS NEW BOARD. THIS DOESN'T FULLY ANSWER THAT BUT I THINK IT MOVES IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION ONE OF YOU COULD SAY A LITTLE MORE ABOUT THE IMPORTANCE WORRIED YOU WERE DESIRES FOR HAVING ACCESS FOR HIGHER ED INDIVIDUALS ON THIS NEW BOARD? >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: WE DO THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO HAVE A REPRESENTATIVE OF TEACHER PREPARATION PROGRAM ON THE BOARD AND TO DO THAT I NEGOTIATED WITH THE PRINCIPLES ABOUT ALLOWING THEIR MEMBERSHIP TO BE ALTERNATING. SO WE WILL HAVE THAT STAFF MEMBER THAT'S BEEN TRADITIONALLY AND THAT WILL CONTINUE BUT WE WANT TO SPECIFICALLY MENTION THAT IT'S FROM A BOARD APPROVED TEACHER PREP PROGRAM PROVIDER. NOT SIMPLY SOMEONE FROM HIGHER EDUCATION. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: I THINK THAT'S A GOOD FAITH FIRST STEP AND I THINK YOU ARE MOVING THE BILL IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION THAT REGARD SO WOULD URGE MEMBER SUPPORT FOR THE BILL. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION ON THE A- 35 AMENDMENT ? ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY; AYE. [CHORUS OF AYES.] OPPOSED; SAY NAY. THE MOTION PREVAILS. THE AMENDMENT IS ADOPTED. >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: MARIANI MOVES TO AMEND HOUSE FILE ONE 4050 ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED. THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 33. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: MEMBERS THAT WOULD STILL MOVE THE AMENDMENT. MEMBERS; WITH THIS DOES RECENTLY FIRST OF ALL LET ME JUST SAY WE HAVEN'T TALKED ABOUT THE BILL BUT I THINK THE BILL CONTAINS A NUMBER OF IMPORTANT REFORMS FOR THE GOVERNANCE AND OVERSIGHT OVER TEACHER LICENSURE PROCESS IN THE STATE. I SUSPECT CHAIRMAN ERICKSON WILL SPEAK MORE ABOUT THAT AS WE GET TO THE THIRD HEARING. I THINK THAT-SO THEREFORE I THINK THERE'S IMPORTANT I THINK THE WAY WE WILL ANSWER THAT PARTLY WILL BE BASED ON WHAT YOUR PHILOSOPHY IS ROLLED TO DO THE EXPECTATION OF A PROFESSIONAL CLASS. IN PARTICULARLY THE PROFESSIONAL CLASSES AND TRUST WITH ONE MOST IMPORTANT THINGS WERE ASKING PEOPLE TO DO IN OUR SOCIETY WHICH IS TO GUIDE THE INSTRUCTION OF OUR YOUNG AND RK 12-E-12 SYSTEM. ONE OF THE PROVISIONS THAT I'M GETTING TOO MUCH DETAIL INTO THE BILL; THAT OCCURS UNDER THE LANGUAGE BEFORE US IS THAT IT REALLY DOES MAKE IT QUITE SIMPLY IN MY OPINION; TOO EASY FOR A ADMINISTRATOR TO HIRE LESS QUALIFIED PEOPLE. SO WE HAVE GOOD LOGIC BEHIND THE WEB OFFICE OF LEGISLATOR AUDITOR HAD RECOMMENDED WE CONSIDER CURE LICENSURE OF FRAMEWORK FOR TEACHER LICENSURE FRAME IN OUR STATE. AND SO THERE'S A TIER 1; TIER 2; TIER 3; TIER 4 WITH LESSER CREDENTIALS I WOULD ARGUE RELATIVE OR APPLY TO TIER 1 AND TIER 2 AND HIGHER CREDENTIALS THAN EXPECTATIONS IN THE TIER 3 AND TIER 4. THE BILL ; HOWEVER IN MY OPINION MAKES IT TOO EASY FOR SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS TO IMMEDIATELY JUMP TO TIER 1 OR TIER 2 RECRUITMENT AND PLACEMENT WITHOUT DEMONSTRATING TO THE PUBLIC THAT THEY HAVE STRIVEN TO PLACE THE MOST QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS IN THE INSTRUCTION OF YOUR CHILDREN. OF COURSE THOSE WOULD BE THOSE WHO FILL THE TIER 3 AND TIER 4 REQUIREMENTS. SO WHY NOT ASK ADMINISTRATORS TO AT THE VERY LEAST MAKE A GOOD-FAITH EFFORT TO RECRUIT WHOSE HEART QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS FIRST BEFORE THEY MOVED TO RECRUITING TIER 1 AND TIER 2. SO MEMBERS; WITH THIS AMENDMENT DOES BASICALLY IS REQUIRES THAT BE THE CASE. FILLING POSITIONS SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS MUST DEMONSTRATE AN EFFORT TO RECRUIT TIER 3 AND TIER 4 BEFORE MOVING ON TO THE GOVERNMENT OF WHICH ARE ONE AND TIER 2 INSTRUCTOR. IT'S ABOUT AND EVERY CLASSROOM IN EVERY DISTRICT ACROSS OUR STATE. THAT'S HOW WE DO HONOR AND JUSTICE TO OUR YOUNG PEOPLE. THAT'S HOW WE ENSURE THE ACADEMIC OUTCOMES THAT WE EXPECT OF THE SYSTEM. THAT'S ALL WE MAKE A STRONGER MINNESOTA. SO MEMBERS; I WOULD ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT OF THIS AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE A- 33 AMENDMENT ? DISCUSSION? REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: THANK YOU REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI. I KNOW THIS IS SOMETHING ABOUT WHICH WE'VE HAD DISCUSSIONS; BUT I THINK WE NEED TO THINK IN TERMS OF WHAT THE EXPECTATION HAS BEEN OF OUR HIRING UNITS PRIMARILY ON SCHOOL BOARDS AND HER TEACHER HIRING POOLS FOR THE LAST 20 YEARS. BECAUSE DISTRICTS HAVE OVER THE YEARS BEEN MAKING DECISIONS AND THERE IS A TEACHER SHORTAGE AND THEY MADE THAT DECISION BASED ON THEIR NEEDS. TO ALMOST INSULT THEM AT THIS POINT AND SUGGEST THAT THEY DON'T HAVE THE KNOWLEDGE AND THE SKILLS TO ENSURE THAT THEY HAVE THE BEST POSSIBLE CANDIDATE IN THE CLASSROOM SO THAT WE HAVE ANOTHER GREAT TEACHER BEFORE OUR STUDENTS; I THINK IS SOMETHING -UP HALFWAY DOWN WHICH WE DO NOT WANT TO GO TO BECAUSE WE HAVE THAT FAITH AND TRUST IN THESE ELECTED OFFICIALS CAN REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI COME I KEEP IN MINE YOUR SCHOOL DISTRICT IS HIRING A SUPERINTENDENT. I THINK IT IS EXLEY. I DON'T THINK WE WOULD PUT INTO STATURE WHAT WE EXPECT THAT SUPERINTENDENT TO BE AND I THINK THE BOARD TO WHICH I'M SURE YOU'VE HAD MANY DISCUSSIONS HAS THE KNOWLEDGE AND THE SKILLS TO MAKE THAT HIGHER; BUT ALSO TO MAKE HIRES WOULD NOW BE BECOME TIER ONE BECAUSE I TRACK ST. PAUL AND I KNOW IT'S HAD OVER THE YEARS; MANY COMMUNITY EXPERTS WERE YOU HAD MANY WAIVER TEACHERS ARE MONEY ON VARIANCES. ALTHOUGH THERE'S BEEN AN APPLICATION PROCESS IN PLACE WE ARE AT A TIME NOW WHERE WE KNOW THAT WE HAVE MORE KNOWLEDGE OF SCHOOL BOARDS HIRING PROCESS BECAUSE WE WANT TO TRUST OUR SCHOOL BOARDS AND WE WANT TO CONTINUE TO HAVE THAT FAITH WE HAVE IN THEM FOR THE LAST 20 YEARS. WHEN WE KNOW VERY WELL THE JOB VACANCIES OCCUR ON ALL WEBSITES NOW THAT THEY ARE INDEED LOOKING FOR THE BEST QUALIFIED CANDIDATES AND THAT'S CERTAINLY A LICENSED TEACHER BUT MEMBERS OF THE TEACHERS NOT ALWAYS AVAILABLE. PLEASE; VOTE; NO >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE A- THREE AMENDMENT? REPRESENTATIVE SANDSTEDE >> REPRESENTATIVE SANDSTEDE: MEMBERS I WOULD URGE A GREEN VOTE ON THE SPIRIT WILL I DO NOT WANT TO COME AND SAY DON'T TRUST YOUR SCHOOL BOARDS; SCHOOL BOARDS RESPONSIBLE FOR MANY THINGS INCLUDING MAKING THEIR BOOKS BALANCE. WHEN WE UNDERFUND PUBLIC EDUCATION AND THE SQUEEZE IS ON PUBLIC SCHOOLS CONTINUALLY THEY HAVE TO CUT AND CUT AND CUT AND IT IS CHEAPER TO HIRE COMMUNITY EXPERTS THAN IT IS TO HIRE A LICENSED EDUCATOR. WE DON'T HAVE TO PAY BENEFITS AND AS YOU VOTE ON THIS AMENDMENT; I WANT YOU TO TAKE THAT INTO CONSIDERATION SERIOUSLY AND A TEACHER WHO WALKED OUT OF THE CLASSROOM 15 WEEKS AGO AND I WITNESSED THIS IS NOT THAT SCHOOL BOARDS -THEIR SHORT AND THEY CAN'T FIND TEACHER. OFTENTIMES THERE'S AN OPTION BUT THE CHEAPER OPTION WITH A MORE AFFORDABLE OPTION IS THE COMMUNITY EXPERT. SO I URGE A GREEN VOTE ON THIS MEMBER'S >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE PRYOR >> REPRESENTATIVE PRYOR: I ALSO WANT TO AGREE AND SAY THAT WE SHOULD DO A GREEN VOTE ON THIS ONE. WHAT I WANT TO ADD TO IT IS THE MESSAGE WE ARE SENDING OUR TEACHERS IN TRAINING RIGHT NOW. SO I HAVE A NUMBER PEOPLE IN MY FAMILY MY EXTENDED FAMILY; THAT IS GONE THROUGH THE PROCESS THAT GOT THEIR UNDERGRADUATE DEGREES THEY'VE DONE THEIR CLASSROOM . YOUR OF CLASSROOM THEY MADE ALL THIS INVESTMENT INTO THEIR EDUCATION AND THEIR CAREER FOR LIFE AND WHAT THEY WANT IS THEY WANT TO GET A JOB WITH BENEFITS. WITH THIS NEW SYSTEM PUTS IN PLACE IS WEDNESDAY WANT TO GO TO THE CITY THEY WANT TO LIVE IN THEM WHEN THEY WANT TO MOVE BACK HOME AND BE WITH HER FAMILY; WHERE THEY GREW UP; THEY'RE GOING TO BE IN COMPETITION WITH PEOPLE THAT MIGHT NOT EVEN HAVE AN UNDERGRADUATE DEGREE. SO AS WE SAY; WHEN TIMES ARE TOUGH; WE ARE PUTTING THE BEST QUALIFIED PEOPLE AT A DISADVANTAGE FOR GETTING THAT NEXT JOB. THEIR FIRST JOB. SO I ALSO WOULD URGE THE GREEN VOTE ON THIS. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: FURTHER DISCUSSION? REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: MEMBERS; I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOUR SUPPORT FOR THIS AMENDMENT. IT'S NOT OFFERED AS A QUESTIONING OF ELECTED SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS WERE SUPERINTENDENTS. BY THE WAY; MEMBERS REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON CAN CORRECT ME IF WRONG COME I THINK THIS FRAMEWORK WOULD APPLY FOR PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS YOU KNOW MY SUPPORT OF CHARTER SCHOOLS BUT FRANKLY DON'T HAVE ELECTED SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS. THERE HAVE SUPERINTENDENTS. YET; THEY'RE PART OF THE EDUCATION ECOSYSTEM. SO HERE BEEN TO BRING IN PROFESSIONALS JOURNEY INTO OUR REGULAR REGULAR PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM THEY WOULD HAVE BEEN CHOSEN INITIALLY ARGUABLY OVER SOMEONE WAS FRANKLY BETTER PREPARED AND YET NOW THEY STOPPED UP EXTERIOR SEVEN STRUCTURE IN THAT SYSTEM EVER BE ABLE TO MOVE EFFECTIVELY INTO THE REGULAR PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM; BUT MEMBERS BELIEVE THE BIGGER POINT HERE IS WHY NOT? WHY NOT HAVE AS DEFINED IN THIS FRAMEWORK. REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI IS NOT DEFINING IT. IT'S A FINE IN THE FRAMEWORK. THAT'S WHY WE HAVE A TIERED SYSTEM. WHY NOT PLACE THE BEST PAIRED FOLKS IN FRONT OF YOUR CHILDREN? WHY NOT DO THAT IF YOU HAVE THE ABILITY TO DO THAT. I TOTALLY GET THAT'S NOT ALWAYS POSSIBLE. WE ARE A BIG STATE A LOT OF DIFFERENT DYNAMICS OUT THERE. REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON IS CORRECT TO USE COMMUNITY EXPERTS FOR NUMBER OF YEARS TO ANSWER THAT QUESTION BUT SIMPLY NOT POSSIBLE AND YET WE ARE STILL LOOKING FOR A LEVEL OF COMPETENCY. THE WHOLE POINT HERE IS DON'T DEFAULT TO THAT AS YOUR FIRST MOVE. FRANKLY; ALL THE AMENDMENT ASKS IS TO THE EXTENT POSSIBLE OUR EXCAVATION BE TO THE EXTENT POSSIBLE. THAT'S A RECOGNITION OF THE DIFFERENT [INAUDIBLE] AROUND THE STATE THE EXTENT POSSIBLE WE WOULD ASK A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO FILL A VACANCY WITH A TIERED THREE OR TIER 4 BEFORE SIMPLY INTO JUMPING INTO A TIER 1 OR TIER TO THOSE TEARS DO HAVE A PURPOSE. I WOULD ARGUE THAT PURPOSE SHOULD NOT BE AT THE EXPENSE OF A HIGHER PER PAIRED INDIVIDUAL. WHAT PARENT IN MINNESOTA WOULD NOT WANT THAT FOR THEIR STUDENT. SO REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; I THINK I CERTAINLY WANT TO WORK WITH YOU. THERE'S A LOT OF GOOD ISSUES IN THE BILL. BUT I THINK THIS IS A REALLY CRITICALLY IMPORTANT POINT SO MR. SPEAKER I WANT TO ASK FOR ROLL CALL ON THIS MIMIC S >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ROLL CALL HAS BEEN REQUESTED. SEEING FIFTEEN HANDS THERE WILL BE A ROLL CALL. ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION ON THE AMENDMENT SEEING NONE; THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL. >>[ROLL CALL VOTE]. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THE CLERK WILL CLOSE THE ROLL. 1359 AYE AND 70 NAY MOTION TO STOP HER VEIL AND THE MOUSE IS NOT ADOPTED >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE'S NO FURTHER MEMOS AT THE DESK AT THE CLERK WILL GIVE THE BILL THIRD READING >> CHIEF CLERK: THIRD READING HOUSE FILE 140 AS AMENDED >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THIRD READING >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON HOUSE FILE 140 AS A RESULT OF A LEGISLATIVE AUDIT DONE AND COMPLETED ABOUT A YEAR AGO. AND DELIVER TO US . SUBSEQUENT TO THEIR THIS IS HIM IN THE OLA REPORT WE FORMED A LEGISLATIVE STUDY GROUP WHICH REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI AND REPRESENTATIVE DAVNIE WERE MEMBERS. IT WAS BIPARTISAN. REPRESENTATIVE LOON. ON THIS SIDE AS REPRESENTATIVE AND CHRISTIANSEN WAS AS WELL INCLUDING YOURS TRULY AND THEN WE HAD DEMOCRATS AND SENATORS REPUBLICAN SENATORS AS WELL. WE MET FOR FIVE MONTHS. WE LISTENED TO HUNDREDS OF STAKEHOLDERS. GIVING US IDEAS ABOUT WHAT A NEW GOVERNANCE AND A NEW WAY TO LICENSE SHOULD LOOK LIKE. BECAUSE THE OLA REPORT HAD DEFINITELY SAID WE NEED ONE ENTITY PRESENTLY THE BOARD OF TEACHING MAKES DECISIONS AS THAT THE LICENSING DIVISION AT THE DEPARTMENT AND WITH SO MANY REQUESTS FOR LICENSURE FOR EITHER IN-STATE CANDIDATES HIM OUT SICK CANDIDATES; SO MUCH CONFUSION RESULTED THAT THE OLA AUDIT WILL AS WE MUST HAVE ONE ENTITY BUT WE ALSO DID MAKE A DECISION TO GIVE THE BOARD OF SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS SEPARATE ALTHOUGH THEY WILL HAVE TO CONTRACT TO HAVE THEIR LICENSEES ISSUED FOR MINISTERS. SO THOSE WERE TO OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS THAT WE WORK TOWARD ON THIS BIPARTISAN GROUP. THE OTHER WAS PATTERNING AFTER THE OLA REPORT 12 A TIERED SYSTEM WE WANT TO KEEP THIS SYSTEM. KEEP IT FOR TEARS AND INTERESTINGLY; WHEN A MET WITH THE COMMISSIONER LAST WEEK SHE WANTS TO YOUR FOR TO BE EVEN MORE ROBUST. SO I THINK IN CONFERENCE COMMITTEE WILL HAVE SOME GOOD DISCUSSIONS THERE WAS EVEN THE GOV.'S COUNCIL IS INTERESTED IN A MORE ROBUST CHEER FOR. TO THEIR QUESTIONS ABOUT TIER 1 ? SOME; BUT TIER 1; YOU HAVE TO REALIZE THAT CURRENT LAW HAS NO MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR A COMMUNITY EXPERTS. WE HAVE A BACHELORS OF ARTS DEGREE. IT WAS AN ASSOCIATES DEGREE BECAUSE WE KNOW MANY OF THOSE WHO NOW SERVE AS COMMUNITY EXPERT ACTUALLY ARE IN THE REAR AND TECHNICAL EDUCATOR FIELD MAY COME WITH ASSOCIATES DEGREE. THERE WE ARE THE PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIALS AND WE'LL ALLOW THREE REQUEST FOR THAT LICENSE. ON THE FOURTH THE BOARD OF TEACHING HAS TO PROMULGATE RULES AND IF THEY DON'T THAN THE QUEST IS ADHERED TO. SO WE HAVE TIGHTENED THAT . TIER 2 IS ACTUALLY THE ASCENT TO A FULL LICENSE. SO; THE REQUIREMENT SET DOWN IN TIER 3 WILLIE MOVES IN THE DIRECTION OF A LICENSED TEACHER. TIER 3 THEN UPSET ONE MORE AND TIER 4 THEN IS OUR HIGHEST COMMISSIONER TOLD ME SHE DIDN'T THINK ANYONE SHOULD START IN TIER 4 WINGED WE ADOPT THIS NEW PROPOSAL SO I THINK WE HAVE SOME REALLY GOOD CONFERENCE CONFERENCE COMMITTEE DISCUSSIONS CONCERNING THE FACT THAT SHE LIKES THIS TIERED SYSTEM. AS I SAID SHE HAS QUESTIONS ABOUT TIER 1 STILL; BUT TIER 4 COMMISSIONER REALLY WANTS TO ELEVATE THAT. SO MEMBERS; THIS IS BASICALLY WHAT IS FOUND IN THE BILL. WE HAVE RECKONED THAT WE ARE VERY PROUD OF BECAUSE THERE'S BEEN A TEAM EFFORT EARED MY TEAM ADMINISTRATOR --VERY INSURMOUNTABLE IN HELPING WITH THIS AS A REPRESENTATIVE LOON. REPRESENTATIVE CHRISTENSEN AS MEMBERS OF THE LEGISLATIVE STUDY GROUP. SEN. PAT OF COURSE CARRIES THIS IN THE SENATE. BUT; MEMBERS; WHAT WE WERE STRIVING FOR IS WELL; WHICH CAME OUT OF THE AUDIT REPORT WAS WE HAVE A REALLY MESSED UP SECTION OF STATUTES IN REGARD TO LICENSING TEACHERS. NO WONDER THEY CAN'T FIGURE OUT TO HOW TO GET A LICENSE IN MINNESOTA IF THEIR OUT-OF-STATE BECAUSE YOU CANNOT WE ARE STATUTES. WE HAVE ALL SORTS OF DIFFERENT LABELS WHICH IS WHY WE TOOK THE TIERED SYSTEM VERY SIMPLE. YOU CAN'T BE NAMING FIVE OR SIX DIFFERENT KINDS OF LICENSE MAYBE FOR THE FIRST TIME AND THINKING A CANDIDATE CAN FIGURE THAT OUT. SO WITH THE HELP OF OUR NEW NONPARTISAN HOUSE RESEARCHER; CHRISTINA PARA; WE WERE ABLE TO REWORK DENIES THESE SECTIONS SIMPLIFY THEM. I TOLD HIM I WANT THEM TO BE READABLE; UNDERSTANDABLE; CLEAR; TRANSPARENT AND ACCOUNTABLE. SHE FILLED ALL THOSE REQUIREMENTS AND WORKING WITH US AND WORKING WITH SENATE COUNSEL AND SO IT'S A PRODUCT THAT WERE VERY VERY PROUD OF. I HOPE ALL OF YOU WILL BE. I KNOW THERE ARE SOME STICKING POINTS IN AREAS BUT MEMBERS; TO SUGGEST WHEN I CAN HAVE THE BEST QUALIFIED CANDIDATES IN OUR CLASSROOMS IS ABSURD. BECAUSE SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE ALWAYS LOOKING FOR THE BEST CANDIDATES FOR THEIR YOUNG PEOPLE FOR THEIR CHILDREN. FOR THE HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS FOR THE CAREER AND TECHNICAL EDUCATORS. THEY'RE ALWAYS DOING THAT. I DON'T EVEN QUESTION FOR A MOMENT-I KNOW THE MSP WEBSITE IS APPLAUDING THE FACT OF THE TALKING ABOUT SCHOOL BOARDS REALLY SHOULD BE TAKING THIS SERIOUSLY THAT I RESPECT THAT AND THEY REALLY LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH US ON THIS ISSUE. MEMBERS; WITH ALL OF THIS SAID I HOPE YOU CAN SUPPORT HOUSE FILE 142 AND LOOK TO IT AS THE FUTURE OF A NEW GOVERNANCE SYSTEM IN MINNESOTA AND A NEW LICENSURE SYSTEM. I WAS SUPPORTIVE TEACHING MEMBER IN THE 90S DID IN FACT A MILD SUPPORT MEMBER ONLY ADOPTED THE COMMUNITY EXPERT THAT FORMER GOV. BURNLEY CARLSON WANTED I LOBBIED EVEN REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON-HE DOESN'T MEMBER THIS BUT I WAS IN IN HIS OFFICE LOBBIED HIM TO PASS THE COMMUNITY EXPERT BECAUSE THE HOUSE AND SENATE WERE CONTROLLED BY DEMOCRATS THAT THAT'S A WE SPENT OUR FRIDAY WE COME TO OUR MEETINGS WE CAN ON THE HILL WE WILL POLICY AND THEN WE WENT TO MEMBERS TO LOBBY THEM TO SUPPORT THIS. MEMBERS; ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT. THIS IS REALLY GOOD REFORM. ITS INNOVATIVE AND IS WHEN A STREAMLINED THE PAST FOR THOSE CANDIDATES THAT WE WANT TEACHING IN MINNESOTA. WE'VE A TEACHER SHORTAGE AS YOU KNOW. THIS IS ONE STEP WE CAN MOVE CLOSER TO FULFILLING THOSE GAPS. PLEASE; VOTE YES >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON >> REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON: MEMBERS; REPRESENTATIVE GENERIC I DON'T HAPPEN TO REMEMBER THAT; BUT YOU MUST NOT HAVE CONVINCED ME. BECAUSE I'M RISING THIS AFTERNOON TO SPEAK AGAINST THE BILL AND LET ME GIVE YOU A COUPLE OF REASONS WHY. WHEN I LOOK AT TIER 1 IN A SAID ON THIS FLOOR BEFORE BY THE WAY; LIKE REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; I'M A FORMER TEACHER RETIRED TEACHER BUT WHEN YOU ALLOW PEOPLE TO TEACH WITH LESS THAN A FOUR YEAR DEGREE; I VIEW THAT AS A STEP BACK WORD. I RAISED THIS QUESTION THE OTHER DAY AND WAYS AND MEANS WHEN THE BILL WAS BEFORE US. WHEN I WAS IN COLLEGE; I FINISHED MY UNDERGRADUATE IN THREE YEARS. I WENT YEAR-ROUND AND THE REASON I MENTION THAT WAS THAT I COMPLETED MY DEGREE FASTER THAN MOST PROBABLY WOULD TODAY. BUT I WENT TO MANKATO STATE UNIVERSITY; MINNESOTA STATE I GUESS; TODAY. MANKATO. DURING THE SUMMER; THE CLASSES THAT I WORKED WAS TAKING WERE LOADED WITH PEOPLE FROM IOWA. IOWA HAD ALLOWED-I GOT MY DEGREE IN THE EARLY 60S; IOWA HAD ALLOWED TEACHERS TO COME IN WITH TWO-YEAR DEGREES. THEN THE IOWA LEGISLATURE MADE THE DECISION THAT THEY REALLY WANTED TO PROFESSIONALIZE THE TEACHING CORE AND THEY INCREASE THE REQUIREMENT AND GAVE THEM SO MUCH TIME TO GET A FOUR YEAR DEGREE TO CONTINUE TO BE LICENSED IN THE STATE OF IOWA. I'M TALKING ABOUT HAVING A PROFESSIONAL TEACHING CORE. I THINK THAT'S AN IMPORTANT THING TO REMEMBER. THERE IS AN EXCEPTION TO THAT ONE AREA OF TWO YEARS WAS DOING WITH VOCATIONAL EDUCATORS BECAUSE T HEY WOULD TYPICALLY AND WE TALKED ABOUT THIS IN COMMITTEE THE OTHER DAY AS WELL ; THEY MAY BE LICENSED IN THEIR FIELD AS AN ATTRITION OR PLUMBER WHATEVER THE SKILL TRADE MIGHT BE BUT THEY ARE REQUIRED TO GO BACK BEFORE THEY CAN BE LICENSED AS A VOCATIONAL EDUCATOR. SO THERE IS THAT PROVISION IN TODAY'S LAWS. WARLOCK. THE OTHER THING I WANT TO ASK AND THIS IS A QUESTION REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; MY FUEL; AND SOCIAL STUDIES; AND I TAUGHT HISTORY GOVERNMENT; MAINLY GOVERNMENT STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND IF SOMEBODY COMES IN WITHOUT A DEGREE COMES IN FROM ANOTHER STATE WHAT ARE THE REQUIREMENTS THEY HAVE SOME KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MINNESOTA GOVERNMENT MINNESOTA GEOGRAPHY IF IT CAN BE TEACHING THOSE SOCIAL STUDIES CLASSES ? WOULD THEY BE EXEMPT FROM MEETING A REQUIREMENT THEY WOULD HAVE TODAY? >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON; THAT'S NOT SOMETHING WE STATE IN LAW BECAUSE THAT WILL IS IN THE PURVIEW OF THE NEW BOARD IN FACT THAT NOT MENTION THE NAME OF IT THE PROFESSIONAL EDUCATOR LICENSING AND STANDARDS BOARD WHICH WILL REPLACE THE BOARD OF TEACHING. BUT THAT IS SOMETHING THAT CAN BE PART OF THEIR WILL MAKING. THE CHANGES THAT MIGHT OCCUR BECAUSE WE'VE OUT-OF-STATE OTHERS COMING IN AND I THINK LOCAL SCHOOL BOARDS AGAIN RESPONSIBLE FOR IF THEY'RE GOING TO ASSIGN A PERSON WHO FOR EXAMPLE A SECURE ONE LICENSE AND REMEMBER; THOSE ARE FOR NEEDY SINGLE COURSES OR SINGLE SECTIONS OF A COURSE; THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE THE FELLOW COLLEAGUES AND MAKE SURE THE TEACHER HAS MINNESOTA HISTORY. BUT FOR THE MOST PART THAT WILL BE IN THE HANDS OF THIS NEW BOARD. TO DETERMINE WHAT NEEDS TO OCCUR WHEN WE HAVE THAT SPECIFICITY IN THE LICENSURE FEEL. THAT'S ALL DONE BY THE BOARD. SPEAK >> REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON. THAT MEANS THERE'LL BE NO ASSURANCE I'M USING MY FUEL THAT'S AN EXAMPLE A LSO STUDIES WOULD HAVE NO BACKGROUND IN STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT APPROVED TEACHING OTHER COURSES WITH THE GEOGRAPHY OR BE A COMPONENT THEY HAVE ANY BACKGROUND IN MINNESOTA GEOGRAPHY EITHER. SO THAT IS A CONCERN I HAVE. I USE ONE MORE EXAMPLE THAT. MY DAUGHTER GRADUATED FROM THE UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA MORRIS; SOCIAL STUDIES EDUCATION; SO SHE WAS LICENSED IN MINNESOTA SHE WENT UP AND GOT HER MASTERS DEGREE AT THE UNIVERSITY OF NORTH DAKOTA AND SHE MARRIED A FELLOW [INAUDIBLE] WAS A PILOT. SO WE GOT A JOB FLYING OUT OF THE GREATER CINCINNATI AIRPORT; CHOOSING KENTUCKY. SO WHEN MY DAUGHTER WENT DOWN THERE EVEN THOUGH SHE WAS LICENSED INTO STATES; SHE WAS REQUIRED BUT SHE HAD TO TAKE A COURSE IN THE HISTORY OF KENTUCKY IF I RECALL ANOTHER COURSE IN THE GOVERNMENT OF KENTUCKY. I THINK SHE HAD A VERY SHORT TIME PER NOT TO DO THAT. THERE WAS MAYBE LIKE A YEAR. A. B. SHE JUST DID IT IN A YEAR BUT THERE WERE SOME TIME CONSTRAINTS. I REMEMBER THAT SO SHE WOULD BE PREPARED TO TEACH THE STUDENTS IN HER CLASSES ABOUT THE HISTORY OF KENTUCKY AND THE GEOGRAPHY AND SO ON. SO I THINK THOSE ARE IMPORTANT ELEMENTS. I'M JUST USING THAT AS AN EXAMPLE W HERE MOST EXPERIENCE AS A SOCIAL STUDIES GOVERNMENT ECONOMICS TEACHER THROUGH THE YEARS THAT WE DON'T WANT TO HAVE A SITUATION WHERE WE HAVE A TEACHER COR PS THAT IS LESS PROFESSIONAL THAN THE ONE WE HAVE TODAY. SO I WOULD URGE A NO; BUT WORKS. THANK YOU. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE TURNER: REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON; IF YOU LOOK AT ALL OUR TEARS; WE HAVE AS ALWAYS ONE OF THE OPTIONS AND THAT'S TO TAKE UPPER-LEVEL DIVISION CREDITS IN RELEVANT CONTENT AREA AND IF A SCHOOL BOARD SEES THAT A CANDIDATE HAS A LACK OF KNOWLEDGE IN AN AREA THEY ARE THINKING OF HIRING THAT PERSON THINK THEY WILL MAKE THEIR ARMS ON THAT CANDIDATE THAT HE OR SHE IS GOING TO HAVE TO TAKE SOME COURSES IN THAT CONTENT AREA THAT; IN FACT IS ONE OF THE MANY ITEMS THAT OFFERED FOR BOTH TIER 1 AND TIER 2 SO I THINK WE CAN SOLVE THIS PROBLEM EASIER THAN YOU MAKE IT SOUND. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: FURTHER DISCUSSION ON HOUSE FILE 140? REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: I'M WONDERING IF REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON WITH YIELD? MEMBERS; BEFORE I DO ASK REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON THIS; I DO WANT TO ENCOURAGE US AS WE GET UP AND DEBATE THAT WE NOT INVOKE THE NAME OF OUR STAFF HERE. IT'S GOT TO PUT THEM IN AN AWFULLY UNCOMFORTABLE POSITION WE ARE THE ONES MAKING THESE DECISIONS AND REDIRECT THEM WHAT TO DO. WE HAVE EXCELLENT STAFF INCLUDING THE ONES BEEN NAMED EARLIER HERE TODAY BUT I DON'T THINK IT REALLY LENDS ITSELF TOWARD DEBATE TO STATE WHETHER GOOD OR BAD OR WHAT ARE RESPECTIVE POSITIONS ARE. MEMBERS; I DON'T THINK IT'S ABSURD TO HAVE A STRONG EXPECTATION THAT AS POLICYMAKERS FEAR THAT WE ARE EXPECTING THE HIGHEST CREDENTIALS OF EVERYONE GIVEN THE PRIVILEGE TO BE ABLE TO INSTRUCT OUR STUDENTS AND I THINK WHAT WE HAVE IN COMMON REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; WE BOTH WANT SOME REALLY GOOD STRONG PROFESSIONAL SKILLS APPLIED IN THE CLASSROOM. YOUR BILL STARTS FROM LEGISLATIVE AUDITOR'S FRAMEWORK THAT PROVIDES ME WITH A LOT OF COMFORT SPIRIT IT SHOULD FOR A LOT OF US HERE. AS WELL. AS I LOOK BACK THE YEARS WE'VE DONE LEGISLATING HERE THAT I'VE BEEN INVOLVED IN THE LEGISLATIVE AUDITOR OFTEN PROVIDES US WITH A POWERFUL OBJECTIVE IN WHICH TO SHAPE OUR BILLS COULD THAT'S WHY THINK THERE'S A NUMBER OF REALLY GOOD PROVISIONS IN THIS BILL THAT I WOULD HOPE WE ARE ABLE TO GO FORWARD. I DO CONTINUE TO HAVE MY CONCERNS. I'M WONDERING REPRESENTATIVE CHART JUST A FEW QUESTIONS. ONE OF THE THINGS THAT'S REQUIRED FOR TIER 1 AND TIER 2 LICENSE WHICH ARE ONE-YEAR LICENSES THAT CAN BE RENEWED IS A MENU EITHER OR MENU ON THE PART OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE MAKING THE DECISION. SO FOR INSTANCE FOR TIER 1; THERE'S A BA OR AND 80 LOSS; MEETING SOME CONDITIONS OFF THE LIST T HAT INCLUDES THINGS LIKE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE. I'M WONDERING REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; IF YOU COULD TELL US WHAT YOUR DEFINITI ON IS BECAUSE I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO HAVE THIS ON THE RECORD HERE. I'M NOT SURE I KNOW WHAT A SUFFICIENT PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIAL IS . IT SEEMS TO ME THAT IS LANGUAGE THAT REALLY OUGHT TO BE MUCH TIGHTER THAN THAT. SOME WONDERING IF YOU CAN TELL US IN YOUR MIND WHAT SUFFICIENT PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIAL WOULD BE THAT WOULD BE THAT OPTION TO EITHER A BACHELOR'S DEGREE OR TWO YEAR DEGREE EQUIPPED >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: I DO WANT TO THANK YOU AND REPRESENTATIVE DAVNIE AND FORMER REPRESENTATIVE-FOR YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE STUDY GROUP AND TO OUR MEETINGS SINCE. I'VE REALLY APPRECIATED THAT. IN REGARD TO THE PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIAL THE DEPARTMENT HAS LAID OUT A NUMBER OF-I SHOULD NOT SAY LATE OUT; HAS LISTED A NUMBER PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIALS THAT ARE RECOGNIZED IN MINNESOTA SO IT WOULD BE AMONG THAT GROUP IS LISTED FROM THE DEPARTMENT YOU CAN FIND THAT ON THE WEBSITE. IT'S A RECENT PUBLICATION BUT THE COMMISSIONER HAS ISSUED THAT. SO THOSE PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIALS WOULD FALL UNDER THAT LISTENING. I >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: I THINK OF THIS BILL WAS 40 MAY BE WISE FOR US TO BE ABLE TO CAPTURE THOSE IN STATE STATUTE AS OPPOSED TO JUST INTEGRATE REFERENCING WHAT THOSE MIGHT BE. SO THERE IS CLEAR DIRECTION BOTH TO THOSE MAKING HIRES AS WELL AS TO THE PUBLIC. WHAT WE MEAN BY SUFFICIENT PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT CREDENTIAL. REPRESENTATIVE TURNER; ONE OF THE REQUIREMENTS THAT POPS UP CONSISTENTLY THROUGH THE FOUR TIERS IS THE OPTION OF COMPLETING THE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE. SO ONE; WANT TO A COLLEGE THAT THE BILL BEFORE US CALLS THAT OUT . HOWEVER; HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE IS NOT A HARD AND FAST REQUIREMENT IN TERMS OF THE TIER 1 AND TIER 2 CREDENTIALING. AS I MENTIONED EARLIER; I THINK I DID; THOSE TEARS CAN RESULT IN THE INTERPLAY BETWEEN THOSE TWO HAVING AN INDIVIDUAL IN OUR CLASSROOMS; PROFESSIONAL INDIVIDUAL IN HER CLASSROOM FOR UP TO EIGHT YEARS. MEMBERS; IT SEEMS TO ME THAT ONE YEAR FRANKLY IS TOO LONG FOR A PROFESSIONAL TO BE IN OUR CLASSROOM WITHOUT THE REQUIREMENT OF HAVING ACQUIRED THE SKILLS AND KNOWLEDGE THAT ARE PRESENTED IN HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE EIGHT YEARS IS CERTAINLY WAY TOO LONG AND MEMBERS JUST SO WE ARE CLEAR ABOUT WHAT THAT MEANS; THE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE AS YOU KNOW; WE CURRENTLY HAVE ABOUT A THIRD; 30% OF OUR STUDENT POPULATION [INAUDIBLE] YOUNG PEOPLE A THIRD OF THOSE COME FROM TWHIRL ARE STUDENTS OF COLOR AMERICAN INDIAN STUDENTS. THAT MEANS THAT THEY'RE PART OF COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE CULTURAL DIFFERENCES THAT ARE DISTINCT FROM WHAT OUR STATE HAS BEEN ACCUSTOMED TO FOR WELL OVER 100 YEARS. THAT GROWTH HAS HAPPENS THE TACTILE HE FAST 20 YEARS AGO IT WAS LESS THAN ONE IN 10 OF OUR STUDENT TO HAVE THIS FAST GROWING DIVERSITY OF STUDENTS AND THE BODY OF EVIDENCE OUT THERE MEMBERS; GOOD RESEARCH EMPIRICAL STUDIES HAVE CONSISTENTLY ARE CONSISTENTLY COMING IN WITH THE IMPORTANCE O F OUR PROFESSIONAL TEACHERS TO BE ABLE TO HAVE THE EFFECT OF SKILLS TO WORK WITH A DIVERSITY RACIAL AND CULTURAL DIVERSITY OF THE STUDENT BODY. I THINK THE EVIDENCE IS QUITE OVERWHELMING. IT IS ACTUALLY TIED TO EVEN BIGGER BODY OF EVIDENCE THAT TALKS ABOUT WHAT A FUNDAMENTAL SKILL IT IS FOR A TEACHING PROFESSIONAL TO BE ABLE TO HAVE THE SKILLS TO BUILD POWERFUL RELATIONSHIPS WITH THEIR STUDENTS. SO; NONETHELESS; UNDER THE SCHEME UNDER THIS FRAMEWORK BEFORE YOU THAT HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE IS NOT A REQUIRED EXPOSURE FOR PROFESSIONALS WITHIN A LICENSE UNDER THIS TIER LICENSING SYSTEM . I THINK IT SHOULD BE. I'M WONDERING IF REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON PERHAPS SHARE A LITTLE BIT AND WE CAN CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION BEYOND THIS IF THE BILL GOES FOR. A LITTLE BIT ABOUT HER THINKING 02 TO THE IMPORTANCE OF THE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE A S A REQUIREMENT FOR ALL OF THE TEARS IN THIS LICENSING SYSTEM? >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: THE HUMANS RELATIONS COURSE IS IN THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL. IT'S NOT IN STATUTE; BUT WE REFERENCED EIGHT. HOUSE FILE 140. IF A CANDIDATE CHOOSES TO TAKE THE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE OUR TEAM BELIEVES THEY ARE CONSIDERING A PATHWAY TO LICENSURE. NO QUESTIONS ADDED BECAUSE IT'S IN RULE A ND 20 REQUIRED THROUGH RULE AND THAT STATUTE. THE FACT THAT WE'VE CULTURAL COMPETENCY IN LAW I THINK TODAY; MEMBERS; MAYBE EVEN A STRONGER STATEMENT ABOUT WHAT WE EXPECT OF OUR TEACHERS TO UNDERSTAND AND KNOW ABOUT THE DIFFERENT STUDENTS IN THEIR CLASSROOMS. SO THE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE A THREE CREDIT COURSE TO STUDY A VARIETY OF ETHNICITIES ; TO HEAR FROM SPECIAL SPEAKERS TO UNDERSTAND SOME OF THE INTRICACIES OF THE CULTURE BUT I THINK THE FACT THE WE HAVE CULTURE COMPETENCY DEFINED IN STATE STATUTE IS JU ST AS IMPORTANT IF NOT MORE IMPORTANT FOR TEACHER CANDIDATES AND AS I SAID AT THE OUTSET OF THIS COMMENT IF A CANDIDATE CHOOSES TO TAKE YOU IN HUMAN RELATIONS AND TIER 1; I THINK THEY'RE CHECKING OUT TO SEE WHAT DO WE LIKE TO BECOME A LICENSED TEACHER THROUGH THE PATHWAYS THAT WE PROVIDE THE SAME IS TRUE IN TIER 2 IN TEARS AND THREE AND FOUR; IT IS OF COURSE A REQUIREMENT THAT SECOND RULE. >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; AND MEMBERS MY THINK THIS IS AN AREA THAT NEEDS SOME WORK. FRANKLY; IT SO IMPORTANT AT SOME POINT IT'S BEYOND OUR SCOPE AT THIS POINT THAT SOME POINT WE MAY ACTUALLY WANT TO BUILD THAT INTO STATUTE. HOWEVER; I WOULD POINT OUT THAT THE TIER 1 AND TIER 2 LICENSURE DOES NOT DO A NOD TO THE RULE SET UP BY THE BOARD OF TEACHING. SO THERE'S GOING TO BE LOCAL DISCRETION. I WOULD CERTAINLY HOPE THAT ALL OUR LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE GOING TO BE ASKING FOR THAT EVENTUAL FOR THAT EXPOSURE FOR THAT SCHOOL SET FROM FOLKS THEY WANT TO PLACE.-THANK YOU MR. SPEAKER-FOLKS THEY WANT TO PLACE AND TIER 1 AND TIER 2 BUT MEMBERS AGAIN I THINK IT'S A IMPORTANT AND WE CLEARLY ARE PRESCRIBING RIGHT NOW IN THIS BILL WHAT THE PARAMETERS ARE ALL THESE TEARS. IT SO IMPORTANT I THINK WE OUGHT TO MAKE TH AT A REQUIREMENT OF ALL THE TEARS. SO I THINK IS WORK THAT NEEDS TO BE DONE HERE. REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; AS YOU KNOW IN COMMITTEE; WE HAD TESTIMONY FROM DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ABOUT THE TIMELINE OF IMPLEMENTING CHANGE. I THINK ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I CERTAINLY HAVE BEEN IN YOUR BOAT WHEN YOU'RE IMPLEMENTING A VIEW POLICY FRAMEWORK FOR THE BIG QUESTIONS IS HOW QUICKLY; HOW INTENSELY TO MOVE FORWARD AND SOMETIMES IT CAN BE QUITE REFRESHING TO WE ONE MOVE FORWARD AS LEGISLATORS VERY QUICKLY. BUT WERE TALKED ABOUT SYSTEMS; PEOPLE IN SYSTEMS WITHOUT SKILLS; TO OUR KNOWLEDGE AND WE ARE TALKING ABOUT PROCESSES THE WHOLE LICENSING PROCESS ISN'T GOING TO COME TO AN END. AND WAIT FOR THIS NEW SPECIAL BOARD TO FIGURE EVERYTHING OUT. THIS COULD BE THIS PROCESS THAT'S GOING ON RIGHT NOW AND TEACHERS DESERVE CERTAINTY AROUND THE DECISION MAKINGS THE PARENTS AND STUDENTS DESERVE THAT SOME WONDERING REPRESENTATIVE TURNER; IF YOU COULD SHARE WITH THE BODY ANY CONCERNS YOU MIGHT HAVE GO TO TO THE PACE OF WHICH YOU'RE EXPECTING THESE CHANGES TO BE IMPLEMENTED AND THEN AS LONG AS I'M UP I'LL ASK YOU MY SECOND QUESTION WHICH HAS TO DO WITH THE IDEA THAT NONE OF THE CURRENT BOARD MEMBERS CAN BE REAPPOINTED. MEMBERS; IT'S NOT GENERALLY A WISE THING TO TOTALLY MOVE ANYONE WHO HAS ANY EXPERIENCE OUT OF THE BODY LIKE THIS. EVEN IF YOU'RE NOT GOING TO RENEW THEM THINK IT'S CRITICALLY IMPORTANT THAT YOU HAVE EXPERIENCE SITTING AT THE TABLE. THE BOARD I THINK HAS BEEN VERY FORTHRIGHT IN WORKING WITH THE CHAIRMAN WITH THE REST OF US IN TERMS OF WANTING CHANGE. IT SEEMS TO ME THAT NOT RENEWING ANY OF THESE NEW BOARD MEMBERS RIGHT NOW; AND THEN EXPECTING AN IMMEDIATE CHANGE IS PROBABLY SETTING US UP FOR QUITE A MESS AND WHOLE LICENSING PROSPECTS AM WONDERING REPRESENTATIVE TURNER; YOU COULD SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS ON WHAT YOU FEEL THE WE CAN MOVE THIS QUICKLY TH E WHOLE BRAND-NEW CAST OF CHARACTERS? >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: I'M CONCERNED ABOUT THAT; BUT I THINK THOSE ARE DISCUSSIONS WE HAVE IN CONFERENCE COMMITTEE. THE SENATE HAS A FEW DIFFERENT AI DS IN PLACE AND THAT'S A ROBUST DISCUSSION THAT NEEDS TO OCCUR AMONG CONFEREES AND THEN TO HEAR INPUT IT IS A REALLY HAVE NOT RECEIVED ANY INPUT ON THE TIMELINE AT ALL FROM ANYONE ON THE OUTSIDE. NO ONE HAS RAISED THE CONCERN. THE COMMISSIONER AND I DID DISCUSS IT LAST WEEK. SHE IS A LITTLE CONCERNED. I WOULD NOT SAY SHE'S CONCERNED ABOUT THE BOARD BEING DISMISSED BECAUSE SHE IS SHE TOTALLY WET WITH LOT OF DYSFUNCTIONAL BOARDS SO I GUESS SHE CONSIDERED THIS ONE DYSFUNCTIONAL ALREADY. NEVERTHELESS; WE HAVE COMING FROM THE DEPARTMENT; AND SHE'S VERY PROUD OF THOSE WHO SERVE IN OUR LICENSING DIVISION ALTHOUGH EELS CONCERT WILL NOT CONTINUE ON BECAUSE HE IS GOING TO BECOME A SUPERINTENDENT IN A RURAL DISTRICT. BUT OTHER STUFF THAT WILL PROCEED WITH GREAT KNOWLEDGE AND I KNOW SHE'S VERY PROUD OF THAT. AS FAR AS A NEW BOARD CANNOT REMEMBER THE PRESENT BOARD WAS SUED AND ALSO FOUND IN CONTEMPT OF COURT BECAUSE THEY DID NOT FOLLOW THROUGH WHAT WAS SPECIFIED IN THE STATUTE OR BECAUSE THEY VIOLATED T HEIR OWN RULES OUTLAWS. SO; YES WE WILL DISCUSS IN CONFERENCE COMMITTEE THE TIMELINES . WILL I BE CONCERNED ABOUT A CREATION OF A BRAND-NEW BOARD AMONG NO BECAUSE AS I SAID TO THE COMMISSIONER ALSO TO THE GOV. STAFF; THE GOVERNOR HAS THE OPPORTUNITY TO POINT PAST MEMBERS WHO HAVE BEEN JUST SELLER ON THE BOARD OF TEACHING. WE TREATED THE BOARD MUCH IN THE SAME WAY THAT THE BOARD WAS RESPECTED IN THE DAYS WHEN I SERVED ON IT. AS A PROFESSIONAL BOARD THAT CONCENTRATES ON TEACHER PREPARATION REPAIRS LICENSES AND DOESN'T OBSCURE THEIR SCHEDULE WITH UNNECESSARY PAPERWORK. SO I THINK THAT WE WILL BE ABLE TO LOOK TO THE GOV. OFFERS SOME NAMES TO HIS POINTING OFFICIAL AND GET OFF TO A REALLY GOOD START AND DO A CLEAN SWEEP BECAUSE WE ARE CREATING A NEW GOVERNANCE MODEL AND MEMBERS IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT THAT WE START WITH A CLEAN SLATE. >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI : I WILL CLOSE WITH THIS. I DO HAVE AND I THINK THAT'S FAIR REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON. I APPRECIATE YOU SHARING THAT ON THE RECORD. CONTINUING TO HAVE A CONVERSATION IF THIS BILL GOES FOR. IN COMMENTS COMMITTEE VOTED TO THE PRAGMATIC ISSUE BEEN ABLE TO IMPLEMENT A NEW BOARD WITH A NEW FRAMEWORK A NEW RESPONSIBILITIES AND BEING ABLE TO DO THAT WITH FOLKS THAT ARE EXPERIENCED . SO I SUSPECT THAT WILL BE A STRONG PART OF THAT CONFERENCE COMMITTEE AND AM ENCOURAGED THAT YOU'RE ACKNOWLEDGING TO HAVE THAT CONVERSATION. MEMBERS COME I DON'T THINK IT'S IMPORTANT- I DON'T THINK IT'S NECESSARY FOR US TO [INAUDIBLE] THE CURRENT RELATIVE BOARD OF TEACHING . FOLKS WHOSE LOSSES ALL THE TIME. SOMETIMES YOU MEET SOME ROUTE REALLY BAD THINGS. SOMETIMES IT DOES. THE IMPORTANT THING IS WE HAVE COMMITTED INDIVIDUALS ON THE BOARD THAT WORKED MIGHTILY HARD IN THE FACE OF COSTLY SHIFTING POLICY THAT COMES OUT OF THIS LEGISLATURE AND A WHOLE LOT OF FROM OUTSIDE GROUPS. SOME MEMBERS WHO I WOULD SUBMIT WE DO NOT HAVE THE BEST INTERESTS OF HIGHLY PROFESSIONAL CLASS OF TEACHERS IN OUR STATE. SOME WHO DO BUT SOME WHO HAVE FRANKLY OTHER POLITICAL CONSIDERATIONS GOES TO ARE ORGANIZED TEACHERS IN OUR STATE. MEMBERS TH E ONLY OTHER THING I WANT TO SHARE QUICKLY-DON'T ASK QUESTIONS BECAUSE GONE ON LONG ENOUGH HERE. IT HAS TO DO WITH TEACHER EVALUATION RESULTS TO THE CURE FOR LICENSURE CATEGORY AN D REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON AND I WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE YOUR OPENNESS IN MOVING THAT CHANGING THAT A BIT. I DO WANT TO POINT OUT; MEMBERS THIS RAISES OTHER ISSUES WE'VE STRUGGLED AROUND HERE WITH A LACK OF UNIFORMITY IN OUR STATE IN IMPLEMENTING TEACHER EVALUATION SYSTEM. ACROSS THE BOARD IN OUR STATE. SOME OF THAT WE'VE ALLOWED BECAUSE OF FLEXIBILITY BUT FRANKLY; BUT IT DOES MEAN PARTICULARLY WHEN WE ARE NOT FUNDING EFFECTIVELY THE ABILITY FOR SCHOOLS TO BE ABLE TO IMPLEMENT STRONG EVALUATION SYSTEMS. SOME SCHOOL DISTRICTS READ WE DO AND SOME WE DON'T. WHAT THAT DOES; MEMBERS IT CREATES AN NON-UNIFORM ENVIRONMENTS OUT THERE SO THAT YOU CAN BE EVALUATED DISCIPLINE TOTALLY THAT YOU MIGHT BE VALUATOR DISTRICT TO AND YET WERE GOING TO TIE YOUR ONGOING CREDENTIALING TO THAT INCONSISTENCY IN EVALUATION. SO I THINK IT'S ON THE EYES LOOKED AT. ENCOURAGE THE CHAIRMAN HAS LOOKED AT THAT AND MADE SOME MOVEMENT IN THIS REGARD. MEMBERS WITH THAT I WILL STOP. I INTEND TO SUPPORT THE BILL HERE TODAY. I DO HAVE CONCERNS. I'M SURE AND I WILL CONTINUE TO DO THAT BUT I WOULD CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND IF; MEMBERS; I FEEL THE BILL IS NOT READY FOR PRIME TIME. THAT PERHAPS SOME OF THE ISSUES RELATIVE TO WHO WE ARE PLACING IN HER CLASSROOM ; IN FRONT OF OUR KIDS OVERLONG PERIOD OF TIME M AY NOT YET BE THE BEST WAY TO DO THAT. SO I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU TO AS YOU DO WITH ALL OTHER BILLS; TO APPROACH IT WITH INDEPENDENT MIND AND UNDERSTAND THAT IF THIS BILL GOES FORWARD IS A GOOD CHANCE TO COME BACK AND HOPEFULLY THERE'S A GOOD CHANCE OF A COMEBACK A BETTER AND STRONGER BILL. THANK YOU MEMBERS; AND THANK YOU REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DAVNIE >> REPRESENTATIVE DAVNIE: MEMBERS; CHAIRMAN ERICKSON; THANK YOU FOR THE WORK THAT YOU DID ON THE TASK FORCE THAT WE WERE BOTH ON I ALSO HAVE THE PRIVILEGE TO SERVE ON THE CTE TASK FORCE. LOOK AT THE VERY REAL CONCERNS AND CHALLENGES ACROSS THE STATE INADEQUATELY STAFFING OUR CAREER AND TECHNICAL EDUCATION OFFERINGS. THIS IS AN AREA; MEMBERS; WERE MINNESOTA HAS BACKED OFF OVER THE YEARS. I WOULD SUGGEST TO THE DETRIMENT OF BOTH OUR STUDENTS AND TO OUR EMPLOYERS BECAUSE THERE'S A LOT OF STUDENTS OUT THERE WHO WANT TO DO WORK WITH OUR BARE HANDS; WE DON'T WANT TO HEAR ABOUT COLL EGE BEING NECESSARILY A FOUR YEAR EXPERIENCE OR HIGH SCHOOL. THEY WANT TO GET OUT WHEN TOGETHER DIRTY TO DO REAL WORK AND HER EMPLOYER'S ARE DESPERATE FOR FOLKS WITH THOSE SKILLS. I APPRECIATE REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; YOU ARE INCLUDING ELEMENTS FROM THAT GROUPS REPORTS. I THINK IT'S A CHALLENGE FOR SOME OF US TO THINK OF SOMEONE ENTERING THE TEACHING PROFESSION WITHOUT A BA DEGREE BUT WITH THAT PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIAL; IN THAT AREA OF CT E EXPERTISE; I DO SHARE REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI IS CONCERNED THAT DEFINITION . I DO ALSO THINK YOU NEED TO BE NARROWED DOWN TO THE CT AREA AND I DON'T THINK THAT IS CLEAR IN THE BILL. I'M ALSO CONCERNED THA T WE TALKED ABOUT NEEDING TEACHERS WITH THE HIGHEST CREDENTIALS. THE BILL DOESN'T ALWAYS GET US THERE HOWEVER. IN THE BILLS THERE IS AN ALLOWANCE FOR SOMEONE TO TEACH WITH NEVER HAVING DONE STUDENT TEACHING ; WITH NEVER HAVING STOOD IN THE FRONT OF THE CLASSROOM ; NEVER AND HAVE IT TO DEVOTE THE LESSON PLAN NEVER HAD TO WORK WITH A GROUP OF STUDENTS; NEVER HAVING HAD TO LEARN HOW TO MANAGE CLASSROOM FOR EDUCATION. AS A PARENT; I WOULDN'T WANT THAT PERSON TEACHING MY CHILD. THERE SIMPLY NOT PREPARED AS A TEACHER; I WOULD NOT WANT THE PERSON IN THE CLASSROOM NEXT TO ME. SO I WOULD HOPE THAT WHEN THIS BILL COMES BACK ASSUMING THAT'S WHAT HAPPENS; THAT GLARING CONCERN AND GLARING HOLE IN THE BILL GETS FIXED. ALSO THE CONCERN THAT THIS LEGISLATION MAY POSE A REAL THREAT TO LICENSING AND RETAINING TEACHERS IN IMMERSION PROGRAMS. MANY DISTRICTS ACROSS THE STATE TO PROVIDE SPANISH VERSION; CHINESE IMMERSION; JAPANESE-I DON'T KNOW ABOUT JAPANESE BUT CHINESE IMMERSION IS VERY POPULAR. THERE'S EVEN SOME-- PROGRAMS. I THINK THERE'S ALWAYS IN THIS BUILD I WOULD THREATEN THE ABILITY TO CREATE AND RETAIN TEACHERS) THE IMPORTANCE OF PROGRAMS AT THE POPULAR PROGRAMS THAT PREPARE OUR CHILDREN FOR THE 21ST CENTURY AND THREATENING THEM AS THIS BILL DOES I QUESTION. SO MEMBERS; THERE ARE SOME GOOD STRONG PROVISIONS IN THIS BILL. THERE'S ALSO SOME AREAS A REAL CONCERN THAT I HOPE WHEN THIS BILL COMES BACK IN A COMEBACK AND VERY DIFFERENTLY. THANK YOU. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HORTMAN >> REPRESENTATIVE HORTMAN: MEMBERS; IN MINNESOTA WE KNOW WE DON'T HAVE ENOUGH TEACHERS WE ABSOLUTELY HAVE TO WORK TO SOLVE THE PROBLEM. BUT REPUBLICANS ARE PROPOSING THIS BILL COULD ACTUALLY MAKE A TEACHER SHORTAGE WORSE. PART OF THE CAUSE OF THE TEACHER SHORTAGE IS A RELENTLESS REPUBLICAN ATTACK ON PUBLIC EDUCATION IN OUR TEACHERS. JUST A FEW DAYS AGO OFF THIS HOUSE FLOOR REPUBLICANS VOTED TO UNDERFUND OUR SCHOOLS AGAIN WHICH COULD CAUSE TEACHER LAYOFFS ACROSS THE STATE. REPUBLICANS USE TEACHERS IN OUR SCHOOLS TO SCORE POLITICAL POINTS YEAR AFTER YEAR . THIS YEAR REPUBLICANS ARE PRIORITIZING PRIVATE SCHOOLS AND CUTTING PRE-K ACROSS THE STATE. THEY PROPOSE BARE-BONES FUNDING AND THEN NO DOUBT WILL TOUT THE FACT THAT AFTER GOV. DAYTON FINALLY GETS HIS WEIGHT SCHOOLS WILL GET A SIMPLE INFLATIONARY INCREASE. THIS IS NOT GOOD ENOUGH. IT'S NOT GOOD ENOUGH FOR OUR TEACHERS COULD NOT GOOD ENOUGH FOR OUR CHILDREN. IF WE WANT TO ATTRACT MORE TEACHERS; AND ENCOURAGE YOUNG MINNESOTANS TO ENTER THE PROFESSION; REPUBLICANS NEED TO QUIT ATTACKING PUBLIC SCHOOLS QUICK CUTTING PUBLIC SCHOOL FUNDING AND QUIT BELITTLING THE TEACHING PROFESSION. MINNESOTANS VALUE EDUCATION AND EXPECT QUALIFIED TEACHERS IN MINNESOTA CLASSROOMS. MEMBERS; PLEASE VOTE NO. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: FURTHER DISCUSSION ON HOUSE FILE 140? REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: THESE SHOULD BE THE CLOSING COMMENTS FOR HOUSE FILE 140. MEMBERS WE BEEN AT THIS FOR BETWEEN 8-9 MONTHS. I DO THINK IT'S VERY OFTEN IN THIS LEGISLATURE THAT WE HAVE SOMETHING THAT'S BEEN VETTED SO MANY TIMES THAT THE FIFTH ENGROSSMENT HERE ON THE FLOOR AND HAS HAD INPUT FROM HUNDREDS OF STAKEHOLDERS. SCHOOL BOARDS ARE LOOKING FOR FLEXIBILITY. I RESPECT HIM. THE GOVERNANCE MODEL HERE IS TEACHER LED TO WE HONOR TEACHERS AND THEY WILL LEAVE THE GOVERNANCE . I VISITED WITH SOME COLLEGE STUDENTS TWO WEEKENDS AGO WHEN HEARD ABOUT THIS BILL AND WAS SO EXCITED AS NEW CANDIDATES ENTERING THE FIELD THAT THERE WAS GOING TO BE A PROMISE FOR THEM FOR THE FUTURE SIMPLIFIED CLEARER UNDERSTANDABLE SYSTEM. THEY WERE SO EXCITED TO READ TO THE BILL AND FIND OUT THEY COULD UNDERSTAND IT AND SO FOR THAT; I THINK WE COULD LOOK FORWARD TO CANDIDATES COMING INTO A PROFESSION; MY PROFESSION; AND BEING EXCITED ABOUT MOVING FORWARD BECAUSE NOW THEY HAVE A STATUTORY SECTIONS THAT ACTUALLY ARE UNDERSTANDABLE THAT ARE CLEAR; TRANSPARENT AND ACCOUNTABILITY. NUMBERS; IN REGARD TO THE TEACHER EVALUATION; THE TEACHER VALUATIONS ACROSS THE STATE HAVE IMPROVEMENT PLANS. WITH THIS SAYS FOR CHEER FOR; THEY ARE NOT IN IMPROVEMENT PLAN. WE HONOR THE DIFFERENCES AMONG TEACHER EVALUATION PLANS. WE SPECIFICALLY THE GOV. AND ME AN D THE FORMER SEN. JAN OLSEN; SPECIFICALLY VISITED ABOUT MAKING SURE THAT THESE COULD BE INDIVIDUALLY DESIGNED. MEMBERS; THIS IS A REALLY GOOD REFORM AND I HOPE YOU CAN ALL VOTE YES. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: PC NO FURTHER DISCUSSION THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL ON THE BILL. >>[ROLL CALL VOTE]. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THE CLERK WILL CLOSE THE ROLL. THERE BEING 76 AYE AND 50 THAT TRIP TO THE BILLS PASS AS AMENDED AND TITLE AGREED TO >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: NEXT BILL ON THE CALENDAR FOR THE DAY IS SENATE FILE 803. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE CLERK WILL REPORT THEBI LL. >> CHIEF CLERK: SENATE FILE 803 NUMBER TWO ON THE CALENDAR FOR THE DAY AND ACT RELATING TO PUBLIC SAFETYUNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: I RECOGNIZE REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH TO INTRODUCE YOUR BIL L >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH; THIS THE PUBLIC SAFETY OMNIBUS BILL SENATE FILE IT 03 BEFORE I BEGIN I LIKE TO THANK THE STAFF JEFFREY DIEBEL AND BEN JOHNSON OUR HOUSE RESEARCH JOHN WALSH THIS GO ANALYST MIKE-COMMITTEE ADMINISTRATOR; JASON-COMMITTEE LEGISLATIVE ASSIGNMENT DAVID [INAUDIBLE] AND LAURA DFL RESEARCH. WITH THEIR HELP IT GET TO ME TO GET 134 VOTES MINOR SENDING [INAUDIBLE]. NOW; TO EXPLAIN THE BILL; I WILL DO A HIGH ALTITUDE FLYOVER AND THEN IF YOU WANT ME TO DIG DEEPER I WILL. I'LL RUN THROUGH THE INCREASE SPENDING HIGHLIGHTS AND SOME OF THE POLICY THEN ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. HE SPENDING HIGHLIGHTS ARE $52 MILLION ACROSS JUDICIAL BRANCH IN AGENCY FOR 1%; TATIAN INCREASE IN INCREASED HEALTH INSURANCE COST. ONE POINT 7;000;004 JUDGE IN IS A TWO OR 1000 YEARS FOR TREATMENT HURT. 20;000 IS FOR NEW CASE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR THE TAX COURT. 4.1 MILLION TO BE PLACED ON PREDATORY OFFENDING REGISTRY AT BCA. 3.2 MILLION FOR UPGRADED TECHNOLOGY SYSTEM TO ALLOW POLICE OFFICERS TO ACCESS AND SERVE AS TRAINING ORDERS FROM 2 MILLION TO REPLENISH THE DISASTER ASSISTANCE ACCOUNT. BYRON THOUSAND OAKS AND GRANTS COMBAT TERRORISM RECRUITMENT FOR AND 79;000 FOR ADDITIONAL SEX TRAFFICKING PREVENTION GRANTS. TWO AND 1000 FOR DE-ESCALATION TRAINING PUBLIC SAFETY PERSONNEL. 150 GRAND FOR A PRIVATE SECURITY GRANTS. 15 MILLION FOR ADDITIONAL REIMBURSEMENTS AND LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES FOR TRAINING. THAT'S THE POLICE TRAINING BILL. 20 MILLION FOR INCREASED INMATE HEALTHCARE COSTS FOR THE DOC DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS OR 5.7 MILLION FOR [INAUDIBLE] SUPERVISION OF SEX OFFENDERS. SOME OF THE SEX OFFENDER BILL WORK WE DID IN HERE IS FUNDED. 2.2 MILLION FOR RED WING D OC THE PREVENTION OF RAPE COMPLIANCE ACT COMING FROM THE FEDS WE HAVE TO FUND. 1.5 MILLION FOR EXPANDED MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES AT DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS OR THREE AND 70;000 FOR ALTERNATIVES INCARCERATION TREATMENT FOR CERTAIN NONVIOLENT SUBSTANCE-ABUSE OFFENDERS WHO VIOLATE TERMS OF PROBATION DRUG THOUSAND FOR TARGETED VESTED PENSION PROGRAM FROM OF CORRECTION IT A COUPLE OF THESE NUMBERS COULD CHANGE TO DO WITH THE AMENDMENT MAKING THE BILL SO THOSE NUMBERS WILL CHANGE SLIGHTLY. FOR THE POLICY HIGHLIGHTS; WE HAVE THAT LAW FORCING TRAINING BILL THAT I TALKED ABOUT WHERE WE MANDATE AND FUND TRACES INTERVENTION MENTAL ON THIS MENTALLY DISTURBED PERSONS; SUICIDE AND CONFLICT MANAGEMENT MEDIATION AND ALSO TRAINING IMPLICIT BIAS. WE'VE INCREASE PENALTIES FOR ILLEGAL PROTESTS GET AT THE PROTESTER BUILDER WE'VE NARROWED DOWN NOW TO MORE OR LESS FREEWAYS AND AIRPORT AND RAIL. THE ONLY INCREASE IT TO A GROSS MISDEMEANOR NOT A FELONY. THEY'RE FINE PLEASE OFFICERS WAY TO CARRY PRIVATE ASSUMPTIONS BASICALLY THAT ALLOWS FULL-TIME LICENSED OFF-DUTY OFFICERS LIKE THE ORIGINAL INTENTION THE BILL BACK IN 2005 AT EFFECTS. WE INCREASE THE FARMERS ACCESS TO LEGAL AID SO THEY MAY APPLY FOR LEGAL AID PROPERTY LIMIT. PROTECTING MEDICAL PERSON L AS ASSAULTING HOSPITAL MEDICAL PERSONNEL TO THE FOURTH DEGREE ASSAULT STATUTE. SO WOULD BE ANY NURSE IN THE BUILDING INSTEAD OF JUST THE EMERGENCY ROOM. OPTION TWO WEEKS OR OWN THE APPLETON PRISON PROTECTING VICTIMS OF SEXUAL ABUSE. THAT'S THE BOUT STATE ADJUDICATION AND IMPOSITION OF SOME OF THESE PROMINENT CASES YOU HEARD ABOUT IN THE NEWS LATELY BEEN ENSURING RURAL CROPS UP DISASTER RELIEF FUNDING AS PART OF THE DISASTER ASSISTANCE FUND. THEN WE HAVE A NUMBER OF THING PROBABLY FOUR BILLS DFL BILLS AND ASSORTED GOP BILLS IN THEIR. I WOULD NOW STAND FOR ANY QUESTIONS OR TAKE AMENDMENT ESTHER SPEAKER. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: CORNISH MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE NUMBER 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS FOLLOWS. THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 31 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH: THIS AMENDMENT REMOVES THE APPROPRIATION FOR MINISTRY THAT COST POTENTIAL LEASE OR PURCHASE OF APPLETON PRISON $208;000. IT ISN'T REALLY NECESSARY AT THIS TIME SINCE ANY POTENTIAL COST WOULDN'T BE INCURRED UNT IL THE COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIONS DETERMINE THE NEEDS EXIST UNDER THE CURRENT LANGUAGE OF THE BILL. THE PROBATES AN ADDITIONAL 100;000 PER YEAR FOR TREATMENT GRANTS UNDER THE ALTERNATIVE INCARCERATION PROGRAM FUND WHICH IS GOING TO BE AVAILABLE FOR TREATMENT OPTIONS OF CERTAIN NONVIOLENT SUBSTANCE ABUSE OFFENDERS WHO RECEIVED TECHNICAL VIOLATIONS WHILE ON PROBATION AND IT INCORPORATES $104;000 A YEAR TO THE TAX COURT TO OPERATE THE NEW CASE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM THEY REQUESTED. THEY REQUESTED MORE THAN THAT BUT I'LL LEAVE THIS WILL NOT BE ENOUGH TO SATISFY THE REQUIREMENTS. MN.IT IS ASKING FOR AN ADDITIONAL $152;000 AND WE ARE NOT COMPLETELY CONVINCED THAT'S NECESSARY SO THAT THE AUTHORS AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION ON THE A- 31 AMENDMENT? REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM: MEMBERS; I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU TO VOTE FOR THE A- 31 AMENDMENT. THIS REMOVES THE MONEY PUT IN PLACE IN ORDER TO ASSESS THE VALUE OF THE APPLETON PRISON WHICH AM VERY MUCH OPPOSED TO AND I BELIE VE IT IS A MORE APPROPRIATE USE OF THE RESOURCES. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION ON THE A- 31 AMENDMENT? SEEING NONE; ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY; AYE. [CHORUS OF AYES.] OPPOSED; SAY NAY. THE MOTION PREVAILS. THE AMENDMENT IS ADOPTED. >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: DEHN BOOST AMEND SENATE FILE 103 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 21. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE DEHN: THE UNIFORM COLLATERAL CONSEQUENCES OF CONVICTION THAT WAS A BILL WE HEARD IN PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE. IT DID NOT MAKE IT INTO THE PUBLIC SAFETY BILL . I THINK THERE ARE SEVERAL OF US VERY DISAPPOINTED IN THAT. WHAT IT DOES DO IS MAKES IT CLEAR THAT FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE CHARGED WITH A CRIME AS THEY GO THROUGH THE PROCESS IN THE COURTS THAT THEY ARE REALLY ENTERING INTO A CONTRACT WITH THE STATE THAT IF I PLEAD GUILTY AND A LARGE MAJORITY OF OUR CASES THE GO THROUGH THE COURT SYSTEM HAVE WHAT'S CALLED A PLEA BARGAIN THAT TAKES PLACE. BUT IF THEY DO PLEAD GUILTY THAT'S IMPORTANT FOR THEM TO UNDERSTAND NOT JUST THE CONSEQUENCE WITHOUT ACTUAL CHARGE WHAT THAT MEANS DIRECTLY BUT ALSO WHAT ARE THOSE COLLATERAL CAUSES MOVING FORWARD; WHETHER THAT BE DIFFICULTY IN FINDING A JOB; DIFFICULTY IN GETTING HOUSING ; MAKING SURE IT'S CLEAR THAT CERTAIN TYPES OF PROFESSIONS THAT MAY BE PROHIBITED FROM GETTING LICENSES TO ACTUALLY PRACTICING. SO I'VE HAD SOME CONVERSATIONS WITH CHAIRMAN CORNISH; AND I DON'T BELIEVE THAT THERE'S INTEREST AT THIS TIME TO TAKE THIS AS A CURRENT AMENDMENT BUT HE'S MADE A COMMITMENT TO CONTINUE TO WORKING ON THIS TO GET THE LANGUAGE IN A PLACE THAT FOLKS CAN BE HAPPY WITH MOVING FORWARD; POSSIBLY KNOWS MAYBE LATER THIS YEAR; MAYBE NOT TILL NEXT YEAR BUT AT THIS TIME I LIKE TO WITHDRAW THIS AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN WITHDRAWS THE A- 21 MIN. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: HILSTROM BOOST AMEND SENATE FILE IT 03 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 22. THE SPEAKER REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM THE A- 22; THE A- 23 AND A- 24 ARE ALL NOW GOING TO BE OUT OF ORDER FINANCIAL WE ADOPTED REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH'S AMENDMENT; WERE MOVING THE MONEY FROM HOUSE AND WE ELIMINATED THE MONEY SO I DO INTEND TO A STRAW ALL THREE OF THESE AMENDMENT. I JUST WANT TO MAKE IT CLEAR WHAT IT IS WE ARE WHAT'S MISSING FROM THIS BILL. SO THAT YOU'RE ALL CLEAR AS WE GET READY TO GO INTO CONFERENCE ABOUT WHAT I HOPE WILL COME OUT BETTER. MEMBERS; THE PROBATION OFFICERS ARE WE WERE REQUESTED IN THE GOV. BUDGET WERE NOT FUNDED. IS A 1% INCREASE FOR THEIR SALARY AND IT GOES TO PAY FOR THEIR INSURANCE. HOWEVER; WAS NO STEPS A ND LANES PROVIDED AND THERE WAS NO INCREASE IN THE ACTUAL NUMBER OF PROBATION OFFICERS. THE M ICE 23 AMENDMENT DOES THAT FOR THE PUBLIC OFFENDERS IT IS NOT ONE NEW PUBLIC DEFENDER IN THIS BILL IN THE A- 24 AMENDMENT IS FOR CORRECTIONS OFFICER. WHILE WERE DISCUSSING WHETHER NOT TO OPEN THE APPLETON PRISON; WE ARE NOT IN THIS BILL EVEN FINDING THE PROPER CORRECTIONS OFFICERS TO ADMINISTER THE CORRECTIONS DEPARTMENT THAT WE HAVE AT THIS TIME. SO WITH THAT MR. SPEAKER AND MEMBERS I WOULD WITHDRAW THE A- 23; A- 22; A- 23; AND A- 24 MARKS >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM WITHDRAWS THE A- RANGE AMEND. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. SPEAKER >> CHIEF CLERK: CONSIDINE MOVES TO AMEND THE UNOFFICIAL GROSSMAN AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 25. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE: THIS AMENDMENT WE HE ARD TESTIMONY AND WE HAVE A PROVISION IN THERE NOW THAT ANYBODY THAT IS 10 YEARS OLD AND OLDER HAS A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO AN ATTORNEY; WHICH WE PUSH FORWARD . UNFORTUNATE; BUT WE DO NOT DO WAS INCREASE THE PUBLIC OFFENDERS BOTTOM LINE WHICH MEANS THAT IN ADDITION TO EVERYTHING ELSE THEY ARE DOING; THEY WILL NOW HAVE TO STEP UP AND REPRESENT THESE 10 YEAR OLDS. UNFORTUNATE; FOR ME; REPRESENTATIVE AND CORNISH BELIEVE NOW HAS USED UP THE MONEY I WAS PLANNING ON USING SO I GUESS I'M GOING UP TO WITHDRAW THE AMENDMENT SO THANK YOU. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE WITHDRAWS THE A- 25 AMENDMENT TO IS IT ALSO 110 TO WITHDRAW THE A- 26 WOULD YOU LIKE ME TO INTRODUCE THAT? THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: CONSIDINE MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 80 3 THE UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 26. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE 28 TO THE A- 26 AMENDMENT. >> REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE: REPRESENTATIVE KRESHA BROUGHT FORTH A BILL THAT I THOUGHT WAS AN OUTSTANDING BILL THAT ALLOWS FARMERS TO ACCESS THE LEGAL SERVICE BUT I THINK WE WANT OUR FACTORIES AND FARM COMMITTEES TO HAVE ACCESS TO LEGAL ADVICE; PARTICULARLY; IF THEY CAN-ME ET THE THRESHOLD FOR INCOME. AGAIN; UNFORTUNATELY; THOUGH WE HEARD LEGAL SERVICES WAS ALREADY A MAJORITY OF THE PEOPLE THAT THEY ARE CURRENT LY REQUESTING SERVICES FROM AND THEY'RE HAVING TO TURN DOWN. SO; KEN WAS HOPING TO SOME MONEY TO SUPPORT REPRESENTATIVE TRENCHARD ISSUES BILL HERE BUT AGAIN THE MONEY HAS DISAPPEARED SO I WILL WITHDRAW IT. THANK YOU >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE WITHDRAWS THE A- 26 AMENDMENT. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: WARD BOOST AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 27. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE WARD TO THE A- 27 AMENDMENT. >> REPRESENTATIVE WARD: MEMBERS; USE INTERVENTION PROGRAMS HAVE BEEN AROUND AROUND FOR A LONG TIME. THEY WERE ORIGINALLY ESTABLISHED AS A FEDERAL PROGRAM AND EVERY COUNTY IN EVERY STATE HAD A USE INTERVENTION PROGRAM. AFTER A NUMBER OF YEARS; THAT WAS ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WAS CUT FROM THE FEDERAL BUDGET AND IT WAS DETERMINED THAT LOCALS LOCAL GOVERNMENT SHOULD PAY FOR THIS. IT IS A COMMUNITY-BASED APPROACH USE INTERVENTION REVERSES THE GROWTH IN STATE GOVERNMENT. THE OUTCOMES ARE SELF-SUFFICIENT ADULTS WORKING SHIPPING MEMBERS OF SOCIETY. USE INTERVENTION WORKS. YOUTH DO BETTER IN SCHOOL ; IMPROVE THEIR LIFE SKILLS; DEVELOP THOSE SOCIAL ATTITUDES AND 90% OF THEM DON'T GET INTO TROUBLE AGAIN WITH THE LAW. IT SAVES MONEY. WE GET ABOUT $10 BACK FOR EVERY DOLLAR THAT WE PUT IN. THAT'S WHY I WAS THINKING IN TERMS OF USING THE MONEY THAT WE WERE GOING TO SPEND ON THE APPLETON PRISON FOR USE INTERVENTION BECAUSE WHY NOT PREVENT THE PROBLEMS FROM DEVELOPING INTO ADULT PROBLEMS? IT WOULD DIMINISH THE NEED FOR MORE PRISONS; BUT I ALSO APPRECIATE WITH A MODERATE IS GOING OUT. SO USE INTERVENTION PROGRAMS SERVICES ARE PROVIDED FOR FRACTION OF THE COST OF OTHER PROGRAMS. TO THOSE MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES; ADDITIONAL SERVICES AND OTHER ISSUES THAT YOUNG PEOPLE FACE ARE DRESSED ADDRESSED AT THE LOCAL LEVEL. LAW ENFORCEMENT SUPPORTS USE INTERVENTION. THE USE INTERVENTION PROGRAMS NEED -THE NEEDS AROUND THE STATE OF MINNESOTA OVER $60 MILLION WAS REQUESTED FROM THE US E INTERVENTION ASSOCIATION IN 2015 ONLY 6.5 WAS APPROPRIATED. SO OUR GOAL IS TO REFORM HOW WE SUPPORT USE T O BECOME PRODUCTIVE ADULTS. TO DO THE INTERVENTION EARLY. RATHER THAN LATER WHEN IT'S FAR MORE EXPENSIVE AND WE HAVE LOST PEOPLE. MR. SPEAKER; GIVEN THAT THERE IS NO MONEY AT THIS POINT; I WITHDRAW THE AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE WARD WITHDRAWS THE A- 27 AMENDMENT. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: DEHN MOVES T O AMEND SENATE 80803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED IN THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 20 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT. BTV DEHN BMIS 20 AMENDMENT THOSE THINGS SIMILAR TO WHAT THE A- 38 AND LOOKS THAT WE JUST PAST. I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WHEN WE TALK LETTER PRISON POPULATION THE WAS A LOT OF TALK THIS YEAR ABOUT EXPANDING THE NUMBER OF BEDS AND THAT'S ONE WAY TO ADDRESS IT. ANOTHER WAY OF COURSE TO ADDRESS IT IS TO LOOK AT ALTERNATIVES INCARCERATION. EVIDENCE SHOWS OFTENTIMES THAT INDIVIDUALS THAT DON'T GO TO PRISON I DON'T GET LOCKED UP ACTUALLY END UP HAVING A MUCH MUCH LOWER RATE OF REOFFENDING IN THE FUTURE. WHILE WE CONSIDER WHAT WE DO WITH THOSE INDIVIDUALS THAT HAVE WANT US ON THE COMMISSION OF CRIMES WE ALSO MAKE IT CLEAR THAT WE CREATE OPPORTUNITIES TO MOVE FORWARD WITHOUT BECOMING [INAUDIBLE] IN OUR DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS. I THINK IT IS FASCINATING THAT MYSELF AND SHERMAN CORNISH HAVE REAL SIMILAR AMENDMENT TO THIS BILL. AND WHAT TO DO WITH THE FUNDING THAT WAS CURRENTLY IN THE BILL FOR FUNDING FOR THE STUDY OF THE APPLETON PRISON. SO; AT THIS TIME I LIKE TO WITHDRAW THIS AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN WITHDRAWS THE A- 28 MOUSE. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: DEHN MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 29 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN; TO INTRODUCE THE AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE DEHN: THIS AMENDMENT WOULD HAVE ACTUALLY PARTIALLY FUNDED THE JUSTICE REINVESTMENT ACCOUNT WHOSE PURPOSE IS TO MAKE SURE THAT THOSE INDIVIDUALS WHO DO THAT ARE CONVICTED OF A CRIME TO END UP SERVING TIME THAT HE ACTUALLY DON'T GO BACK AGAIN AND THE INTENT OF COURSE IS IF WE INVEST IN REDUCING THE AMOUNT OF RECIDIVISM TO OFFENDERS WHEN THEY RECOMMIT THAT ULTIMATELY THAT'S QUICK TO SAVE US MONEY IN THE LONG RUN. THE ON SAVING US MONEY IS ALSO THE RIGHT THING TO DO. I THINK ALL OF US THINK ABOUT THOSE THINGS WHEN WE WERE YOUNG THAT WE DID IT MAY NOT HAVE BEEN THE SMARTEST THINGS THAT MANY OF YOU KNOW MY STORY. IF GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY MANY INDIVIDUALS ARE MORE THAN HAPPY; MORE THAN WILLING AND THEY REALLY DESIRE TO DO THE THINGS THAT ARE GOOD IN SOCIETY THE THINGS GOOD FURTHER SOCIETIES AND THINGS GOOD FOR ALL OF US. BUT SINCE THERE'S NO LONGER ANY FUNDING AVAILABLE GIVING TO A- 31 MR. SPEAKER I LIKE TO WITHDRAW THE AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN WITHDRAWS THE A- 19 AMENDMENT. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: HILSTROM MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 20 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: I RECOGNIZE THE MEMBER REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM MEMBERS THIS IS THE PRE--JUDGMENT INTEREST AMENDMENT THE CHANGES MINNESOTA LAW. CURRENTLY; IF YOU SUE SOMEONE AND YOU FIND THAT THE COURT FINDS THAT A HARMED YOU YOU ARE CURRENTLY ENTITLED TO PREJUDGMENT INTEREST IN THE AMOUNT OF 10%. THIS BILL CHANGES THAT. IT MAKES IT SO THAT IF YOU WERE AN INDIVIDUAL AND YOU WIN IN YOUR CASE; THAT THE AMOUNT OF INTEREST IS LOWERED AND IT'S BASED ON A CALLED EIGHT T-BILL BUT BASICALLY IT'S WHAT A COST FOR SOMEONE TO BORROW MONEY. NOT WHAT IT COST YOU TO BORROW MONEY. MEMBERS; THE INTERESTING PIECE ABOUT W HAT THIS BILL DOES IS IT SAYS IF YOU'RE A LITTLE PERSON AN INDIVIDUAL SU ING SOMEBODY YOU DON'T GET THAT HIGHER INTEREST RATE ANYMORE. HOWEVER; COMPANIES WHO CHOOSE TO SUE ONE ANOTHER THEY STILL GET THAT HIGHER INTEREST. SO WHAT THIS DOES; IF YOU LOOK AT LINE -PAGE 30 LINE 23; THAT'S WHAT THAT STATUTE 68.011 SAYS. MEMBERS; THIS IS MAKING AN ON LEVEL PLAYING FIELD IT'S MAKING IT HARDER FOR INDIVIDUALS TO RECOVER THE MONEY THEY'RE ENTITLED TO IN THE COURT PROCESS AND IT GIVES A DISINCENTIVE FOR BUSINESSES TO SETTLE WHEN THEY ARE IN CASES THAT INVOLVE INDIVIDUALS. MEMBERS; I WOULD ASK FOR A ROLL CALL BOAT AND I'D ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT FOR THE A- 20 AND LOOKS TO REMOVE THIS PROVISION >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ROLL CALL HAS BEEN REQUESTED. SEEING FIFTEEN HANDS THERE WILL BE A ROLL CALL. REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH I WOULD ASK FOR A NO VOTE ON THE AMENDMENT BUT I DEFER TO REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS TO EXPLAIN WHY. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS >> REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS: MEMBERS; THIS LANGUAGE WAS ALSO IN THE PUBLIC SAFETY OMNIBUS BILL THAT THIS HOUSE PAST TWO YEARS AGO. IT'S HELPFUL TO GO BACK A WHILE AND FIGURE OUT HOW WE ENDED UP YOUR. REMEMBER THAT IT WAS A FEW YEARS BACK THAT THE LEGISLATURE DECIDED TO MOVE PRE-AND POST JUDGMENT INTEREST RATES TO 10%. ONE YEAR AFTER THAT MOVE LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT CAME BACK TO THE LEGISLATURE AND LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT CITIES COUNTIES TOWNSHIPS SCHOOL BOARDS; THEY CAME BACK TO THE LEGISLATURE AND THEY SAID; 10% INTEREST IS NOT CONNECTED TO THE MARKET. IT'S PUNITIVE. WE CAN'T AFFORD TO PAY THAT. SO WHAT DID THE LEGISLATURE DO? THE LEGISLATURE SAID; OR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT WE CAN CHANGE THAT BACK TO 4%. BUT FOR EVERYONE ELSE; WE WILL STICK YOU WITH A 10%. SO WE'VE COME BACK YEAR AFTER YEAR TO TRY TO RETURN THE P JUDGMENT INTEREST BACK TO REALITY AND BACK TO THE NORMS OF THE MARKET. IN STATUTE; THIS IS CONNECTED DIRECTLY TO THE P-BILL RATE. IF THE T -BILL RATE; OR 10% IN STATUTE NOW AFTER TH AT CHANGE. WHAT WE ARE TRYING TO DO IS CHANGE BAC K TO CONNECTED TO THE T-BILL RATE WITH A FLOOR OF 4%. IT MIGHT INTEREST YOU THAT 35 STATES ARE NOW BELOW 10% HAVING MOVED DOWN OVER THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS BECAUSE OF HISTORICALLY LOW INTEREST RATES. SEVERAL STATES JUST THIS YEAR LOWERED THEIR RATES AGAIN AND AGAIN. IN FACT; WEST VIRGINIA JUST A FEW WEEKS AGO WENT FROM 7% TO 4%. SO WE'RE SEEING THIS CONSTANT MARCH DOWN AS OTHER STATES ARE IDENTIFYING WITH THE REALITY OF THE MARKET IS WITH INTEREST RATES. I JUST WANT TO MENTION; REALLY BRIEFLY; CHAPTER 60-A .08 11 THE LAW PROVISION THAT EXCLUDED IN THIS IS A SEPARATE AGREEMENT WAS HAMMERED OUT HAVING TO DO WITH A PUNITIVE INTEREST RATE FOR AN INSURANCE COMPANY THAT HAS A FAILURE IN THEIR DUTY TO REPRESENT. THAT IS A PUNITIVE CLAUSE FOR A BREACH OF CONTRACT. COMPARING THAT IS LIKE COMPARING APPLES TO MONSTERS. IT JUST DOESN'T WORK. SO DON'T BE CONFUSED. WE NOW HAVE 35 OTHER STATES THAT ARE FOLLOWING THE MARKET . THAT ARE FOLLOWING WHAT WE SAY IN STATE STATUTE THAT WE OUGHT TO DO WHICH IS CONNECTED TO THE T-BILL. LET'S FOLLOW THAT. REMEMBER; WHEN GOVERNMENT CAME AND ASKED FOR HELP THIS LEGISLATURE HELPED. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS; TO PARAPHRASE WHAT MY MOTHER ONCE ASKED ME; IF YOUR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT TOLD YOU TO JUMP OFF A BRIDGE WOULD YOU EQUIP >> REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH; I GUESS IT DEPENDS IF YOU GO FIRST. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: WELL; IS BEEN QUITE A FEW DAYS SINCE I'VE GONE BRIDGE JUMPING AND YES MY MOTHER WOULD HAVE CAUTIONED AGAINST IT. WHICH WHY I DID NOT TELL HER AT THE TIME BUT HERE'S MY POINT. YOUR ENTIRE ARGUMENT IS PREDICATED ON THE FACT THAT WE ALL THOUGHT THAT CHANGING INTERES T FOR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT WAS A GREAT IDEA. WE DIDN'T. MR. SPEAKER ; REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS; DO YOU KNOW THE VOTE BY WHICH THAT PASSED THE HOUSE WE MAYBE INTEREST CHANGE FOR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT? >> REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS : THAT WAS BEFORE MY TIME. I DO NOT. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: WE'VE ALL GOT THESE COMPUTERS ON YOUR. THEY'RE SUPPOSED TO TELL US IN THE HOUSE JOURNAL BUT WAS NOT BY A HUGE MARGIN I WILL TELL YOU THAT. SO THE SUGGESTION THAT WE GOT 1% AGREEMENT OF THE FACT THAT SHOULD WORK FOR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT WE SHOULD APPLY TO EVERYONE; IS A BIT OF A STRETCH. I WOULD NOTE THIS. REMEMBER MEMBERS; THIS INTEREST IS FOR PEOPLE WHO WERE WRONGED. THIS IS NOT FOR FOLKS ARE JUST TRYING TO SHOOT FOR THE MOON AND GET A GOOD DEAL AGAINST THE LOCAL EUROPE GOVERNMENT OVER A BUSINESS COULD THIS IS FOR PEOPLE WHO WERE WRONGED. WHILE THEY HAVE TO WAIT FOR THE GRINDING YEARS OF JUSTICE TO COME AROUND AND GIVE THEM WHAT IS THERE DUE THE Y HAVE TO PAY FOR THOSE COST OF NOT HAVING A JOB OF MEDICAL BILLS. OF HOUSING AND YOU KNOW WHAT THEY DO; THEY PUT IT ON A CREDIT CARD. WHICH ARE CREDIT CARD INTEREST RATE? YOU THINK SOMEHOW IT'S A GOOD IDEA TO LOWER THIS TO THE T-BILL RATE YOU KNOW. IT WAS NOT I GET YOU REPRESENTATIVE ZERWAS FOR LOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNMENT. BUT THEY CAME AROUND HAT ENHANCING THIS IS JUST TOO MUCH AND BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT FOR PROFIT ENTITIES; THEY'VE ALL HEAVY HERE AT TH E LEGISLATURE; THEY GOT IT BECAUSE THEY SQUEAKY WHEEL GETS THE GREASE AROUND HERE. BUT THAT DOESN'T MEAN IT WAS A GOOD IDEA. S O TO SUGGEST WE PASSED OUT AGAINST WHAT WAS THE BETTER JUDGMENT OF MANY OF US IN THIS BODY THAT SOMEHOW WE NEED TO STICK IT TO EVERYBODY ELSE; TOO; THAT SOMEHOW YOU WERE FAMILY MEMBER WAS INJURED BY TARGETS WERE BY CAR GUILT OR BY GENERAL MILLS; OR ANY OF THE OTHER MULTINATIONAL CORPORATIONS IN THE UNITED STATES; SOMEHOW; NO; YOU GOT TO PUT THAT ON YOUR CITIBANK CARD AT 15% INTEREST BUT WE WILL PAY YOU BACK; FOUR. THAT'S NOT FAIR; MEMBERS. THIS PROVISION SHOULD BE REMOVED. YOU ARE GOING TO HEAR FROM MAYBE NOT A MAJORITY OF YOUR CONSTITUENTS BUT THERE WILL BE SOMEONE HERE OR THERE WHO SAYS; THIS IS CRAZY BY DIRECTOR PAY CITIBANK 15% OF THE PEOPLE WHO DID THE DAMAGE ON ME 4% ON THAT? IT'S NOT FAIR. VOTE FOR THE ADDITIONAL AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM: MEMBERS; AGAI N AS REPRESENTATIVE LESCH JUST SAID; MOST OF THE FOLKS GOING THROUGH THIS PROCESS OF COURT ARE PAYING THE BILLS BY PUTTING THEIR EXPENSES ON THEIR CREDIT CARDS. I DON'T KNOW TOO MANY PEOPLE THAT CAN BORROW MONEY AT 4%. EVEN MANY PEOPLE AS HOMEOWNERS MORTGAGES ARE AT A HIGHER RATE THAN THAT. YOU DON'T GET THE INTEREST THAT YOU WERE DUE UNLESS YOU PROVEN IN COURT THAT YOU'RE ENTITLED TO THE MONEY. S O WHAT INCENTIVE DOES THE COMPANY HAVE TO SETTLE BUT THEY CAN USE YOUR MONEY AT A CHEAPER RATE THAN WHAT YOU CAN USE IT FOR. THERE'S A LOW PENALTY FOR IT. NUMBERS; I DON'T THINK WE SHOULD PUT OUR FINGER ON THE SCALE AND HELP BIG BUSINESS COMPARED TO OUR INDIVIDUAL CONCISION. THAT'S WHAT I BELIEVE THIS PROVISION DOES. PLEASE; SUPPORT THE A- 20 AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: SEEING NO FURTHER DISCUSSION THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL ON THE AMENDMENT. >>[ROLL CALL VOTE]. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THE CLERK WILL CLOSE THE ROLL. THERE BEING 56 AYE AND 75 NAY THE MOTION DOES NOT TRAIL AND THE AMENDMENT IS NOT ADOPTED >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: HILSTROM OFFERS THE FOLLOWING MEMBERS. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. SPEAKER >> CHIEF CLERK: HILSTROM MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 18 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM ON THE A- 18 MIN. BTB HILSTROM: MEMBERS YOU SHOULD BE GETTING THREE HANDOUTS FROM ME RELATED TO THIS PROVISION. IN THIS BILL ON PAGE 33 T HIS BILL REPEALS THE SEATBELT GAG RULE THAT MINNESOTA HAS HAD IN LAW FOR MANY MANY YEARS. I BELIEVE SINCE ABOUT 1965. MEMBERS; WE AT THE LEGISLATURE AND THE COURT MAKE A DETERMINATION ABOUT WHAT IS FAIR FOR A JURY TO HEAR AS EVIDENCE WHEN THEY ARE DETERMINING WHAT SHOULD HAPPEN IN A CASE. WE HAVE DECIDED SINCE 1965 THAT JURIES SHOULD NOT HERE WHETHER OR NOT A DRIVER HAS INSURANCE. WE DON'T BELIEVE THAT JURIES SHOULD HEAR WHETHER OR NOT SOMEONE WHO'S INVOLVED IN A CRASH; IF THEY HAVE INSURANCE BECAUSE WE BELIEVE THAT MIGHT CHANGE THE OUTCOME IN THE DECISION THE JURY MIGHT MAK E. IF SOMEONE HAS INSURANCE; THEY MAY BELIEVE THEY CAN AFFORD TO PAY MORE IN DAMAGES. WE AL SO HAVE SAID THAT THE JURY SHOULD NOT HEAR WHETHER OR NOT THE PERSON WHO IS HARMED IN THE CRASH WAS WEARING A SEATBELT. BECAUSE IF YOU'RE NOT AT FAULT FOR THE CRASH YOU'RE STOPPED AT A STOP SIGN ; YOU ARE NOT MOVING AND SOMEONE RUNS YOU OVER; AND YOU ARE HARMED; WE DON'T BELIEVE THAT GOES TO WHETHER OR NOT YOU WERE AT FAULT FOR THE CRASH. THEREFORE; THE JURY SHOULD NOT HERE IN DETERMINING DAMAGES. THIS BILL UNDOES THAT GAG RULE. I'M PASSING OF THREE PIECES OF PAPER . THE FIRST ONE; TRACY MORGAN. I CAN'T BELIEVE WALMART IS BLAMING ME. THIS IS AN EXACT EXAMPLE OF HOW AN INSURANCE COMPANY; OR SOMEONE WHO DID YOU HARM; WOULD SAY TO A COURT; I SHOULD PAY YOU LESS. YOU SHOULD BE ENTITLED TO LESS DAMAGES BECAUSE YOU WERE NOT WEARING YOUR SEATBELT. EVE N IF YOU HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH WHY THE CRASH OCCURRED. RIGHT HERE IN MINNESOTA; RIGHT NOW; WE HAVE A CRASH OUT OF ST. CLOUD WHERE SOME FOLKS WERE SITTING AT A TRAFFIC LIGHT AND THEY WERE KILLED. THAT'S THE SECOND HANDOUT YOU HAVE HERE. THE PROVISION OF THIS BILL WOULD SAY THAT THE TWO FOLKS WHO WERE KILLED ; THAT THE JURY SHOULD GET TO LOWER THE AMOUNT OF DAMAGES THEY POTENTIALLY ARE PAID. ON WHETHER OR NOT THEY WERE WEARING THEIR SEATBELT. AGAIN; THEY WERE STOPPED. THE CRASH WAS NOT THEIR FAULT. IN DETERMINING HOW MANY DAMAGES SHOULD BE PAID THIS BILL WOULD ALLOW INSURANCE; NEEDS TO PAY LESS GOOD THAT'S WHAT THIS IS ABOUT. THEN THERE'S AN ARTICLE YOU HAVE AS WELL WHERE IT ACTUALLY TALKS A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT WALMART BLAMING TRACY MORGAN FOR NOT WEARING HIS SEATBELT. MEMBERS; SOMEONE IS SAYING THIS IS TRACY MORGAN GETS BLAMED; WHAT CHANCES DO YOUR CONSTITUENTS HAVE TO FIGHT THIS? MEMBERS; WE DECIDE WHAT IS FAIR FOR JURIES TO HEAR BECAUSE WE WANT A FAIR AND JUST OUTCOME. WHAT A THIS PROVISION WOULD DO; FOR EXAMPLE; IF YOU ARE STOPPED YOU ARE STOPPED IN YOUR DRIVEWAY; STOPPED IN FRONT OF YOUR HOUSE AND MAYBE YOU HAVE YOUR SEATBELT ON BECAUSE YOU'RE WAITING FOR SOMEONE AND YOU ARE HIT BY A DRUNK DRIVER. NOT YOUR FAULT. THE INSURANCE; HE WOULD GET TO PRODUCE EVIDENCE THAT YOU WERE NOT WEARING YOUR SEATBELT AND THEREFORE YOU ARE HARMED BECAUSE OF YOUR OWN FAULT. I DON'T THINK IT'S THE RIGHT PUBLIC POLICY TO INCENTIVIZE PEOPLE WHO HARM OUR CONSTITUENTS TO PAY LESS. THIS THEN BECOMES A WAR OVER EXPERT WITNESSES. CAN YOUR CONSTITUENTS AFFORD EXPERT WITNESSES TO GO UP AGAINST BIG INSURANCE COMPANIES? MANY OF MINE CANNOT. THIS PROVISION WOULD ALLOW INSURANCE COMPANIES IN THESE CASES TO SAY; MOMS AND DADS; YOU PUT THAT KID IN THE CAR SEAT AND YOU DO NOT PUT THE CAR SEAT IN QU ITE RIGHT. THEREFORE; YOU ARE AT FAULT FOR THE DAMAGE TO YOUR CHILD SUFFERED; THE INJURIES Y OUR CHILD SUFFERED; EVEN IF YOU ARE HIT BY A DRUNK DRIVER AND IT WAS NOT YOUR FAULT. I DON'T THINK THAT IS FAIR. I DON'T THINK THAT IS JUST. I THINK THAT IS THE WRONG THING TO DO. I WOULD ASK YOU TO VOTE IN FAVOR OF THE A- 18 MIN. AND MR. SPEAKER I WOULD ASK FOR ROLL CALL >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ROLL CALL HAS BEEN REQUESTED. SEEING FIFTEEN HANDS THERE WILL BE A ROLL CALL. REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH: MEMBERS I WOULD AGAIN ASK FOR A NO VOTE ON THIS AMENDMENT. AS GIFTS REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN WOULD YIELD TO EXPLAIN WHY. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: MEMBERS; WITH THIS AMENDMENT ON THE BILL IS ATTEMPTING TO DO IS TO TAKE A PROVISION OUT OF THE BILL THAT WILL ALLOW A JURY TO CONSIDER ALL RELEVANT OR GERMANE FACTS IN EVIDENCE TO A CASE. YOUR PREVIOUS BILL SHEEH AN MENTIONED PUTTING A FINGER ON THE SCALE. THE SEATBELT GAG ORDER IN TODAY'S LEGAL ENVIRONMENT DOES JUST THAT. LET ME WALK YOU THROUGH WHY WE HAVE THE GAG ORDER. FOR A LOT OF PEOPLE IT'S HARD TO EVEN IMAGINE WHY WOULD WE INTENTIONALLY KEEP EVIDENCE OF THE COURT CASE? WHEN SEATBELTS WERE FIRST INVENTED YOU HAD TO PURCHASE THEM AS AN EXTRA ON YOUR CAR. HOW LIABILITY WAS SUPPOSED TO MINNESOTA AT THE KIND WAS THAT IF YOU WERE INJURED THAT YOU PLAYED A ROLE IN-YOUR NEGLIGENCE CLAIM A ROLE IN HOW [INAUDIBLE] OR IF YOU ARE INJURED AT ALL YOU DO NOT COLLECT IF YOU CONTRIBUTED TO THE CAUSE OF THE ACCIDENT YOU WERE OUT. IN MINNESOTA WE CHANGED HOW WE IMPOSE OUR LIABILITY AND NOW DO WHAT IS CALLED COMPARATIVE NEGLIGENCE. EVERYONE IN HERE IS FAMILIAR WITH THAT WERE WE ARE GOING TO CO MPARE WHAT HOW MUCH YOU WERE AT FAULT IN THE ACCIDENT TO HOW MUCH I WAS AT FAULT IN THE ACCIDENT TO HOW MUCH THE PASSENGER IN THE CAR WAS AT FAULT FOR THE ACCIDENT THE TOTAL AMOUNT IS 100%. THE EXAMPLE THAT WENT AROUND THE HANDOUTS THAT WENT AROUND IF HIS SEATBELT USAGE WAS NOT A FACTOR DURING THE RULES OF EVIDENCE PHASE DURING THE CIVIL TRIAL; THE JUDGE WOULD DEEM IT TO BE INADMISSIBLE. IT WON'T BE PUT IN. THER E ARE MANY CASES WHERE SEATBELTS ARE NOT A FACTOR IN THE LOSS AT ALL. BUT THERE ARE MANY CASES WHERE THEY ARE A FACTOR. IT'S GERMANE EVIDENCE THAT PERMIT APPLIES TO ALL OF THAT. THE AUTHOR OF THIS AMENDMENT HALF OF THE COS T OF EXPERT WITNESSES. IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING CIVIL CASES THAT IF SOMEONE PREVAILS AND AGAIN; THE USAGE OF SEATBELT THAT EVIDENCE IS IN COURT TO CHANGE WAS AT FAULT. IT CHANGES HOW MUCH YOU WERE AT FAULT. IF THEY PREVAIL; ANY OF THOSE COURT COSTS CAN BE SHIFTED TO THE OTHER PARTY. I ASK YOU TO VOTE; NO; THIS AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; DO YOU KNOW WHAT RELEVANT EVIDENCE IS DEFINED AS IN MINNESOTA? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: I DON' T KNOW WHAT THE TECHNICAL DEFINITION WOULD BE LITTLE BE MY ASSUMPTION AND COMMON SENSE- BECAUSE THIS IS COMMON LAW-WOULD BE EVIDENCE THAT WOULD HAVE A DEMONSTRATABLE RELATIONSHIP TO WHATEVER THE INJURY OR DAMAGE WAS. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; IT'S NOT COMMON LAW. STATUTORY LAW. BECAUSE IT'S CODIFIED IN MINNESOTA STATUTES. I'LL READ IT TO YOU. RELEVANT EVIDENCE MEANS EVIDENCE HAVING ANY TENDENCY TO MAKE THE EXISTENCE THAT EFFECT OF CONSEQUENCE TO THE DETERMINATION OF THE ACTION MORE PROBABLE OR LESS PROBABLE THAN WOULD BE WITHOUT THE EVIDENCE. SO IN A LAWSUIT FOR NEGLIGENCE; YOU GOT FOUR PARTS ROUTE YOU KNOW THIS. I KNOW YOU KNOW THIS. JUDY; BREACH; CAUSATION AND DAMAGES. NOW; TH E BREACH; THE BREACH OF THE DUTY MEANING THAT YOU SHOULD'VE BEEN AWARE OF SOME INCIDENT ON THE ROAD AND YOU ARE NOT; AND SO YOU CRASH INTO ANOTHER VEHICLE; HOW DOES THE FACT THAT A PERSON IN THE CAR THAT YOU HIT WAS OR WAS NOT WEARING A SEATBELT; HOW DOES THAT MAKE IT MORE LIKELY THAT YOU WERE GOING TO HIT THEM WITH YOUR CAR? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: THE PREACHER TALK ABOUT AT THAT ASPECT WOULD BE FAILURE TO PUT ON THE SEATBELT. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: THAT' S NOT CORRECT. YOU ARE NOT LEGALLY CORRECT. BECAUSE THE DUTY IN THE BREACH ARE TWO DIFFERENT THINGS. THE DAMAGES THAT THEY SUFFER THAT YOU WANT TO ENHANCE BY THE FACT THEY WERE NOT WEARING A SEATBELT THAT'S THE DAMAGES PHASE OF A TRUCK THAT'S WHAT CURRENTLY HAPPENS. SO PERSON WOULD HAVE BEEN IN THE HOSPITAL WITH A MASSIVE HEAD WOUND AND SUFFERED A LOT MORE. HAVE THEY BEEN- IT COST $1 MILLION. IF THEY HAD BEEN WEARING A SEATBELT WE LL IT WOULD'VE COST LESS THAN THE DAMAGES PORTION OF WHAT YOU ARE DOING HERE; RIGHT NOW; IS YOU WANT TO BE ABLE TO INTRODUCE THE EVIDENCE OF SEATBELT USE IN ORDER TO PREJUDICE THE JURY AGAINST A DEFENDANT WHO IS OTHERWISE INNOCENT OF THIS. THAT'S WHAT'S UNFAIR. NOW; THE EXAMPLE OF THIS THAT REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM JUST PASSED OUT OF THE TRACY MORGAN INCIDENT. BACKUPS WATCHING SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE WITH MIKE LAST NIGHT I SAW THE EPISODE REKEY BACK THE FIRST TIME WITHOUT WALMART TRUCK ROLLED OVER HIS LIMO BUS AND TRY TO BLAME HIM. HE DID WELL ON THEIR. WE HA VE THIS GRAPHIC AND TRAGIC EXAMPLE OF HOW UNFAIR THIS IS TO MINNESOTA TO JUST COME ON MARCH 19; MEMBERS; ON MARCH 19; LESS THAN A MONTH AGO; A SEM I TRUCK STRUCK FROM BEHIND A STOP TAXICAB ON HIGHWAY 10 IN ST. CLOUD REPRESENTATIVE KNOBLACH; YOUR DISTRICT AND I KNOW THIS GUY DRIVE RIGHT THAT INTERSECTION EVERY TIME WHEN I DROVE UP TO CAMP RIPLEY THIS MCDONALD'S ON ONE CORNER EIGHT COPPER KETTLE ON THE OTHER ONE. IT JUST PAST THE UNDERPASS THERE. THIS INDIVIDUAL THE CAB JAYBIRD SITTING THERE HAD TO BACKSEAT PASSENGERS. THEY WERE GOING EASTBOUND AND A SEMI TRUCK ON A 50 MILE AN H OUR ROAD SMASHED INTO THE BACKEND . MEMBERS; THERE WAS NOT A SINGLE SKIDMARK IS BUT A SINGLE SKIDMARK BEFORE STRIKING THE VEHICLE. THE CAB DRIVER; TOM FINLEY DIED. A 22-YEAR-OLD PASSENGER OF THE TAXICAB DIED AT THE SCENE. THE BACKSEAT PASSENGER; MARK SHEA; IS CRITICALLY INJURED SHE STILL IN THE HOSPITAL. MEMBERS; IF YOU LOOK AT THE HANDOUT THAT REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM HANDED OUT SHOWING THE DISRUPTION OF THE GAP AND THINK ABOUT THE ACCIDENT RELATION TO THE PROPOSAL BY INSURANCE COMPANIES AND TRUCKING FIRMS; TO AVOID PAYING DAMAGES; YOU SEE HOW OUTRAGEOUS THIS PROVISION IS. JURIES HEAR THIS RELEVANT EVIDENCE AND NOW IN THIS PROVISION REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN WANTS YOU TO THINK THAT THE RELEVANT EVIDENCE TO WHEN THE TRUCK SMASHED INTO THE BACK OF A CAB AT 50 MILES AN HOUR WAS WHETHER OR NOT THEY WERE WEARING A SEATBELT. IN THE CAUSATION OF THE CRASH. JURIES HEAR THAT IN DETERMINING CAUSATION OF THE CRASH. CURRENTLY; IT'S LIMITED JUST TO THE DAMAGES PORTION YOU WANT TO INCLUDE IT SO YOU JURIES WHEN THEY DECIDE WHO IS MORE AT FAULT FOR THE CRASH ITSELF THEY CAN DECIDE WHETHER OR NOT SOMEONE WAS WEARING A SEATBELT. BY THE WAY; IN THE TRACY MORGAN SITUATION IT WAS A LIMO BUS AND IN THIS CASE IT WAS A CAB. SO HOW MANY OF YOU PUT SEATBELTS ON ANY CABS? THEY HAVE IN NEW YORK THEY HAVE THOSE SIGNS IN THE FRONT SEAT THAT YOU ARE SUPPOSED TO WEAR YOUR SEATBELT BUT DON'T HAVE A BOX OF DISINFECTANT BECAUSE IN NEW YORK CITY TAXICAB SO HOW MANY PEOPLE ACTUALLY GRAPPLE WITH THE THING IS UNKNOWN. BUT WE KNOW FROM CASE EXAMPLES IN THREE STATES ALLOWS THIS EVIDENCE THAT INSURANCE AND TRUCKING COMPANIES BLAME THEIR VICTIMS FOR THEIR INJURED. IT'S HAPPENING RIGHT NOW IN ST. CLOUD. IT'S HAPPENING IN NEW JERSEY WITH TRACY MORGAN. TRACY MORGAN IS A HIGH-PROFILE CELEBRITY AND WALMART BLAMED HIM FOR HIS INJURIES WHEN THIS TRUCK-THIS DRIVER WOULD NOT SLEPT FOR 28 HOURS FALSELY AND CRASHED INTO THE BACK OF HIS LIMO BUS. SEVERELY INJURING FOUR PEOPLE AND KILLING COMEDIAN JIMMY MAC. WALMART RESPONSE WAS THAT MORGAN AND THE OTHERS WERE RESPONSIBLE FOR THEIR OWN INJURIES BECAUSE THEY WERE NOT BELTED INTO THIS LIMOUSINE BUS. YOU HAVE THIS PICTURE ON YOUR DESKS THAT SHOWS YOU THE DAMAGE TO THAT. IT'S PRETTY SEVERE AND SUBSTANTIAL. 30;000 MINNESOTANS ARE INJURED IN SOME WAY IN OVER 75;000 AUTO CRASHES EVERY YEAR. IF WE APPLY THIS PROPOSAL TO THE ST. CLOUD INCIDENT THAT HAPPENED LESS THAN A MONTH AGO THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT WILL HAPPEN. SO MS. LETOURNEAU; WHO DIED AND MS. PRICE; WHO'S LANGUISHING IN CRITICAL CARE RIGHT NOW LIKE MANY OF US BACKSEAT PASSENGERS A LOT OF TIMES THEY WERE THE SEATBELT IN THE BACKSEAT. MR. FINLEY WITH THE CAB DRIVER DID HE WAS BELTED HIM IN ST. CLOUD BUT HE STILL LOST HIS LIFE. SO; I WONDER REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: IF YOU CAN ADDRESS YOUR QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS TO THE SPEAKER IN WHICH WE RECOGNIZE. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: THANK YOU. I S THAT MEAN YOU WANT ME TO FACE YOU YOU'LL SENT AWAY ? REPRESENTATIVE G O TALK TO IRAN BECAUSE IT WAS KIND OF CREEPY WHEN TALKING TO REPRESENTATIVE LIEBLING SO I CAN BUT I DON'T KNOW HOW YOU LIKE TO LOOK AT THE BACK OF MY HEAD REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN BUT I FIND IT KIND OF DISRESPECTFUL BUT I'LL TRY TO DO THAT MR. SPEAKER. LET ME ASK YOU THIS. I WILL THIS UP REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN I KNOW YOU HAVE A PICTURE O F THIS. EMILY PATERNO; SHE BELIEVED SHE WAS AT FAULT FOR HER DEATH IN A CRASH IN ST. CLOUD? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH; BASED ON THE LIMITED AMOUNT OF TAX I HAVE I WOULD SAY; NOT. DURING A CASE LIKE THIS YOU CONTEND THAT THE PLAINTIFF PART SUCH AS THE CASE OF TRACY MORGAN HOMERED CONTENDING THE SEATBELTS WERE A FACTOR IS NOT THERE CALL. IT WILL BE THE CALL OF THE JUDGE WHETHER EVIDENCE IS ADMISSIBLE OR NOT. I AGREE WITH YOU IN THESE IS IS IS AND I'LL AGREE THERE'S OTHER INSTANCES WITH OTHERS SEATBELT USAGE IS AWKWARD TO BE A FACTOR. BUT MY POINT IS AND WHAT REMOVING THE GAG ORDER DOES IS IT INAPPROPRIATE WITH THAT DECISION IS CLOSE TO THE SITUATION AS POSSIBLE. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: YOU JUST ADMITTED THERE'S NO REASON FOR YOUR BILL. Y OU JUST ADMITTED THAT THERE IS NO REASON FOR YOUR BILL FOR THIS PROVISION IN THIS BILL. BECAUSE IF SHE IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR HER OWN DEATH THE N YOUR BILL IS GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY FOR A JURY TO THINK THAT SHE COULD BE RESPONSIBLE FOR HER OWN DEATH. NOW CURRENTLY IN MINNESOTA LAW JURIES TO GET TO CONSIDER SEATBELT USAGE WITHIN THE DAMAGES PHASE 2 IS NOT IN THE CAUSATION PAGE WHICH IS WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING AT DOING. YOU ARE SUGGESTING WHETHER OR NOT SHE WAS WEARING US ABOUT IT MORE LIKELY THAT THAT TRUCK WAS CALLED CRASH INTO HER. REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; DO YOU BELIEVE THAT MARSH A PRICE WAS AT FAULT FOR HER INJURIES WHEN SHE MAY NEVER BE COVERED FROM? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: AGAIN REPRESENTATIVE LESCH ASKED ME TO ANSWER A QUESTION I DON'T HAVE ALL THE INFORMATION ON. I HAVE NOT SAT TO THE FACT THAT I'M NOT ON ANY JURY. WITH THIS PROVISION DOES IS IT MOVES THE DECISION ON WHETHER OR NOT EVIDENCE IS ADMISSIBLE OR NOT IS CLOSE TO THE SITUATION AS POSSIBLE. THIS IS IN ANY DIFFERENT THAN YOU ARE TAUGHT HANDWRITING TEACHER SAID GET YOUR HAND ON BY THE END OF THE PENCIL. YOU GET AS CLOSE TO THE SITUATION AS POSSIBLE. HAVE BETTER DATA. THERE SITUATIONS WHEN I'M AWARE OF IN MY INSURANCE AGENCY WHERE SEATBELTS WERE NOW FUNCTIONING. WE COULD UP WITH THE SEATBELT ON. THE REALITY IS THIS A BILL DOESN'T FIT YOU MUST ACQUIT. YOU CAN COUNT THAT WITHOUT ALL BE DONE BASED ON THE RULES OF EVIDENCE DONE ON THE TRIAL. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; IN LIGHT OF WHAT YOU ARE JUST SAYING; YOU HAVE INSURANCE; YOU SELL INSURANCE POLICIES TO PEOPLE ASSUMING INSURANCE POLICIES FOR OPERATING MOTOR VEHICLES. SO; DO YOU THINK IT'S APPROPRIATE FOR JURIES TO HEAR EVIDENCE AS TO WHETHER OR NOT A PERSON WAS INSURED TO A CERTAIN LEVEL? OBVIOUSLY IN FACT THIS MUST MEAN THE MOVIE SPENT A LONG TIME SINCE I PUT A MOVIE IN THERE BUT WAS FRIED GREEN TOMATOES WHEN A WOMAN CRASHED INTO A BETTER WOMAN IN A PARKING NOT AND SHE SAYS; FACE IT; LADIES I'M OLDER I HAVE A LOT I BETTER ENGENDERED MAYBE IF YOU WERE INSURANCE USUALLY LESS CAREFUL DRIVING ON BECAUSE YOU'RE COVERED. SO IS IT APPROPRIATE BECAUSE UNDER YOUR DEFINITION OF RELEVANCE IS IT APPROPRIATE FOR JURY TO HEAR RELEVANT EVIDENCE LIKE THAT IN MINNESOTA? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH; I WOULD HAVE TO ASK YOU A QUESTION FIRST. WITH THE AMOUNT OF INSURANCE THE PERSON CARRY HA VE ANY RELATIONSHIP OR ANY AFFECT ON HOW INJURED THE OTHER PARTY WAS OR NOT? >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: I THINK REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; YOU JUST PROVIDED AN ANSWER WHY THIS BILL IS IRRELEVANT. BECAUSE IF YOU'RE SUGGESTING THAT YOUR LEVEL OF INSURANCE HAS NO BEARING ON WHETHER THE CRASH OCCURRED THEN THERE IS NO WAY THAT A PERSON WHO'S SITTING IN THE CAR THAT WAS HIT HAS A BEARING ON WHETHER THE GUILTY PARTY STRUCK YOU. YOU JUST ESSENTIALLY ADMITTED THAT THIS BILL IS POINTLESS AS NOTHING MORE THAN A GIVEAWAY TO INSURANCE COMPANIES. REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; CAN YOU TELL ME IF WE WERE TO ADOPT THE TRUCKERS AN INSURANCE COMPANY PROPOSAL WE KNOW THEY WILL USE THIS TO LIMIT THEIR RESPONSIBILITY FOR CRASHES LIKE THIS. WE SAW IT IN OTHER STATES MUCH LIKE THEY DID IN NEW JERSEY THE TRACY MORGAN TO SAVE THE MONEY. REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; MS. PRICE'S LANGUISHING IN CRITICAL CARE RIGHT NOW IS 21 YEARS OLD. SHE STILL RECOVERING. LET'S ASSUME HER MEDICAL BILLS WOULD BE $500;000 FOR WEEKS OR MONTHS OF BEING IN THE HOSPITAL AND SURGERIES. OPERATIONS AND REHABILITATION WHICH IS NOT A REASONABLE NUMBER WHATSOEVER FOR THAT AMOUNT TIME AND THIS LEVEL OF INJURED CAN YOU TELL ME HOW MUCH YOUR MEDICAL INJURIES IF THE TRUCK AND INSURANCE COMMITTEES CONVINCES AN INJURY THAT SHE'S 50% AT FAULT FOR HER INJURY BECAUSE SHE'S NOT WEARING A SEATBELT? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: WHAT I CAN TE LL YOU REPRESENTATIVE LESCH SHE WOULD COLLECT 20;000 UNDER PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION UNDER THE NO-FAULT STATUTE. AS FAR AS THE 50% ASSIGNMENT O F NO CUSHIONS WHICH IS VERY UNCOMMON; CERTAINLY IS NOT IN THE 35 YEARS IN THE BUSINESS HAS SEEN IT ONCE-I DON'T THINK EITHER PARTY CAN COLLECT. WHAT YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT IS YOU LIKE TO SEE A CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE WHICH ARE WE HAPPY TO WORK WITH YOU ON CHANGING THE LIABILITY HOW SIMPLE 02 CONTRIBUTORY BASIS WHERE IT'S ALL OR NOTHING ALL BE ALL FOR THAT. THAT'S WHEN THE GAG ORDER CAME TO PLACE. WHEN WE CHANGED THE COMPARATIVE DATA BECAME A CAKE AND EAT IT TOO SITUATION THAT WE WILL ASSIGN NEGLIGENCE TO DIFFERENT PEOPLE BUT WE ARE NOT GOING TO COUNT-WE ARE NOT GOING TO BE ALLOWED TO SUBMIT CERTAIN EVIDENCE THAT IS RELATED TO THE AMOUNT OF INJURY YOU SUSTAINED OR WHETHER YOU ARE INJURED OR NOT. I WOULD ASK REPRESENTATIVE LESCH TO YIELD TO A QUESTION. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH HAS THE FLOOR RIGHT NOW. REPRESENTATIVE LESCH >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: MR. SPEAKER; LAST QUESTION AND YOUR INSTITUTE AND I'LL ANSWER THAT IN MY NEXT ONE. THE ANSWERS BELOW LIEBLING IS 50%. FOR HALF BILLION-DOLLAR MEDICAL BILLS SHE BE RESPONSIBLE FOR $250;000. I DON'T KNOW WHO AROUND HERE IS $250;000 LAYING AROUND INCLUDE THIS EVIDENCE OF SEATBELT USE. IF THE BIG INSURANCE AND TRUCKING COMPANY LAWYERS CONVINCE PEOPLE THAT THAT'S HOW MUCH SHE WOULD HAVE TO PAY. LET'S SAY; THEY FIND HER A 10% FAULT. SHE WOULD LOSE OVER $50;000 TO COVER HER MEDICAL BILLS UNDER YOUR PROPOSAL. THE SHIFT TO PAY FOR THAT HERSELF OR CAN THE STATE PAY? TO EMPLOYER PAID HEALTH INSURANCE PAY ? WHERE ARE THESE COSTS SHIFTED TO UNDER YOUR PLAN ? WINZIP COVERING THESE MEDICAL BILLS? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: REPRESENTATIVE LESCH TO THAT QUESTION THAT'S ON THE NATURE OF THE BILLS IF THEY'RE ACTUAL MEDICAL BILLS THE MEDICAL PROVIDER CAN PARTICIPATE IN THE SETTLEMENT AS WELL GET TYPICALLY WHEN THIS BIG CASE LIKE THAT THEY DO GET IN LINE AND SEEK COMPENSATION UNDER THE AMOUNT OF COVERAGE THAT IS AVAILABLE. AS FAR AS HER PAIN IT THEMSELVES SHE HAS HEALTH INSURANCE THAT'S WHERE WOULD END UP GOING. THERE'S A COUPLE MORE STOPS. WE FINISH MY ANSWER. SHE WHAT HAPPENS IS SHE COLLECTS FROM AN ASPHALT PARTY THEY DON'T HAVE ENOUGH INSURANCE ENOUGH COVERAGE TO INDEMNIFY HER UP TO IF SHE IS; AND THEN SHE COMES BACK UNDER HER OWN POLICY UNDER HER UNINSURED MORALS AND INVOKES THE COVERAGE AS WELL. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: THANK YOU FOR YOUR LATITUDE. THE ANSWER THAT REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN JUST GAVE IS WE ALL DO. WE ALL PAY THAT. SO IF IT IS UNDER HEALTH INSURANCE WE ALL PAY. THE STATE PAYS FOR WE ALL PAY IT YOU KNOW WHO DOESN'T PAY AT? THE DRIVER WHO SMASHED INTO HER CAR. THAT'S WHO DOES NOT PAY THIS. NOW REPRESENTATIVE 10 AMENDMENTS LIKELY THE TRUCKING COMPANY AT THE ACADEMY TO SPREAD THE PLANE TO OTHERS. JUST TO KNOW; LET'S SAY IF YOU GET WHAT YOU WANT AND LET'S SAY THAT A JURY COMES BACK AND FINDS MS. MARSH EIGHT WAS LANGUISHING CRITICAL CARE RIGHT NOW 40% AT FAULT AND LET'S SAY THEY FIND THE CHUNKING COMPANY IN THE CAPITAL MANY AS 60% OF FALL. EQUALLY AT 30% EACH. REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; IN THAT SCENARIO; HOW MUCH DOES MS. MARSH EIGHT COVER FOR INJURIES OR MEDICAL BILLS? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: FOR THAT QUESTION; AND THESE WONDERFUL WERE PROBLEMS. THE CONNECTION OF A DETERMINED SETTLEMENT IS MY UNDERSTANDING AM NOT AN ATTORNEY AND INSURANCE AGENT; I'VE STUDIED THIS. IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THE JURY GOES THROUGH A PROCESS AND DECIDES WITH THE ACTUAL DAMAGES TO THE PLAINTIFF . THEN THEY GO THROUGH IT ASSIGN PERCENTAGES OF NEGLIGENCE IN ANY AMOUNT OF RECOVERY THAT PLAINTIFF WOULD HAVE WOULD BE REDUCED BY THE AMOUNT OF NEGLIGENCE THAT'S ASSIGNED TO THEM. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH: I WILL GIVE YOU THE ANSWER. THE ANSWER ZERO. ZERO. SHE SAID 40% THE CAP COMPANIES THAT 30 THE TRUCKING COMPANIES AT 30 SHE GETS ZERO BECAUSE YOU CANNOT RECOVER IF YOU ARE AT FAULT SINGLE PERCENTAGE OR HAIR OFF PERCENTAGE MORE THAN ANY OTHER PERSON AND YOU CANNOT RECOVER. YOU GET ZERO DOLLARS. THAT'S WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING TO DOING THIS. WE'LL TRUCKERS AND INSURANCE COMPANIES WANT TO PAY LESS THAN THIS. BUT MY LAST QUESTION MR. SPEAKER IF I COULD; REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; HOW MUCH WILL THE REST OF THE SAFE IN AUTO INSURANCE COSTS OR INSURANCE COSTS IF WE PASS THIS BILL WITH YOUR PROVISION IN IT? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: THANK YOU FOR THAT QUESTION REPRESENTATIVE LESCH BECAUSE YOU ARE RIGHT. THEY SHOULD PUT DOWNWARD PRESSURE ON INSURANCE PREMIUMS ON AUTO INSURANCE PREMIUMS. THOSE TWO ROLE OF THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT IS TO ENFORCE THE STATUTE OF HIS DREAMS CANNOT BE EXCESSIVE THEY CANNOT BE INADEQUATE AND THEY CANNOT BE DISCRIMINATE. WERE PUTTING IN PROVISIONS THAT BRINGS MORE FAIRNESS INTO ALL OUR LOSSES ARE SETTLED MESS WITH THIS PROVISION DOES; THEN YOU ARE RIGHT. VISHNU DOWNWARD MOVEMENT ON WITH THE AUTO PREMIUMS ARE. NOW YOUR PRIOR QUESTION WERE TALKING ABOUT THE COMPARATIVE NEGLIGENCE THRESHOLD AND WITHOUT MEANS MEMBERS IS THAT IF THE VICTIM C AN ONLY COLLECT FOR PEOPLE MORE AT FAULT IN AN INCIDENT LIKE CAR ACCIDENT IN THIS CASE THAN THEY ARE. A CHANGE THAT THRESHOLD I DON'T WANT NO I WANT TO SAY THE LAST EIGHT YEARS MAYBE SOMETHING LIKE THAT. I WAS NOT HERE OBVIOUSLY BUT THEY CHANGED IT AS FAR AS WOULD GET STUCK PAYING FOR EVIDENT THAT THROUGH THE TERM DEEP POCKETS. THAT'S WHERE THAT COMES FROM. REPRESENTATIVE LESCH; THE IMPORTANCE OF AWARENESS HE FELT WERE NOT WEARING A SEATBELT IS FILLED OUT CORRECTLY THAT A SENIOR BEAUTIFUL DAUGHTER TIME I'VE A GRANDDAUGHTER THAT SAME AGE. WHEN I TAKE HER IN A VEHICLE AND MAKE SURE TO PUT IT IN A CAR SEAT. I PUT HER IN A CAR SEAT BECAUSE I KNOW THAT IS SAFE THAT IS SAFER B UT EVERYONE UNDERSTANDS THAT. IF I FAILED TO DO THAT IF I FAILED TO PUT MY SEATBELT ON I'M NOT AS SACRED VOWS MY NEGLIGENT ACT. THAT WAS MY DETERMINATION. >> REPRESENTATIVE LESCH ON A NOT ASK AN Y MORE QUESTIONS BECAUSE I'M KIND OF GETTING THE STINK EYE FROM YOU SO WHAT I WILL SAY IS THIS. MEMBERS; SEATBELT USE OF MINNESOTA IS AT -OVER 94%. THAT'S 90% FOR WOMEN. I DON'T SEE ANYTHING IN THIS BILL THAT'S GOING TO INCREASE SEATBELT USE . ALL I SEE ARE PROVISIONS THAT ARE 28 HANDOFF TO INSURANCE COMPANIES. AGAIN. WE SAW WITH THE HEALTH INSURANCE COMPANIES AT THE BEGINNING OF THE SESSION WE SAW IT WITH TRAINS JUST THE OTHER DAY FOR INSURANCE COMPANIES. JUST LOOKING TO GIVEAWAY TO INSURANCE COMMISSIONER THAT DOWNWARD PRESSURE YOU TALK ABOUT REPRESENTATIVE COMPANY WHICH HER MONEY WHERE YOUR MOUTH IS. LET' S SEE SOME REAL NUMBERS ABOUT WHAT WERE ACTUALLY GOING TO SAVE AND INSURANCE PREMIUMS. BUT WITHOUT THOSE REAL NUMBERS IN THE BILL; ALL IT IS IS A GIVEAWAY. IT DOESN'T DO ANYTHING FOR MINNESOTANS. I T DOESN'T DO ANYTHING FOR SAFER STREETS. ALL DOES IS ALLOW INSURANCE COMPANY LAWYERS TO GET INFORMATION IN FRONT OF JURIES THAT THEY THINK IS GOOD TO MAKE PEOPLE LOOK BAD. SO; YES; MY DAUGHTER NIGHT; SO SHE'S A PEACH FOR SILLY ACTIVITY HERE TALK ING TO YOU FINE PEOPLE AND SET UP GOING WITH HER THE FACT IS I LOVE SPENDING TIME WITH HER AND I REMEMBER WHEN SHE WAS BORN MY WIFE I S NOT UPSTAIRS THIS TIME; WHICH HE MADE US GO DOWN TO THE FIRE STATION TO GET THE CAR SEAT PUT IN AND YOU COULD'VE HEARD MY EYES ROLL FROM A MILE AWAY. GIMME A BREAK I COULD READ INSTRUCTIONS AND PUT THE CAR SEAT IN THE RIGHT WAY. IT'S A NEWFANGLED EUROPEAN MODEL WITH SCOTT THE FOOT THAT SITS ON THE FLOOR WERE SOMETHING THAT KICKS OUT. I WONDER IF I HAD USE THE OLD MINNESOTA MERRICK AND INGENUITY DECIDED TO READ THE INSTRUCTIONS TO PUT THAT SEATBELT AND AN SOMETHING HAD HAPPENED AND I KNOW EXACTLY THE KIND OF LINE OF QUESTIONING I WOULD GET FROM AN INSURANCE COMPANY LAWYER FROM 80 MAIN DOOR DECEASED CHILD TRIAL AND THAT WOULD BE ; DID YOU GO DOWN TO THE FIRE STATION EQUIPPED TO OTHER OPTIONS DID YOU DO ANY KIND OF SUMMER TO MAKE SURE YOU PUT IN THE RIGHT WAY? THIS IS THE KIND OF THING THAT REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN WANTS INSURANCE; YOU WARRIORS TO BE ABLE TO DO TO YOU. SHOULD TRAGEDY EVER BEFALL ON YOU OR A FAMILY MEMBER. AT THE WORST TIME OF YOUR LIFE WHEN YOU'RE SUFFERING AND BREATHING MORE THAN YOU EVER COULD THEY WANT TO MAKE YOU THINK IT IS YOUR FAULT. BY THE WAY; TAKE A BIG OLD PAYDAY ALONG WITH IT. THAT IS SAD. THE RE IS NO REASON JURORS NEED TO GET THAT INFORMATION ABOUT YOU OR YOUR FAMILY BECAUSE YOU CAN WEAR YOUR SEATBELT WHICH I VOTED AGAINST BY THE WAY AND I'LL PUNCH YOU IN THE FREEDOM CAUCUS DID YOU. PRIMARY CIPRO. THEY WANT USE THAT AGAINST YOU. AND THE WORST TIME OF YOUR LIFE. GO LOOKS CLEAN ON THE HILSTROM AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM >> REPRESENTATIVE TRY NOSECONE JUST HAVE TWO QUESTIONS; REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN:. REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN HIGHLIGHT HUBEI WAS WEARING MY SEATBELT? DON'T WAS PEOPLE GET OUT OF THE CAR WHEN THERE'S A CRASH ? HOW DO THEY THEN PROVE THEY ACTUALLY WERE WEARING THEIR SEATBELT? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION. AT THIS SCENE OF THE ICE OF THE OPPOSITE IS COULD YOU FILL OUT AN INCIDENT REPORT THAT'S WHAT QUESTIONS PEER THAT IS CURRENT AS NOTHING. THIS BILL DOES NOT CHANGE THAT. >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM: REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN; HOW MANY MORE TRIALS WITH THIS BILL REQUIRED AND HOW MUCH DOES IT COST THE JUDICIARY? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: I DO KNOW THE ANSWER TO THAT KID I KNOW ACTUALLY A SMALL NUMBER OF CASES GO ALL THE WAY TO TRIAL. THE VAST MAJORITY THE BULK OF THEM ARE ACTUALLY SETTLED OUTSIDE OF COURT. >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM : REPRESENTATIVE CHUMLEY; THE COURT DISAGREES WITH THE GROUP MEMBERS I'VE A FISCAL NOTE RIGHT HERE. PREPARED BY THE COURT. IT SAYS THAT THE FULL-TIME EQUIVALENT POSITIONS ARE THREE FTES IN THE BIENNIUM WILL COST $851;000 . IN THE SECOND BIENNIUM $818;000. YOU CAN EXPECT IT TO BE MORE CASES THAT WILL GO TO TRIAL I T ACTUALLY COST MORE THAN AN ENTIRE JUDGE UNITS. LET ME REPEAT THAT. THESE CASES WILL BE A NEW ENTIRE JUDGE UNITS. OR MORE. WHY SET THE CASE MEMBERS? IS BECAUSE MORE PEOPLE ARE GOING TO TRY TO PAY LESS. THEY WILL FIGHT IT OUT IN COURT BECAUSE YOU HAVE THE HIGHER EXPERT WITNESSES. MEMBERS; I WANT YOU TO KNOW THERE'S ALSO TO THINGS IN STATUTE THAT WE KEPT JURIES FROM HER BECAUSE WANT PEOPLE TO GET A FAIR HEARING. IN ADDITION TO KEEPING THEM FROM HEARING WHETHER OR NOT YOU HAVE INSURANCE WE ALSO UNDER MINNESOTA STATUTE 169.94; TO NOT PERMIT THE ADMISSIBILITY OF EVIDENCE OF YOUR CONVICTION . SPECIFICALLY SAYS; NO RECORD OF THE CONVICTION OF THE PERSON FOR ANY VIOLATION OF THIS CHAPTER SHALL BE ADMISSIBLE AS EVIDENCE IN ANY COURT IN ANY CIVIL ACTION. SO WHILE REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN MAKES HIS ARGUMENT THAT THE JURY SHOULD HEAR EVERY PIECE OF EVIDENCE ; WE HAVE DECIDED AS A BODY AND ASSIST STATE WHAT IS FAIR EVIDENCE FOR THE JURY TO HEAR. MEMBERS REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN IS GOING ALONG WE HAD TO BENEFIT INSURANCE COMPANIES CAUSE THEM TO PAY LESS. I THINK IT IS WRONG AND ASK YOU TO GO LOOKS IN FAVOR OF MY AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE PINTO >> REPRESENTATIVE PINTO WHO WOULD'VE THOUGHT SUCH A SIMPLE PROVISION OF SUMMIT HOMES IS OUR HOPE POINT OUT OF CONCERN ON BEHALF OF KIDS. THIS BIN REFERENCE BEFORE THE CHILD RESTRAINT SEATS AT THIS WON'T TAKE TOO LONG BUT I DO WANT TO POINT OUT THAT THIS BILL WOULD PROHIBIT WHETHER OR NOT A KID WAS A CHILD RESTRAINT SEAT FROM BEING- TAKEN OUT AS WILL MY CONCERN THIS WILL WILL PUNISHING KIDS IN CAR I THEY NOT DON'T PUT THEMSELVES IN THESE SEATS. IF THERE'S A MISTAKE IN TERMS OF BUCKLEY AND THE MEN OR REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN REFERENCES FAMILIES WELL SO MY QUESTION RECOGNIZING THIS WOULD WE PUNISH KIDS WERE IN THOSE CAR ACCIDENTS BY ALLOWING WHETHER OR NOT THEY WERE IN THE SEA TO BE USED IN THE CASE IS THAT YOUR INTENT OF THOSE KIDS WHO BROUGHT IN AND HAVE THEM EXTRINSIC PUNISHMENT AS WELL AND IS ADDITION TO OTHERS? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION REPRESENTATIVE PINTO. NO; THAT'S NOT MY INTENT. I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE NUMBERS. AGAIN I'M NOT A LAWYER BUT I BELIEVE THAT A CHILD THAT IS A MINORITY AGE IS NOT CONSIDERED PEOPLE COMMITTING AN INTENTIONAL ACT IS HELD TO A DIFFERENT STANDARD THAN ADULT WOULD BE. >> REPRESENTATIVE PINTO: IF YOU DON'T WANT TO HAVE KIDS BE A BROUGHT IN UNDER THIS PROVISION I WAS SUGGEST YOU SUPPORT THE HILSTROM AMENDMENT. THIS CLEARLY NEEDS MUCH MORE WORK TO GET THIS WILL DOUBT IT ALLOWS THE USER NONUSE OF THE CHILD RESTRAINT TO BE USED AND INTRODUCES EVIDENCE IN TRIAL. S O IF YOUR INTENT IS TO NOT HAVE THAT BE BROUGHT IN REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN CAN I WAS CERTAINLY SUGGEST YOU SUPPORT THE HILSTROM AMENDMENT. IN ADDITION TO THIS BY PEOPLE NOT REQUIRED TO BE WEARING SEATBELTS. FOR EXAMPLE; FOLKS INVOLVED IN FARMING DURING FARM ACTIVITIES. DRIVING OR RIDING IN A PICKUP TRUCK REPRESENTATIVE CHUMLEY; IS YOU INCLUDING THOSE PEOPLE BECAUSE THEY'RE NOT REQUIRED TO THE SEATBELT BUT INSURANCE COMPANIES COUL D INTRODUCE THEIR USER NONUSE OF THE SEATBELT. IS IT YOUR INTENTION OF THEM BE PUNISHED AND BROUGHT IN BY THIS WILL AS WELL? >> REPRESENTATIVE LOONAN: THANK YOU REPRESENTATIVE PINTO. HERE'S WHAT THE HEAVY LIFTING THE GAG ORDER DOES. IT ALLOWS IN EACH CASE BASED ON THE EVIDENCE OF EACH CASE; TO DECIDE WHAT EVIDENCE IS ADMISSIBLE AND WHAT IS A GOOD THAT'S WHERE DOES IT THE CASE THAT YOU'RE CITING RIGHT NOW; WOULD BE MY ASSUMPTION BUT JUST MY ASSUMPTION- THAT DURING THOSE FEW RULES OF EVIDENCE THEY WOULD SAY THAT'S NOT ADMISSIBLE. >> REPRESENTATIVE PINTO: I'M NOT SURE WHY THE PERSON BEING REQUIRED OR NOT REQUIRED TO THE SEATBELT WOULD BE A ALL RELEVANT; JUST LIKE WHETHER OR NOT THE PERSON WEARING THE SEATBELT WOULD NOT BE RELEVANT TO WHETHER OR NOT AN ACCIDENT OCCURS GOOD ALL DAY TO THE CONCLUSION MEMBERS CHRIS IS A LONG TIME ON THIS PROVISION; JUST TO POINT OUT; KIDS; PEOPLE ENGAGE IN FARM CARRIED MAIL CARRIERS BELOW DON'T HAVE A CIPRO AVAILABLE AFTER LEADER VEHICLE NUMBER OF THESE PEOPLE ARE REQUIRED TO WEAR SEATBELT AND WHAT WE ARE DOING UNDER THIS UNDERLYING BILL PUTTING THIS EVIDENCE IT FRONT OF THE JURY HAVE IT BE CONSIDERED IN FACT IT HAS NO RELEVANCE AS TO WHETHER A ACTION HAS OCCURRED. MEMBERS APPRECIATES THE CHUMLEY TALK ABOUT KIDS AND THESE ARE THE GROUP SHOULD THIS NEEDS A LOT MORE WORK FOR GO FORWARD AT ALL AND MEMBERS I WOULD URGE YOU TO VOTE SCREEN AND DEFEAT THIS PROVISION. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION? THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL. >>[ROLL CALL VOTE]. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: [INAUDIBLE] 66 NAY MOUSE IS NOT ADOPTED THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: CONSIDINE MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS FOLLOWS. THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 30. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE >> REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE: MR. SPEAKER I THINK THERE'S A AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE'S A AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: CORNISH MOVES TO AMEND THE CONSIDINE AMENDMENT. TO SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 42 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: CHAIRMAN CORNISH TO YOUR AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH: THE A- 42 AMENDMENT AMENDS A- 30 EXTENDS THIS ON-SITE DATE BUT SPECIFIES THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT WOULD BE REQUIRED OF THE BOUNCE IN THE RAILROAD OF PIPELINE SAFETY ACCOUNT IT GOES BELOW 1 MILLION SHOULD ALSO INCREASE THE APPROPRIATION FOR URBAN SAFETY ROPE CROSSINGS BY $100 THOUSAND WHICH WILL FUND BALANCES CURRENTLY 6.2 MAY BE WILL TO CONTINUE EXPANDING THE USE OF THIS FUN TO IMPROVE SAFETY AT RAILROAD CROSSINGS WITHOUT THE NEED TO CONTINUE THIS SPECIAL RAILROAD AND PIPELINE TAX. MR. SPEAKER; THE REASON FOR THIS AMENDMENT IS THERE WAS A TWO-YEAR AGREEMENT; AN AGREEMENT THAT WENT ON WITH THE RAILROAD AND ITS SON SAID. WELL; THEN HAVING A SUNSET DATE AND ALWAYS SEVEN THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY CAME INTO TESTIFIED JU ST SAID THERE WERE GOING TO EXTEND THAT THEY HAD NOT DONE ANY TALKING TO THE RAILROAD. SO SINCE IT WAS AN AGREEMENT THAT WAS ENDED WE DECIDED TO END IT SO THAT' S WHAT THIS IS ALL ABOUT NOW WITH THE AMENDMENT AND THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT COULD REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE ADDRESSES A FURTHER REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER I LIKE TO YIELD TO HIM EVENTUALLY TO TALK ABOUT IT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER >> REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER: THANK YOU CHAIRMAN CORNIS H FOR BRINGING THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT FORWARD TO AT A MEASURE OF SAFETY TO OUR RAIL SYSTEMS IN A RAIL CROSSINGS. I'VE UNIQUE SITUATION IN MY DISTRICT WHICH FRANKLY IS PROBABLY SIMILAR TO MANY VIEWERS. THERE IS SPINE OF MY DISTRICT IS THE BURLINGTON NORTHERN FREIGHT LINE. WE HAVE THE UNIT TRAINS THAT GO THROUGH ROUGHLY EVERY 20 AND 30 MIN. AS THEY TRAIN THAT RUNS THROUGH . FIVE MY SIX MAJOR CITIES IN MY DISTRICT. ALSO THE DISTRICTS ANYWHERE OF THAT WHOLE LINE YOU CAN GO FROM MOREHEAD ALL-ENCOMPASSING CLOUD THESE UNIT TRAINS MEMBERS THAT CARRY EVERYTHING. THEY CARRY EVERYTHING FROM NUMBER TWO CHEMICALS TO PETRO CHEMICALS TO SOMETIMES THE THINGS WE DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT THEY ARE CARING; MEMBERS. THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT TO OUR SAFETY. I CAN TELL YOU RIGHT NOW WITH THE THE AMENDMENT IS ADOPTED. TALKING OILFIELDS SOMETIMES THOSE TRAINS THOSE UNIT TRAINS OF TWO HUNDRED 10 CARS APIECE. THE FLASHPOINT IF YOU ASK ANYONE IN FIREFIGHTING THE FLASHPOINT FOR BOK INCLUDE OIL IS VERY LITTL E RATE COMPARED TO OTHER PETROL LOOK AT IT ONLY TAKES ONE MEMBERS ONE TANKER CAR IN THIS POST-9/11 WORLD TO EXPLODE TO SET OFF THE OTHER 109 CARS AND 110 UNIT TRAIN SYSTEM. ONE CAR . ONE CAR CAN FLY UP TO THREE QUARTERS OF A MILE AFTER IT EXPLODES. MEMBERS COME IF WE HAVE 110 OF THESE GOING OFF INSIDE ANYONE'S COMMUNITY MAY GOD HAVE MERCY ON ALL OF US. MEMBERS; VERY GRATEFUL THAT CHAIRMAN CORNISH WAS ABLE TO BRING THIS FORWARD. THIS MIMICS TO THE AMENDMENT IT GUARANTEES. AS I READ IT IF [INAUDIBLE] THIS WILL KICK IN AND ALSO ALLOCATES EXTRA FUNDING TO MNDOT. SO CHAIRMAN CORNISH UNGRATEFUL YOU THE FORESIGHT TO SEE THIS TO OFFER THE MIMICS TO THIS AMENDMENT AND MEMBERS COME AGAIN I WOULD LIKE YOU TO MEMBER VIEW OF A REAL SYSTEM VIEW OF ANY RAIL AT ALL IN YOUR DISTRICT IS OR TO YOU. ANOTHER EXAMPLE IS TO REVIEW MIGHT SAY WEALTH WE DON'T HAVE ANY PETRO PRODUCTS: ON. NONE. BUT I CAN TELL YOU WHAT YOU DO HAVE. YOU HAVE FARM CHEMICALS. THOMPSON [INAUDIBLE] AMMONIA IS USED FREQUENTLY IN THE AGRICULTURE INDUSTRY. IT'S WHAT HELPS TO MAKE THIS THRIVE IN OUR ECONOMY. BUT MEMBERS IT ONLY TAKES ONE ANHYDROUS LEAK TO WIPE OUT AN ENTIRE COMMUNITY. WE HAVE A SITUATION A COUPLE DECADES BACK IN REVERSE POPULATION IS WORKING AT NIGHT. WHEN A SITUATION WHERE WE HAD A TRAIN DERAILED. IT WAS AN ACCIDENT AND I JUST CART IT WAS AN ANHYDROUS LEAK. THE ONLY THING MEMBERS; THE ONLY THING THAT KEPT THAT ANHYDROUS FROM BECOMING LETHAL IN WIPING OUT AN ENTIRE COMMUNITY NEWLY REASON YOU NEVER HEARD ABOUT IT IN THE NEWS BECAUSE THE IMMUNE AIR TEMPERATURE WAS ABOUT 43°. IT KEPT THAT ANHYDROUS FROM SPREADING TO GET THAT DOWN CLOSE TO THE GROUND THERE BUT TO CONTAIN IT AND ABLE TO TAKE CARE OF THAT PROBLEM. MEMBERS; THAT AMBIENT AIR TEMPERATURE CAN 40° OR HIGHER; WE PROBAB LY BE STILL TALKING ABOUT THIS NOT TO NAME THE COMMUNITY BECAUSE A CAUSE OF LOT OF DISTRESS TO THE MEMBERS THAT LIVE IN THE COMMUNITY COULD THEY DON'T WANT TO THINK ABOUT IT. MEMBERS OF THINGS THAT TRAVEL ON OUR RAILS ARE IMPORTANT TO OUR ECONOMY. IMPORTANT TO THE WAY WE LIVE. IMPORTANT TO THE VERY STRUCTURE OF OUR SOCIETY. MUST HAVE RAIL. BUT THERE'S A SITUATION WE HAVE TO DEAL WITH IT IT'S CALLED SAFETY. CHAIRMAN CORNISH ONCE AGAIN I'D LIKE TO THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THIS AMENDMENT TO THE MIMICS. FOR ADDING ADDITIONAL FUNDING AND WITHOUT MEMBERS WOULD ASK YOU FOR A YES VOTE ON THE CHAIRMAN CORNISH'S AMENDMENT THIS AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HORNSTEIN >> REPRESENTATIVE HORNSTEIN; MEMBERS I WOULD ALSO URGE A YES VOTE. THIS PROVISION WAS INCLUDED IN ORIGINAL 2014 WIL L SAFETY LEGISLATION I THINK REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER TO THE NEXT JOB OF DESCRIBING SOME OF THE SCENARIOS THAT WE WORR Y ABOUT. THOSE ARE ASHES FROM THE SCENARIOS WE DISCUSSED ON FRIDAY WHEN WE ACTUALLY LET THE RAILROAD'S OFF LIABILITY INSURANCE. SO THAT IS WHY I HOPE THIS ISSUE CAN BE REVISITED WE TALKED ABOUT ON FRIDAY ON LIABILITY AND SECONDLY; WE HAVE RECENTLY; AS RECENTLY AS JUST NOVEMBER 2016 HAD A MAJOR ACCIDENT IN ALLENDALE MINNESOTA. THE ENTIRE TOWN WAS EVACUATED I THINK IT'S BEEN REPRESENTED THAT THIS IS A SAFE INDUSTRY AND EVERYTHING IS GREAT AND THERE ARE STILL OUTSTANDING ISSUES. SO EXTENDING THIS SUNSET IS A GOOD IDEA AND I WOULD SUPPORT IT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH MR. SPEAKER ONE LAST THING. WE ALSO HAVE PENDING LEGISLATION WHERE SOME OF THE FIRST RESPONDERS AND THE ROAD COMPANIES HAVE BEE N IN DISCUSSION BECAUSE THERE'S NOT THE KIND OF COMMUNICATION THAT WE NEED TO HAVE BETWEEN THE FIRST RESPONDERS AND THE RAIL COMPANIES THAT LEGISLATION HAS ALSO BEEN INTRODUCED. I DID A VERSION OF IT GOO D THAT LEGISLATION IS JUST SITTING WAITING TO BE ACTED ON. WE NEED TO DO THAT THE SESSION AS WELL. SO THIS IS REALLY IMPORTANT WITH A COUPLE OF THE RAIL SAFETY ITEMS THAT NEED TO BE ADDRESSED. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE >> REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE: REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH ; THERE'S A SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION FOR $100;000 FOR RAIL RATE CROSSING IS THAT IN ADDITION TO THE 500;000 THAT I HAVE IN THE AMENDMENT WAS THAT REPLACING THE 500;000 WITH 100;000? >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH: THAT IS IN ADDITION. >> REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE: IN ADDITION. THANK YOU MR. CHAIR AND REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH. GOODNESS; I LIKE THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT. THIS RAIL SAFETY ACCOUNT IS A 2.5 MILLION DOLLAR ASSESSMENT TO THE RAILROADS AND PIPELINES FOR RAILROAD AND PIPELINE SAFETY. WE HAVE SOMETHING IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD OF 4000 AT GRADE CROSSINGS. A LOT OF THEM LIKE REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER'S OR THERE'S ONE IN ANOKA AND NOT EVEN SURE WHOSE DISTRICT THAT IS IN-IT IS EWERS?-EXTREMELY DANGEROUS. I GUESS THE ONLY THING I WOULD SAY IS THAT I THINK WE SHOULD PROBABLY KEEP THIS ASSESSMENT AND UNTIL WE DEAL WITH THOSE . THESE ARE SAFETY ISSUES THAT ARE DIRECTLY ATTRIBUTABLE TO THE RAILROADS IN THE PIPELINES DOING BUSINESS IN MINNESOTA. BUT I WOULD URGE EVERYBODY FOR A CLEAN VOTE FOR REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH'S AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE FRANKE >> REPRESENTATIVE FRANKE: I RISE IN SUPPORT OF CHAIRM AN CORNISH'S AMENDMENT. I DON'T KNOW HOW MANY BE NOBODY IN MY AREA WE HAD TWO YEARS AG O SEMITRUCK VERSUS A TRAIN. IT HAPPENED TO BE RIGHT ALMOST SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE OF WESTERN REFINERY. SO IN MY AREA I CPA RAILROAD. I PNS RAILROAD OF RUN ALMOST COINCIDE STRAIGHT THROUGH WESTERN REFINERY. SO WHEN IT COMES TO BILL SAFETY AND PIPELINE SAFETY THIS IS A BIG CONCERN OF MINE AND CITIZENS IN MY AREA. SO AT THE TIME THIS AT THE RAILROAD CROSSING WHERE THE ACCIDENT HAPPENED WAS THE FIFTH MOST DANGEROUS ON GOV. DEAN'S LIST OF AT GRADE RAILROAD CROSSINGS. THROUGH THE HELP OF THE GOVERNOR AND OTHERS STAKEHOLDERS AND THE RAILROAD ASHLEY KICK IN A LITTLE BIT WE WERE ABLE TO GET THAT CROSSING CLOSED AND REDESIGN. SOME IN BIG SUPPORT OF THIS IN ANY FASHION I WOULD THINK THE CHAIRMAN FOR BRINGING FORTH AND REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE. THANK YOU >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE LOEFFLER >> REPRESENTATIVE LOEFFLER: MEMBER S I WANT TO SAY I WAS DISAPPOINTED IN THE ORIGINAL BILL THAT SUNSET IT THIS KEY FUNDING SOURCE FOR PUBLIC SAFETY AND WHILE THE TWO WEEK YEAR EXTENSION IS BETTER THAN NOTHING I'VE GOT TO SAY PROTECTING OUR COMMUNITIES IS AN ONGOING RESPONSIBILITY A S REPRESENTATIVE NEWBERGER DID A NICE JOB OF SHARING HOW SCARY THESE KIND OF SITUATIONS CAN BE I REPRESENT A DISTRICT WITH TWO RAILROAD YARDS. I THINK 27 RAILROAD BRIDGES; PROBABLY 45-50 AT GRADE GRADE CROSSINGS AND MY ABSOLUTELY ENTIRE DISTRICT IS IN THE AQUATIC BLAST ZONE IF USING THE BLAST ZONE MAPS. THIS IS NOT A MINOR ISSUE IN ANY PART OF OUR STATE. I THINGS GOING TO BE AN ONGOING ISSUE WE WILL HAVE TO TRAIN FIRST RESPONDERS TO DO WITH NEW CHEMICALS; NEW SHIPMENTS NEW RISKS ONGOING AND I HOPE THIS EXTENSION EXISTS IS THE BEGINNING OF MAKING THIS MAKING AN ONGOING PART OF OUR SUPPORT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE CORNISH AMENDMENT TO THE CONSIDINE AMENDMENT? ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY; AYE. [CHORUS OF AYES.] OPPOSED; SAY NAY. THE MOTION PREVAILS. >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: TO THE CONSIDINE AMENDMENT AS AMENDED. DISCUSSION? ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY; AYE. [CHORUS OF AYES.] OPPOSED; SAY NAY. THE MOTION PREVAILS. THE AMENDMENT IS AMENDED TO THE BILL >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: HILSTROM MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED IN THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 35. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM; >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM; MEMBERS MY AMENDMENT ALSO GOES TO THIS RAILROA D SAFETY ASSESSMENT THAT IS PAID FOR BY THE RAILROADS. AMHERST; WE HAVE AN EMERGENCY RESPONSE TEAMS THAT WE HAVE ALL CROSSED THE STATE TO RESPOND TO EMERGENCIES. CURRENTLY; IN THE BILL IT TAKES THE MONEY TO FUND THOSE FROM THE FIRE SAFETY ACCOUNTS. WE HEARD FROM THE FOLKS OF THE FI RE SAFETY ACCOUNT THEY BELIEVE THAT WAS NOT THE PROPER PLACE TO BE FUNDING IT FROM A BELIEVE THE RAILROAD PIPELINE SAFETY ASSESSMENT IS A MORE APPROPRIATE PLACE. SO NUMBERS I WOULD ASK YOU SUPPORT THE MIMICS TO FUND THESE EMERGENCY RESPONSE TEAMS OUT OF THAT RAIL SAFETY ASSESSMENT THAT IS DUE TO SUNSET. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE'S A MIMICS TO THE HILSTROM MEMBERS. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIE F CLERK: CORNISH MOVES TO AMEND THE HILSTROM MIMICS TO SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 43 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: CHAIRMAN CORNISH >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH: B- 43 AMENDMENT MEANS THE A- SERVER BASIN IN THE SUNSET DATE BY COUPLE YEARS. TWO YEARS. IT SPECIFIES THE OWNER WILL SUSPECT WILL ONLY BE [INAUDIBLE] AND PIPELINE SAFETY ACCOUNT GETS TO THE $1 MILLION BUT I ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT ON THE A- 43 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT? REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM: MEMBERS I'M GOING TO ENCOURAGE YOU TO SUPPORT REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH'S MIMICS BECAUSE I WANT THE MONEY TO BE IN PLA Y BUT MEMBERS I WANT YOU TO KNOW THAT REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH DOESN 'T MAKE IT SO THAT IF THE MONEY THAT'S IN THE COUNT IS MORE THAN $1 MILLION I N THE ASSESSMENT DOES NOT CONTINUE IN HIS THE GOV.'S POSITION IS ASSESSMENT SHOULD CONTINUE WHILE HE REDUCES THE AMOUNT OF THE ASSESSMENT. HE DOES BELIEVE THAT ASSESSMENT SHOULD CONTINUE THIS WOULD SAY IT ONLY CONTINUES I F IT GOES TO $1 MILLION. SO WHILE I WOULD ENCOURAGE MEMBERS TO SUPPORT REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH'S AMENDMENT I WOULD ASK REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH TO CONSIDER IN CONFERENCE LOSING THAT PROVISION ABOUT $1 MILLION. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE CORNISH AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT? ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY; AYE. [CHORUS OF AYES.] OPPOSED; SAY NAY. AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDMENT IS ADOPTED. >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: TO THE METRICS A S AMENDED. REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM: ELECT TO SEND A VERY STRONG MESSAGE TO THE SENATE THAT WE IN THE HOUSE LEAVE RAIL SAFETY IS VERY IMPORTANT FILM HOPING THAT EVERYONE WILL BE A GREEN VOTE AND ONGOING ASKED FOR ROLL CALL TWO AT THAT AMENDMENT TO THE BILL >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ROLL CALL HAS BEEN REQUESTED. SEEING FIFTEEN HANDS THERE WILL BE A ROLL CALL. DISCUSSION TO THE AMENDED AMENDMENT? THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL. >>[ROLL CALL VOTE] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THE CLERK WILL CLOSE THE ROLL. THERE BEING 129 TREMONT AND TWO TREE TO THE AMENDED MEMO SAYS ADOPTED. >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: BECKER-FINN MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 17. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE BECKER-FINN >> REPRESENTATIVE BECKER-FINN: MEMBERS; THIS AMENDMENT WOULD DELETE THE LANGUAGE IN THE BILL HE ANTI-PROTESTER LANGUAGE THAT INCREASES PENALTIES FOR THOSE WHO PARTICIPATE IN PROTESTS. I WANT TO START BY POINTING OUT THE IRONY HERE AS WE SIT HERE TODAY DEBATING THIS BILL THAT WOULD FURTHER PENALIZE PROTESTERS WE SIT IN A BUILDING THAT SITS ON REV. DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING JUNIOR BOULEVARD. HER BUSINESS CARDS ARE STATIONARY; THE SIGNS OUTSIDE THIS BUILDING ALL BEAR HIS NAME. WHEN WE HEARD THESE BILLS IN COMMITTEE I LEARNED THAT ON EVERYONE IN THIS BODY IS FAMILIAR WITH LETTER FROM UPPER MANHATTAN GET TO THE UNFAMILIAR IS PERHAPS DR. KING'S MOST WELL-KNOWN WRITING. THE LETTERS HE WROTE WHILE IN JAIL FOR PEACEFULLY PROTESTING. IN THAT LETTER; HE RESPONDED TO THOSE WHO WONDERED WHY HE CAME TO BIRMINGHAM IN THE FIRST PLACE. HIS ANSWER WAS; I AM BIRMINGHAM BECAUSE INJUSTICE IS IN HERE. SO I SUBMIT TO YOU THAT THE RECENT WOULD HAVE MORE PROTESTS RECENTLY IN OUR STATE IS THAT INJUSTICE IS HERE . I KNOW SOME YOU WILL WAY THAT AWAIT OR ARE NOT LISTEN BECAUSE YOU DO NOT SEE THE INJUSTICE. YOU DO NOT FEEL THE INJUSTICE. THAT ABILITY TO WAVE IT AWAY IS CALLED PRIVILEGE. IT IS NOT A PRIVILEGE THAT ALL MINNESOTANS OUT. I ASK YOU TO REALLY TRULY TRY TO PUT YOURSELF IN THE SHOES OF THOSE WHO PARTICIPATE IN PROTESTS. WHY DO YOU THINK THEY DO IT? IS IT TO THEM KNOW WHAT YOU? IS IT TO CAUSE TROUBLE? IS IT TO INCONVENIENCE YOU? THE REALITY IS THAT IT'S NOT ABOUT YOU. IT IS ABOUT DRAWING ATTENTION TO INJUSTICE. TH E ABILITY TO USE DIRECT ACTION AS A TOOL TO DRAW ATTENTION TO THAT INJUSTICE THAT THE CORE OF WHAT IT MEANS TO BE AMERICAN. ABO UT OUR HISTORY AMERICANS HAVE USED THIS TOOL TO MOVE OUR GREAT COUNTRY TOWARDS PROGRESS. EARLIER THIS SESSION WHILE WE WERE IN THE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE WE TALKED ABOUT FIREWORKS. SEVERAL REPRESENTATIVES WERE IN FAVOR OF EXPANDING THE FREEDOM TO BUY FIREWORKS. THE FIRE DEPARTMENT AND THE EMTS AND MANY IN THE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE TOLD US THIS WAS A BAD IDEA. FOR MANY REPUBLICANS ON THE COMMITTEE THE FREEDOM TO BUY AND SELL FIREWORKS SUPERSEDED ALL THOSE SA FETY CONCERNS. SO WHAT MESSAGE DO YOU THINK YOU ARE SENDING PARTICULARLY; TO THOSE WHO SUFFER THESE GREAT INJUSTICES IF WE ARE IN FAVOR OF FREEDOM TO BUY FIREWORKS COME UP BUT NOT IN FAVOR OF THE FREEDOM TO EXERCISE A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT? WHAT I'M FOR EVERYONE IN THIS ROOM AND EVERYONE WATCHING TO CONSIDER IS THAT THE MESSAGE YOU ARE SENDING ; THE PEOPLE OF MINNESOTA IS THAT IT'S MORE IMPORTANT FOR YOU TO BE FREE THAN IT IS FOR OTHERS. THAT; THAT IS PRIVILEGE AND THAT IS INJUSTICE. I WILL NOW SHARE WITH YOU THE WORDS OF DR. KING. WE KNOW THROUGH PAINFUL EXPERIENCE THAT FREEDOM IS NEVER VOLUNTARILY GIVEN BY THE OPPRESSOR. IT MUST BE DEMANDED BY THE OPPRESSED. FRANKLY; I'VE YET TO ENGAGE IN A DIRECT ACTION CAMPAIGN THA T WAS WELL-TIMED IN THE VIEW OF THOSE WHO'VE NOT SUFFERED UNDULY FROM THE DISEASE OF SEGREGATION. LAW ENFORCEMENT TO NOT ASK YOU TO MAKE THIS CHANGE REGARDING PENALTIES. PROSECUTORS ARE NOT ASK YOU TO MAKE THIS CHANGE. ST . PAUL AND MINNEAPOLIS DID NOT ASK YOU TO MAKE THIS CHANGE IN THE PEOPLE OF MINNESOTA DID NOT ASK YOU TO MAKE THIS CHANGE. I ENCOURAGE A YES VOTE ON THIS AMENDMENT TAKE THE LANGUAGE OUT OF THE BILL. THANK YOU. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION? CHAIRMAN KNOBLACH >> REPRESENTATIVE KNOBLACH I LIKE TO REQUEST A ROLL CALL ON THIS AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ROLL CALL HAS BEEN REQUESTED. SEEING FIFTEEN HANDS THERE WILL BE A ROLL CALL. CHAIRMAN KNOBLACH >> REPRESENTATIVE KNOBLACH: MEMBERS; PEOP LE HAVE A RIGHT TO PROTEST. PEOPLE HAVE A RIGHT TO FREEDOM OF SPEECH AND I FULLY SUPPORT THAT. BUT; THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT AN EXERCISING THOSE RIGHTS THEY NEED TO PUT THE LIVES AND LIVELIHOODS OF OTHER PEOPLE AT RISK. SO WHAT WE'VE GOT IN THIS BIL L IS LANGUAGE SAYING THAT YOU CAN'T BLOCK FREEWAYS. M OUNCES TRAVEL ON FREEWAYS. LAW ENFORCEMENT TRAVELS ON FREEWAYS. TAKING THIS LANGUAGE OUT ALLOWING PEOPLE TO PROTEST ON FREEWAYS WITH THE LIMITED PENALTIES THAT ARE IN IT RIGHT NOW THE HONORA BLE KURT L. DAUDT; SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE AND THE HONORABLE SANDRA L. PAPPAS; PRESIDENT OF THE [INAUDIBLE] >> REPRESENTATIVE ECKLUND AM GOING TO SAY THIS A LITTLE TOO LITTLE TOO LATE. YOU'RE IN THE WRONG STATE IN FACT. BACK IN YEAR 2004 WERE FREEWAY BLOCKAGES AND IT ACTUALLY SKEWED PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION. TOO LITTLE; TOO LATE. IT'S EMBARRASSING TO HEAR THAT YOU WANT TO ANALYZE MINNESOTANS FOR ENTHUSIASTICALLY EXPRESSION OF THEIR GRIEVANCES CONCERNING THE ACTIONS OF LAW-ENFORCEMENT OFFICIALS. YOU SEEM TO FORGET THIS PARTICULAR TACTIC WORKS WELL FOR GEORGE W. BUSH TO THANK YOU. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE THISSEN >> REPRESENTATIVE THISSEN: MEMBERS; I URGE YOU TO SUPPORT THIS MAN WORKS. THE PROTEST THAT WE ARE SEEING HERE IN MINNESOTA RECENTLY AND ACROSS THE COUNTRY ARE ONLY A REFLECTION OF A LARGER CRISIS FOR OUR DEMOCRACY. IT'S NOT JUST ON THE STREET IS IN OUR WORKPLACE. IT'S AT THE BALLOT BOX. THAT IS THIS BROUGHT UNEASY SENSE OF THIS-EMPOWERMENT THAT THEY ARE FEELING BETTER COMMITTEES AND THEMSELVES CAN CONTROL THEIR OWN DESTINY ANYMORE. THAT'S WAS UNDERLYING THIS. WE CAN SEE WHY. CITIZENS UNITED THAT AMPLIFY THE VOICES OF WEALTHY WELL-CONNECTED PEOPLE AT THE EXPENSE OF ORDINARY VOICES IN OUR ELECTION PROCESS. WE ARE SEEING MORE AND MORE AND MORE ECONOMIC POWER ESPECIALLY IN THE COMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY AND INFORMATION ECONOMY WILL BUY FEWER AND FEWER HUGE CORPORATIONS WHO REALLY DON'T HAVE ANY VAL UE AND SHOULDN'T BECAUSE THIS IS HOW WE SET THEM UP; VALUE FOR HUMAN BEINGS EXCEPT THEIR VALUE TO THE CORPORATE BOTTOM LINE. WE HAVE A GOVERNMENT ESPECIALLY IN WASHINGTON DC; BRIGHT HERE; IN THE STATE OF MINNESOTA MORE AND MORE UNFORTUNATELY THAT SIMPLY ISN'T RESPONSIVE AND CAN'T GET ANYTHING MEANINGFULLY DONE ANYMORE. NO WONDER; PEOPLE ARE FEELING THIS SENSE OF THIS EMPOWERMENT THIS FEELING THEY HAVE NO VOICE. THE PROTEST THAT WE'VE SEEN RECENTLY AS THE IN THE CASE REALLY THROUGHOUT OUR COUNTRY'S HISTORY IS THE VOICE OF THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN UNHEARD TO LONG DEMANDING TO BE HEARD. THAT IS PROBABLY THE MOST AMERICAN THING THAT THERE IS. IN FACT; YOU COULD DEFINE AMERICAN HISTORY IN THOSE WORDS. THAT'S AMERICAN HISTORY IS ABOUT MORE AND MORE PEOPLE DEMANDING THAT THEIR UNHEARD VOICE BE HEARD. SIMPLY BECAUSE WERE ANY CONVENIENCE STORE PROBABLY WAS MORE IMPORTANT BECAUSE WERE MADE UNCOMFORTABLE BY THOSE VOICES; SHOULD NOT GIVE US ANY RIGHT OR ANY REASON TO PUNISH THEM OR SHUT THEM DOWN. IN FACT; WHAT WERE DOING HERE TODAY IS EXACTLY THE WRONG SOLUTION TO OVERSEEING IN THIS COUNTRY. THE PROTESTS ARE NOT THE PROBLEM . THE PROBLEM IS THAT WE'VE HAD AN UNWILLINGNESS TO LISTEN TO AND RESPOND TO THESE PEOPLE WOULD HAVE NOT OTHERWISE BEEN HEARD. SO INSTEAD OF PUSHING THEM ASIDE WE SHOULD BE DOING IS INVITING THEM TO THE TABLE. WE SHOULD BE RESPONDING TO REAL PEOPLE'S NEEDS. WHEN ROBERT KENNEDY WENT TO DELANO CALIFORNIA TO BE WITH CAESAR CHAVEZ BACK IN 1966; THE YEAR I WAS BORN; -BY THE WAY PROTESTERS MARCHING DOWN THE HIGHWAY FROM THEIR FIELDS THEY WORKED INTO THE CAPITOL IN SACRAMENTO- HE SAID THIS. I THINK THIS REALLY CAPTURES WHAT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT TODAY. IN THE LAST ANALYSIS ; THE ANSWER IS THAT WE PASSED LAWS OF THE OLD REMEDY INJUSTICES. THAT'S WHAT WE SHOULD DO. THAT'S WHAT THOSE OF US IN GOVERNMENT SHOULD DO. WE SHOULD JUST DEPLORE THE VIOLENCE AND UP FOR THE LAWLESSNESS. WE SHOULD PASS THE LAWS THAT REMEDY WERE PEOPLE WRITE ABOUT. WE HAVE NOT BEEN DOING THAT. MEMBERS; INSTEAD OF PASSING THIS KIND OF LUCK I WOULD ENCOURAGE US TO DO THAT WORK TO PAY ATTENTION TO THAT. IT IS MUCH HARDER. IT REQUIRES MORE COURAGE THAN MAKING CRIMINALS OUT OF OUR FELLOW MINNESOTANS BECAUSE THEY FRIGHTEN US. BUT IN THE LONG TERM; IT IS THE BEST AND REALLY THE ONLY ANSWER TO DEALING WITH WHAT WE'RE SEEING IN OUR STATE AND COUNTRY COULD I WOULD ENCOURAGE A YES VOTE ON THE AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE PINTO >> REPRESENTATIVE PINTO: MEMBERS IT SEEMS TO ME WE CAN'T IGNORE THE CONTEXT WITHIN WHICH THIS PROVISION IS BEING PROPOSED. THIS IS PART OF A NATIONAL TREND. AS BILLS IN MANY STATES TARGETING PEOPLE WERE PROTESTING FOR THEIR RIGHTS THAT IS TRUE IN OUR STATE AS WELL. A TREND OF TARGETING PEOPLE WERE PROTESTING ON BEHALF OF THEIR RIGHTS. THIS WOULD'VE A PACKAGE OF BILLS ADVANCE BY THE MAJORITY . THIS ONE FOLKS ARE AWARE OF THAT'S MOVE THROUGH THE PROCESS ALONE THE GOVERNMENT TO SUE PROTESTERS FOR EXERCISING CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS. I CAN'T LEAVE ANYTHING MORE UN-AMERICAN OF THAT CONCEPT THE GOVERNMENT SUING PROTESTERS. I WANT TO NOTE THAT THIS STATE-RUN CERTAINLY NATIONAL TREND AS WELL STOPPING US FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT ARE PROXIES THEY DID NOT TESTIFY ON THIS BILL DID NOT TESTIFY THIS IT IS NO COINCIDENCE OF TARGETING PROTEST IS COMING AT THE SAME TIME A TREND OF PEOPLE INCREASINGLY SPEAKING UP ON BEHALF OF THEIR RIGHTS. MANY OF THEM MINNESOTANS OF COLOR AND IMMIGRANT PEOPLE FEEL DISPOSSESSED RECOGNIZING: ATTENTION TO RESPONDING TO FUNDAMENTAL INEQUITIES IN OUR SOCIETY. A SENSE THAT TOO OFTEN IN OUR SOCIETY WHAT YOU EXPERIENCED YOUR EDUCATION YOUR HEALTH YOUR INCOME; YES YOUR EXPERIENCE WITH THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM IS TOO OFTEN STATISTICALLY LINKED TO THE COLOR OF YOUR SKIN. INCREASING RECOGNITION OF THE ROLE THAT RACIAL DESCRIPTION BY DISPLAY IN A BROAD SET OF VARIOUS SOCIETY. ONE POINT OUT CONTRAST NUMBERS. SEVERAL YEARS AGO THERE WAS A TREND OF RIOT S ON COLLEGE CAMPUSES. QUITE A FEW. WERE TREMENDOUS PROPERTY DAMAGE AND INJURY FAR EXCEEDED MOST CASES THAT FROM THE PROTEST BY THIS BILL WHITE IN THOSE THESE SORTS OF CHANGES. RATHER THAN INCIDENTS PROTESTING FOR THEIR RIGHTS. INCREASING THE PENALTY FROM A 90 DAY MISDEMEANOR TO A ONE-YEAR GROSS MISDEMEANOR IS NOT GOING TO ACT AS A TOKEN PEOPLE DON'T GO TO THE LIBRARY POCKETBOOK AND OPEN UP AND LOOK AND SAY; GUESS WHAT; THE GROSS MISDEMEANOR AND I GUESS I WON'T GO OUT AND PROTEST TODAY. I WOULD'VE IT WOULD BE A MISDEMEANOR. THIS IS A RESPONSE TO INJUSTICE WHICH IS NOT BEING ADDRESSED. IT'S TRUE THIS MAY WELL SCARE SOME PEOPLE FROM ATTENDING CERTAIN EVENTS. AS THEY WAIT CHILL SPEECH AS WE THINK CONSTITUTIONAL LAW CHILL SPEECH PEOPLE TENDING TO ATTEMPTING CONSTITUTIONAL SPEECH. THE MIGHTY SMALL PULP PROTEST THE GHOSTLY PROCESS. THE MIGHTY BIGGER PROTESTS PEOPLE WHO FEEL THE SENSE OF INJUSTICE. I ANTICIPATE THE ARGUMENT THAT OFTEN WE ARE SUPPORTING ANY INCRE ASE IN PENALTIES IT IS NOT ABOUT DETERRENCE AS WELL. WELL; NO; MEMBERS; PENALTY WE IMPOSED FOR OFFENSES OFTEN AMONG ABOUT TO TURN. PLEASE NOT MIGHTY WAS A PROSECUTOR. THE PENALTIES NEVER TOLD THAT AN OFFENDER ACCOUNTABLE FOR BEHAVIOR THAT VIOLATES THE CITY NORMS. THAT IS THE POWER OF PROTEST OF COURSE THAT BREAKS THE LAW. IT IS SAYING; THE PEOPLE PROTESTING ARE SAYING WE THINK THAT SUCH AN UNFAIR SITUATION WERE WILLING TO VIOLATE SOCIETY'S NORMS AND IT EXCEPT CONSEQUENCE. THERE'S OF COURSE A LONG HISTORY IN OUR COUNTRY. MANY OF US ARE AWARE THAT BU T HOPING BECOMING EVER MORE WET BUT THE COST WAS UP TO BE COMMENSURATE WITH THE CONDO. AS A POLICY MAKER THE PROSECUTOR ON CONCERN THE PENALTY FOR OFFENSE BASED ON THE BROADER STRUCTURE [INAUDIBLE] WITH THE BROADER STRUCTURE HERE? I KNOW MISDEMEANOR 90 DAYS. WHAT'S ANOTHER EXAMPLE THE PENALTY THAT'S 90 DAYS? WELL; THE TWO- WAY FLOW WITH DOMESTIC ASSAULT. FIRST TIME YOU PUNCH YOUR SPOUSE GIRLFRIEND; BOYFRIEND; THAT IS A MISDEMEANOR. IT'S GOT A PRETTY HIGH LEVEL ENTRY TO GET TO GROSS MR. MIRROR WITHOUT IT ACTUALLY INFLICT A LOT OF DAMAGE BUT A LOT OF CUTS A LOT OF BRUISES THAT ARE STILL MISDEMEANOR DOMESTIC ASSAULT. THIS MORE SIGNIFICANT A VIOLATION THAN THAT? YOU THINK ABOUT PARTICULAR KINDS OF PROTEST IN THIS BILL. BUT THINKING ABOUT INTERSTATE SITUATIONS. I WOULD POINT OUT THIS IS FAR BROADER THAN THIS. YOU BLOCK THE ENTRANCE TO LIGHT RAIL TRAIN THAT QUALIFIES FOR THIS. IT'S ONLY PICKING IF YOU NOTICE HER; IS ONLY PICKING CERTAIN PROVISIONS TO BE INCREASED IN ONLY SOME KINDS OF BLOCK. NONE OF US ARE: THE PLOT TRANSPORTATION BILL. WE ALL KNOW WHAT THIS IS. DOES THE LOCK PROTEST OH. #WERE AIMING IN A SET SPEECH THAT'S WHY CHAIRMAN KNOBLACH; WITH RESPECT ABOUT PUBLIC SAFETY. IF THERE ARE INCIDENTS IN WHICH THERE IS A DAMAGE IN THAT CASE OTHER OFFENSES APPLY. WERE PICKING UP THE TICKER KINDS OF BLOCKING INCREASING APPEARED AGAIN THIS IS NOT THE REQUEST BY LAW ENFORCEMENT BY THOSE OFFICERS OUT THERE I WORK WITH EVERY DAY WORKING TO KEEP PEOPLE SAFE . THIS IS BEING PUSHED AS PART OF A SYSTEMIC AGENDA NATIONALISTS ON THE INTERSTATE TO SUPPRESS DISSENT. I JUST WANT- AND WITH A FINAL QUESTION ONTO FOLK SUPPORTED BY THE TEA PARTY? THE TEA PARTY WAS AN ILLEGAL PROTEST RIGHT? WE WENT TO 7073 UNTHINKABLE COMES TO KING GEORGE VERSUS THE AMERICAN REVOLUTIONARIES I WOULD KNOW WHICH SIDE YOU WOULD BE ON. VOTE; GREEN. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE FISCHER >> REPRESENTATIVE FISCHER: I'VE GOT THREE THINGS I'D LIKE TO SHARE IN REGARD TO THIS AMENDMENT. FIRST OF ALL ON ENCOURAGING PEOPLE TO VOTE SCREEN AND COMES FROM THREE DIFFERENT THINGS THAT COME TO MIND. NUMBER ONE IS BACK IN 79 I WAS INVOLVED IN A PEACEFUL PROTEST WAS A MINOR INJUSTICE GOING ON. AT THAT POINT INVOLVED IN OCCUPATIONAL [INAUDIBLE] EVENTUALLY MOVED IN AND WE OCCUPIED THE WEEKEND HERE IN THE STATE CAPITAL AND THE THERE FOR ABOUT A WEEK AND A HALF. THAT POINT IN TIME WILL POINT OUT BECAUSE WE FELT WAS MINOR INJUSTICE AT THE TIME WE WERE TO GO TO JAIL BECAUSE OF WHAT WAS GOING ON. THAT'S ONE OF FOCUS ON THE INJUSTICES IS WHEN PEOPLE FEEL THERE'S BEEN A GREAT INJUSTICE YOU CAN PUT A PENALTY OUT THAT THEY'RE GOING TO SAY THE PENALTY OF THEIR PILLS COMPARISON TO THE INJUSTICE. THAT BRINGS ME TO MY SECOND STORY. NOT LONG AGO THERE WAS A SHOOTING IN MINNEAPOLIS AT THE FOURTH PRECINCT I WORK AT A HOMELESS YOUTH SHELTER HALFWAY BETWEEN WHERE A PERSON WAS KILLED AND THE FOURTH PRECINCT. DURING THAT TIME THE NUMBER OF OUR YOUTH WERE INVOLVED WITH THE PROTESTS. ONE OF THE THINGS THAT CAME TO MY ATTENTION SOME PEOPLE LAW-ENFORCEMENT HAD CONTACTED ME AND TOLD ME THEY WERE SEEING A LOT OF SOME DISTURBING VIDEOS OUT THERE OF PEOPLE WHO WANTED TO COME TO THE PROTEST CREATE AN INCIDENT AND DO SOME SHOOTING BECAUSE THEY WERE TRYING TO SUPPORT RACISM OUT THERE WANT TO KILL SOME PEOPLE WHO WERE OF COLOR. PURE AND SIMPLE BACK INTO MY ATTENTION ABOUT A WEEK AND A HALF BEFORE THE SHOOTING. I FORMAT INFOR MED SOME OF OUR STUFF AND SOME OF OUR YOUTH SAYING THIS IS A DANGEROUS SITUATION YOU MAY NOT WANT TO GO THERE. WHAT ENDED UP HAPPENING IS SOME OF THE STAFF AND YOU DAVNIE AND SAID; THAT THE INJUSTICE THAT IS OUT THERE IS SO GREAT WE FEEL THAT WE COULD END UP DYING WITH HER WERE OUT THERE PROTESTING WERE NOT. SHORTLY AFTER THE SHOOTING TURNOUT ONE OF OUR YOUTH WERE THERE AND WAS GRAZED BY BULLET THAT OCCURRED AT THAT POINT IN TIME TO REMEMBER THESE ARE YOUTH I WANT IS A POSSIBILITY THEY COULD BE KILLED BEING THERE. THAT DID NOT STOP THEM FROM A PROTEST. THE NEXT THING I'LL MENTION GOING BACK TO A LEADER OF INDIA; GANDHI; BACK IN THE 40S; I WANT TO MENTION AN INCIDENT THAT STANDS OUT VERY STRONGLY THAT WHEN THEY GET THEIR PEACEFUL PROTEST AT THE SALTWORKS THEY WERE TRYING TO SHUT IT DOWN. HER MEMBER THESE PEOPLE COMING UP TO THE GATES OF THESE FACILITIES. THEY HAD CARDS. THAT THE POLICE ENFORCEMENT OF FRONT WITH WOODEN STICKS. EACH PEACEFUL PROTESTERS THEY WALKED FOR WAS BEATEN WITH A STICK INTO THE PEOPLE COLLAPSED AND WERE HAULED AWAY. THIS WENT ON FOR OUT TO THE ENTIRE DAY. WHEN ON SOME OF THE MULTIPLE TIMES >> >> >> MINNESOTA STATE GOVERNMENT; HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES FLOOR SESSION FOR MONDAY; APRIL 3; 2017 WILL RECONVENE SHORTLY. >> >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THE HOUSE WILL COME TO ORDER. CALENDAR FOR THE DAY. THE FIRST BILL ON THE CALENDAR FOR THE DAY IS HOUSE FILE 140. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE BILL. >> CHIEF CLERK: HOUSE FILE NUMBER 140 NUMBER ONE ON THE CALENDAR FOR THE DAY AND ACT RELATING TO EDUCATION 50 ENGROSSMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: TO THE BILL REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON I HAVE A AUTHORS AMENDMENT AT THE TABLE I LIKE TO TAKE UP PLEASE >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: ERICKSON MOVES TO AMEND HOUSE FILE NUMBER ONE 4050 ENGROSSMENT AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 35. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: TO THE A- 35 AMENDMENT REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: MEMBERS; THE A- 35 AMENDMENT IS BASICALLY A CLARIFICATION . FIRST OF ALL IT CHANGES THE MEMBERSHIP SLIGHTLY IN THAT THE PRINCIPLES NOW WILL ALTERNATE BETWEEN SECONDARY AND ELEMENTARY SPEECH OR EXCUSE ME CHAIRMAN ERICKSON >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: EXCUSE ME. MEMBERS PLEASE TAKE YOUR CONVERSATIONS TO THE ALCOVE OR THE BACK ROOM WHERE THE PARKING GARAGE REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON : THANK YOU. MEMBERS; AND OF COURSE; MR. SPEAKER THE OTHER CHANGE IN MEMBERSHIP WOULD BE ADDING A BOARD APPROVED TEACHER REPARATION. PROVIDER. WE THINK THAT'S IMPORTANT TO BE-WE LISTEN TO THIS IS MEDICS-35 SO YOU KNOW WE'VE BEEN LISTENING TO ALL THE CONCERNS THAT COME ALONG. WE ALSO DELETE SOME REDUNDANT LANGUAGE. WE ALSO MAKE SOME SPECIFICITY FOR ALLOWING THE BOARD TO DETERMINE CERTAIN TEACHER PREPARATION PROGRAMS ETC. SO WITH THAT; MEMBERS I WOULD ASK YOUR FOR YOUR SUPPORT ON THE A- 35. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE A- 30 AMENDMENT ? REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: I WONDER IS HE WENT TO ERIC WOULD YIELD TO A QUESTION? REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; SO PART OF THIS AMENDMENT ALLOWS FOR INSTEAD OF A-INSTEAD OF ONE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL SECONDARY SCHOOL PRINCIPAL THE BOARD WILL INSTEAD HAVE ONE STAFF MEMBER OF A BOARD APPROVED PROGRAM SHOULD I THINK THAT'S MOVING IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION. WHEN OF THE CONCERNS THAT WAS EXPRESSED ABOUT THE PROCESS HAD TO WORK ON IT [INAUDIBLE] HIGHER EDUCATION PRESENCE ON THIS NEW BOARD. THIS DOESN'T FULLY ANSWER THAT BUT I THINK IT MOVES IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION ONE OF YOU COULD SAY A LITTLE MORE ABOUT THE IMPORTANCE WORRIED YOU WERE DESIRES FOR HAVING ACCESS FOR HIGHER ED INDIVIDUALS ON THIS NEW BOARD? >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: WE DO THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO HAVE A REPRESENTATIVE OF TEACHER PREPARATION PROGRAM ON THE BOARD AND TO DO THAT I NEGOTIATED WITH THE PRINCIPLES ABOUT ALLOWING THEIR MEMBERSHIP TO BE ALTERNATING. SO WE WILL HAVE THAT STAFF MEMBER THAT'S BEEN TRADITIONALLY AND THAT WILL CONTINUE BUT WE WANT TO SPECIFICALLY MENTION THAT IT'S FROM A BOARD APPROVED TEACHER PREP PROGRAM PROVIDER. NOT SIMPLY SOMEONE FROM HIGHER EDUCATION. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: I THINK THAT'S A GOOD FAITH FIRST STEP AND I THINK YOU ARE MOVING THE BILL IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION THAT REGARD SO WOULD URGE MEMBER SUPPORT FOR THE BILL. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION ON THE A- 35 AMENDMENT ? ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY; AYE. [CHORUS OF AYES.] OPPOSED; SAY NAY. THE MOTION PREVAILS. THE AMENDMENT IS ADOPTED. >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: MARIANI MOVES TO AMEND HOUSE FILE ONE 4050 ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED. THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 33. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: MEMBERS THAT WOULD STILL MOVE THE AMENDMENT. MEMBERS; WITH THIS DOES RECENTLY FIRST OF ALL LET ME JUST SAY WE HAVEN'T TALKED ABOUT THE BILL BUT I THINK THE BILL CONTAINS A NUMBER OF IMPORTANT REFORMS FOR THE GOVERNANCE AND OVERSIGHT OVER TEACHER LICENSURE PROCESS IN THE STATE. I SUSPECT CHAIRMAN ERICKSON WILL SPEAK MORE ABOUT THAT AS WE GET TO THE THIRD HEARING. I THINK THAT-SO THEREFORE I THINK THERE'S IMPORTANT I THINK THE WAY WE WILL ANSWER THAT PARTLY WILL BE BASED ON WHAT YOUR PHILOSOPHY IS ROLLED TO DO THE EXPECTATION OF A PROFESSIONAL CLASS. IN PARTICULARLY THE PROFESSIONAL CLASSES AND TRUST WITH ONE MOST IMPORTANT THINGS WERE ASKING PEOPLE TO DO IN OUR SOCIETY WHICH IS TO GUIDE THE INSTRUCTION OF OUR YOUNG AND RK 12-E-12 SYSTEM. ONE OF THE PROVISIONS THAT I'M GETTING TOO MUCH DETAIL INTO THE BILL; THAT OCCURS UNDER THE LANGUAGE BEFORE US IS THAT IT REALLY DOES MAKE IT QUITE SIMPLY IN MY OPINION; TOO EASY FOR A ADMINISTRATOR TO HIRE LESS QUALIFIED PEOPLE. SO WE HAVE GOOD LOGIC BEHIND THE WEB OFFICE OF LEGISLATOR AUDITOR HAD RECOMMENDED WE CONSIDER CURE LICENSURE OF FRAMEWORK FOR TEACHER LICENSURE FRAME IN OUR STATE. AND SO THERE'S A TIER 1; TIER 2; TIER 3; TIER 4 WITH LESSER CREDENTIALS I WOULD ARGUE RELATIVE OR APPLY TO TIER 1 AND TIER 2 AND HIGHER CREDENTIALS THAN EXPECTATIONS IN THE TIER 3 AND TIER 4. THE BILL ; HOWEVER IN MY OPINION MAKES IT TOO EASY FOR SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS TO IMMEDIATELY JUMP TO TIER 1 OR TIER 2 RECRUITMENT AND PLACEMENT WITHOUT DEMONSTRATING TO THE PUBLIC THAT THEY HAVE STRIVEN TO PLACE THE MOST QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS IN THE INSTRUCTION OF YOUR CHILDREN. OF COURSE THOSE WOULD BE THOSE WHO FILL THE TIER 3 AND TIER 4 REQUIREMENTS. SO WHY NOT ASK ADMINISTRATORS TO AT THE VERY LEAST MAKE A GOOD-FAITH EFFORT TO RECRUIT WHOSE HEART QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS FIRST BEFORE THEY MOVED TO RECRUITING TIER 1 AND TIER 2. SO MEMBERS; WITH THIS AMENDMENT DOES BASICALLY IS REQUIRES THAT BE THE CASE. FILLING POSITIONS SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS MUST DEMONSTRATE AN EFFORT TO RECRUIT TIER 3 AND TIER 4 BEFORE MOVING ON TO THE GOVERNMENT OF WHICH ARE ONE AND TIER 2 INSTRUCTOR. IT'S ABOUT AND EVERY CLASSROOM IN EVERY DISTRICT ACROSS OUR STATE. THAT'S HOW WE DO HONOR AND JUSTICE TO OUR YOUNG PEOPLE. THAT'S HOW WE ENSURE THE ACADEMIC OUTCOMES THAT WE EXPECT OF THE SYSTEM. THAT'S ALL WE MAKE A STRONGER MINNESOTA. SO MEMBERS; I WOULD ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT OF THIS AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE A- 33 AMENDMENT ? DISCUSSION? REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: THANK YOU REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI. I KNOW THIS IS SOMETHING ABOUT WHICH WE'VE HAD DISCUSSIONS; BUT I THINK WE NEED TO THINK IN TERMS OF WHAT THE EXPECTATION HAS BEEN OF OUR HIRING UNITS PRIMARILY ON SCHOOL BOARDS AND HER TEACHER HIRING POOLS FOR THE LAST 20 YEARS. BECAUSE DISTRICTS HAVE OVER THE YEARS BEEN MAKING DECISIONS AND THERE IS A TEACHER SHORTAGE AND THEY MADE THAT DECISION BASED ON THEIR NEEDS. TO ALMOST INSULT THEM AT THIS POINT AND SUGGEST THAT THEY DON'T HAVE THE KNOWLEDGE AND THE SKILLS TO ENSURE THAT THEY HAVE THE BEST POSSIBLE CANDIDATE IN THE CLASSROOM SO THAT WE HAVE ANOTHER GREAT TEACHER BEFORE OUR STUDENTS; I THINK IS SOMETHING -UP HALFWAY DOWN WHICH WE DO NOT WANT TO GO TO BECAUSE WE HAVE THAT FAITH AND TRUST IN THESE ELECTED OFFICIALS CAN REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI COME I KEEP IN MINE YOUR SCHOOL DISTRICT IS HIRING A SUPERINTENDENT. I THINK IT IS EXLEY. I DON'T THINK WE WOULD PUT INTO STATURE WHAT WE EXPECT THAT SUPERINTENDENT TO BE AND I THINK THE BOARD TO WHICH I'M SURE YOU'VE HAD MANY DISCUSSIONS HAS THE KNOWLEDGE AND THE SKILLS TO MAKE THAT HIGHER; BUT ALSO TO MAKE HIRES WOULD NOW BE BECOME TIER ONE BECAUSE I TRACK ST. PAUL AND I KNOW IT'S HAD OVER THE YEARS; MANY COMMUNITY EXPERTS WERE YOU HAD MANY WAIVER TEACHERS ARE MONEY ON VARIANCES. ALTHOUGH THERE'S BEEN AN APPLICATION PROCESS IN PLACE WE ARE AT A TIME NOW WHERE WE KNOW THAT WE HAVE MORE KNOWLEDGE OF SCHOOL BOARDS HIRING PROCESS BECAUSE WE WANT TO TRUST OUR SCHOOL BOARDS AND WE WANT TO CONTINUE TO HAVE THAT FAITH WE HAVE IN THEM FOR THE LAST 20 YEARS. WHEN WE KNOW VERY WELL THE JOB VACANCIES OCCUR ON ALL WEBSITES NOW THAT THEY ARE INDEED LOOKING FOR THE BEST QUALIFIED CANDIDATES AND THAT'S CERTAINLY A LICENSED TEACHER BUT MEMBERS OF THE TEACHERS NOT ALWAYS AVAILABLE. PLEASE; VOTE; NO >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION TO THE A- THREE AMENDMENT? REPRESENTATIVE SANDSTEDE >> REPRESENTATIVE SANDSTEDE: MEMBERS I WOULD URGE A GREEN VOTE ON THE SPIRIT WILL I DO NOT WANT TO COME AND SAY DON'T TRUST YOUR SCHOOL BOARDS; SCHOOL BOARDS RESPONSIBLE FOR MANY THINGS INCLUDING MAKING THEIR BOOKS BALANCE. WHEN WE UNDERFUND PUBLIC EDUCATION AND THE SQUEEZE IS ON PUBLIC SCHOOLS CONTINUALLY THEY HAVE TO CUT AND CUT AND CUT AND IT IS CHEAPER TO HIRE COMMUNITY EXPERTS THAN IT IS TO HIRE A LICENSED EDUCATOR. WE DON'T HAVE TO PAY BENEFITS AND AS YOU VOTE ON THIS AMENDMENT; I WANT YOU TO TAKE THAT INTO CONSIDERATION SERIOUSLY AND A TEACHER WHO WALKED OUT OF THE CLASSROOM 15 WEEKS AGO AND I WITNESSED THIS IS NOT THAT SCHOOL BOARDS -THEIR SHORT AND THEY CAN'T FIND TEACHER. OFTENTIMES THERE'S AN OPTION BUT THE CHEAPER OPTION WITH A MORE AFFORDABLE OPTION IS THE COMMUNITY EXPERT. SO I URGE A GREEN VOTE ON THIS MEMBER'S >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE PRYOR >> REPRESENTATIVE PRYOR: I ALSO WANT TO AGREE AND SAY THAT WE SHOULD DO A GREEN VOTE ON THIS ONE. WHAT I WANT TO ADD TO IT IS THE MESSAGE WE ARE SENDING OUR TEACHERS IN TRAINING RIGHT NOW. SO I HAVE A NUMBER PEOPLE IN MY FAMILY MY EXTENDED FAMILY; THAT IS GONE THROUGH THE PROCESS THAT GOT THEIR UNDERGRADUATE DEGREES THEY'VE DONE THEIR CLASSROOM . YOUR OF CLASSROOM THEY MADE ALL THIS INVESTMENT INTO THEIR EDUCATION AND THEIR CAREER FOR LIFE AND WHAT THEY WANT IS THEY WANT TO GET A JOB WITH BENEFITS. WITH THIS NEW SYSTEM PUTS IN PLACE IS WEDNESDAY WANT TO GO TO THE CITY THEY WANT TO LIVE IN THEM WHEN THEY WANT TO MOVE BACK HOME AND BE WITH HER FAMILY; WHERE THEY GREW UP; THEY'RE GOING TO BE IN COMPETITION WITH PEOPLE THAT MIGHT NOT EVEN HAVE AN UNDERGRADUATE DEGREE. SO AS WE SAY; WHEN TIMES ARE TOUGH; WE ARE PUTTING THE BEST QUALIFIED PEOPLE AT A DISADVANTAGE FOR GETTING THAT NEXT JOB. THEIR FIRST JOB. SO I ALSO WOULD URGE THE GREEN VOTE ON THIS. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: FURTHER DISCUSSION? REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: MEMBERS; I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOUR SUPPORT FOR THIS AMENDMENT. IT'S NOT OFFERED AS A QUESTIONING OF ELECTED SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS WERE SUPERINTENDENTS. BY THE WAY; MEMBERS REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON CAN CORRECT ME IF WRONG COME I THINK THIS FRAMEWORK WOULD APPLY FOR PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS YOU KNOW MY SUPPORT OF CHARTER SCHOOLS BUT FRANKLY DON'T HAVE ELECTED SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS. THERE HAVE SUPERINTENDENTS. YET; THEY'RE PART OF THE EDUCATION ECOSYSTEM. SO HERE BEEN TO BRING IN PROFESSIONALS JOURNEY INTO OUR REGULAR REGULAR PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM THEY WOULD HAVE BEEN CHOSEN INITIALLY ARGUABLY OVER SOMEONE WAS FRANKLY BETTER PREPARED AND YET NOW THEY STOPPED UP EXTERIOR SEVEN STRUCTURE IN THAT SYSTEM EVER BE ABLE TO MOVE EFFECTIVELY INTO THE REGULAR PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM; BUT MEMBERS BELIEVE THE BIGGER POINT HERE IS WHY NOT? WHY NOT HAVE AS DEFINED IN THIS FRAMEWORK. REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI IS NOT DEFINING IT. IT'S A FINE IN THE FRAMEWORK. THAT'S WHY WE HAVE A TIERED SYSTEM. WHY NOT PLACE THE BEST PAIRED FOLKS IN FRONT OF YOUR CHILDREN? WHY NOT DO THAT IF YOU HAVE THE ABILITY TO DO THAT. I TOTALLY GET THAT'S NOT ALWAYS POSSIBLE. WE ARE A BIG STATE A LOT OF DIFFERENT DYNAMICS OUT THERE. REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON IS CORRECT TO USE COMMUNITY EXPERTS FOR NUMBER OF YEARS TO ANSWER THAT QUESTION BUT SIMPLY NOT POSSIBLE AND YET WE ARE STILL LOOKING FOR A LEVEL OF COMPETENCY. THE WHOLE POINT HERE IS DON'T DEFAULT TO THAT AS YOUR FIRST MOVE. FRANKLY; ALL THE AMENDMENT ASKS IS TO THE EXTENT POSSIBLE OUR EXCAVATION BE TO THE EXTENT POSSIBLE. THAT'S A RECOGNITION OF THE DIFFERENT [INAUDIBLE] AROUND THE STATE THE EXTENT POSSIBLE WE WOULD ASK A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO FILL A VACANCY WITH A TIERED THREE OR TIER 4 BEFORE SIMPLY INTO JUMPING INTO A TIER 1 OR TIER TO THOSE TEARS DO HAVE A PURPOSE. I WOULD ARGUE THAT PURPOSE SHOULD NOT BE AT THE EXPENSE OF A HIGHER PER PAIRED INDIVIDUAL. WHAT PARENT IN MINNESOTA WOULD NOT WANT THAT FOR THEIR STUDENT. SO REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; I THINK I CERTAINLY WANT TO WORK WITH YOU. THERE'S A LOT OF GOOD ISSUES IN THE BILL. BUT I THINK THIS IS A REALLY CRITICALLY IMPORTANT POINT SO MR. SPEAKER I WANT TO ASK FOR ROLL CALL ON THIS MIMIC S >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ROLL CALL HAS BEEN REQUESTED. SEEING FIFTEEN HANDS THERE WILL BE A ROLL CALL. ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION ON THE AMENDMENT SEEING NONE; THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL. >>[ROLL CALL VOTE]. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THE CLERK WILL CLOSE THE ROLL. 1359 AYE AND 70 NAY MOTION TO STOP HER VEIL AND THE MOUSE IS NOT ADOPTED >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE'S NO FURTHER MEMOS AT THE DESK AT THE CLERK WILL GIVE THE BILL THIRD READING >> CHIEF CLERK: THIRD READING HOUSE FILE 140 AS AMENDED >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THIRD READING >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON HOUSE FILE 140 AS A RESULT OF A LEGISLATIVE AUDIT DONE AND COMPLETED ABOUT A YEAR AGO. AND DELIVER TO US . SUBSEQUENT TO THEIR THIS IS HIM IN THE OLA REPORT WE FORMED A LEGISLATIVE STUDY GROUP WHICH REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI AND REPRESENTATIVE DAVNIE WERE MEMBERS. IT WAS BIPARTISAN. REPRESENTATIVE LOON. ON THIS SIDE AS REPRESENTATIVE AND CHRISTIANSEN WAS AS WELL INCLUDING YOURS TRULY AND THEN WE HAD DEMOCRATS AND SENATORS REPUBLICAN SENATORS AS WELL. WE MET FOR FIVE MONTHS. WE LISTENED TO HUNDREDS OF STAKEHOLDERS. GIVING US IDEAS ABOUT WHAT A NEW GOVERNANCE AND A NEW WAY TO LICENSE SHOULD LOOK LIKE. BECAUSE THE OLA REPORT HAD DEFINITELY SAID WE NEED ONE ENTITY PRESENTLY THE BOARD OF TEACHING MAKES DECISIONS AS THAT THE LICENSING DIVISION AT THE DEPARTMENT AND WITH SO MANY REQUESTS FOR LICENSURE FOR EITHER IN-STATE CANDIDATES HIM OUT SICK CANDIDATES; SO MUCH CONFUSION RESULTED THAT THE OLA AUDIT WILL AS WE MUST HAVE ONE ENTITY BUT WE ALSO DID MAKE A DECISION TO GIVE THE BOARD OF SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS SEPARATE ALTHOUGH THEY WILL HAVE TO CONTRACT TO HAVE THEIR LICENSEES ISSUED FOR MINISTERS. SO THOSE WERE TO OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS THAT WE WORK TOWARD ON THIS BIPARTISAN GROUP. THE OTHER WAS PATTERNING AFTER THE OLA REPORT 12 A TIERED SYSTEM WE WANT TO KEEP THIS SYSTEM. KEEP IT FOR TEARS AND INTERESTINGLY; WHEN A MET WITH THE COMMISSIONER LAST WEEK SHE WANTS TO YOUR FOR TO BE EVEN MORE ROBUST. SO I THINK IN CONFERENCE COMMITTEE WILL HAVE SOME GOOD DISCUSSIONS THERE WAS EVEN THE GOV.'S COUNCIL IS INTERESTED IN A MORE ROBUST CHEER FOR. TO THEIR QUESTIONS ABOUT TIER 1 ? SOME; BUT TIER 1; YOU HAVE TO REALIZE THAT CURRENT LAW HAS NO MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR A COMMUNITY EXPERTS. WE HAVE A BACHELORS OF ARTS DEGREE. IT WAS AN ASSOCIATES DEGREE BECAUSE WE KNOW MANY OF THOSE WHO NOW SERVE AS COMMUNITY EXPERT ACTUALLY ARE IN THE REAR AND TECHNICAL EDUCATOR FIELD MAY COME WITH ASSOCIATES DEGREE. THERE WE ARE THE PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIALS AND WE'LL ALLOW THREE REQUEST FOR THAT LICENSE. ON THE FOURTH THE BOARD OF TEACHING HAS TO PROMULGATE RULES AND IF THEY DON'T THAN THE QUEST IS ADHERED TO. SO WE HAVE TIGHTENED THAT . TIER 2 IS ACTUALLY THE ASCENT TO A FULL LICENSE. SO; THE REQUIREMENT SET DOWN IN TIER 3 WILLIE MOVES IN THE DIRECTION OF A LICENSED TEACHER. TIER 3 THEN UPSET ONE MORE AND TIER 4 THEN IS OUR HIGHEST COMMISSIONER TOLD ME SHE DIDN'T THINK ANYONE SHOULD START IN TIER 4 WINGED WE ADOPT THIS NEW PROPOSAL SO I THINK WE HAVE SOME REALLY GOOD CONFERENCE CONFERENCE COMMITTEE DISCUSSIONS CONCERNING THE FACT THAT SHE LIKES THIS TIERED SYSTEM. AS I SAID SHE HAS QUESTIONS ABOUT TIER 1 STILL; BUT TIER 4 COMMISSIONER REALLY WANTS TO ELEVATE THAT. SO MEMBERS; THIS IS BASICALLY WHAT IS FOUND IN THE BILL. WE HAVE RECKONED THAT WE ARE VERY PROUD OF BECAUSE THERE'S BEEN A TEAM EFFORT EARED MY TEAM ADMINISTRATOR --VERY INSURMOUNTABLE IN HELPING WITH THIS AS A REPRESENTATIVE LOON. REPRESENTATIVE CHRISTENSEN AS MEMBERS OF THE LEGISLATIVE STUDY GROUP. SEN. PAT OF COURSE CARRIES THIS IN THE SENATE. BUT; MEMBERS; WHAT WE WERE STRIVING FOR IS WELL; WHICH CAME OUT OF THE AUDIT REPORT WAS WE HAVE A REALLY MESSED UP SECTION OF STATUTES IN REGARD TO LICENSING TEACHERS. NO WONDER THEY CAN'T FIGURE OUT TO HOW TO GET A LICENSE IN MINNESOTA IF THEIR OUT-OF-STATE BECAUSE YOU CANNOT WE ARE STATUTES. WE HAVE ALL SORTS OF DIFFERENT LABELS WHICH IS WHY WE TOOK THE TIERED SYSTEM VERY SIMPLE. YOU CAN'T BE NAMING FIVE OR SIX DIFFERENT KINDS OF LICENSE MAYBE FOR THE FIRST TIME AND THINKING A CANDIDATE CAN FIGURE THAT OUT. SO WITH THE HELP OF OUR NEW NONPARTISAN HOUSE RESEARCHER; CHRISTINA PARA; WE WERE ABLE TO REWORK DENIES THESE SECTIONS SIMPLIFY THEM. I TOLD HIM I WANT THEM TO BE READABLE; UNDERSTANDABLE; CLEAR; TRANSPARENT AND ACCOUNTABLE. SHE FILLED ALL THOSE REQUIREMENTS AND WORKING WITH US AND WORKING WITH SENATE COUNSEL AND SO IT'S A PRODUCT THAT WERE VERY VERY PROUD OF. I HOPE ALL OF YOU WILL BE. I KNOW THERE ARE SOME STICKING POINTS IN AREAS BUT MEMBERS; TO SUGGEST WHEN I CAN HAVE THE BEST QUALIFIED CANDIDATES IN OUR CLASSROOMS IS ABSURD. BECAUSE SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE ALWAYS LOOKING FOR THE BEST CANDIDATES FOR THEIR YOUNG PEOPLE FOR THEIR CHILDREN. FOR THE HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS FOR THE CAREER AND TECHNICAL EDUCATORS. THEY'RE ALWAYS DOING THAT. I DON'T EVEN QUESTION FOR A MOMENT-I KNOW THE MSP WEBSITE IS APPLAUDING THE FACT OF THE TALKING ABOUT SCHOOL BOARDS REALLY SHOULD BE TAKING THIS SERIOUSLY THAT I RESPECT THAT AND THEY REALLY LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH US ON THIS ISSUE. MEMBERS; WITH ALL OF THIS SAID I HOPE YOU CAN SUPPORT HOUSE FILE 142 AND LOOK TO IT AS THE FUTURE OF A NEW GOVERNANCE SYSTEM IN MINNESOTA AND A NEW LICENSURE SYSTEM. I WAS SUPPORTIVE TEACHING MEMBER IN THE 90S DID IN FACT A MILD SUPPORT MEMBER ONLY ADOPTED THE COMMUNITY EXPERT THAT FORMER GOV. BURNLEY CARLSON WANTED I LOBBIED EVEN REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON-HE DOESN'T MEMBER THIS BUT I WAS IN IN HIS OFFICE LOBBIED HIM TO PASS THE COMMUNITY EXPERT BECAUSE THE HOUSE AND SENATE WERE CONTROLLED BY DEMOCRATS THAT THAT'S A WE SPENT OUR FRIDAY WE COME TO OUR MEETINGS WE CAN ON THE HILL WE WILL POLICY AND THEN WE WENT TO MEMBERS TO LOBBY THEM TO SUPPORT THIS. MEMBERS; ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT. THIS IS REALLY GOOD REFORM. ITS INNOVATIVE AND IS WHEN A STREAMLINED THE PAST FOR THOSE CANDIDATES THAT WE WANT TEACHING IN MINNESOTA. WE'VE A TEACHER SHORTAGE AS YOU KNOW. THIS IS ONE STEP WE CAN MOVE CLOSER TO FULFILLING THOSE GAPS. PLEASE; VOTE YES >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON >> REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON: MEMBERS; REPRESENTATIVE GENERIC I DON'T HAPPEN TO REMEMBER THAT; BUT YOU MUST NOT HAVE CONVINCED ME. BECAUSE I'M RISING THIS AFTERNOON TO SPEAK AGAINST THE BILL AND LET ME GIVE YOU A COUPLE OF REASONS WHY. WHEN I LOOK AT TIER 1 IN A SAID ON THIS FLOOR BEFORE BY THE WAY; LIKE REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; I'M A FORMER TEACHER RETIRED TEACHER BUT WHEN YOU ALLOW PEOPLE TO TEACH WITH LESS THAN A FOUR YEAR DEGREE; I VIEW THAT AS A STEP BACK WORD. I RAISED THIS QUESTION THE OTHER DAY AND WAYS AND MEANS WHEN THE BILL WAS BEFORE US. WHEN I WAS IN COLLEGE; I FINISHED MY UNDERGRADUATE IN THREE YEARS. I WENT YEAR-ROUND AND THE REASON I MENTION THAT WAS THAT I COMPLETED MY DEGREE FASTER THAN MOST PROBABLY WOULD TODAY. BUT I WENT TO MANKATO STATE UNIVERSITY; MINNESOTA STATE I GUESS; TODAY. MANKATO. DURING THE SUMMER; THE CLASSES THAT I WORKED WAS TAKING WERE LOADED WITH PEOPLE FROM IOWA. IOWA HAD ALLOWED-I GOT MY DEGREE IN THE EARLY 60S; IOWA HAD ALLOWED TEACHERS TO COME IN WITH TWO-YEAR DEGREES. THEN THE IOWA LEGISLATURE MADE THE DECISION THAT THEY REALLY WANTED TO PROFESSIONALIZE THE TEACHING CORE AND THEY INCREASE THE REQUIREMENT AND GAVE THEM SO MUCH TIME TO GET A FOUR YEAR DEGREE TO CONTINUE TO BE LICENSED IN THE STATE OF IOWA. I'M TALKING ABOUT HAVING A PROFESSIONAL TEACHING CORE. I THINK THAT'S AN IMPORTANT THING TO REMEMBER. THERE IS AN EXCEPTION TO THAT ONE AREA OF TWO YEARS WAS DOING WITH VOCATIONAL EDUCATORS BECAUSE T HEY WOULD TYPICALLY AND WE TALKED ABOUT THIS IN COMMITTEE THE OTHER DAY AS WELL ; THEY MAY BE LICENSED IN THEIR FIELD AS AN ATTRITION OR PLUMBER WHATEVER THE SKILL TRADE MIGHT BE BUT THEY ARE REQUIRED TO GO BACK BEFORE THEY CAN BE LICENSED AS A VOCATIONAL EDUCATOR. SO THERE IS THAT PROVISION IN TODAY'S LAWS. WARLOCK. THE OTHER THING I WANT TO ASK AND THIS IS A QUESTION REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; MY FUEL; AND SOCIAL STUDIES; AND I TAUGHT HISTORY GOVERNMENT; MAINLY GOVERNMENT STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND IF SOMEBODY COMES IN WITHOUT A DEGREE COMES IN FROM ANOTHER STATE WHAT ARE THE REQUIREMENTS THEY HAVE SOME KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MINNESOTA GOVERNMENT MINNESOTA GEOGRAPHY IF IT CAN BE TEACHING THOSE SOCIAL STUDIES CLASSES ? WOULD THEY BE EXEMPT FROM MEETING A REQUIREMENT THEY WOULD HAVE TODAY? >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON; THAT'S NOT SOMETHING WE STATE IN LAW BECAUSE THAT WILL IS IN THE PURVIEW OF THE NEW BOARD IN FACT THAT NOT MENTION THE NAME OF IT THE PROFESSIONAL EDUCATOR LICENSING AND STANDARDS BOARD WHICH WILL REPLACE THE BOARD OF TEACHING. BUT THAT IS SOMETHING THAT CAN BE PART OF THEIR WILL MAKING. THE CHANGES THAT MIGHT OCCUR BECAUSE WE'VE OUT-OF-STATE OTHERS COMING IN AND I THINK LOCAL SCHOOL BOARDS AGAIN RESPONSIBLE FOR IF THEY'RE GOING TO ASSIGN A PERSON WHO FOR EXAMPLE A SECURE ONE LICENSE AND REMEMBER; THOSE ARE FOR NEEDY SINGLE COURSES OR SINGLE SECTIONS OF A COURSE; THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE THE FELLOW COLLEAGUES AND MAKE SURE THE TEACHER HAS MINNESOTA HISTORY. BUT FOR THE MOST PART THAT WILL BE IN THE HANDS OF THIS NEW BOARD. TO DETERMINE WHAT NEEDS TO OCCUR WHEN WE HAVE THAT SPECIFICITY IN THE LICENSURE FEEL. THAT'S ALL DONE BY THE BOARD. SPEAK >> REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON. THAT MEANS THERE'LL BE NO ASSURANCE I'M USING MY FUEL THAT'S AN EXAMPLE A LSO STUDIES WOULD HAVE NO BACKGROUND IN STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT APPROVED TEACHING OTHER COURSES WITH THE GEOGRAPHY OR BE A COMPONENT THEY HAVE ANY BACKGROUND IN MINNESOTA GEOGRAPHY EITHER. SO THAT IS A CONCERN I HAVE. I USE ONE MORE EXAMPLE THAT. MY DAUGHTER GRADUATED FROM THE UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA MORRIS; SOCIAL STUDIES EDUCATION; SO SHE WAS LICENSED IN MINNESOTA SHE WENT UP AND GOT HER MASTERS DEGREE AT THE UNIVERSITY OF NORTH DAKOTA AND SHE MARRIED A FELLOW [INAUDIBLE] WAS A PILOT. SO WE GOT A JOB FLYING OUT OF THE GREATER CINCINNATI AIRPORT; CHOOSING KENTUCKY. SO WHEN MY DAUGHTER WENT DOWN THERE EVEN THOUGH SHE WAS LICENSED INTO STATES; SHE WAS REQUIRED BUT SHE HAD TO TAKE A COURSE IN THE HISTORY OF KENTUCKY IF I RECALL ANOTHER COURSE IN THE GOVERNMENT OF KENTUCKY. I THINK SHE HAD A VERY SHORT TIME PER NOT TO DO THAT. THERE WAS MAYBE LIKE A YEAR. A. B. SHE JUST DID IT IN A YEAR BUT THERE WERE SOME TIME CONSTRAINTS. I REMEMBER THAT SO SHE WOULD BE PREPARED TO TEACH THE STUDENTS IN HER CLASSES ABOUT THE HISTORY OF KENTUCKY AND THE GEOGRAPHY AND SO ON. SO I THINK THOSE ARE IMPORTANT ELEMENTS. I'M JUST USING THAT AS AN EXAMPLE W HERE MOST EXPERIENCE AS A SOCIAL STUDIES GOVERNMENT ECONOMICS TEACHER THROUGH THE YEARS THAT WE DON'T WANT TO HAVE A SITUATION WHERE WE HAVE A TEACHER COR PS THAT IS LESS PROFESSIONAL THAN THE ONE WE HAVE TODAY. SO I WOULD URGE A NO; BUT WORKS. THANK YOU. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE TURNER: REPRESENTATIVE CARLSON; IF YOU LOOK AT ALL OUR TEARS; WE HAVE AS ALWAYS ONE OF THE OPTIONS AND THAT'S TO TAKE UPPER-LEVEL DIVISION CREDITS IN RELEVANT CONTENT AREA AND IF A SCHOOL BOARD SEES THAT A CANDIDATE HAS A LACK OF KNOWLEDGE IN AN AREA THEY ARE THINKING OF HIRING THAT PERSON THINK THEY WILL MAKE THEIR ARMS ON THAT CANDIDATE THAT HE OR SHE IS GOING TO HAVE TO TAKE SOME COURSES IN THAT CONTENT AREA THAT; IN FACT IS ONE OF THE MANY ITEMS THAT OFFERED FOR BOTH TIER 1 AND TIER 2 SO I THINK WE CAN SOLVE THIS PROBLEM EASIER THAN YOU MAKE IT SOUND. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: FURTHER DISCUSSION ON HOUSE FILE 140? REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: I'M WONDERING IF REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON WITH YIELD? MEMBERS; BEFORE I DO ASK REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON THIS; I DO WANT TO ENCOURAGE US AS WE GET UP AND DEBATE THAT WE NOT INVOKE THE NAME OF OUR STAFF HERE. IT'S GOT TO PUT THEM IN AN AWFULLY UNCOMFORTABLE POSITION WE ARE THE ONES MAKING THESE DECISIONS AND REDIRECT THEM WHAT TO DO. WE HAVE EXCELLENT STAFF INCLUDING THE ONES BEEN NAMED EARLIER HERE TODAY BUT I DON'T THINK IT REALLY LENDS ITSELF TOWARD DEBATE TO STATE WHETHER GOOD OR BAD OR WHAT ARE RESPECTIVE POSITIONS ARE. MEMBERS; I DON'T THINK IT'S ABSURD TO HAVE A STRONG EXPECTATION THAT AS POLICYMAKERS FEAR THAT WE ARE EXPECTING THE HIGHEST CREDENTIALS OF EVERYONE GIVEN THE PRIVILEGE TO BE ABLE TO INSTRUCT OUR STUDENTS AND I THINK WHAT WE HAVE IN COMMON REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; WE BOTH WANT SOME REALLY GOOD STRONG PROFESSIONAL SKILLS APPLIED IN THE CLASSROOM. YOUR BILL STARTS FROM LEGISLATIVE AUDITOR'S FRAMEWORK THAT PROVIDES ME WITH A LOT OF COMFORT SPIRIT IT SHOULD FOR A LOT OF US HERE. AS WELL. AS I LOOK BACK THE YEARS WE'VE DONE LEGISLATING HERE THAT I'VE BEEN INVOLVED IN THE LEGISLATIVE AUDITOR OFTEN PROVIDES US WITH A POWERFUL OBJECTIVE IN WHICH TO SHAPE OUR BILLS COULD THAT'S WHY THINK THERE'S A NUMBER OF REALLY GOOD PROVISIONS IN THIS BILL THAT I WOULD HOPE WE ARE ABLE TO GO FORWARD. I DO CONTINUE TO HAVE MY CONCERNS. I'M WONDERING REPRESENTATIVE CHART JUST A FEW QUESTIONS. ONE OF THE THINGS THAT'S REQUIRED FOR TIER 1 AND TIER 2 LICENSE WHICH ARE ONE-YEAR LICENSES THAT CAN BE RENEWED IS A MENU EITHER OR MENU ON THE PART OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE MAKING THE DECISION. SO FOR INSTANCE FOR TIER 1; THERE'S A BA OR AND 80 LOSS; MEETING SOME CONDITIONS OFF THE LIST T HAT INCLUDES THINGS LIKE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE. I'M WONDERING REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; IF YOU COULD TELL US WHAT YOUR DEFINITI ON IS BECAUSE I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO HAVE THIS ON THE RECORD HERE. I'M NOT SURE I KNOW WHAT A SUFFICIENT PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIAL IS . IT SEEMS TO ME THAT IS LANGUAGE THAT REALLY OUGHT TO BE MUCH TIGHTER THAN THAT. SOME WONDERING IF YOU CAN TELL US IN YOUR MIND WHAT SUFFICIENT PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIAL WOULD BE THAT WOULD BE THAT OPTION TO EITHER A BACHELOR'S DEGREE OR TWO YEAR DEGREE EQUIPPED >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: I DO WANT TO THANK YOU AND REPRESENTATIVE DAVNIE AND FORMER REPRESENTATIVE-FOR YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE STUDY GROUP AND TO OUR MEETINGS SINCE. I'VE REALLY APPRECIATED THAT. IN REGARD TO THE PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIAL THE DEPARTMENT HAS LAID OUT A NUMBER OF-I SHOULD NOT SAY LATE OUT; HAS LISTED A NUMBER PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIALS THAT ARE RECOGNIZED IN MINNESOTA SO IT WOULD BE AMONG THAT GROUP IS LISTED FROM THE DEPARTMENT YOU CAN FIND THAT ON THE WEBSITE. IT'S A RECENT PUBLICATION BUT THE COMMISSIONER HAS ISSUED THAT. SO THOSE PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIALS WOULD FALL UNDER THAT LISTENING. I >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: I THINK OF THIS BILL WAS 40 MAY BE WISE FOR US TO BE ABLE TO CAPTURE THOSE IN STATE STATUTE AS OPPOSED TO JUST INTEGRATE REFERENCING WHAT THOSE MIGHT BE. SO THERE IS CLEAR DIRECTION BOTH TO THOSE MAKING HIRES AS WELL AS TO THE PUBLIC. WHAT WE MEAN BY SUFFICIENT PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT CREDENTIAL. REPRESENTATIVE TURNER; ONE OF THE REQUIREMENTS THAT POPS UP CONSISTENTLY THROUGH THE FOUR TIERS IS THE OPTION OF COMPLETING THE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE. SO ONE; WANT TO A COLLEGE THAT THE BILL BEFORE US CALLS THAT OUT . HOWEVER; HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE IS NOT A HARD AND FAST REQUIREMENT IN TERMS OF THE TIER 1 AND TIER 2 CREDENTIALING. AS I MENTIONED EARLIER; I THINK I DID; THOSE TEARS CAN RESULT IN THE INTERPLAY BETWEEN THOSE TWO HAVING AN INDIVIDUAL IN OUR CLASSROOMS; PROFESSIONAL INDIVIDUAL IN HER CLASSROOM FOR UP TO EIGHT YEARS. MEMBERS; IT SEEMS TO ME THAT ONE YEAR FRANKLY IS TOO LONG FOR A PROFESSIONAL TO BE IN OUR CLASSROOM WITHOUT THE REQUIREMENT OF HAVING ACQUIRED THE SKILLS AND KNOWLEDGE THAT ARE PRESENTED IN HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE EIGHT YEARS IS CERTAINLY WAY TOO LONG AND MEMBERS JUST SO WE ARE CLEAR ABOUT WHAT THAT MEANS; THE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE AS YOU KNOW; WE CURRENTLY HAVE ABOUT A THIRD; 30% OF OUR STUDENT POPULATION [INAUDIBLE] YOUNG PEOPLE A THIRD OF THOSE COME FROM TWHIRL ARE STUDENTS OF COLOR AMERICAN INDIAN STUDENTS. THAT MEANS THAT THEY'RE PART OF COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE CULTURAL DIFFERENCES THAT ARE DISTINCT FROM WHAT OUR STATE HAS BEEN ACCUSTOMED TO FOR WELL OVER 100 YEARS. THAT GROWTH HAS HAPPENS THE TACTILE HE FAST 20 YEARS AGO IT WAS LESS THAN ONE IN 10 OF OUR STUDENT TO HAVE THIS FAST GROWING DIVERSITY OF STUDENTS AND THE BODY OF EVIDENCE OUT THERE MEMBERS; GOOD RESEARCH EMPIRICAL STUDIES HAVE CONSISTENTLY ARE CONSISTENTLY COMING IN WITH THE IMPORTANCE O F OUR PROFESSIONAL TEACHERS TO BE ABLE TO HAVE THE EFFECT OF SKILLS TO WORK WITH A DIVERSITY RACIAL AND CULTURAL DIVERSITY OF THE STUDENT BODY. I THINK THE EVIDENCE IS QUITE OVERWHELMING. IT IS ACTUALLY TIED TO EVEN BIGGER BODY OF EVIDENCE THAT TALKS ABOUT WHAT A FUNDAMENTAL SKILL IT IS FOR A TEACHING PROFESSIONAL TO BE ABLE TO HAVE THE SKILLS TO BUILD POWERFUL RELATIONSHIPS WITH THEIR STUDENTS. SO; NONETHELESS; UNDER THE SCHEME UNDER THIS FRAMEWORK BEFORE YOU THAT HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE IS NOT A REQUIRED EXPOSURE FOR PROFESSIONALS WITHIN A LICENSE UNDER THIS TIER LICENSING SYSTEM . I THINK IT SHOULD BE. I'M WONDERING IF REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON PERHAPS SHARE A LITTLE BIT AND WE CAN CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION BEYOND THIS IF THE BILL GOES FOR. A LITTLE BIT ABOUT HER THINKING 02 TO THE IMPORTANCE OF THE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE A S A REQUIREMENT FOR ALL OF THE TEARS IN THIS LICENSING SYSTEM? >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: THE HUMANS RELATIONS COURSE IS IN THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL. IT'S NOT IN STATUTE; BUT WE REFERENCED EIGHT. HOUSE FILE 140. IF A CANDIDATE CHOOSES TO TAKE THE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE OUR TEAM BELIEVES THEY ARE CONSIDERING A PATHWAY TO LICENSURE. NO QUESTIONS ADDED BECAUSE IT'S IN RULE A ND 20 REQUIRED THROUGH RULE AND THAT STATUTE. THE FACT THAT WE'VE CULTURAL COMPETENCY IN LAW I THINK TODAY; MEMBERS; MAYBE EVEN A STRONGER STATEMENT ABOUT WHAT WE EXPECT OF OUR TEACHERS TO UNDERSTAND AND KNOW ABOUT THE DIFFERENT STUDENTS IN THEIR CLASSROOMS. SO THE HUMAN RELATIONS COURSE IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE A THREE CREDIT COURSE TO STUDY A VARIETY OF ETHNICITIES ; TO HEAR FROM SPECIAL SPEAKERS TO UNDERSTAND SOME OF THE INTRICACIES OF THE CULTURE BUT I THINK THE FACT THE WE HAVE CULTURE COMPETENCY DEFINED IN STATE STATUTE IS JU ST AS IMPORTANT IF NOT MORE IMPORTANT FOR TEACHER CANDIDATES AND AS I SAID AT THE OUTSET OF THIS COMMENT IF A CANDIDATE CHOOSES TO TAKE YOU IN HUMAN RELATIONS AND TIER 1; I THINK THEY'RE CHECKING OUT TO SEE WHAT DO WE LIKE TO BECOME A LICENSED TEACHER THROUGH THE PATHWAYS THAT WE PROVIDE THE SAME IS TRUE IN TIER 2 IN TEARS AND THREE AND FOUR; IT IS OF COURSE A REQUIREMENT THAT SECOND RULE. >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI: REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; AND MEMBERS MY THINK THIS IS AN AREA THAT NEEDS SOME WORK. FRANKLY; IT SO IMPORTANT AT SOME POINT IT'S BEYOND OUR SCOPE AT THIS POINT THAT SOME POINT WE MAY ACTUALLY WANT TO BUILD THAT INTO STATUTE. HOWEVER; I WOULD POINT OUT THAT THE TIER 1 AND TIER 2 LICENSURE DOES NOT DO A NOD TO THE RULE SET UP BY THE BOARD OF TEACHING. SO THERE'S GOING TO BE LOCAL DISCRETION. I WOULD CERTAINLY HOPE THAT ALL OUR LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE GOING TO BE ASKING FOR THAT EVENTUAL FOR THAT EXPOSURE FOR THAT SCHOOL SET FROM FOLKS THEY WANT TO PLACE.-THANK YOU MR. SPEAKER-FOLKS THEY WANT TO PLACE AND TIER 1 AND TIER 2 BUT MEMBERS AGAIN I THINK IT'S A IMPORTANT AND WE CLEARLY ARE PRESCRIBING RIGHT NOW IN THIS BILL WHAT THE PARAMETERS ARE ALL THESE TEARS. IT SO IMPORTANT I THINK WE OUGHT TO MAKE TH AT A REQUIREMENT OF ALL THE TEARS. SO I THINK IS WORK THAT NEEDS TO BE DONE HERE. REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; AS YOU KNOW IN COMMITTEE; WE HAD TESTIMONY FROM DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ABOUT THE TIMELINE OF IMPLEMENTING CHANGE. I THINK ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I CERTAINLY HAVE BEEN IN YOUR BOAT WHEN YOU'RE IMPLEMENTING A VIEW POLICY FRAMEWORK FOR THE BIG QUESTIONS IS HOW QUICKLY; HOW INTENSELY TO MOVE FORWARD AND SOMETIMES IT CAN BE QUITE REFRESHING TO WE ONE MOVE FORWARD AS LEGISLATORS VERY QUICKLY. BUT WERE TALKED ABOUT SYSTEMS; PEOPLE IN SYSTEMS WITHOUT SKILLS; TO OUR KNOWLEDGE AND WE ARE TALKING ABOUT PROCESSES THE WHOLE LICENSING PROCESS ISN'T GOING TO COME TO AN END. AND WAIT FOR THIS NEW SPECIAL BOARD TO FIGURE EVERYTHING OUT. THIS COULD BE THIS PROCESS THAT'S GOING ON RIGHT NOW AND TEACHERS DESERVE CERTAINTY AROUND THE DECISION MAKINGS THE PARENTS AND STUDENTS DESERVE THAT SOME WONDERING REPRESENTATIVE TURNER; IF YOU COULD SHARE WITH THE BODY ANY CONCERNS YOU MIGHT HAVE GO TO TO THE PACE OF WHICH YOU'RE EXPECTING THESE CHANGES TO BE IMPLEMENTED AND THEN AS LONG AS I'M UP I'LL ASK YOU MY SECOND QUESTION WHICH HAS TO DO WITH THE IDEA THAT NONE OF THE CURRENT BOARD MEMBERS CAN BE REAPPOINTED. MEMBERS; IT'S NOT GENERALLY A WISE THING TO TOTALLY MOVE ANYONE WHO HAS ANY EXPERIENCE OUT OF THE BODY LIKE THIS. EVEN IF YOU'RE NOT GOING TO RENEW THEM THINK IT'S CRITICALLY IMPORTANT THAT YOU HAVE EXPERIENCE SITTING AT THE TABLE. THE BOARD I THINK HAS BEEN VERY FORTHRIGHT IN WORKING WITH THE CHAIRMAN WITH THE REST OF US IN TERMS OF WANTING CHANGE. IT SEEMS TO ME THAT NOT RENEWING ANY OF THESE NEW BOARD MEMBERS RIGHT NOW; AND THEN EXPECTING AN IMMEDIATE CHANGE IS PROBABLY SETTING US UP FOR QUITE A MESS AND WHOLE LICENSING PROSPECTS AM WONDERING REPRESENTATIVE TURNER; YOU COULD SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS ON WHAT YOU FEEL THE WE CAN MOVE THIS QUICKLY TH E WHOLE BRAND-NEW CAST OF CHARACTERS? >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: I'M CONCERNED ABOUT THAT; BUT I THINK THOSE ARE DISCUSSIONS WE HAVE IN CONFERENCE COMMITTEE. THE SENATE HAS A FEW DIFFERENT AI DS IN PLACE AND THAT'S A ROBUST DISCUSSION THAT NEEDS TO OCCUR AMONG CONFEREES AND THEN TO HEAR INPUT IT IS A REALLY HAVE NOT RECEIVED ANY INPUT ON THE TIMELINE AT ALL FROM ANYONE ON THE OUTSIDE. NO ONE HAS RAISED THE CONCERN. THE COMMISSIONER AND I DID DISCUSS IT LAST WEEK. SHE IS A LITTLE CONCERNED. I WOULD NOT SAY SHE'S CONCERNED ABOUT THE BOARD BEING DISMISSED BECAUSE SHE IS SHE TOTALLY WET WITH LOT OF DYSFUNCTIONAL BOARDS SO I GUESS SHE CONSIDERED THIS ONE DYSFUNCTIONAL ALREADY. NEVERTHELESS; WE HAVE COMING FROM THE DEPARTMENT; AND SHE'S VERY PROUD OF THOSE WHO SERVE IN OUR LICENSING DIVISION ALTHOUGH EELS CONCERT WILL NOT CONTINUE ON BECAUSE HE IS GOING TO BECOME A SUPERINTENDENT IN A RURAL DISTRICT. BUT OTHER STUFF THAT WILL PROCEED WITH GREAT KNOWLEDGE AND I KNOW SHE'S VERY PROUD OF THAT. AS FAR AS A NEW BOARD CANNOT REMEMBER THE PRESENT BOARD WAS SUED AND ALSO FOUND IN CONTEMPT OF COURT BECAUSE THEY DID NOT FOLLOW THROUGH WHAT WAS SPECIFIED IN THE STATUTE OR BECAUSE THEY VIOLATED T HEIR OWN RULES OUTLAWS. SO; YES WE WILL DISCUSS IN CONFERENCE COMMITTEE THE TIMELINES . WILL I BE CONCERNED ABOUT A CREATION OF A BRAND-NEW BOARD AMONG NO BECAUSE AS I SAID TO THE COMMISSIONER ALSO TO THE GOV. STAFF; THE GOVERNOR HAS THE OPPORTUNITY TO POINT PAST MEMBERS WHO HAVE BEEN JUST SELLER ON THE BOARD OF TEACHING. WE TREATED THE BOARD MUCH IN THE SAME WAY THAT THE BOARD WAS RESPECTED IN THE DAYS WHEN I SERVED ON IT. AS A PROFESSIONAL BOARD THAT CONCENTRATES ON TEACHER PREPARATION REPAIRS LICENSES AND DOESN'T OBSCURE THEIR SCHEDULE WITH UNNECESSARY PAPERWORK. SO I THINK THAT WE WILL BE ABLE TO LOOK TO THE GOV. OFFERS SOME NAMES TO HIS POINTING OFFICIAL AND GET OFF TO A REALLY GOOD START AND DO A CLEAN SWEEP BECAUSE WE ARE CREATING A NEW GOVERNANCE MODEL AND MEMBERS IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT THAT WE START WITH A CLEAN SLATE. >> REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI : I WILL CLOSE WITH THIS. I DO HAVE AND I THINK THAT'S FAIR REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON. I APPRECIATE YOU SHARING THAT ON THE RECORD. CONTINUING TO HAVE A CONVERSATION IF THIS BILL GOES FOR. IN COMMENTS COMMITTEE VOTED TO THE PRAGMATIC ISSUE BEEN ABLE TO IMPLEMENT A NEW BOARD WITH A NEW FRAMEWORK A NEW RESPONSIBILITIES AND BEING ABLE TO DO THAT WITH FOLKS THAT ARE EXPERIENCED . SO I SUSPECT THAT WILL BE A STRONG PART OF THAT CONFERENCE COMMITTEE AND AM ENCOURAGED THAT YOU'RE ACKNOWLEDGING TO HAVE THAT CONVERSATION. MEMBERS COME I DON'T THINK IT'S IMPORTANT- I DON'T THINK IT'S NECESSARY FOR US TO [INAUDIBLE] THE CURRENT RELATIVE BOARD OF TEACHING . FOLKS WHOSE LOSSES ALL THE TIME. SOMETIMES YOU MEET SOME ROUTE REALLY BAD THINGS. SOMETIMES IT DOES. THE IMPORTANT THING IS WE HAVE COMMITTED INDIVIDUALS ON THE BOARD THAT WORKED MIGHTILY HARD IN THE FACE OF COSTLY SHIFTING POLICY THAT COMES OUT OF THIS LEGISLATURE AND A WHOLE LOT OF FROM OUTSIDE GROUPS. SOME MEMBERS WHO I WOULD SUBMIT WE DO NOT HAVE THE BEST INTERESTS OF HIGHLY PROFESSIONAL CLASS OF TEACHERS IN OUR STATE. SOME WHO DO BUT SOME WHO HAVE FRANKLY OTHER POLITICAL CONSIDERATIONS GOES TO ARE ORGANIZED TEACHERS IN OUR STATE. MEMBERS TH E ONLY OTHER THING I WANT TO SHARE QUICKLY-DON'T ASK QUESTIONS BECAUSE GONE ON LONG ENOUGH HERE. IT HAS TO DO WITH TEACHER EVALUATION RESULTS TO THE CURE FOR LICENSURE CATEGORY AN D REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON AND I WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE YOUR OPENNESS IN MOVING THAT CHANGING THAT A BIT. I DO WANT TO POINT OUT; MEMBERS THIS RAISES OTHER ISSUES WE'VE STRUGGLED AROUND HERE WITH A LACK OF UNIFORMITY IN OUR STATE IN IMPLEMENTING TEACHER EVALUATION SYSTEM. ACROSS THE BOARD IN OUR STATE. SOME OF THAT WE'VE ALLOWED BECAUSE OF FLEXIBILITY BUT FRANKLY; BUT IT DOES MEAN PARTICULARLY WHEN WE ARE NOT FUNDING EFFECTIVELY THE ABILITY FOR SCHOOLS TO BE ABLE TO IMPLEMENT STRONG EVALUATION SYSTEMS. SOME SCHOOL DISTRICTS READ WE DO AND SOME WE DON'T. WHAT THAT DOES; MEMBERS IT CREATES AN NON-UNIFORM ENVIRONMENTS OUT THERE SO THAT YOU CAN BE EVALUATED DISCIPLINE TOTALLY THAT YOU MIGHT BE VALUATOR DISTRICT TO AND YET WERE GOING TO TIE YOUR ONGOING CREDENTIALING TO THAT INCONSISTENCY IN EVALUATION. SO I THINK IT'S ON THE EYES LOOKED AT. ENCOURAGE THE CHAIRMAN HAS LOOKED AT THAT AND MADE SOME MOVEMENT IN THIS REGARD. MEMBERS WITH THAT I WILL STOP. I INTEND TO SUPPORT THE BILL HERE TODAY. I DO HAVE CONCERNS. I'M SURE AND I WILL CONTINUE TO DO THAT BUT I WOULD CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND IF; MEMBERS; I FEEL THE BILL IS NOT READY FOR PRIME TIME. THAT PERHAPS SOME OF THE ISSUES RELATIVE TO WHO WE ARE PLACING IN HER CLASSROOM ; IN FRONT OF OUR KIDS OVERLONG PERIOD OF TIME M AY NOT YET BE THE BEST WAY TO DO THAT. SO I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU TO AS YOU DO WITH ALL OTHER BILLS; TO APPROACH IT WITH INDEPENDENT MIND AND UNDERSTAND THAT IF THIS BILL GOES FORWARD IS A GOOD CHANCE TO COME BACK AND HOPEFULLY THERE'S A GOOD CHANCE OF A COMEBACK A BETTER AND STRONGER BILL. THANK YOU MEMBERS; AND THANK YOU REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DAVNIE >> REPRESENTATIVE DAVNIE: MEMBERS; CHAIRMAN ERICKSON; THANK YOU FOR THE WORK THAT YOU DID ON THE TASK FORCE THAT WE WERE BOTH ON I ALSO HAVE THE PRIVILEGE TO SERVE ON THE CTE TASK FORCE. LOOK AT THE VERY REAL CONCERNS AND CHALLENGES ACROSS THE STATE INADEQUATELY STAFFING OUR CAREER AND TECHNICAL EDUCATION OFFERINGS. THIS IS AN AREA; MEMBERS; WERE MINNESOTA HAS BACKED OFF OVER THE YEARS. I WOULD SUGGEST TO THE DETRIMENT OF BOTH OUR STUDENTS AND TO OUR EMPLOYERS BECAUSE THERE'S A LOT OF STUDENTS OUT THERE WHO WANT TO DO WORK WITH OUR BARE HANDS; WE DON'T WANT TO HEAR ABOUT COLL EGE BEING NECESSARILY A FOUR YEAR EXPERIENCE OR HIGH SCHOOL. THEY WANT TO GET OUT WHEN TOGETHER DIRTY TO DO REAL WORK AND HER EMPLOYER'S ARE DESPERATE FOR FOLKS WITH THOSE SKILLS. I APPRECIATE REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON; YOU ARE INCLUDING ELEMENTS FROM THAT GROUPS REPORTS. I THINK IT'S A CHALLENGE FOR SOME OF US TO THINK OF SOMEONE ENTERING THE TEACHING PROFESSION WITHOUT A BA DEGREE BUT WITH THAT PROFESSIONAL CREDENTIAL; IN THAT AREA OF CT E EXPERTISE; I DO SHARE REPRESENTATIVE MARIANI IS CONCERNED THAT DEFINITION . I DO ALSO THINK YOU NEED TO BE NARROWED DOWN TO THE CT AREA AND I DON'T THINK THAT IS CLEAR IN THE BILL. I'M ALSO CONCERNED THA T WE TALKED ABOUT NEEDING TEACHERS WITH THE HIGHEST CREDENTIALS. THE BILL DOESN'T ALWAYS GET US THERE HOWEVER. IN THE BILLS THERE IS AN ALLOWANCE FOR SOMEONE TO TEACH WITH NEVER HAVING DONE STUDENT TEACHING ; WITH NEVER HAVING STOOD IN THE FRONT OF THE CLASSROOM ; NEVER AND HAVE IT TO DEVOTE THE LESSON PLAN NEVER HAD TO WORK WITH A GROUP OF STUDENTS; NEVER HAVING HAD TO LEARN HOW TO MANAGE CLASSROOM FOR EDUCATION. AS A PARENT; I WOULDN'T WANT THAT PERSON TEACHING MY CHILD. THERE SIMPLY NOT PREPARED AS A TEACHER; I WOULD NOT WANT THE PERSON IN THE CLASSROOM NEXT TO ME. SO I WOULD HOPE THAT WHEN THIS BILL COMES BACK ASSUMING THAT'S WHAT HAPPENS; THAT GLARING CONCERN AND GLARING HOLE IN THE BILL GETS FIXED. ALSO THE CONCERN THAT THIS LEGISLATION MAY POSE A REAL THREAT TO LICENSING AND RETAINING TEACHERS IN IMMERSION PROGRAMS. MANY DISTRICTS ACROSS THE STATE TO PROVIDE SPANISH VERSION; CHINESE IMMERSION; JAPANESE-I DON'T KNOW ABOUT JAPANESE BUT CHINESE IMMERSION IS VERY POPULAR. THERE'S EVEN SOME-- PROGRAMS. I THINK THERE'S ALWAYS IN THIS BUILD I WOULD THREATEN THE ABILITY TO CREATE AND RETAIN TEACHERS) THE IMPORTANCE OF PROGRAMS AT THE POPULAR PROGRAMS THAT PREPARE OUR CHILDREN FOR THE 21ST CENTURY AND THREATENING THEM AS THIS BILL DOES I QUESTION. SO MEMBERS; THERE ARE SOME GOOD STRONG PROVISIONS IN THIS BILL. THERE'S ALSO SOME AREAS A REAL CONCERN THAT I HOPE WHEN THIS BILL COMES BACK IN A COMEBACK AND VERY DIFFERENTLY. THANK YOU. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HORTMAN >> REPRESENTATIVE HORTMAN: MEMBERS; IN MINNESOTA WE KNOW WE DON'T HAVE ENOUGH TEACHERS WE ABSOLUTELY HAVE TO WORK TO SOLVE THE PROBLEM. BUT REPUBLICANS ARE PROPOSING THIS BILL COULD ACTUALLY MAKE A TEACHER SHORTAGE WORSE. PART OF THE CAUSE OF THE TEACHER SHORTAGE IS A RELENTLESS REPUBLICAN ATTACK ON PUBLIC EDUCATION IN OUR TEACHERS. JUST A FEW DAYS AGO OFF THIS HOUSE FLOOR REPUBLICANS VOTED TO UNDERFUND OUR SCHOOLS AGAIN WHICH COULD CAUSE TEACHER LAYOFFS ACROSS THE STATE. REPUBLICANS USE TEACHERS IN OUR SCHOOLS TO SCORE POLITICAL POINTS YEAR AFTER YEAR . THIS YEAR REPUBLICANS ARE PRIORITIZING PRIVATE SCHOOLS AND CUTTING PRE-K ACROSS THE STATE. THEY PROPOSE BARE-BONES FUNDING AND THEN NO DOUBT WILL TOUT THE FACT THAT AFTER GOV. DAYTON FINALLY GETS HIS WEIGHT SCHOOLS WILL GET A SIMPLE INFLATIONARY INCREASE. THIS IS NOT GOOD ENOUGH. IT'S NOT GOOD ENOUGH FOR OUR TEACHERS COULD NOT GOOD ENOUGH FOR OUR CHILDREN. IF WE WANT TO ATTRACT MORE TEACHERS; AND ENCOURAGE YOUNG MINNESOTANS TO ENTER THE PROFESSION; REPUBLICANS NEED TO QUIT ATTACKING PUBLIC SCHOOLS QUICK CUTTING PUBLIC SCHOOL FUNDING AND QUIT BELITTLING THE TEACHING PROFESSION. MINNESOTANS VALUE EDUCATION AND EXPECT QUALIFIED TEACHERS IN MINNESOTA CLASSROOMS. MEMBERS; PLEASE VOTE NO. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: FURTHER DISCUSSION ON HOUSE FILE 140? REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON >> REPRESENTATIVE ERICKSON: THESE SHOULD BE THE CLOSING COMMENTS FOR HOUSE FILE 140. MEMBERS WE BEEN AT THIS FOR BETWEEN 8-9 MONTHS. I DO THINK IT'S VERY OFTEN IN THIS LEGISLATURE THAT WE HAVE SOMETHING THAT'S BEEN VETTED SO MANY TIMES THAT THE FIFTH ENGROSSMENT HERE ON THE FLOOR AND HAS HAD INPUT FROM HUNDREDS OF STAKEHOLDERS. SCHOOL BOARDS ARE LOOKING FOR FLEXIBILITY. I RESPECT HIM. THE GOVERNANCE MODEL HERE IS TEACHER LED TO WE HONOR TEACHERS AND THEY WILL LEAVE THE GOVERNANCE . I VISITED WITH SOME COLLEGE STUDENTS TWO WEEKENDS AGO WHEN HEARD ABOUT THIS BILL AND WAS SO EXCITED AS NEW CANDIDATES ENTERING THE FIELD THAT THERE WAS GOING TO BE A PROMISE FOR THEM FOR THE FUTURE SIMPLIFIED CLEARER UNDERSTANDABLE SYSTEM. THEY WERE SO EXCITED TO READ TO THE BILL AND FIND OUT THEY COULD UNDERSTAND IT AND SO FOR THAT; I THINK WE COULD LOOK FORWARD TO CANDIDATES COMING INTO A PROFESSION; MY PROFESSION; AND BEING EXCITED ABOUT MOVING FORWARD BECAUSE NOW THEY HAVE A STATUTORY SECTIONS THAT ACTUALLY ARE UNDERSTANDABLE THAT ARE CLEAR; TRANSPARENT AND ACCOUNTABILITY. NUMBERS; IN REGARD TO THE TEACHER EVALUATION; THE TEACHER VALUATIONS ACROSS THE STATE HAVE IMPROVEMENT PLANS. WITH THIS SAYS FOR CHEER FOR; THEY ARE NOT IN IMPROVEMENT PLAN. WE HONOR THE DIFFERENCES AMONG TEACHER EVALUATION PLANS. WE SPECIFICALLY THE GOV. AND ME AN D THE FORMER SEN. JAN OLSEN; SPECIFICALLY VISITED ABOUT MAKING SURE THAT THESE COULD BE INDIVIDUALLY DESIGNED. MEMBERS; THIS IS A REALLY GOOD REFORM AND I HOPE YOU CAN ALL VOTE YES. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: PC NO FURTHER DISCUSSION THE CLERK WILL TAKE THE ROLL ON THE BILL. >>[ROLL CALL VOTE]. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THE CLERK WILL CLOSE THE ROLL. THERE BEING 76 AYE AND 50 THAT TRIP TO THE BILLS PASS AS AMENDED AND TITLE AGREED TO >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: NEXT BILL ON THE CALENDAR FOR THE DAY IS SENATE FILE 803. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE CLERK WILL REPORT THEBI LL. >> CHIEF CLERK: SENATE FILE 803 NUMBER TWO ON THE CALENDAR FOR THE DAY AND ACT RELATING TO PUBLIC SAFETYUNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: I RECOGNIZE REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH TO INTRODUCE YOUR BIL L >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH; THIS THE PUBLIC SAFETY OMNIBUS BILL SENATE FILE IT 03 BEFORE I BEGIN I LIKE TO THANK THE STAFF JEFFREY DIEBEL AND BEN JOHNSON OUR HOUSE RESEARCH JOHN WALSH THIS GO ANALYST MIKE-COMMITTEE ADMINISTRATOR; JASON-COMMITTEE LEGISLATIVE ASSIGNMENT DAVID [INAUDIBLE] AND LAURA DFL RESEARCH. WITH THEIR HELP IT GET TO ME TO GET 134 VOTES MINOR SENDING [INAUDIBLE]. NOW; TO EXPLAIN THE BILL; I WILL DO A HIGH ALTITUDE FLYOVER AND THEN IF YOU WANT ME TO DIG DEEPER I WILL. I'LL RUN THROUGH THE INCREASE SPENDING HIGHLIGHTS AND SOME OF THE POLICY THEN ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. HE SPENDING HIGHLIGHTS ARE $52 MILLION ACROSS JUDICIAL BRANCH IN AGENCY FOR 1%; TATIAN INCREASE IN INCREASED HEALTH INSURANCE COST. ONE POINT 7;000;004 JUDGE IN IS A TWO OR 1000 YEARS FOR TREATMENT HURT. 20;000 IS FOR NEW CASE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR THE TAX COURT. 4.1 MILLION TO BE PLACED ON PREDATORY OFFENDING REGISTRY AT BCA. 3.2 MILLION FOR UPGRADED TECHNOLOGY SYSTEM TO ALLOW POLICE OFFICERS TO ACCESS AND SERVE AS TRAINING ORDERS FROM 2 MILLION TO REPLENISH THE DISASTER ASSISTANCE ACCOUNT. BYRON THOUSAND OAKS AND GRANTS COMBAT TERRORISM RECRUITMENT FOR AND 79;000 FOR ADDITIONAL SEX TRAFFICKING PREVENTION GRANTS. TWO AND 1000 FOR DE-ESCALATION TRAINING PUBLIC SAFETY PERSONNEL. 150 GRAND FOR A PRIVATE SECURITY GRANTS. 15 MILLION FOR ADDITIONAL REIMBURSEMENTS AND LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES FOR TRAINING. THAT'S THE POLICE TRAINING BILL. 20 MILLION FOR INCREASED INMATE HEALTHCARE COSTS FOR THE DOC DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS OR 5.7 MILLION FOR [INAUDIBLE] SUPERVISION OF SEX OFFENDERS. SOME OF THE SEX OFFENDER BILL WORK WE DID IN HERE IS FUNDED. 2.2 MILLION FOR RED WING D OC THE PREVENTION OF RAPE COMPLIANCE ACT COMING FROM THE FEDS WE HAVE TO FUND. 1.5 MILLION FOR EXPANDED MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES AT DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS OR THREE AND 70;000 FOR ALTERNATIVES INCARCERATION TREATMENT FOR CERTAIN NONVIOLENT SUBSTANCE-ABUSE OFFENDERS WHO VIOLATE TERMS OF PROBATION DRUG THOUSAND FOR TARGETED VESTED PENSION PROGRAM FROM OF CORRECTION IT A COUPLE OF THESE NUMBERS COULD CHANGE TO DO WITH THE AMENDMENT MAKING THE BILL SO THOSE NUMBERS WILL CHANGE SLIGHTLY. FOR THE POLICY HIGHLIGHTS; WE HAVE THAT LAW FORCING TRAINING BILL THAT I TALKED ABOUT WHERE WE MANDATE AND FUND TRACES INTERVENTION MENTAL ON THIS MENTALLY DISTURBED PERSONS; SUICIDE AND CONFLICT MANAGEMENT MEDIATION AND ALSO TRAINING IMPLICIT BIAS. WE'VE INCREASE PENALTIES FOR ILLEGAL PROTESTS GET AT THE PROTESTER BUILDER WE'VE NARROWED DOWN NOW TO MORE OR LESS FREEWAYS AND AIRPORT AND RAIL. THE ONLY INCREASE IT TO A GROSS MISDEMEANOR NOT A FELONY. THEY'RE FINE PLEASE OFFICERS WAY TO CARRY PRIVATE ASSUMPTIONS BASICALLY THAT ALLOWS FULL-TIME LICENSED OFF-DUTY OFFICERS LIKE THE ORIGINAL INTENTION THE BILL BACK IN 2005 AT EFFECTS. WE INCREASE THE FARMERS ACCESS TO LEGAL AID SO THEY MAY APPLY FOR LEGAL AID PROPERTY LIMIT. PROTECTING MEDICAL PERSON L AS ASSAULTING HOSPITAL MEDICAL PERSONNEL TO THE FOURTH DEGREE ASSAULT STATUTE. SO WOULD BE ANY NURSE IN THE BUILDING INSTEAD OF JUST THE EMERGENCY ROOM. OPTION TWO WEEKS OR OWN THE APPLETON PRISON PROTECTING VICTIMS OF SEXUAL ABUSE. THAT'S THE BOUT STATE ADJUDICATION AND IMPOSITION OF SOME OF THESE PROMINENT CASES YOU HEARD ABOUT IN THE NEWS LATELY BEEN ENSURING RURAL CROPS UP DISASTER RELIEF FUNDING AS PART OF THE DISASTER ASSISTANCE FUND. THEN WE HAVE A NUMBER OF THING PROBABLY FOUR BILLS DFL BILLS AND ASSORTED GOP BILLS IN THEIR. I WOULD NOW STAND FOR ANY QUESTIONS OR TAKE AMENDMENT ESTHER SPEAKER. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: CORNISH MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE NUMBER 803 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS FOLLOWS. THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 31 >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH: THIS AMENDMENT REMOVES THE APPROPRIATION FOR MINISTRY THAT COST POTENTIAL LEASE OR PURCHASE OF APPLETON PRISON $208;000. IT ISN'T REALLY NECESSARY AT THIS TIME SINCE ANY POTENTIAL COST WOULDN'T BE INCURRED UNT IL THE COMMISSIONER OF CORRECTIONS DETERMINE THE NEEDS EXIST UNDER THE CURRENT LANGUAGE OF THE BILL. THE PROBATES AN ADDITIONAL 100;000 PER YEAR FOR TREATMENT GRANTS UNDER THE ALTERNATIVE INCARCERATION PROGRAM FUND WHICH IS GOING TO BE AVAILABLE FOR TREATMENT OPTIONS OF CERTAIN NONVIOLENT SUBSTANCE ABUSE OFFENDERS WHO RECEIVED TECHNICAL VIOLATIONS WHILE ON PROBATION AND IT INCORPORATES $104;000 A YEAR TO THE TAX COURT TO OPERATE THE NEW CASE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM THEY REQUESTED. THEY REQUESTED MORE THAN THAT BUT I'LL LEAVE THIS WILL NOT BE ENOUGH TO SATISFY THE REQUIREMENTS. MN.IT IS ASKING FOR AN ADDITIONAL $152;000 AND WE ARE NOT COMPLETELY CONVINCED THAT'S NECESSARY SO THAT THE AUTHORS AMENDMENT. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: DISCUSSION ON THE A- 31 AMENDMENT? REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM: MEMBERS; I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU TO VOTE FOR THE A- 31 AMENDMENT. THIS REMOVES THE MONEY PUT IN PLACE IN ORDER TO ASSESS THE VALUE OF THE APPLETON PRISON WHICH AM VERY MUCH OPPOSED TO AND I BELIE VE IT IS A MORE APPROPRIATE USE OF THE RESOURCES. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION ON THE A- 31 AMENDMENT? SEEING NONE; ALL THOSE IN FAVOR SAY; AYE. [CHORUS OF AYES.] OPPOSED; SAY NAY. THE MOTION PREVAILS. THE AMENDMENT IS ADOPTED. >>[GAVEL] >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: DEHN BOOST AMEND SENATE FILE 103 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 21. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE DEHN: THE UNIFORM COLLATERAL CONSEQUENCES OF CONVICTION THAT WAS A BILL WE HEARD IN PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE. IT DID NOT MAKE IT INTO THE PUBLIC SAFETY BILL . I THINK THERE ARE SEVERAL OF US VERY DISAPPOINTED IN THAT. WHAT IT DOES DO IS MAKES IT CLEAR THAT FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE CHARGED WITH A CRIME AS THEY GO THROUGH THE PROCESS IN THE COURTS THAT THEY ARE REALLY ENTERING INTO A CONTRACT WITH THE STATE THAT IF I PLEAD GUILTY AND A LARGE MAJORITY OF OUR CASES THE GO THROUGH THE COURT SYSTEM HAVE WHAT'S CALLED A PLEA BARGAIN THAT TAKES PLACE. BUT IF THEY DO PLEAD GUILTY THAT'S IMPORTANT FOR THEM TO UNDERSTAND NOT JUST THE CONSEQUENCE WITHOUT ACTUAL CHARGE WHAT THAT MEANS DIRECTLY BUT ALSO WHAT ARE THOSE COLLATERAL CAUSES MOVING FORWARD; WHETHER THAT BE DIFFICULTY IN FINDING A JOB; DIFFICULTY IN GETTING HOUSING ; MAKING SURE IT'S CLEAR THAT CERTAIN TYPES OF PROFESSIONS THAT MAY BE PROHIBITED FROM GETTING LICENSES TO ACTUALLY PRACTICING. SO I'VE HAD SOME CONVERSATIONS WITH CHAIRMAN CORNISH; AND I DON'T BELIEVE THAT THERE'S INTEREST AT THIS TIME TO TAKE THIS AS A CURRENT AMENDMENT BUT HE'S MADE A COMMITMENT TO CONTINUE TO WORKING ON THIS TO GET THE LANGUAGE IN A PLACE THAT FOLKS CAN BE HAPPY WITH MOVING FORWARD; POSSIBLY KNOWS MAYBE LATER THIS YEAR; MAYBE NOT TILL NEXT YEAR BUT AT THIS TIME I LIKE TO WITHDRAW THIS AMENDMENT >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE DEHN WITHDRAWS THE A- 21 MIN. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: HILSTROM BOOST AMEND SENATE FILE IT 03 UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 22. THE SPEAKER REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM THE A- 22; THE A- 23 AND A- 24 ARE ALL NOW GOING TO BE OUT OF ORDER FINANCIAL WE ADOPTED REPRESENTATIVE CORNISH'S AMENDMENT; WERE MOVING THE MONEY FROM HOUSE AND WE ELIMINATED THE MONEY SO I DO INTEND TO A STRAW ALL THREE OF THESE AMENDMENT. I JUST WANT TO MAKE IT CLEAR WHAT IT IS WE ARE WHAT'S MISSING FROM THIS BILL. SO THAT YOU'RE ALL CLEAR AS WE GET READY TO GO INTO CONFERENCE ABOUT WHAT I HOPE WILL COME OUT BETTER. MEMBERS; THE PROBATION OFFICERS ARE WE WERE REQUESTED IN THE GOV. BUDGET WERE NOT FUNDED. IS A 1% INCREASE FOR THEIR SALARY AND IT GOES TO PAY FOR THEIR INSURANCE. HOWEVER; WAS NO STEPS A ND LANES PROVIDED AND THERE WAS NO INCREASE IN THE ACTUAL NUMBER OF PROBATION OFFICERS. THE M ICE 23 AMENDMENT DOES THAT FOR THE PUBLIC OFFENDERS IT IS NOT ONE NEW PUBLIC DEFENDER IN THIS BILL IN THE A- 24 AMENDMENT IS FOR CORRECTIONS OFFICER. WHILE WERE DISCUSSING WHETHER NOT TO OPEN THE APPLETON PRISON; WE ARE NOT IN THIS BILL EVEN FINDING THE PROPER CORRECTIONS OFFICERS TO ADMINISTER THE CORRECTIONS DEPARTMENT THAT WE HAVE AT THIS TIME. SO WITH THAT MR. SPEAKER AND MEMBERS I WOULD WITHDRAW THE A- 23; A- 22; A- 23; AND A- 24 MARKS >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE HILSTROM WITHDRAWS THE A- RANGE AMEND. THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. SPEAKER >> CHIEF CLERK: CONSIDINE MOVES TO AMEND THE UNOFFICIAL GROSSMAN AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 25. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE TO INTRODUCE YOUR AMENDMENT >> REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE: THIS AMENDMENT WE HE ARD TESTIMONY AND WE HAVE A PROVISION IN THERE NOW THAT ANYBODY THAT IS 10 YEARS OLD AND OLDER HAS A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO AN ATTORNEY; WHICH WE PUSH FORWARD . UNFORTUNATE; BUT WE DO NOT DO WAS INCREASE THE PUBLIC OFFENDERS BOTTOM LINE WHICH MEANS THAT IN ADDITION TO EVERYTHING ELSE THEY ARE DOING; THEY WILL NOW HAVE TO STEP UP AND REPRESENT THESE 10 YEAR OLDS. UNFORTUNATE; FOR ME; REPRESENTATIVE AND CORNISH BELIEVE NOW HAS USED UP THE MONEY I WAS PLANNING ON USING SO I GUESS I'M GOING UP TO WITHDRAW THE AMENDMENT SO THANK YOU. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE WITHDRAWS THE A- 25 AMENDMENT TO IS IT ALSO 110 TO WITHDRAW THE A- 26 WOULD YOU LIKE ME TO INTRODUCE THAT? THERE IS AN AMENDMENT AT THE DESK. THE CLERK WILL REPORT THE AMENDMENT. >> CHIEF CLERK: CONSIDINE MOVES TO AMEND SENATE FILE 80 3 THE UNOFFICIAL ENGROSSMENT AS AMENDED AND THE AMENDMENT IS CODED A- 26. >> SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: REPRESENTATIVE CONSIDINE 28 TO THE A- 26 AMENDMENT. >> REPRESENTATIVE

qualitative masters dissertation buy best dissertation com cheap lektorat englisch dissertation sample virancityli bela dissertation do my writing dissertation while pregnant online dissertation explicative cyrano de bergerac exemple de dissertation philo bac s open directory of the ses and dissertations umi dissertation explicative la vie devant soi personnages sujet de dissertation en francais 3eme write for me education dissertation help for money order methodology dissertation proposal for money dissertations on gender mainstreaming dissertation proposal sample economics major dissertation proposal sample document berlin dans la guerre froide dissertation examples dumisile mkhizes dissertation topics do my education dissertation help online buy dissertation headings what to wear for a dissertation defense culture clash bbk dissertation buckleitner dissertation definition marketing dissertation methodology example dissertationen rwth email thesis topics for m tech ece theoretical framework for thesis example dissertation umi online statement of the problem in a dissertation dissertation msc methods investigation dissertation muster vorwort dissertation proposal example comment introduire une conclusion de dissertation definition write for me dissertation writing services birmingham order introduction type de dissertation do my abstract dissertation cheap difference between a thesis and a dissertation dissertation sur les passions gf flammarion capital partners order best dissertation writing website cheap program evaluation as a dissertation dissertation powerpoint presentation example do my umi dissertation search berlin symbole de la guerre froide cours funny dissertation acknowledgments 2007 honda sample argumentative research paper apa style la ddhc de 1789 dissertation proposal write for me essay and dissertation writing service order foreign language dissertation how to write a thesis oxford sebastian lehnhoff dissertation defense dissertation resume sample social media small business dissertation dissertation juridique la force obligatoire du contrat terrell strayhorn dissertation writing dissertation acknowledgements undergraduate quellenangaben dissertation writing advanced higher english dissertations mba dissertation findings dissertations on distributed leadership in schools order dissertation writing experts online gary wurtz dissertation help uk dissertation database search dissertation de philosophie la conscience write for me dissertation psychology cheap educational outcomes for looked after children dissertations order dissertation writing for construction students for money data collection and analysis dissertation format extinction de laction publique dissertation definition dissertation philo linconscient dissertation journal paper beispiel arbeitsplan dissertation proposal example good radiography dissertations correction dissertation bac francais 2019 conclusion dissertation for money dissertation writing quantitative research cheap phrase pour introduire une dissertation plan dissertation liberte dexpression order writing dissertation in 3 weeks for money music performance dissertation topics dissertation timeline calculators swetnam d writing your dissertation dissertation topics speech hearing ilko bald dissertation titles define thesis and dissertation search dissertation kuba cloth stefan kolev dissertation abstract what to write in a dissertation acknowledgement conflit de loi dans le temps dissertation lois constitutionnelles de 1875 dissertation format buy dissertation on after sales service order taner aydogmus dissertation format events management dissertation topics pdf comment traiter un sujet de dissertation en histoire et geographie video art dissertation music dissertations uk examples of archaeology dissertations order dissertation research question help cheap methode dissertation francais 1ere dissertation doctor methode commentaire philo bac es intro dissertation philo exemple liberte masters thesis vs doctoral dissertation irex dissertation fellowship thesis statement on computer networking methodologie dissertation master gary wurtz dissertation abstracts negotiation dissertation information systems phd thesis pdf annika raatz dissertation meaning dissertation cest quoi lamour buy hrm dissertation order all but dissertation for money melanie kuhn dissertation how to convert a dissertation into a book uni bremen dissertation online logos verlag berlin dissertation defense exemple dintroduction dune dissertation en histoire space law topics for dissertation sigcomm dissertation award nomination pour ou contre lavortement dissertation definition dissertation sur lironie plan write for me art dissertation cheap write for me dissertation proof reading museum dissertation pdf sqa advanced higher classical studies dissertation outline dissertation limitations chapter dissertation hints ideas for equine dissertations septennat quinquennat dissertation outline ku graduate studies dissertation definition dissertation philosophie bac thesis writing introduction chapter of dissertation company law dissertation topic write for me dissertation planning cheap buy dissertation history help order writing dissertation leicester order do my dissertation writing podcast cheap puis je savoir qui suis dissertation defense dissertation sur le naturalisme seconde labsolutisme monarchique dissertation defense dissertation commentaire article 16 ddhcc la litterature engagee dissertation sample of interview questions for dissertation bolker writing your dissertation in 15 minutes a day dissection aortique asymetrie tensionnelle false memory dissertation nina moliver dissertation rackham dissertation committee problems rural development phd thesis topics jan brademann dissertations thesis dissertation binding sacramento dissertation acknowledgements thank god la justice constitutionnelle en europe dissertation amorce dissertation argumentation persuasion dissertation economie terminale es cv for masters dissertation phd dissertation committee invitation letter wits electronic theses and dissertations etd mens fashion dissertation topics cp4101 bcom dissertation proposal example dissertation subjects marketing international economics master thesis topics simon brendle dissertation examples le controle de lequilibre contractuel dissertation lois constitutionnelles de 1875 dissertation writing introduction dissertation philo verite what is the difference between a dissertation and an essay buy engineering dissertation help for money masters dissertation writing help social media marketing dissertation pdf to word dissertation thesis graduate educational research school readyness uclan dissertation extension child health nursing dissertation topics fashion history dissertation apa style dissertation abstract comment faire une intro de dissertation proposal leeds beckett dissertation cornell university doctoral dissertations cest quoi la dissertation peut on avoir peur de soi meme dissertation dissertation aims and objectives do my professional dissertation help reviews online tamu dissertation approval form undergraduate dissertation examples on leadership graduate the ses and dissertations dissertation topics for project management dissertation table of contents apa template how to write analysis section of dissertation titles results chapter of thesis budrich verlag dissertation proposal example dissertation quantity surveying topics do my dissertation fellowships education cheap methode de la dissertation en cpge library dissertation on root canal irrigants sebik dissertation write for me need help with dissertation for money bharathiar university phil dissertation submission form zeitplan dissertation erstellen 3d sample dissertation for msc buy how to do a dissertation order sujet dissertation ses instabilite de la croissance do my dissertation writing block online de broglie dissertation meaning apa citation for dissertations dissertation title generator le mieux est lennemi du bien dissertation do my writing dissertation background buy introduction dissertation cheap writing an executive summary dissertation abstract do my fashion dissertation order ulu binding dissertation filip granek dissertation definition digital marketing dissertation pdf to word writing an acknowledgement page for dissertation doctorate in education dissertation topics margarita mathiopoulos dissertation abstract vorlage danksagung doktorarbeit successfully defended my dissertation titled mphil thesis in cloud computing pdf nyu deans dissertation attachment dissertation ideas la personne en droit penal dissertation write for me dissertation writing images for money dissertationspreis rechtswissenschaft auf exemple de dissertation dialogique social work masters dissertation ideas saa dissertation award multicultural rackham dissertation format article 8 cedh dissertation abstract dissertation printing and binding edinburgh lherbe est toujours plus verte ailleurs dissertation abstracts dissertation proposal memes dissertationen fu berlin online radio educational technology dissertations path to success write a doctoral dissertation examples dissertation topics accounting students dissertations on his dudeness write for me dissertation assistance writing online cambridge university dissertations elektronische dissertationen rwth email le conseil constitutionnel depuis 1958 dissertation sample format of dissertation cpsp dissertation proposal on terrorism sample religion and crime dissertation titles stalinisme et nazisme dissertation format causes of ruptured dissecting aortic aneurysm exemple dintroduction de dissertation sur les fables interpretative phenomenological analysis dissertation order dissertation proposal help uk order dissection aortique chance de survie the dissertation process helps learners by reinforcing which skills literature based dissertation example pdf meaning of dissertation work buy dissertation writing phrases for money example of business dissertation literature review dissertation abstracts international search order need dissertation help online structure dune dissertation en anglais dissertation writing schedule ii chronic aortic dissection symptoms ignou ma education dissertation proposal dissertation what does it mean help with data analysis for dissertation how to write analysis and findings in dissertation special education dissertation topics nouvelles orientales marguerite yourcenar dissertation defense all but dissertation balca best latex template for phd thesis dissertation layout tips sujet dissertation philosophie linconscient est modele dissertation philosophie comment faire une dissertation d histoire geographie antti laiho dissertation examples what is a 3 minute thesis sample literature review for thesis pdf la ddhc de 1789 dissertation abstracts business management dissertations business thesis topic examples sample contents page for dissertation 60 page dissertation navons nous de devoirs quenvers autrui dissertation topics lektorat dissertation rechtswissenschaft auf dissertation writing services singapore post where to find published dissertations dissertation ideas art history dissertation intro do my to write a dissertation online acknowledgement dissertation examples business information technology dissertation jan roggenbuck dissertation topics buy dissertation qualitative nurse patient interaction a review of the literature for dissertation dissertation peut on parler dune philosophie africaine seth yalcin dissertation sample plaire et instruire dissertation proposal leonid sharashkin dissertation defense write for me thesis dissertation cheap do my dissertation help help online beispiele fur expose dissertation thesis data analysis format cover letter for thesis survey treatment of acute type b aortic dissection ursula von der leyen dissertation proposal example le magistrat du parquet dissertation dissertation topics in education from school environment conducive to learning dissertation sur les passions gf flammarion paris sarah beth cornwell dissertation dissertation concours ira how to do an appendix in a dissertation do my dissertation thesis help divorce et faute dissertation dissertation in accounting and finance order history dissertation proposal online technique de dissertation en francais pdf comment reussir une dissertation juridique write for me dissertation thesis cheap vg wort dissertation 2019 nissan zdenek kalal dissertation proposal hermann sinsheimer dissertation defense write for me sujet dissertation service public for money dissertation on study abroad m ed dissertations pdf dissertation medical ethics conclusion dissertation culture generale msc dissertation titles samples stefan einsle dissertation proposal seabasing naval postgraduate dissertation physiocratie dissertation writing baylor dissertation guidelines faire une conclusion dissertation philo do my dissertation design for money joseph mitola dissertation abstracts la goutte dor michel tornier dissertation help jon soske dissertation outline dissertation loi de finance 2018 dissertation homework hotline phd thesis proposal example dissertation help writing resume marcus grosh dissertation help sample consent letter for thesis order dissertation writing block cheap steps to writing a dissertation for money 20 dissertation la parole pdf files dissertation on patient flow ekaterina nannen dissertation demi lovato autotune dissertation dissertation commerce equitable sujet de dissertation sur les sources de lhistoire le gaullisme dissertation outline dissertation on strategy do my dissertation writing hints online dissertation topics mba hr formalisme cambiaire dissertation definition example biomedical science dissertation vesa ruuskanen dissertation definition buy dissertation sur le service public en droit administratif cheap dissertation research fellowships online writing proposal for thesis write good research methodology dissertation dissertation prospectus definition wikipedia im rahmen meiner dissertation englisch buy writing dissertation in 3 days cheap risico dissertation dissertation philosophique sur la nature humaine peut on tout echanger dissertation philosophie how long to write your dissertation buy dissertation argument order computer science dissertation order binding your dissertation buy mba dissertation assistance order dissertation topics related to obesity la ddhc de 1789 dissertation sample sample apa research paper pdf methodologie dissertation eco droit stg kumulative dissertation philosophie medizinische doktorarbeit schreiben buch dissertation wirtschaft pdf islamic banking dissertation pdf merge res 150 what makes a good dissertation topic thesis and dissertation examples guerre froide dissertation bac buy dissertation abstracts cheap aau electronic library thesis and dissertation abstracts ford dissertation scholarship education uae thesis dissertation dissertation article 6 cedh non cumul des peines dissertation la cohabitation en france dissertation definition do my computing dissertation write for me dissertation writing services oxford for money dissertation examples 2014 lorraine hedtke dissertation proposal example dissertation topics nursing education dissertation juridique droit civil pdf methodologie dissertation histoire de lart bts luis dissertation paper in urban forestry dissertation intro examples cited in harvard reference system dissertation dissertation en histoire sur la seconde guerre mondiale do my dissertation writing anxiety order sample thesis proposal for computer science students dissertation formatting berkeley umi dissertation search online dissertation book getting published apa style research paper sample pdf dissertation other names university of florida theses and dissertations sample research objectives for dissertation nikolai vitti dissertations angela kasner dissertation proposal example writing dissertation quickly cheap write for me dissertation methodology antonia scholkmann dissertation defense comment rediger une dissertation en francais pdf do my dissertation statistics consultant cheap organization of the study sample dissertation dissertation ideas advertising marketing begruendung fuer den titel der dissertation how to do a literature based dissertation writing dissertation aims and objectives for money mahmoud kaddoura dissertation aortic dissection 3d math dissertation topic ideas dissertation negative scanner thesis and dissertation in library information science stanford art history phd dissertation composition la guerre froide 1ere s dissertation sur le marketing viral video andrea stachelhaus dissertation writing dissertation juridique quest ce que letat dissertation dhzb convaincre persuader dissertation defense phd comics dissertation defense videos buy dissertation help malaysia cheap exemple introduction composition geographie literature review for phd dissertation writing qualitative research dissertation format how long abstract dissertation sample distinguished dissertation fellowship uwm examples of dissertation essays environmental related dissertation topics find research dissertation numbers umi thesis dissertation samples dissertation lacquisition de la personnalite juridique en droit dissertation youtube song interpretive approach dissertation definition dissertation innovation et emploi public schmalzl hans peter dissertation outline dissertation topics on early years structure of qualitative research thesis exemple de dissertation sur le roman construction dissertations titles dissertation writing funny captions comment faire la dissertation pdf literary analysis outline worksheet for dissertation felix dietlein dissertation proposal example what to include in a dissertation proposal presentation writing qualitative dissertations proquest dissertation publication difference dissertation and thesis dissertation professionnalisation politique francaise singers formant dissertation do my sociology dissertation help for money dissertation cce write for me dissertation research richtige quellenangabe dissertation proposal example global education dissertation dissertation business ethics best dissertation writing services order dissertation topics on human rights in india used car depot dissertation never finished dissertation format list of topics for dissertation in marketing dissertation on abstinence gutachten beispiel dissertation format order branding dissertation write for me law dissertation service order dissertation gerfried sitar indian dissertations on ethical leadership theory la monarchie parlementaire en france dissertation veronika manitius dissertation sample difference between results and discussion dissertation proposal ntruhs nic courses mbbs dissertation guidelines structure of economics dissertation thesis on construction project management buy dissertation design cheap good books advanced higher english dissertation topics methodologie dissertation philosophie terminale stg buy synopsis for dissertation order professional dissertation writers uk for money phrase daccroche dissertation abstracts oxford brookes degree for acca students dissertation report on telecom write for me best dissertation writing service uk review for money vorwort dissertation musterbation write for me dissertation phrases order do my dissertation help chennai for money merger and acquisition case study dissertation format literature based masters dissertations write for me dissertation services in uk online groups sociaux dissertation abstract real estate dissertation topics uk introduction dissertation sur le roman nicole fitzner dissertation definition dissertation project on international business dissertation sur jeux video qualitative research thesis sample dissertation philosophique sur lhistoire write for me dissertation writer uk mergers and acquisitions dissertation pdf to jpg einreichung von dissertationen tumor bien rediger une dissertation apa dissertation reference example for job dissertation title examples english literature fonctions de la litterature dissertation write for me dissertation completion fellowships order cecil graham doctoral dissertation award unesco guide to electronic theses and dissertations dissertation zitieren lmu baseball order buy cheap dissertation order retail banking dissertation dissertation about classroom management audit trail in dissertation do literature review dissertation nitroglycerin aortic dissection writing dissertation proposal order phd dissertation in educational management dissertation mondialisation geographie proquest dissertation uconn autocritique dissertation definition write for me writing dissertation on ipad online dissertations in education uk knowledge management dissertation for money nils hellrung dissertation proposal example acknowledgement sample for thesis paper fault tolerance in cloud computing thesis physiocratie dissertation order dissertation editing uk order policy implementation dissertation good business dissertation ideas counseling plan dissertation la distinction du droit et de morale bristol uni history dissertations letter of recommendation thesis mba dissertation assistance cheap defend thesis dissertation publishing dissertation for money debakey type 3 aortic dissection order top dissertation writing services order buy dissertation team this dissertation is dedicated to provide fabian pfrengle dissertation writing m tech thesis latex template vg wort dissertation 2018 tx68 write for me dissertation writing block order roman dapprentissage dissertation dissertation money laundering online write for me affordable dissertation order dissertation results section online dissection aorte abdominale traitement quantitative research methodology dissertation example apa geology dissertation examples analyser le sujet de la dissertation how to write a good introduction for thesis paper funny dissertation acknowledgments 2019 silverado dissertation questions on climate change apsa dissertation prizes dissertation topics in tourism and hospitality dissertation sur la beaute de lart customer service dissertation questions order buy history dissertation proposal order apa style 6th edition for dissertations retrograde ascending aortic dissection what is research background in dissertation dissertationen online bible never finished dissertation abstract dissection aorte abdominale edaa outstanding dissertation award 2018 calendar relationship marketing dissertation dissertation christoph behrendt sap phd without dissertation for money kumulative dissertation anzahl msc business dissertation examples uk oxford university dissertation dissertation poster guidelines dissertation topics in health and safety dissertation coach newsletter archives thesis to journal article dissertation structure university of liverpool dissertation topic outline example what is a problem statement in a dissertation temple university dissertation format visual merchandising dissertation ideas autism hongbo zhang dissertation format industrial psychology masters thesis topics dissertation aid introduction dissertation philosophie terminal d political science dissertation chapter outline online dissertation abstracts citoyen grec dissertation proposal example example of list of tables and figures in thesis order writing dissertation for money for money kcl trs dissertation proposal proquest umi dissertations publishing a book lalcool chez les jeunes dissertation definition do my phd dissertation help cheap dissertation definitie romantiek dissertation in tagalog meaning rene fuhrich dissertations buy writing dissertation research questions online not sure if my dissertation makes sense dissertation lmu abgabenverordnung interview transcript example dissertation johannes uhlig dissertation definition roland baker dissertation titles thesis essay writing definition personality dissertation ideas business gregor weihs dissertation writing data protection law dissertation exemple de dissertation philo sur le dsir sujets de dissertation en francais dissertation printing services belfast exemple commentaire de texte histoire des institutions clifford asness dissertation sample dipankar sahoo dissertation tim hucho dissertation proposal example dissertation help tutors london lars castellucci dissertations oodoc dissertation proposal dissertation sur le consentement en droit de la famille undergraduate criminology dissertation examples dissertation topics outsourcing sujet dissertation croissance fluctuations et crisis averted thesis proposal outline example free finance dissertations exemple dissertation sur la question de lhomme dissertation sur la science et la philosophie customer relationship management in hotel industry dissertation choosing dissertation supervisor do my dissertation proposal writing help cheap how to defense thesis title psychology dissertation methods section tamara madensen dissertation icd 10 code for traumatic aortic injury florian scheiber dissertation help apa 6th edition citation dissertation dissertation uq inaugural dissertation medizina comment reussir une dissertation de droit constitutionnel vorlage gutachten dissertation topics master thesis research methods linitiative populaire dissertation samples teses disertations about teaching learning opportunities dorli harms dissertation outline humour noir dissertation outline dissertation defense presentation outline example health and social care dissertation examples dissertation writing advice for teens dissertation philosophie faut il aimer la verite annika grabbe dissertation sujet dissertation francais bac 2012 write for me writing a dissertation facultas dissertation drucken thesis grading rubric dissertation apologue efficace anglais structuring a literature review for dissertation english language and literature dissertation ideas examples dintroduction de dissertation defense how to begin writing your dissertation dissertation sur athenes et rome dissertation de lonu en histoire write for me what does a dissertation consist of order buy researching and writing a dissertation cheap importance art education dissertation labus de droit dissertation en des obligations cours master dissertation how many references should be on a resume betekenis van dissertation dissertation information security hylke dijkstra dissertation sample doit on respecter la nature dissertation abstracts phrases types dissertation write for me aauw dissertation fellowship order roy fielding in his doctoral dissertation whole life cycle costing dissertation danksagung dissertation medizinischer dissertation quels sont les determinants de la mobilite sociale traumatic descending aortic dissection do my doctoral dissertation help business culture dissertation how long is a literature review dissertation thesis topics related to public administration order dissertation coaching services online behavioural economics dissertation titles dissertation retreat order dissertation review expose dissertation musikwissenschaft order writing a dissertation literature review online electronic word of mouth dissertation defense write for me best dissertation service order exemple dun plan detaille dissertation verlag fur dissertation mitgutsch konstantin dissertation outline la culture nest pas un luxe cest une necessite define teacher self efficacy dissertation alexander bartelt dissertation topics whoqol bref dissertation abstract termes darticulation dissertation format iv republique dissertations hard back binding dissertation dissertations in ict msc dissertation how many references for a job dissertation datenbank gesprochenes staples bound dissertation dissertation mit mac schreiben dissertation quotes or italics for journal article write for me dissertation writing literature review online dissertation de culture generale hec buy digital dissertation cheap ifa nyu dissertations on leadership funny quotes about writing dissertation dissertation binding bristol triangle dissertation topics on working capital management robert klopfleisch dissertation defense dissertation information and communication technology martin scharrer dissertation titles deckblatt latex dissertation title dissertation psychology research dissertation diagnostic radiography uni heidelberg dissertationen online game nottingham university dissertation binding david hume dissertation sur les passions pdf creator dissertation proposal sample nursing care plans emotional intelligence at work dissertation do my master dissertation proposal online zakhar kabluchko dissertation abstract english dissertation defense slides quel est le lien entre letat et la nation dissertation dissertation sur les horreurs de la guerre torrent systematic literature review masters thesis thesis front cover do my help dissertation cheap free english dissertations phd dissertation requirements verlag dissertation berlin scholarly articles on dissertation exemple de dissertation explicative language write for me write my dissertation cheap what is a literature review in a dissertation comment faire une accroche dans une dissertation ses guide for preparing theses and dissertations usask stephen hawking 1966 phd thesis pdf orin starn dissertation meaning write for me biology dissertation for money how to motivate yourself to write dissertation sample of acknowledgment in thesis anne bochow dissertation lennui philosophie dissertation abstract write for me how to do a dissertation foreign literature in thesis definition dissertation how many words is a psychology dissertation writing an engineering dissertation do my dissertation computer science order la dissertation comparative exemple de phrases pour dissertation thesis proposals for computer science students ou dissertation format gsas nyu dissertations what is a dissertation case study akteur netzwerk theorie dissertation outline buy dissertation express order buy umi dissertations publishing cheap buy architecture dissertation library dissertation on zirconia service innovation dissertation sample writing a 10000 word dissertation nina haferkamp dissertation amorce dissertation philo conscience znh dissertation corrosion of metals dissertation soziale kognition dissertations unique psychology dissertation ideas statistician for hire dissertation meaning explain why you want to do a dissertation dickleburgh hall dissertation dissertation ethical leadership in schools yelkenlere dissertation order dissertation service uk cheap dissertation reflection example essays write for me biology dissertation vg wort dissertation 2011 dodge dissertations on nonperforming assets writing a qualitative research thesis writing the winning thesis or dissertation art history dissertation examples about business writing a proposal for a dissertation order mariana bozesan dissertation format rechtsvergleichende dissertation writing write for me quality dissertation help epistemology ontology dissertation titles hr related topics for dissertation can you get your dissertation published dissertation editing rates tedirgin dissertation dissertation ehlers elektronische dissertationen uzhavoor do my phd thesis dissertation online petar ivandic dissertation defense dissertation examples in human resource buy dissertation writing oxford order order masters dissertation writing services for money quantity surveyor dissertation titles in educational administration dissertation sur les communes au maroc questionnaire for a dissertation how to prepare for dissertation defence write for me dissertation essays order buy constructing a good dissertation online bridal shower planning timeline for dissertation what is the right spelling of dissertation dissertation in software do my dissertation project help online dissertation topics in finance pdf dissertation lenfer cest les autres sartre nausea lindividu en droit international dissertations sujets de dissertation seconde dissertation sur la notion du patrimoine dissertation proposal writing pdf inaugural dissertation kantor mba dissertation wikipedia phd thesis number of references dissertation on flexible working dissertation binding in sacramento ca do my dissertation questions most common cause of death with aortic dissection dissertation help writing thank peut on tout dire dissertation philosophie intestinale lipopolysacharide dissertation dissertation on policy analysis dissertation writing reflection of strengths national academy of education spencer dissertation fellowship program dissertation editing serviced apartment in hong kong dissertation science po terminale le scrutin majoritaire dissertation meaning dissertation introduction content buy dissertation mean cheap write for me theses dissertations buy dissertation abstracts international a the humanities and social sciences for money indiana state university dissertations gender watch proquest dissertations the dissertation co uk review gang culture dissertation urban architecture dissertation kumulative dissertation kiel oliver wendt dissertation sample dissertation nicole neumeister auktion writing dissertation in 10 days order my dissertation supervisor stating hypothesis in dissertation topics order dissertation binding service leeds dissertation pcr sanjar yasta yeni dissertation high impedance electromagnetic surfaces ph d dissertation dissertationen online tbingen order dissertation writing service uk cheap il faut imaginer sisyphe heureux dissertation sample example of degree thesis proposal liana molaski dissertation write for me phd dissertation proposal online dissertation sur la rhetorique dissertation philosophique sur le travail pdf rackham dissertation committee guidelines richwine phd dissertation length dissertation proposal example pdf portfolio marlen schachinger dissertation format hoblin pq proquest digital dissertations write for me editing dissertation online palgrave study skills dissertation meaning uk dissertation binding cost michel tremblay dissertation critique order qualitative dissertation help cheap victim participation doc dissertation aortic dissection acute vs chronic ct dissertation pierre bourdieu symbolic violence choosing a good dissertation topic phd comics dissertation proposal la philosophie en terminale dissertation outline le concubinage dissertation writing fashion business dissertation ideas for educational leadership buy automatic dissertation writer for money write for me dissertation service public et interet general for money university of essex sociology dissertation dissertation aims veronika manitius dissertation defense dissertation topics m tech computer science otto schmidt verlag dissertation outline rosedales dissertation write for me dissertation writing phrases for money write for me dissertation consulting fees for money proquest umi dissertations publishing 2018 ram law dissertation proposal order dissertation topic for project management thesis and dissertation in mathematics dissertation topics in education for meducation how to make a good dissertation title aufbau diskussion dissertation amakhulu amathathu dissertation lorenzaccio de musset dissertation proposal write for me economic dissertation buy dissertation on law dissertation literature review percentage apa format for dissertation abstract pe dissertation titles samples michael kummer dissertation definition phedre platon dissertation help work schedule for dissertation introduction dune dissertation de droit constitutionnel ivoirien dissertation mcdonalds three minute thesis ontario dissertation economique sur la mondialisation piirtola dissertation titles universitat koln dissertationen dissertation topic for architecture deconcentration et decentralisation dissertation titles dissertation videosurveillance newsbank vs proquest dissertations davrick dissertation la cause droit des obligations dissertation uk dissertation template software do my dissertation buy cheap order fine art dissertation cheap dissertation literature review help online dissertation training and development buy purchase dissertations for money hr dissertation topic ideas latex phd thesis title page organizational change dissertation niklot krohn dissertation help buy dissertation help student room for money usc columbia dissertations do my economics dissertation how to write a dissertation structure andreas moodler dissertations music dissertations in progress write for me phd dissertation services cheap findings chapter dissertation masters dissertation chapter proquest dissertations and theses pqdt theses and dissertations search history dissertation le bonheur est il accessible format contents page dissertation defense trouver un plan de dissertation philosophie marcellus dissertation acknowledgments phd dissertation sample definition of academic dissertation afm dissertation table of contents in dissertation example dissertation du bac 2010 proposals that work a guide for planning dissertations and grant pdf writting a dissertation dissertation and methodology dissertation work for money tips for writing chapter 5 of dissertation buy discussion in dissertation online dissertation cover letter questionnaire about yourself intro dissertation phedre florian ramsperger dissertation examples dissertation on leadership and motivation styles audition libre dissertation titles kkhsou dissertation purdue dissertation search possible dissertation topics in finance comment faire une intro de dissertation abstract what all but dissertation mean lower aortic dissection writing doctoral dissertation systematic approach to coaching dissertation writing literature review online buy another word for dissertation online order writing a dissertation in a day cheap how to write a thesis for a discussion paper dissertation on preeclampsia and eclampsia sujet de dissertation en philosophie sur la conscience brand preference dissertation nora bensahel dissertation writing prgs dissertation abstracts international three minute thesis vitae buy best dissertation com university of michigan dissertation defense dedalus foundation dissertation fellowship dissertation topics on tourism management dissertation on hris average dissertation marks ika dissertation yachmenev dissertation help agile software development dissertation lse geography and environment dissertation defense order dissertation help in dubai online international dissertation fellowship presenting findings in library based dissertations subjectivation de la cause dissertation proposal thesis on juvenile delinquency in pakistan dissertation la faute en droit civil methode dissertation de droit constitutionnel laction en justice des associations dissertation outline writing dissertations online do my dissertation research proposal order masters dissertation failure jay z deshawn stevenson dissertation help with dissertations cheap dissertation serions nous plus libres sans letat nation dissertation grade boundaries best english dissertations my dissertation is about tu hamburg dissertationen write for me edit my dissertation for money dissertation zur erlangung des doktorgrades english hilfen order purchase dissertation for money doktorarbeit korrekturlesen kosten fabio crivellari dissertation proposal example order dissertation dedication cheap vorwort dissertation rechtswissenschaften do my dissertation writing plan writing phd proposal methodology do my dissertation writing coach cheap dumisile mkhizes dissertation outline aortic enlargement and late reoperation after repair of acute type a aortic dissection dissertation topics for sociology students hire dissertation writer uk online eurozone dissertation dissertation islamic banking bachelor thesis human resource management dissertation literature review example uk cheque dissertation on smoking cessation phd research proposal political science example exemple dintro dans une dissertation filmmaking dissertation ideas thesis on the shadow lines by amitav ghosh bac francais 2019 dissertation corrige language and gender dissertation narrowing down your dissertation topic examples largent bonheur dissertation 3 point thesis definition dissertation ttu electronic theses and dissertations do my dissertation assignment help order dissertation proposal outline title page verteidigung doktorarbeit ablauf gestation pour autrui et filiation dissertation sarrazin dissertation outline do my history dissertation proposal sarah morelli dissertation ncu dissertation boot camp synonym dissertation wolf dieter springer dissertation advanced higher modern studies dissertation conclusion change management pdf dissertation on csr do my phd dissertation writing service online dissertation tu dresden chemieingenieurwesen history dissertation writing fellowships tv write for me dissertation help tutors cheap example of apa thesis statement dissertation je men vais dissertation sur les sources du droit administratif argent ne fait pas le bonheur dissertation proposal do my mba dissertation writers online sample of reflective statement for dissertation sociology dissertation awards florian ramsperger dissertation topics order psychology dissertation ideas heike egner dissertation meaning do my dissertation research proposal help order eugene garfield doctoral dissertation fellowship management of aortic dissection guidelines examples of research questions for dissertations referencing a website in a dissertation order dissertation help nottingham george b dantzig dissertation award la dissertation litteraire plan dissertation topics for sports therapy path to success game walkthrough doctoral dissertation proposal sample dissertation literature review purpose dissertation sur guerre froide daniel kirch dissertation sample michael kummer dissertations title for dissertation in management how to write research methodology in phd thesis apa dissertation title page exemple dintroduction de dissertation en sociologie bibliographieren dissertation proposal example phd dissertation citation chicago risk management construction industry dissertation tu freiberg dissertation dmu dissertation fail proquest search dissertations online write for me citing dissertations cheap comment rediger une introduction de dissertation de francais how long does it take to do an undergraduate dissertation dissertation lmu jobs nick pontius dissertation sub uni hamburg dissertation sample dissertation apa proofreading sonja gauguin dissertation examples bana bashour dissertations cite dissertation thesis korrekturlesen von dissertationen faire une synthese de dissertation structured review of the literature for a dissertation citation generator dissertation pirmin schwander dissertation entrepreneurship dissertation pdf thesis progress report ppt dissertation litteraire classe de seconde explication de texte exemple dintroduction dissertation problem statement in thesis sample order dissertation write up for money order dissertation writing anxiety lucian leahu dissertation abstracts library dissertation in periodontics dissertation explicative sur caligula action research doctoral dissertation sample drnevich dissertation titles methodologie dissertation en relations internationales ibd dissertation dissertation data analysis plan julia enzelsberger dissertation definition dissertation printing holborn youth dissertation topics examples de dissertation historique la buy methodology for dissertation deutsche dissertationen datenbank server gcu dissertation ethics form dissertation bac histoire geographie dissertation pour ou contre la peine de mort john nash game theory dissertation abstract comment faire une dissertation en methodologie stefan einsle dissertation proposal example write for me dissertation writing naoum cheap writing dissertation in latex for money dissertations on poverty reduction research proposal for thesis undergraduate dissertations examples of pronouns linda vang dissertation ed program online no dissertation dissertation vs thesis nz immigration dissertation on motivation theories in nursing order dissertation writing the importance of alignment online where to get dissertation bound manchester nora szech dissertation proposal body mass index dissertation thesis on occupational health and safety in nigeria frechdachs dissertation write for me custom dissertations order definition essay thesis statement examples essay dissertation thesis master thesis topics in wind energy write for me dissertation consulting services cheap dissertation proposal assistance cheap free uk university dissertations how to write a acknowledgement for a dissertation uh manoa library dissertations online phd dissertation parts malte gersh dissertation defense dissertation ruth lietzau difference between a dissertation and thesis annonce de plan dissertation datenbank dissertationen lmu soccer dissertationsdatenbank uni leipzig notenspiegel methodologie dissertation anglaise best survey site for dissertation examples of quantity surveying dissertations dissertation philosophie exemple culture investigation of stent grafts in patients with type b aortic dissection dissertation pages mac dissertations customer services dissertation innovation management articles abnormal psychology dissertation topics digitial dissertations buy dissertation writing workshop for money case study dissertation titles in psychology how to make a dissertation flow phd dissertation youtube tectum verlag dissertation proposal example dissertation writing services dubai online mba dissertation on change management src dissertation binding california dissertation phd uk ltd international trade dissertation examples wena salutuj dissertation philosophie dissertation ou explication de texte outline buy master dissertation proposal online nuig geography dissertation how to write a research proposal for dissertation five colleges dissertation fellowship length of a doctoral dissertation do my dissertation competition for money how to write all but dissertation on resume malte gersh dissertation examples les types de sujets en dissertation juridique nicole dissertation university of exeter english dissertation order how do you spell dissertation cheap how to write thesis in word 2010 law dissertation war crimes ww2 dissertation bilder urheberrecht biomedical engineering thesis projects modele de dissertation de francais connecteurs dissertation abstracts descriptive research methodology thesis faire une dissertation en ses how to write art history dissertation berginski dissertation help order dissertation process is the word dissertation capitalized dissertation abstract definition do my umi dissertations do my dissertation writting dissertation philosophie croyance raison dissertation sur matrix order bachelor dissertation for money doctoral dissertation improvement proposals ddig sample dissertation progress report ilaria frana dissertation titles leandro madrazo dissertation defense thesis proposal defense presentation sample sujet de dissertation droit civil l1 elke bosse dissertation definition methodologie dissertation capeps ecrit 1 dzoole dissertation consulting akademischer lebenslauf dissertation writing la place de la volonte des epoux dans le divorce dissertation write great essays and dissertations msc dissertation proposal sample pdf files search for dissertations online mischo kelling dissertation topics dissertation philosophie conscience pdf byu dissertation landscape planning dissertation buy phd by dissertation for money buy dissertation writing prompts order dissertation support order guttenberg vorwort dissertation dissertation sur linterpretation de la regle de droit dissertation etre citoyen dans lempire romain dissertation on theme parks excerpta de dissertations in sacra theology today dissertation topics architecture technology drawings write for me dissertation methodology section order crise de cuba dissertation sample dissertation architektur innsbruck druckkostenzuschuss dissertation dfgf social science dissertation advice what is the purpose of chapter 1 in a dissertation nlp dissertation robert kniese dissertation how many references should a 10000 word dissertation have contract administratif et service public dissertation titles getting your dissertation published correction dissertation bac francais s 2019 dissertation proposal sample history and physical examination naoum 2019 dissertation help solid waste management for dissertation buell dissertation colloquium 2019 interview request letter dissertation topics the glass menagerie dissertations introduction lhistorien et les memoires de la guerre dalgerie do my dissertation plan help cheap msc dissertation template ukraine ukip dissertation dissertation examples psychology in everyday danksagung dissertation musterole dissertation topics in marketing strategy dissertation philosophie 20 sur les fonctions et formes de la monnaie dissertation phd dissertations computer science buy dissertation dictionary order do my editing services for dissertation for money good topics for law dissertation dissertation book binding london dissertation online publizieren accroche dissertation esh uf chemistry dissertation was ist eine thesis arbeit what to include in your dissertation abstract do my qualitative dissertation order dissertation software programs dissertation sur lhistoire de lart nyasha junior dissertation dissertation sur largumentation directe composition geographie premiere s 2019 dissertation ux berkeley 2019 dissertations dissertation de philosophie conclusion write for me dissertation support order dissertation afrique berceau de lhumanite 1999 acts 29 missional leadership dissertation language dissertation on idoma dissertation committee request credit risk management in banks dissertation format do my graduate dissertation cheap dissertation topics in insurance and risk management dissertation on communicative language teaching do my dissertation and theses for money lerreur vice du consentement dissertation sample methode dissertation fac de droit database for the ses and dissertations on instructional supervision elena hubschmid dissertation abstracts phd dissertation means robert howell cobol dissertation at on besoin dapprendre a etre libre dissertation kumulative dissertation beispiel des buy student dissertation cheap example of a discussion dissertation nehemiah chapter 5 outline dissertation do my mba dissertation help order lopinion publique nexiste pas dissertation defense methode dissertation litterature gender and crime dissertation ideas african doctoral dissertation research fellowship 2014 dissertation philosophique introduction dissertation la croissance economique est elle soutenable questions for thesis proposal defense sample dissertation for education dissertation how long dissertation de philo sur lamour dissertation format uitm shah dissertation in a month dissertation introduction chapter outline example introduction dune partie de dissertation sample dissertation model on strategic communication writing master thesis in a company do my dissertation methodology help order dissertation topics for it management symptome dune dissection aortique comment elaborer un plan dune dissertation write for me done dissertation online le pouvoir de lagent dissertation topics composition la guerre froide en europe topics for library dissertation in endodontics public order policing dissertation writing chris mounsey essays and dissertations online de idolatria magicka dissertations phd thesis dissertation database search largumentation indirecte dissertation proposal example write for me hrm dissertation help for money buy theses and dissertations online for money title of master thesis biology phd dissertation dissertation writing services legal dictionary sujet dissertation agregation externe lettres modernes 2019 le vrai monde michel tremblay dissertation primary physical education dissertation ideas in school nyu dissertation format dissertation chicago style manual dissertation topics about social media marnie wedlake phd dissertation sample planning and conducting a dissertation research project mba dissertation methodology order write a dissertation in a month online present for thesis supervisor dissertations on school leadership lipset thesis definition dissertation dissertation sur lalcool chez les jeunes synthese dissertation plan dialectique do my dissertation proposal service for money introduction to a dissertation samples dissertation proposal layout usager du service public dissertation examples dissertation juridique le vol acca oxford brookes degree partnership on meeting the english language requirement particularisme du droit commercial dissertation proposal example what do you wear to a dissertation defense nike marketing dissertation are dissertation titles italicized write for me knowledge management dissertation cheap rediger conclusion de dissertation order methodology section dissertation order termes darticulation dissertation sample how to write research methodology in dissertation do my dissertation proposal layout order dissertation chapter 1 checklist technique de lentonnoir dissertation proposal example sebastian zeidler dissertation abstracts 20 dissertations la parole de jesus exemple de dissertation philosophie sur le bonheur apologue dissertation conclusion and recommendation philosophie dissertation le travail dissertation roman damour les principes de letat federal dissertation uk undergraduate dissertation examples about business job satisfaction and job performance dissertation glasgow university philosophy dissertation dissertation principes generaux de droit do my writing a methodology for a dissertation cheap annonce du plan dissertation droit how long should an undergraduate thesis be dissertation lafricain est il inapte a la philosophie dissertation revisions online le nantissement du fonds de commerce dissertation topics dissertation example acknowledgements simon brendle dissertation outline concept map for dissertation sample research paper outline in apa format how to find a good dissertation title dissertation using discipline referrals sales management dissertation topics where to find old dissertations sujets dissertation conomie terminale es dissertation writing service projectsdeal cheap write proposal dissertation cuvillier verlag dissertation writing trutz graf kerssenbrock dissertation format conformisme anticonformisme dissertation examples dissertation topics mental health nursing apa for dissertations 6th edition susan mann dissertation scholarship vdi fortschrittsberichte dissertation abstract dissertation writer uk dissertation topics in operations management write for me professional dissertation writers reviews order comment faire une bonne dissertation philosophique dissertation prospectus guidelines dissertation smoking write for me your dissertation in education online apa works cited dissertation protest song dissertation abstract julia garfield dissertation meaning electronic thesis and dissertation lsu dissertation methode introduction exemple yaelle biro dissertations social work dissertation literature review ideas sections of a masters thesis dissertationen uni stuttgart 2019 dodge dissertation reference apa 2019 dissertation editing services prices dissertation in education book dissertation critique les fous de bassan write for me dissertation on motivation edinburgh dissertation binding dissertation doit on apprendre a devenir soi meme abstract on dissertation order dissertation outline order sample request letter for thesis proposal order dissertation research and writing for construction students 3rd edition online reflective diary dissertation example apa lera boroditsky dissertation format dissertation on organizational performance do my dissertation undergraduate dissertation urban heat islands dissertationes historic aerials dissertation totalitarisme second guerre mondiale hollande order dissertation proposal assistance online kurzfassung der dissertationsschrift efficacite economique et justice sociale dissertation prgs dissertations definition order writing a dissertation order order dissertation for masters degree online gender inequality in the workplace dissertation dissertation topics on cultural diversity write for me dissertation writing workshops online 1000 words a day dissertation definition methodologie dissertation commentaire compose sujet et corrige dissertation ses spencer fluhman dissertation do my abstract of dissertation le dol dissertation bernhard wunderle dissertation topics methodologie dissertation philosophie bac s write for me writing your dissertation or capstone cheap academic dissertations order dissertation examples psychology master thesis topics in behavioral finance do my literature review dissertation for money open thesis and dissertations middlesex university dissertation format write for me dissertation preface online how to write first chapter of phd thesis proquest umi dissertations publishing 2019 cars dokumentationsstelle juristische dissertationen fribourg switzerland comment faire un dissertation en droit invitation serve dissertation committee free dissertation topics in international business microfilms international distinguished dissertation john adams 1765 dissertation springer copyright dissertation second language acquisition master thesis plan dissertation en anglais dariusz jonczyk dissertation topics define dissertation writing retreat do my business dissertation writing for money alle dissertationen deutschland karte zeitplan dissertation kunstgeschichte basel template dissertation importance of dissertation proposal critical essay topics examples theoretical framework about bullying thesis brunel dissertation help dissertation background section buy proposal for dissertation for money dissertation autrui philosophie thesis data gathering sample dissertation method order dissertation methodology online intestinal lipopolysacharid dissertation buy dissertation writing london online publish my dissertation methode pour une dissertation de philo lintroduction dune dissertation philosophique latest dissertation topics for mca davit harutyunyan dissertation sample martin scharrer dissertation sample order dissertation revisions for money exemple de problematique dissertation droit write for me dissertation writing retreat umn for money dissertations on church leadership manual le domaine de abus confiance dissertation domestic violence male victims dissertation blood pressure control aortic dissection dissertation public health fdi dissertation examples nursing dissertation verlag findengineeringschools art 16 ddhc dissertation outline ideas for a dissertation in psychology topics for dissertation project ina ehnert dissertation format dissertation sur lhumanisme et la religion romana buy need help with dissertation for money le conseil constitutionnel en france dissertations thesis layout format introduction dissertation revolution francaise phd thesis on leadership development buy discussion in dissertation approach methodology dissertation dissertation sur leducation des filles dissertation uni heidelberg medizin studium dissertation thesaurus and dictionary chapter 3 dissertation examples english phrases for dissertation work based learning dissertation titles la dissertation litteraire c est quoi do my dissertation binders le consentement au marriage dissertation help write for me dissertation limitations cheap comment rediger une introduction de dissertation en philosophie dissertation einreichen englisch hilfen sujet de dissertation sur le leadership sujet de dissertation philosophique sur la culture write for me dissertation writing tense order how long is a history phd dissertation uwe dissertation deadline dissertation uni wien juridicum stockholm writing thesis introduction chapter exemple de phrase de transition dans une dissertation nltd dissertation outline jan klohs dissertation format dissertation lappel decentralisation et deconcentration dissertation defense dissertation zitieren verlagsgruppe thesis topics hrm students write for me diploma dissertation cheap kumulative dissertation rechte what are the first 3 chapters of a dissertation final dissertation exemple dannonce du plan dans une dissertation academic dissertation thesaurus uwe kamenz dissertation defense dissertation francais 3eme political theory dissertation questions affection societatis dissertation educational leadership dissertation pdf to jpg buy writing dissertation while pregnant online public order policing dissertation abstract housekeeping dissertation doctoral dissertation en francais nsf graduate dissertation fellowship dissertation bac es 2014 methodology dissertation introduction elements can i use bullet points in my dissertation dissertation geographie la mondialisation why is it so hard to write a dissertation lsd doctoral dissertations northern ireland politics dissertation proposal degree dissertation proposal sample do my dissertation summary order quote thesis apa exemple de dissertation francais sur le theatre zeitplan dissertation mustering vanderbilt dissertation proposal type de conclusion dissertation comment faire un sujet de dissertation de philosophie do my bachelor dissertation for money les villes au moyen age dissertation proposal example apa style thesis structure publishing your phd dissertation article 16 ddhc dissertation titles dissertation art 16 ddhc sample dissertation in education dissertation tu dresden vorlage rechnung sample action research dissertation good dissertation writers the best dissertation sample body language dissertation zitation dissertation meaning la conscience dissertation philosophique pdf loughborough university thesis binding plan dissertation bac francais 2019 dissertation topics in educational management and planning michel et augustin dissertation meaning dissertation economics finance job market paper vs dissertation topics visual merchandising dissertation ideas health ancient history dissertation examples in apa largumentation directe et indirecte dissertation sample dissertation examples management how to do your dissertation in geography and related disciplines pdf dissertation totalitarisme 1ere es ses me dissertation topics dissertation sagesse et bonheur conclusion dissertation philo exemple dissertation research problems in data management and related areas writing dissertation introduction example published phd dissertation acknowledgments example dissertation chapter masters dissertation topics international relations google dissertations write for me dissertation coaching online nul nest mechant volontairement plan dissertation approach business dissertation environmentally essence strategic sustainable killa hakan sagopaya dissertation proquest dissertations and theses a i dedication page in a dissertation dissertation only distance phd susanna burghartz dissertation format writing a built environment dissertation practical guidance and examples johannes kirschenmann dissertation proposal le federalisme dissertation proposal socialisme allemand dissertation definition quest ce que doit etre la regle de droit dissertation a dissertation upon a roast pig essay writing a dissertation research question writing chapters 4 5 dissertation dissertation sur lurbanisation en cote divoire aortic dissection medical treatment order dissertation writing tense order write for me full dissertation help online dissertation litteraire sur la litterature dissertation methodology sample pdf files economic dissertation order ajs dissertation completion fellowship dissertation on non executive directors ccdmd exemple dissertation critique paper dissertation acknowledgement sample parents speech how to write a dissertation based on secondary research in marketing do my professional dissertation writers reviews dissertation sur lhomme libre dissertation explicative therese raquin author andreas zouch dissertation sample lse msc dissertation handbook wo dissertation veroffentlichen faire une introduction de dissertation philosophique umi dissertations publishing 2018 ram dissertation sur le roman mariama ba thesis grammar tense peter neumeister dissertation examples dissertation sur la mondialisation terminale s dissertation consentement au mariage write for me best dissertation editing services for money average length of a dissertation chapter dissertation title examples business model ford foundation dissertation fellowship notification sounds lit based dissertation sample write for me dissertation on law for money usf thesis and dissertations buy dissertation expert order conclusion dissertation exemple philo write for me methodology dissertation dissertation ideas for hr a student working on his dissertation plans interviewing techniques osu dissertation latex performance analysis in football dissertation meaning when writing a dissertation what is an abstract thesis for m tech mechanical capes lettres modernes 2019 sujet dissertation sujet de dissertation 5eme defense vs defended my dissertation dissertation on feminist epistemology gantt chart for mba dissertation examples lextinction de laction publique dissertation sample matthias grzeschik dissertation proposal dissertation le rire au theatre order hypothesis for dissertation for money bristol history of art dissertations walter abish dissertation ed dissertation in psychology hela zellen dissertation topics do my dissertation discussion for money buy undergraduate dissertation introduction order limitations for dissertation financial reporting dissertation topics correction dissertation argumentation menaud maitre draveur dissertation proposal example dissertation completion grant temple thesis statement examples for persuasive essays how to write a phd dissertation proposal comment rediger une dissertation en geographie midwifery dissertation ideas 2019 le gouvernement des juges dissertation format outline proposal for dissertation literature review format for dissertation how to write summary conclusion and recommendation in thesis jeff koinange dissertation buy dissertation support services non dissertation ministry doctorate masters thesis ideas dissertation formatting in word best phd dissertation writing service what is appendix in a dissertation exemple d intro de dissertation write for me dissertation writing service in dubai order introduction dissertation droit pnal acute aortic dissection aha dissertation scholarship dissertation literature review step by step corrig dissertation ses liban 2006 20 dissertations la guerre pdf reader unine droit dissertation inclusion exclusion criteria dissertation synopsis format for masters thesis dissertation service militaire online content page dissertation meaning birmingham dissertation proposal labus de droit en civil dissertation abstract marlen schachinger dissertation proposal write for me researching and writing a dissertation for money subjects music dissertation dissertation referencing figures in a paper what is a good introduction for dissertation sample phd thesis dissertation laerd dissertation philosophie sur la tolerance first draft of dissertation sample contents page dissertation meaning pitt dissertation database dissertation religion et bonheur how to come up with a good dissertation topic how to write scope of study in dissertation ma dissertation proposal online buy affordable dissertation for money dissertations and theses from start to finish psychology related fields pdf faut il bruler le code du travail dissertation first class dissertation sample pqdt open proquest dissertations theses dissertation erziehungswissenschaft die gleitende logik der seele dissertation ideas for dissertation topics in special education approche des territoires du quotidien dissertation examples danksagung dissertation verstorben dissertation manchester united quantitative research design dissertation amanda quist dissertation meaning sample of review related literature in dissertation master thesis proposal cover page entrepreneur dissertation ideas buy dissertation writing literature review order telecharger 20 dissertations on bullying microsoft word 2010 thesis template history dissertation leicester implications chapter dissertation plan de dissertation sur le comique dissertation service uk review online dissertation topics on social work thomas hastings dissertations write for me dissertation proposal on customer service for money transparent practices primary and secondary data in business ethics dissertations dissertation gone wrong eias zahalka phd dissertation dissertationen online sucheng applied behaviour analysis dissertation diffusion of innovation dissertation proposal order dissertation data collection for money exemple de dissertation philosophie sur la conscience dissertation abstracts international auen preise lektorat dissertation abstracts les valeurs du sport dissertation titles introduction for a dissertation online mc derdo 2018 dissertation le gardien de la constitution dissertation proquest dissertation password welcome do my sports dissertation order legende dissertation titles examples dintroduction de dissertation philosophie sur resume thesis title literature based research dissertation samples literature review or dissertation jsd dissertation dr gregor gysi rede order best place to buy a dissertation order illustration dissertation titles verlag publication dissertation titles format dissertation uitm dissertation topics corporate finance quantity surveying dissertation topic ideas phd dissertations order social theorists and dissertations graphic design dissertation statement synonym fr dissertation kcl history dissertation guidelines uc surbhi madia barger phd dissertation sujet de dissertation sur la litterature engagee literature review style dissertation la dissertation en histoire et geographie how to write a mini dissertation sample dissertation proposal social science irina lokteva dissertation topics amorce dissertation philo art how to write a thesis statement for a case study marketing master thesis examples do my dissertation writers in uae vorwort zur dissertation writing sujet dissertation explicative marketing dissertation case study do my mini dissertation order apa format 6th edition sample thesis topics for dissertation for mba all theses and dissertations culture barbarie dissertation introduction dune dissertation de droit constitutionnel congolais dissertation liberte et egalite presenting findings in library based dissertation abstracts international economics dissertation topics 2017 bhagavad gita dissertation dissertation ses fluctuations economiques citoyen grec dissertations methodologie methode dissertation anglais example of qualitative dissertation proposal buy best dissertation writing service uk online dissertation completion fellowships uiuc la guerre du golfe dissertation outline how to write an essay introduction and thesis statement how to pick a graduate thesis topic write for me advanced higher english dissertation format guidelines for doctoral dissertations samples order dissertation retreat dissertation autonomie droit administratif writing acknowledgments dissertation defending a phd dissertation dissertation abstracts international wikipedia free nicolas ziebarth dissertation literature review doctoral dissertations performance related pay dissertation dissertation questions examples economics apa style dissertation template roger pierenkemper dissertation defense thesis critique essay quellenangabe bei dissertation format dissertation purpose of study guide writing dissertation methodology dissertation proposal sample master of ceremonies britney grayson dissertation music dissertation abstracts international search phedre platon dissertation abstract help with data analysis for dissertation cheap dissertation lmu tiermedizin wartesemester aide a la dissertation de francais master degree dissertation sample publishing journal articles dissertation thesis case study sheets of architecture students aortic dissection surgery guidelines ute bracklow dissertation outline degree no dissertation dissertation defence powerpoint buy doctoral dissertation order library dissertation on lasers in prosthodontics pourquoi ecrire dissertation dissertation contrat de franchise anmeldung vg wort dissertation dissertation pour ou contre les reseaux sociaux write for me phd by dissertation for money uconn dissertation defense chapter 3 qualitative thesis order dissertation writing block order qn norikiyo dissertation dissertation binding in birmingham sujet de dissertation culture dissertation ideas globalisation how to cite a thesis in mla style architectural dissertation presentation ppt guggenheim dissertation grants us phd dissertations master thesis proposal kth tu darmstadt bibliothek dissertationen template of dissertation dissertation defense party le role de la bce dissertation writing stephan menzel dissertation proposal example metalium as one chapter four of dissertation dissertationen lmu medizinisches best dissertation co uk dean staffieri proquest digital dissertations do my dissertation abstract international cheap do my dissertation help liverpool for money how many words for each section of a dissertation comment faire une bonne dissertation en philo dissertationspreis adlershof industriepark political philosophy dissertation ideas hr how to make dissertation file theses and dissertations normally follow what format are kindle sample gantt chart for phd proposal summer internship project report finance mba dissertation imperial college thesis template laney graduate school dissertation guidelines le premier ministre anglais dissertation types of phd dissertations on teacher mario heiderich dissertation topics help with dissertation statistics burcu dogramaci dissertation sample what should an abstract contain in a dissertation dissertation with only secondary research tools criminology library based dissertation examples dissertation einleitung lange dissertation mobilite sociale corrige example of a business dissertation research objectives in dissertation analytical study of master of library science dissertation chapter 3 dissertation samples arbeitsplan expose dissertation definition conclusion en dissertation philosophie stating hypothesis in dissertation help syndicalisme et socialisme dissertation sample emergency physician focused cardiac ultrasound improves diagnosis of ascending aortic dissection alexander poraj dissertation proposal example toksikologija dissertation dissertation on humour phd dissertation signal processing sujet dissertation economie bac 2016 sample of dissertation for masters dissertation topics in mass communication verena krausneker dissertation topics nouvelles orientales marguerite yourcenar dissertation topics questions and answers for thesis defense mellon fellowships for dissertation research leadership case study dissertation research papers on marketing topics for dissertation gift for thesis supervisor order it dissertation for money dissertation definition antonym la quatrieme republique dissertation abstracts droit au respect de la vie privee dissertation ma dissertation help valija juliana doctoral dissertations fashion business dissertation ideas health dissertation mit isbn richard l greene dissertation award what is defending your dissertation dissertation sur levolution du roman dissertation on organizational culture le travail philosophy dissertation advice nust dissertation moritz leuenberger dissertation topics elargissement du monde seconde dissertation proposal example doctoral dissertation defense video do quotes count in word dissertation buy introduction of a dissertation online quest ce que la mondialisation dissertation outline do my all but dissertation for money oregon state dissertation format psychology dissertation proposal format master thesis dissertation examples for educational leadership warren goetzel dissertation dissertation juridique sur la police judiciaire write for me dissertation summary cheap dissertation secouer le joug de lopinion publique lascenseur social est il en panne dissertation abstracts dissertation reference list example for resume do my cheap dissertation writing for money what font should i use for my dissertation uk dissertation pdf psychology tirf british council doctoral dissertation grant 2019 dissertation chairman cest quoi un dissertation environmental dissertation prof dr karl lauterbach dissertations dissertation writing discussion cheap how to name tables in dissertation dissertation topics english literature example of qualitative data analysis in thesis pdp for dissertation hauptberichter dissertations diabetes and depression dissertation aortic dissection types pdf example geography dissertation croissance fluctuations et crisis dissertation writing tess of the durbervilles dissertation composition histoire seconde athenes dissertation methodologies cheap dissertation proposal oral presentation checklist knowledge management and innovation dissertation nouveau vocabulaire de la dissertation complete your dissertation in two semesters or less dissertation en pdf do my synopsis for dissertation cheap oxford university dissertation format methodologie dissertation brevet stereoselective synthesis dissertation sujet dissertation en francais dissertation wiki 2014 buy dissertation service uk review online write for me proquest digital dissertations online buy custom dissertation writing uk order write for me dissertation assistance for money dissertation structure uk templates list of dissertation topics in psychology la mondialisation culturelle dissertation abstracts social networking dissertation thomas cadenbach dissertation sample phd dissertation proposal latex template article write for me dissertation binding service bristol online le traite en droit administratif dissertation implications of dissertation chinese electronic theses dissertations service structure of thesis research proposal thoracic endovascular aortic repair into the false lumen in chronic aortic dissection hauptberichter dissertation outline thesis topics for tourism in the philippines dissertation reflective report sample buy custom dissertation writing uk cheap dissertation on leadership versus management vgtc dissertation award exemple introduction dissertation philosophie travail uclan dissertation handbook andreas bachmann dissertation format ryman thesis binding dissertation typing format dissertation library for money examples of education dissertation topics write for me business management dissertation for money thesis on public library order dissertation data analysis help order order write a dissertation in a month order le travail et la technique dissertation philosophie sample dissertation on diabetes dissertation fellowship economics documentary research dissertation format introduction de dissertation methodologie uclan nursing dissertation comment ecrire un dissertation dissertation katja marek the new hexagon proof dissertation uni marburg dissertation fb 20 motor undergraduate dissertation tips to winning dissertation topics international human resource management dissertation economie exemple dissertation dedications examples how long should a college thesis be write for me undergraduate dissertation proposal for money jaysus dissertation dissertation segmentation du marche du travail dissertation advisor duties dissertation writing services australia immigration melanie schienle dissertation format natural hazard dissertation ideas dissertation topics in islamic finance recommendations in dissertation writing tourism dissertation proposal example dissection aortique protocole scanner dissertation how many words a day dissertation approval form ucf ma dissertation exemple de dissertation philosophique sur la conscience zeno buy dissertation search for money stefan einsle dissertations questions to ask my dissertation supervisor le survenant dissertation explicatives fiche dissertation juridique buy results section dissertation online generate a dissertation title dissertation wiki fr dissertation process timeline in excel amorce de dissertation philo british library dissertations verzeichnis dissertationen online translator layout of undergraduate dissertation lexclusion sociale dissertation titles dissertation clinical psychology first class psychology dissertation example comment faire une introduction de composition dhistoire dissertationes archaeologicae gandenses vuw library thesis dissertations methodology dissertation introductions constanze kurz dissertation proposal write for me table of contents for dissertation online how to write your dissertation amerikanische dissertationen finden konjugation dissertations on arts education dissertation multiculturalisme exemple dissertation concours police nationale aufbau zusammenfassung dissertation examples write for me hr dissertation help for money what to include in an abstract for a dissertation dissertation pour ou contre le referendum find dissertation numbers doctoral dissertation citation mla buy dissertation essays thesis front page format filipino dissertation abstract what to include chapter 5 dissertation example peut on ne croire en rien dissertation glenda eoyang dissertation writing research methodology for dissertation dissertation word count order dissertation coach san francisco bay area peter neumeister dissertation discourse analysis in dissertation fallait pas faire du droit dissertation titles sujet dissertation travail emploi chomage write for me dissertation fellowships social science mikko siponen dissertation format exemple dintroduction de dissertation sur lart advanced higher music dissertation strength and conditioning dissertation ideas dissertations in public health history dissertation how many references should i put order doctoral dissertation fellowship order dissertations on line dissertation language testing mikrofiche dissertation meaning methodologie dissertation francais lycee order manual for writers of term papers theses and dissertations for money english dissertation proposal definition of terms for dissertation reussir dissertation ses mapua library thesis dissertations order phd dissertation search online write for me dissertation writing methods online dissertation gratuite droit constitutionnel td proposal dissertation hrm dissertation juridique la garde de la chose michelle prytula dissertation meaning university of manchester dissertation printing doktorarbeit zahnmedizin kiel bristol english dissertation devoir de dissertation philosophique exemple up theses and dissertations good dissertation topics for nutrition dissertations on self discipline vietinghoff dissertation titles umi dissertations proquest lamour est une illusion dissertation definition sujet dissertation concours orthophonie knut graichen dissertation proposal commentaire de phedre acte 1 scene 3 letat et la nation dissertation dissertation travail et bonheur dissertation de l imperialisme europeen en afrique odds of surviving aortic dissection les types de sujets en dissertation juridique pdf finance dissertation topics 2017 dissertation ursula von der leyen thema thesis on occupational health and safety urheberrechte dissertation advanced higher english dissertation cheap dissertationes forestales 15656 buy best dissertation help order study plan for thesis optimisme pessimisme dissertation outline le concordat de bologna dissertation format uzh dissertation titelblatt introduire citation dans dissertation defense creative dissertation cheap technique de la dissertation en histoire et geographie trent university 3 minute thesis droit administratif jurisprudentiel dissertation les directives communautaires dissertation examples dissertation synonym ford foundation predoctoral and dissertation fellowships dissertation oncology fast track independent scholarship and the dissertation history dissertation examples about business plan simple de dissertation peter picht dissertation sample stanford classification for aortic dissection comment rediger une dissertation francaise english literature dissertation gothic write for me dissertation writing a research journey italicize dissertation title lisa collins dissertation sociology dissertation proposal online initial proposal for dissertation order the dissertation for money dissertation grants higher education all copyrights reserved in dissertation examples dissertation article journal proquest dissertations publishing gap analysis dissertation example of short acknowledgement in thesis erp thesis topics order dissertation support services dissertation findings online dissertation topics hedge funds les apologies dissertation write for me pay for dissertation sample literature review for phd proposal lektorat berlin dissertation help using apa guidelines dissertation peter tauber dissertations dissertation coach walden dissertation drucken und binden online masters by research dissertation dissertation rub biologie animale examples of dissertation rationales in a sentence msc dissertation tips sujet de dissertation en finance dissertation sur la conscience philosophie marx manuscrits de 1844 dissertation format annoncer un plan dans une dissertation aortic dissection outcomes after surgery apa style psychology dissertation powerpoint how to start an introduction for a dissertation clever dissertation titles exemple dissertation arts plastiques allegorico piaggia dissertation composition geographie mondialisation et territoires il lavoro nobilita luomo chi lo dissertation dissertation roman methode dissertation rub bochum abbildung zitieren dissertation examples write for me conclusion dissertation cheap writing aims and objectives for dissertation ucla dissertation adviser lse past dissertations dissertation christoph behrendt dissertation on mathematics writing your mba dissertation brian white dissertation template word research methods dissertation proposal panic lauren oliver first three chapters of dissertation dissertation europe et federalisme dissertation histoire romaine stephan nopp dissertation definition il est interdit dinterdire dissertation meaning wargo dissertation comment analyser la structure sociale sujet de dissertation sujet dissertation ses pib presentation du sujet dissertation peut on penser librement dissertation abstracts dissertation on hybrid electric vehicle conclusion dissertation historique what to do if you fail your dissertation uk nursing dissertation examples about business nsf doctoral dissertation ultrasound dissecting aortic aneurysm write for me dissertation service public et contrat administratif cheap thank you notes dissertation committee do my dissertation consulting fees online mini dissertation format dissertation sur les sondages dopinion i cant finish my dissertation dissertation zitieren literaturverzeichnis open research paper dissertation thesis validity and reliability princeton dissertation boot camp brookes dissertation binding london qarizma rap flex dissertation pleure pas germaine dissertation abstracts drph no dissertation nursing dissertation proposal methodologie dissertation culture generale concours pdf writing your dissertation in fifteen minutes a day free download qualitative research dissertation proposal dissertation planning schedules social media dissertation example nadja noske dissertation meaning umfang kumulative dissertation many references should you have dissertation bettina lotsch dissertation abstract is dissertation capitalized buy qualitative dissertation assistance cheap hrm dissertation order law dissertation topics 2017 michael menrath dissertation titles exercices corriges de dissertation economique a guide to writing the dissertation literature review justus j randolph political geography dissertation ideas a dissertation on roast pig summary bac francais 2018 dissertation titles order dissertation proposal writer online dissertation philosophique sur lhumanite dissertation literature review writing services write for me dissertation for dummies online buy doctoral dissertations do my conclusion for dissertation order la mise en place de la veme republique dissertation arguable thesis definition dissertation danksagung dissertation doktorvater definition gantt chart for phd dissertation political science dissertation funding wolfgang dippel dissertation proposal insanity defence dissertation master thesis proposal contents construction project management dissertation pdf la bonte dissertation order conclusion de dissertation cheap meaning of thesis and dissertation dissertation planning document dissertation writing company order buy dissertation sur le service public corriger du sujet de dissertation dopage sportif dissertation central banking dissertation arnolphe est un personnage comique dissertation writing dissertation architecture romaine mla citation phd dissertation how to carry out a literature review for dissertation dissertationen datenbank mit michael seimetz dissertation sample umi dissertations publishing 20110 proquest dissertations and theses 2018 hyundai best dissertation title do my dissertation index research proposal samples dissertation shock advertising dissertation ideas counseling psychotherapy dissertation examples in finance exemple dintroduction de dissertation juridique pdf to jpg dissertation topics digital image processing format for dissertation sample dissertation data collection cheap ssrc acls international dissertation research fellowship idrf mellon pre dissertation fellowship ucla medical center dissertation proposal examples educational technology dissertationen lmu chemie periodensystem sujet dissertation classe 3eme referencing images in dissertations sustainable architecture dissertation affordable dissertation writing order what is an msc dissertation sample titles of dissertation eric dissertation examples acute vs chronic aortic dissection taner aydogmus dissertation proposal jirai cracher sur vos tombes dissertation write for me social work dissertations online early childhood studies dissertation ideas autism dissertation hindi case study approach dissertation titles buy dissertation index order hr dissertation hospitals doctoral dissertation search online dissertation explicative sur lecume des jours le sous sol ivoirien dissertation apa dissertation editors review defending dissertation dissertation front page example uk address where to find articles for dissertation administration dissertation educational philippine dissertation afrique martin hackl dissertation format dissertation argumentation directe indirecte conclusion carmen binnewies dissertation outline dissertation vocation poesie celebrer lamour dissertationsschrift englisch lernen dissertation purdue stating hypothesis in dissertation abstract write for me dissertation subjects online marc wucherer dissertation format 20 dissertations espace musique alexander blecken dissertation naoum 2019 dissertation examples of masters thesis druckkostenzuschuss dissertation dfghj write for me sociology dissertation online order business dissertation proposal cheap puis je comprendre autrui dissertation write for me research methods for dissertation online buy dissertation question help for money binding services for dissertations do my dissertation write online how to choose my dissertation topic start good introduction dissertation construction dissertation research methods film dissertation methodology writing msc dissertation guidelines banking dissertation questions single gender education dissertation dissertation topics for french thesis graphic design idea le marivaudage dissertation help souverainete plan dissertation dissertation francais plan dialectique dissertation philo nature culture free dissertation ideas different blood pressure in each arm aortic dissection verena klapdor dissertations sophie bistro dissertation charles lamb a dissertation upon roast pig sparknotes pride depuis la nuit des temps dissertation proposal example tekfur dissertation buy dissertation on motivation order results section of a thesis example dissertation topics in forensic science rebecca scarborough dissertation good titles for dissertation write for me nsf dissertation improvement grant order phd dissertation writing process pdf italian word for dissertation sharon ravitch dissertation abstracts constitution britannique dissertation sample write for me dissertation writing anxiety for money dissertation appendix interview do my social work dissertation for money apa dissertation reference example page justin gengler dissertation examples biggam succeeding with your masters dissertation sample bankhead dissertation le legislateur et la notion de contrat de travail dissertation anna reska dissertation proposal example dissertation 2018 write for me write a dissertation in 2 days order andrew lotz dissertation chris garran dissertation social work dissertation child protection how to write a doctoral dissertation in philosophy charlene rivera and dissertation justin gengler dissertation abstract how to write a good phd thesis conclusion what do you write in a dissertation conclusion write for me professional dissertation help reviews online dissertation finance public dissertation quest ce qui pousse lhomme a travailler buy writing a good dissertation order marjon dissertation handbook layout dissertation seitenrand dissertation deutsch chapter one qualitative dissertation write for me thesis or dissertation for money dissertation project proposal sample gestation pour autrui dissertation proposal example write for me history dissertation help order write for me secondary research dissertation disserting dissertation on brain drain writing your dissertation or capstone online dissertation reflection example c greenwich university dissertation binding conducting interviews for dissertation ub tum dissertationen elena maria antonia chandler dissertation help dissertation topic ideas history of the internet thematic analysis example dissertation hot dissertation topics in finance uclan dissertation title page important topic dissertation la guerre froide bipolarisation du monde dissertation examples order dissertation help service online doctoral dissertation fellowship ndsu unine droit dissertation proposal dissertation le fait dautrui loi des douze tables dissertation titles symptoms of aortic dissection aneurysm rguhs digital library thesis dissertations formatting page numbers for dissertation cornell dissertations buy dissertation help glasgow for money met1300 dissertation format sujet dissertation bac franais 2018 word 2018 apa 6th edition dissertation title dissertationen datenbank zeitungen pamela luckau dissertation meaning dissertations on church leadership development do my writing dissertation in latex heike kamerlingh onnes dissertation topics doctoral dissertation proposal ppt le plan de dissertation en histoire example of acknowledgement in making thesis do my dissertation help birmingham dissertation key questions order writing phd dissertation order niemann gottigen dissertation veronika burian dissertation outline dissertation viola bullmann as hidden curriculum dissertation le parlementarisme en france dissertation definition write for me masters degree dissertation order dissertation sur lobjet de la constitution write for me proquest umi dissertation publishing for money dissertations in health economics help me in my dissertation methode dissertation en anglais dissertation study participation letter form dissertation on teachers attitude and test scores dissertation for international business definition of the word dissertation lotta zernial dissertation abstracts de quoi nous libre la culture dissertation ulrich kortenkamp dissertations alice marwick dissertation defense order doctoral dissertation abstracts cheap anonymous interviews dissertation plan explicatif en dissertation dissertation editing online order buy dissertation writing services uk reviews order dissertations on options risk management buy conclusion dissertation order dissertation drucken isbn 20 dissertation la parole pdf to excel methodologie de dissertation de histoire une guerre daneantissement composition

Your One and Only Stop for All Types of Writing Services

All types of works. All kinds of complexity. Any deadline. Any time.

Our Samples

Our Samples

We write from scratch
according to your instructions.

Our Guarantees

Our Prices

Start at $10/page. Edit and
proofread your paper.

Our Prices

Our Guarantees

Get plagiarism free papers,
100% guarantee!

Want to make sure if we have an available expert? Learn now! Place a Free Inquiry
We have taken appropriate security measures to protect you against loss, misuse or alteration of the information we
have collected from you. Please read our Privacy Policy to learn more.